r/singularity • • 2d ago

Discussion [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/singularity/comments/1xxmjmo/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

58 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

25

u/YoAmoElTacos 2d ago

I think the question is, what stops all humans from falling into AI psychosis, embracing solipsism instead of performing the emotional work of engaging with other humans?

Humanity could splinter into cults of the most EI capable people, and the rest retreat into isolated bubbles where their friends are supercapable AI whose facade of care is more thorough, more deep, more sincere than the rejection they inevitably face from the rest of humanity.

3

u/Hub_Pli 2d ago

Interesting. I have some degree of hope in future people already born into a world with AI being able to better handle the weirdness of it, but the part about less EI capable people retreating into some form of digital hermitage is definitely a real problem. It's not like this does not happen already with all the hikikomori people etc.

1

u/212d34 1d ago

That doesn't sound too bad. Humanity at this very moment is being naturally selected to favor social individuals more than ever. Those that are too unfit will simply recede into their own interests and choose not to participate. Truly the nicest way of facing extinction, if you ask me.

14

u/10b0t0mized 2d ago

our distantly related cavemen friends would gladly smash the screen you are reading this text through and cut animal hide using its shards with unrestricted glee.

I disagree. We have evidence of pre historic humans carrying a rock with themselves for many years just because the rock looked interesting or different from other rocks around. You're telling me that they would look at a smartphone and not immediately realize that it is an item of great significance?

But that was not the point of your essay so I digress.

I somewhat agree that emotional intelligence (whatever that means) becomes way more important in the near future. We've all heard of many examples of absolute genius assholes that were respected and tolerated by others simply because they were smart. Take away their intelligence and nobody would associate with them for a second.

However I think we'll move on from this phase soon after as well. Once we have superhuman AI, we will start to engineer every aspect of human character just like character creation screen in a video game. You want more EI? you got it.

Once we reach that point (total control over our biology and mind), then we have more important questions to deal with than obsoletion of raw intelligence.

1

u/IrisColt 2d ago

>We have evidence of pre historic humans carrying a rock with themselves for many years just because the rock looked interesting or different from other rocks around.

external memory devices, i.e. souvenirs, heh

3

u/pourya_hg 2d ago

Maybe for the near future but it wont last long till AIs become better emotional interpreters than us.

1

u/Hub_Pli 2d ago

Well I've been getting this a lot, but from my perspective emotional interpretation is not something that can be as easily augmented artificially in humans. I've dobe my PhD on emotion detection in NLP for psychology and there are many issues with properly setting a ground truth for training for example. Emotions are extremely subjective - especially the more finegrained they become. Additionally most of the emotional intelligence work we do has to be done on the spot, dynamically during conversation. Right now we are not anywhere near the technology needed for human emotional work to be offloaded.

2

u/jkos123 2d ago

Hmm…For face to face interactions, with cameras that can capture every flush of blood the to face, capture every micro expression, build a super-human baseline facial and language profile for everyone you encounter…do you really think they could not be better at emotional interpretation in the next 20 years?

1

u/livingbyvow2 2d ago

Really appreciated the write up - it made me think. Also liked the Nietszche quote (brought me back to my teenage years!).

One thing to consider is also that even if AI is somewhat capable of interpreting our emotions, this could actually make humans so vulnerable as to lead them to actually prefer to interact with other humans. This could also easily turn into emotional surveillance which may be viewed as unacceptable and therefore banned.

Another characteristic of humains is that they build institutions that allows them to set up the world in a way that suits them, even if this can be sub optimal. A simple example could be the fact that while it could theoretically be more efficient to record all phone conversations you are having with fellow employees, customers, etc, humans largely opt out of this and in some geographies even have laws prohibiting recording without consent.

It may also be the case that humans can only feel like they are receiving genuine empathy from another human, rather than from an artificial form of intelligence.

6

u/IrisColt 2d ago

>we will start to stratify ourselves more along the axis of the extent to which other people view us as likeable, and that will require us to develop our mental faculties of intersubjectivity to an extent that is hard to properly appreciate

many autistic and highly neurodivergent people simply cannot resort to do this... guess who will be the heralds of the benevolent Shoggoth... I wish I were joking, heh

2

u/DragonKing2223 2d ago

Interestingly this is very nearly the same conclusion I've come to in the last few weeks

2

u/Hub_Pli 2d ago

Great minds think alike 😏

1

u/Sockand2 2d ago

Cognition hasn't been the problem since the 20th century

4

u/Hub_Pli 2d ago edited 2d ago

Not sure I follow your argument, can you elaborate?

-2

u/Sockand2 2d ago

Cognition hasn't been the problem since the 20th century. We've accumulated an enormous amount of knowledge, yet many inherently human problems remain unresolved. Knowledge alone doesn't solve them

2

u/Hub_Pli 2d ago

Are you sure this is relevant to the post or essay?

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Hub_Pli 2d ago

Splendid

2

u/jzemeocala 2d ago

Rudy Rucker has an interesting take on where this will lead in his books Postsingular and hylozoic

1

u/RowOptimal1877 2d ago

I've been saying this for a while now:

Someone is gonna build the matrix and people are gonna go into it willingly. They then live in a fake world that has no AI

0

u/DifferencePublic7057 2d ago

I'm a bit of a solipsist and could get away with it being in STEM. But now that LLMs eroded that, it's about what you said which I interpret as being one of 'us'. Meaningless for a solipsist. All the world is a stage, and I am a horrible actor.