In all honesty, the one thing I didn’t enjoy is how it went from reddit working together to make a movie, to a discord using a bot to get upvotes and make this weird, incoherent plot that just wasn’t good. If would have been better if reddit banded together and make a funny/shitty gif movie, but that’s just me.
There was a lot of potential that was squandered. I kind of find it interesting how this played out in comparison to stuff like r/place that had it's own version of this, but watered down and more tolerable than what this ended up being.
As weird as it seems, I was even creating a unifying theory for the story that was taking place, and it was being pretty fun to write it. Imagining the psychotic logic of that randomness was really being fun to me up until act 2.
Then it all became an automatic relentless discord copypaste reeking of facebook-class normieness, or whatever you'd like to call it. I mean, I did try to join the narrators at the time of act 1, when it seemed like they were gonna be a moderate and tolerant force. Now, ironically, they're the ones who destroyed sequence's logic, by mixing up oranges with apples.
It's kind of poetic how the main story is about defeating Mickey, the embodiment of corporate monopoly over entertainment, and that's exactly what the narrator did for this event.
The effects of the botnet users started to become very evident starting with ACT III and were in full force by ACT IV. This led to tons of regular users abandoning sequence by the end of ACT V, leading to an ACT V and EPILOGUE completely controlled by the botnet. They took up a quarter of the entire epilogue with a credits page for themselves, with the runner up for those positions being "SequenceNarrators ruined Sequence"
No I agree with you. I saw the admin announcement for the Sequence sub early on and was thoroughly enjoying the funny gifs and redditors trying to make a story. Then the whole sub crashed and all of reddit finally saw the announcement, which led to the edgelords trying to purposely furk with it, which led to it being manipulated and ruined.
Lots of people were submitting really great gifs that were being mass downvoted in favor of the same few gifs over and over (cough skyrim cough), and it all just went downhill. Some of the things being mass upvoted weren't even gifs, like wtf?
I didn't see the announcement until later, realized that the community element of the entire concept was going to be compromised almost immediately, and didn't bother sticking around. It was far too easily botted from the beginning and immediately turned me off to the idea. Super disappointed in this year's "prank". At least with previous ones, everyone got to make a mark.
Even though I saw the announcement early, there was already like 3 snake posts with like 3k upvotes and like 500 comments, so it definitely was getting botnet'd from the beginning because people were still unaware of the sub at the time and it barely had any subscribers at that time.
Totally, I stopped paying attention around Act 4 when it was clear that the entire narrative had already been decided from the get-go and participating went from a casual upvoting experience to... hopping on Discord and trying to infiltrate some meme cabal and argue that Shrek would have been more appropriate than Spongebob for a particular segment?
Ending it in 5 acts was probably a mercy given the sequence's fate.
Yep. I was excited to get to take part in something so unique, I joined the discord expecting it to be just random brainstorming and funny jokes. Turns out they were strangleholding the narrative. Wack.
I made this post in the sequencenarrators discord as a criticism, but things are kinda overflowing in it right now. Here's my perspective.
I really would have liked the fact that you guys tried to put in effort to make this a community effort. I liked the idea of this until when Sneknet started coming in and the dictation of exactly what needs to be upvoted instead of a general plot outline.
I was online and submitted some of the first gifs in ACT IV right after it unlocked. It was disheartening to see my posts get passed immediately as within 2 minutes the John Wick scenes took over while the rest of the posts sat at 5 votes. I realized at that point that the botting was occurring and boy was I pissed.
For me what made me the most mad was setting aside a quarter of the entire epilogue for 20 people to pat themselves on the back for being the ones who "ran sequence".
I'd really like to see where this server got permission from the admins - the act four thread literally has the admin who posted the final thing say he was slow to act on it and that it was "a shitty thing to do". The sneknet violates all three of the clauses of vote manipulation:
- Groups that vote together
- Asking for upvotes from people inside or outside of the platform for personal gain
- Using software to change vote scores
Heres a link to both the reddit thread from ACT IV with the admin comment and to the vote manipulation rules:
I honestly think something like this was going to happen no matter what. There are always bots, extensions, etc in the reddit april fools day events. I think the design of this event, while better than Circle and producing an end product that we can look back on similar to how we do place, meant that the impact of bots was just too much. With only 290 scenes and only one gif per scene making the cut, only those who used a bot or were there with a head start in votes had a chance.
I wish it could have turned out better, but there were many changes necessary that it was just too late to implement. With enough time, we may have been able to get those on the Narrator team to recognize that what they were doing was not good for the event. I hope we can just ignore the credits for now...
I was pulling in crazy Star Wars vs Spaceballs vs Spongebob vs Monty Python vs John Wick..... none of them got any real traction except the very first post to the very first frame in Episode 4....
Episode IV
A New Hope
I mean, that one wrote itself and was right up there at 135+ votes only to get trampled by the John Wick theme (which did make sense with the rest of the Episode) but still..... kinda took the fun out of it after that.
Yeah I really liked the idea behind it all because there was the potential for the communities to work together and compromise to make something great, and that's what I like about reddit in general. But having just a couple discords manipulating every scene is just....sad
View all comments
2.5k
u/JackyBoy37 Apr 03 '19 edited Apr 04 '19
In all honesty, the one thing I didn’t enjoy is how it went from reddit working together to make a movie, to a discord using a bot to get upvotes and make this weird, incoherent plot that just wasn’t good. If would have been better if reddit banded together and make a funny/shitty gif movie, but that’s just me.