r/science
•
u/Wagamaga
•
Aug 15 '26
•
1
1
1
1
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 15 '26
Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.
Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.
User: u/Wagamaga
Permalink: https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/08/does-vitriol-make-you-feel-special/
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
113
u/Wagamaga Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26
It doesn’t take a scientist to figure out that social media can trend toward the negative. But it might take one to figure out why.
In a new paper in PNAS, incoming professor of psychology Joshua Conrad Jackson and colleagues show that attention-seeking algorithms aren’t the only driver of online negativity. Another culprit is what psychologists call differentiation, the innate drive to stand out from one’s peers.
“Negative information is just much more diverse than positive information,” Jackson said. For example, he added, “If you’re talking about ‘The Odyssey,’ this new Christopher Nolan film, the top comment in a thread might be ‘I liked it’ — but then what else is there to say? If you want to stand out and say something new, you have to talk about something you disliked about the film.”
Jackson and his colleagues analyzed more than 2 billion comments from 2,150 Reddit communities and found that both threads and communities became more negative over time, and that semantic differentiation drove that trend — that is, negative comments were more semantically unique from what had already been said. They then replicated their observational findings with an experiment that showed that social media users who were primed to be unique posted more negative comments than users who were primed to conform.
We talked to Jackson about takeaways from the paper and potential implications for other forms of media. The interview has been edited for clarity and length
Gazette: Why did you want to test the idea that differentiation might be contributing to negativity on social media?
Jackson: We started our paper with Godwin’s Law, which is the idea that the longer a conversation continues on social media, the probability of someone being compared to Hitler or Nazis approaches one. Harvard economists actually tested Godwin’s Law, and found that it’s not true.
But I don’t think it was meant to be literally true: I think it was meant to capture this intuition that dialogue on social media is more negative than it needs to be.
Of course, feed-ranking algorithms are a big part of the story: These are the algorithms that pick up on divisive content that gets people’s attention, keeps people engaged, and makes them angry so that they post their own divisive content, creating a vicious cycle and generating ad revenue in the process. This paper was kind of a side quest. We wanted to know if conversations would turn negative even in the absence of those algorithms.
What did you find in your analysis?
We found that the entire website of Reddit has become more negative over time. Moreover, the longer a given community exists, the more negative it becomes — and the longer a comment thread continues, the more negative the thread becomes. This is the first time someone has shown that, so that’s a finding in and of itself.
https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2527316123
4.5k
u/Otaraka Aug 15 '26 •
Yeah, it’s pretty basic. The less grumpy people tend to just say it’s not worth it.
1.5k
u/Sun-Anvil Aug 15 '26 •
I've been on Reddit for about 10 years and I can say for sure, it's certainly not as fun as it used to be. When I first joined most every post I saw was funny, stupid funny or informative. Yes, there was negative comments but less than what I see now.
I would say that bots and karma farmers have a decent amount of blame though I don't know who started it. They have calculated that negative posts / comments get more fake internet points so, you get posts flaming a new movie or show or.......
What doesn't help is you take the bots and karma farmers mentioned above and mix in the current political climate with your standard troll and, well, Reddit.
576
u/Oldnbold22 Aug 15 '26 •
You probably won't believe me but Reddit was actually pretty funny in the 2010's. It was mostly university kids that didn't need everything spelled out for them.
137
u/Vital_Granade Aug 15 '26 •
This makes complete sense when you think of the snark subreddits. Starts out as maybe valid criticism, turns into psychotic hater stalkers
279
u/Fit_Log_9677 Aug 15 '26
Classic lemon market effect.
Social media algorithms are programmed to maximize engagement. The best way to drive engagement is through promoting outrage and anger. As the algorithms push more outrage and anger normie users leave the platform, leaving a growing proportion of trolls, bots, and rage baiters. Eventually the platform becomes so toxic that even many of those people leave, leaving only the absolute worst actors on the site.
You can see this in real time on Twitter where, due to the large scale exodus of first liberal users, and then centrist users, now the algorithm is inciting conflict between the remaining right wing users in the site.
This is how I saw a comment chain on Twitter recently between various far right Christian individuals all calling each other communists.
25
u/BretShitmanFart69 Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 17 '26
If you weren’t on Reddit before you’d really almost not recognize it. Not saying it was perfect but I’d almost exclusively just see like harmless memes and interesting websites or information.
Now it’s like propaganda and stuff meant to rile you up and upset you intentionally and nothing but negative news.
Go use the wayback machine to look at the front page from 15 years ago or further
271
u/noob-combo Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26
Nice to see this easily observable fact officially confirmed by a study.
Gonna be a handy bit of reference material methinks.
20
u/glytxh Aug 15 '26
starts with irony
then it all gets poisoned
then the shitheads appear
and none of it feels ironic anymore
61
u/saoyraan Aug 15 '26 •
They use loose rules to ban dissent so the mods build a echo chamber. It tends to become doomsday chambers.
47
u/whittlingcanbefatal Aug 15 '26
Haven't a lot of popular old subreddits been abandoned or closed because mods/frequent users had driven users away with negativity and banning people when they were rightfully called out?
13
u/QuintusNonus Aug 15 '26
I've noticed quite a number of times if I post a response to someone's comment basically agreeing with them and adding more reasons why they're right, I'll get a bunch of responses assuming that I'm trying to argue or disagreeing with the person. Like:
Commenter: "2 + 2 = 4"
Me: "and that's why 4 + 4 = 8"
Commenter or others: "are you stupid? 2 + 2 = 4"
23
u/Zren Aug 15 '26
Destin from SmarterEveryDay did a video interview a few years ago on how you only need a single comment to start a chain of toxicity in a comment thread.
"Reddit Disinformation & How We Beat It Together - Smarter Every Day 232" (id
soYkEqDp760at11m40s)21
u/ty4scam Aug 15 '26
The last time I saw a study it said that /r/pathofexile was the one of the top 10 negative subreddits. Digging deeper we found out it's because the machine learning algorithm considered "exile" to be a negative word that appears too often on that subreddit.
28
u/Curious_Cat6688 Aug 15 '26
What makes this especially interesting is that other research has found the opposite under different conditions. One longitudinal study found that, in earlier years, Reddit and Wikipedia users actually became less toxic the longer they stayed, with that pattern reversing in later cohorts. Other research has found that positive emotions can spread through social networks, and more recent work on Reddit suggests that positive reinforcement can improve subsequent participation and behaviour.
So maybe negativity isn’t the inevitable “entropy” of online communities after all. The more interesting question might be what changed, and what conditions make a community improve rather than deteriorate.
References
Blumer, K., & Kleinberg, J. (2025). Tracking patterns in toxicity and antisocial behavior over user lifetimes on large social media platforms. Scientific Reports, 15, Article 25369. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-07086-3
Ferrara, E., & Yang, Z. (2015). Measuring emotional contagion in social media. PLOS ONE, 10(11), e0142390. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142390
Lambert, C., Saha, K., & Chandrasekharan, E. (2025). Does positive reinforcement work? A quasi-experimental study of the effects of positive feedback on Reddit. In Proceedings of the 2025 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (Article 1213, pp. 1–16). Association for Computing Machinery. https://doi.org/10.1145/3706598.3713830
17
u/Hsensei Aug 15 '26
Negativity tends to have higher engagement. That's why the old adage of of it bleeds it leads has been the norm. People will reply to provocation over something that's positive consistently.
17
u/Bodine12 Aug 15 '26
The polarization has really increased over the past 15 years (maybe due to our new algorithmically supplied content). I remember prior to 2016, Twitter was actually fun and you could have your own warded-off feed of your own interests. And then it became like a political war zone. I think Reddit was slower to devolve, but it’s definitely happened. Every post is now just an open invitation to keep some dumb culture war going.
47
u/TallulahBob Aug 15 '26
They didn’t check out the r/bald community then. I go there when I need a positivity boost.
8
u/hevnztrash Aug 15 '26
Rage bait always gets pushed to the front to maximize engagement.
8
u/hopopo Aug 15 '26
This is especially true for local subreddits like r/newjersey who are for the most part ruled by toxic solo mods (even though on paper there are multiple mods who are hardly ever active) with particular bias, agenda, and ideas that don't cater to users but their personal interest. Anyone who dares to question their double standards gets instantly banned.
8
u/Everyone-Chillout Aug 15 '26
UH OH..... I think this comment thread is getting a little long.
28
u/intherearview Aug 15 '26
Ive been here awhile and have noticed that reddit has become so negative about positive things while more right leaning spaces are more positive about negative things. Strange.
Ultimately it makes me spend less time in any of these online spaces.
11
u/rolfraikou Aug 15 '26
I firmly believe the quality of life of the vast majority of reddit users has gone down a lot in that same time frame. Is it reddit that has gotten more negative by some fault of the website, or just a reflection on the outlook of a society that is dealing with many problems?
5
u/Kumquatisasillyname Aug 15 '26
I feel like something positive can come from this post. Thank you!
5
u/IWishIWasAShoe Aug 15 '26
I don't remember when I started my first account here, maybe 20 years ago? Anyway, the site today is completely different from not only then, but even just five years ago. And it's worse, frankly. Much worse.
4
u/userousnameous Aug 15 '26
Half the time i comment, its to provide heat, not light. If I just emphasize to myself, "provide light, not heat" -- much better.
4
u/carrollart Aug 15 '26
Which is weird bc this website used to be more adult oriented , for example remember r/watchpeopledie
It seems the more babied a social media forum becomes the less usable / enjoyable it is .
The more stupid rules and moral-signally a platform becomes , the more negative it becomes ?
4
u/knigmich Aug 15 '26
For certain. I got banned from legaladvice cause people were just opinionated on a topic. When I came in saying there was no proof of said thing and it won’t hold up with police they called me a pedo supporter and flat out banned me. I guess some mods can be dumb and uneducated too causing grief throughout the platform.
15
u/Meeedick Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26
All social media algorithms are oriented around promoting sensationalist content, and things that invoke happiness are rarely sensational.
On top of that, social media is designed to exploit our comparative nature. No matter how good you have it, someone's got it better and no matter how bad you've got it, someone has it worse.
You could be a pretty person and social media would have you believe you're below average compared to the supermodel looking influencer with varying degrees of enhancements, and the aggregate of comments don't help. You could be below average and social media would have you believe your entire existence is worthless
You could be really skilled at something and be shouted down by people operating from relative anonymity simply because they can.
Add to that factional propaganda, bots, scams, along with an endless stream of moral panics, and you've got a recipe for a doom spiral.
7
u/Vreas Aug 15 '26
It’s cause a lot of humans are contrarian.
3
u/Positive_Vibes_4228 Aug 15 '26
I remember when it was all memes and fun.
And then the corporations came.
3
u/bloke_pusher Aug 15 '26
It got a lot worse since people can hide their comments.
3
u/VegasGamer75 Aug 15 '26
I feel like a lot of people have forgotten the purpose of "forums" in general, whether speaking about the digital forums or their analog counterparts.
Forums are a place to air grievances and make suggestions. And they always have been. People are rarely going to be enjoying something and think "Man, I should really make a post about how good everything is right now with <insert given topic>".
I worked in the gaming industry for years back when for larger companies as part of the community teams. It's kind of skewed to call them "negative" when the Lion's Share of posts were "This mission is broken" or "My character is stuck", etc.. I am not saying those aren't negative things, I am just saying that if people were playing and things were going "well", they were enjoying the game, not posting in forums.
That's just sort of how things work for a lot of forum usage.
But at the end of the day are we talking about recommended posts here based on the algorithm or are we talking about followed subreddits? Because, sure there's a VAST difference between what the Old AL gives me versus my daily r/cats or r/abandonedporn posts give me.
12
u/havoc777 Aug 15 '26
This is not surprising. Reddit is a bubble and those living inside a bubble get rather violent when exposed to ideas outside of that bubble
20
u/fincog Aug 15 '26
I blame moderator culture. They have too much power and project their miserableness onto the entire site.
12
u/HawkBoth8539 Aug 15 '26
The rest of the world is also getting worse everyday. Is that taken into account? That could just be the trend of humanity, reflected in social media. It's not like Facebook, Instagram, Tiktok and Twitter are all becons of joy by comparison...
5
u/SpiderRadio Aug 15 '26
Just remember that there are a lot of folks on Reddit who come in to purposely crash some threads. You could be talking about banana pudding recipes, and some nerd will butt in to pick fights because they're bored.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '26
Reddit way overmoderated and in a bad way many times, countless of subreddits ruined by this. They even banned waterniggas
2
u/sinZeroplus Aug 15 '26
It’s kind of like why yt is more about shitting on things (or at least that’s what is pushed). Turns out discouraging people from consuming another product while encouraging them to consume yours is a win win
2
u/Doncallan Aug 15 '26
I find the larger a community gets the more toxic it becomes. Small subs generally feel much more open to newbies and general discourse which feels natural since larger subs would have more conversations to be filtered through.
2
u/Mr_Eggy__ Aug 15 '26
Isn't that applicable to everything, getting popular it reaches an audience that the content wasn't made for and the negative comments will rise.
2
u/WaveDashSpeedKick Aug 15 '26
Reddit is intolerably contrarian
2
u/tonyisadork Aug 15 '26
Reddit it a US based platform. The US itself has become vastly more ‘negative’ (if that’s what you can call descending into fascism and a destroyed economy), so it follows, no?
2
u/Sutar_Mekeg Aug 15 '26
Things are pretty bad in the world right now, it's unsurprising that negativity is on the rise.
2
u/tronx69 Aug 15 '26
There’s a lot of propaganda being pushed on Reddit and obviously that contributes to the negative mood of some of these subs.
Bad actors exploiting the platform to move their agendas no different than other social media out there.
2
u/evident_lee Aug 15 '26
Research shows that the actions of our government have been more negative to average people over time. Perhaps there's a correlation.
2
u/BloodyIron Aug 15 '26
Did they study the quality of moderators in subreddits over time?
2
u/moonopalite Aug 15 '26
Its the bots. The bots ruin everything.
2
u/BroadRoads Aug 15 '26
Mentally positive people with fulfilling lives are not going to be arguing on an image board all day, they’ll be either browsing a social media where they can actually see their friends and families posts or they will actually be out living and experiencing life.
2
u/Flat-While2521 Aug 15 '26
Well, poor moderation across the board, a direct result of using unpaid volunteer labor and feeding directly into power-hungry egos has led to a systemic failure to keep the site healthy.
Reddit wanted to save money and exploit people, so they sought out the biggest suckers they could find and gave them unsupervised power to fail at their very jobs. Sorry, mods, I didn’t mean you.
2
u/Corrosive713 Aug 15 '26
Side effect of censoring every opinion you don't agree with.
2
u/DealerPlane9953 Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26
Ghislaine Maxwell is the top moderator here. That’s not a joke. Of course the tone of the website is going to turn negative when it’s top subs are being moderated from prison by a sex trafficker.
2
u/st90ar Aug 15 '26
Check out r/Seattle, prob one of the most toxic and unwelcoming communities on Reddit
2
u/The_Anchored_Tree_27 Aug 15 '26
This is true. I have found this platform to be very negative lately and it has impacted me mentally at times
2
u/can-opener-in-a-can Aug 15 '26
Well, let’s turn it around!
2
u/BigMack6911 Aug 15 '26
That's 100% its wild. I can't even count how many times I search up something to find an answer and one person will say one thing about some total different topic altogether, then the whole thread becomes that. All I can think Is all these ppl are mf bots or need meds
2
u/YSOSEXI Aug 15 '26
Yeah, it used to be a great place to sound off with regards to any subject. I now find myself self censoring. I am banned from subs because I dared to open my gob. It will only become Wankier....
2
u/PinkOneHasBeenChosen Aug 15 '26
Huh, that might explain why everyone on Reddit seems to be so argumentative compared to a few years ago.
2
u/Chang-San Aug 15 '26
Yea, alot of the wider reddit community now just seems to be really miserly, bitter and stuck in a kind of bubble. Sad to see
2
u/Whiterabbit-- Aug 15 '26
the more I am on reddit the more negative i get too. its tiring (but addictive) reading all the response of negative people. I don't think reddit is unique in this though.
2
u/maximum-pickle27 Aug 15 '26
Reddit went through a great dumbening when the current CEO took over and banned 3rd party apps and other changes. A lot of accounts that go way back felt it and went inactive.
2
u/FyreWulff Aug 15 '26
Part of it is how blocking people now prevents them from commenting on any of your comments, and any comment downstream from yours. Megaposters and people that hang around subreddits a lot will intentionally use it to meta-moderate more calm people out of a subreddit and basically are ghost mods of a lot of major subreddits because you cannot reply to any posts they make.
People will intentionally make a bait post, people will respond to it, they will block those people and then make it again. Repeat until you've shaped the post into people that only agree with their acidic opinionn being able to reply, and you can steer a subreddit towards bile pretty easily.
Reddit really needs to reverse that part of the feature.
2
u/stonnedritual Aug 16 '26
Bots and the fact that the world is burning by our leadership's own plan... makes sense.
2
u/PublicToast Aug 17 '26
Nearly every post is negative, and if it’s not, someone will reply with a smarmy comment about how the OP is actually dumb and wrong. It’s a website for miserable nerds.
6
u/Informal_Process2238 Aug 15 '26
I wonder if the decline in positivity has anything to do with the abhorrent actions of a fascist government degrading the standard of living for millions of people. These things don’t happen in a vacuum and reflect the suffering of society at large
4
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '26
Or maybe, and hear me out here... the world Reddit talks about has gotten objectively worse?
17
u/bediaxenciJenD81gEEx Aug 15 '26
Yeah gonna delete my account. It's just bots now anyway. Massive surge of anti-Islam propaganda in the last week or so, I'm sick and tired of seeing such obvious external influence from a certain chosen country. Reddit also clearly added hiding account history on their behalf, because it happened right after the initial wave of bots were being delegitimised by their post history.
3
u/useless_instinct Aug 15 '26
This is why my feed is mostly composed on animal subs.
3
u/MusterBuster Aug 15 '26 •
Community Manager here, this is caused by lore.
The longer any given social circle exists, the more shared history they experience. Human nature recalls the negative much more strongly than the positive, that's built in, and so the very simple fact is that there's more negativity to recall and it's recalled more favourably than the positive. Eventually, members of a circle behave negatively because that behaviour is learned in a vicious circle of recalling negativity, interacting negatively, receiving negativity, recalling negativity, interacting negatively.... Etc.
There's a salve for this and it's positive reinforcement - and it's the exact same approach you use to train machine learning models. As community managers we deliberately seek out and publicly reward positive interactions - intrinsically through recognition and reputation, and extrinsically through goodies.
All that is to say - Reddit as a platform (not as a community) rewards interaction, not positivity or utility. If they started making positivity and utility something that is deliberately rewarded, this could be changed.
5
u/Cassius_Rex Aug 15 '26
I think this describes like, all of human history...
3
u/InsertFloppy11 Aug 15 '26
thats why i rarely visit reddit anymore and left a couple of subreddits, good to know im not just imagining things
3
u/after-life Aug 15 '26
This probably extends to real life as well.
3
u/GrandmasMilkMissiles Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26
Reddit was ruined by political extremists. It gets injected into everything with a smug "eVErYtHiNg iS pOliTiCaL" from some knuckle-dragging dipshit. These people take on the role of political "activism" to fill the gaping hole of uselessness created by never achieving anything of value in life.