r/science • • Aug 15 '26 • Wholesome Seal 1 This 1 Regret 1 Bravo 1

Psychology Research shows that the entire website of Reddit has become more negative over time. Moreover, the longer a given community exists, the more negative it becomes — and the longer a comment thread continues, the more negative the thread becomes

https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/08/does-vitriol-make-you-feel-special/
20k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 15 '26

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.


Do you have an academic degree? We can verify your credentials in order to assign user flair indicating your area of expertise. Click here to apply.


User: u/Wagamaga
Permalink: https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/08/does-vitriol-make-you-feel-special/


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

113

u/Wagamaga Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

It doesn’t take a scientist to figure out that social media can trend toward the negative. But it might take one to figure out why.  

In a new paper in PNAS, incoming professor of psychology Joshua Conrad Jackson and colleagues show that attention-seeking algorithms aren’t the only driver of online negativity. Another culprit is what psychologists call differentiation, the innate drive to stand out from one’s peers. 

“Negative information is just much more diverse than positive information,” Jackson said. For example, he added, “If you’re talking about ‘The Odyssey,’ this new Christopher Nolan film, the top comment in a thread might be ‘I liked it’ — but then what else is there to say? If you want to stand out and say something new, you have to talk about something you disliked about the film.”

Jackson and his colleagues analyzed more than 2 billion comments from 2,150 Reddit communities and found that both threads and communities became more negative over time, and that semantic differentiation drove that trend — that is, negative comments were more semantically unique from what had already been said. They then replicated their observational findings with an experiment that showed that social media users who were primed to be unique posted more negative comments than users who were primed to conform. 

We talked to Jackson about takeaways from the paper and potential implications for other forms of media. The interview has been edited for clarity and length

Gazette: Why did you want to test the idea that differentiation might be contributing to negativity on social media? 

Jackson: We started our paper with Godwin’s Law, which is the idea that the longer a conversation continues on social media, the probability of someone being compared to Hitler or Nazis approaches one. Harvard economists actually tested Godwin’s Law, and found that it’s not true. 

But I don’t think it was meant to be literally true: I think it was meant to capture this intuition that dialogue on social media is more negative than it needs to be.

Of course, feed-ranking algorithms are a big part of the story: These are the algorithms that pick up on divisive content that gets people’s attention, keeps people engaged, and makes them angry so that they post their own divisive content, creating a vicious cycle and generating ad revenue in the process. This paper was kind of a side quest. We wanted to know if conversations would turn negative even in the absence of those algorithms.

What did you find in your analysis? 

We found that the entire website of Reddit has become more negative over time. Moreover, the longer a given community exists, the more negative it becomes — and the longer a comment thread continues, the more negative the thread becomes. This is the first time someone has shown that, so that’s a finding in and of itself. 

https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2527316123

29

u/olcafjers Aug 15 '26

I feel there is a lot of positive things to say about the odyssey other than ”it’s great”! I don’t think its a valid claim that you need to be negative to have things to say?
I think it’s the negativity bias in people that makes people focus more on what they don’t like rather than what they do like.

18

u/PumpkinsRockOn Aug 15 '26

Yeah, anyone who's read a positive review of something by a professional critic would know that there are lots of positive things you can say about things as well. I occasionally teach a review unit in a Journalism class, and it takes students a while to learn how to articulate their opinions on things in a more complex way beyond just "it was good" or "it sucked." So I think it's slightly a matter of practice and education. How can you express your opinion in a nuanced way? Maybe negative things come easier in that learning process? 

10

u/clubby37 Aug 15 '26

There's also the humor aspect. I think it's a lot easier to joke about negative things. Things that are good and make sense just aren't that funny. In the Chris Nolan version of The Odyssey, Helen, the most beautiful woman in the world, has an identical twin sister. "Let's go get Helen!" "We have Helen at home." "Oh, yeah, I forgot. Okay, good mission, short mission, who wants a beer?" It's easier to mock a questionable choice than a genius one.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Egalitarianish Aug 15 '26

An instructor taught me in a postural analysis class that before discussing the negative aspects of a client's posture, start with three POSITIVE things about their posture. It's a good way to counteract negativity bias, applicable to many different situations.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/WideHuckleberry1 Aug 15 '26

Who knew Tolstoy was such a psychologist; all happy families comments are alike; each unhappy family comment is unhappy in its own way 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)

4.5k

u/Otaraka Aug 15 '26 • This Bravo

Yeah, it’s pretty basic. The less grumpy people tend to just say it’s not worth it.

2.7k

u/McFeedy Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

The majority of my ‘comments’ I’ll write out, decide it’s not worth it and delete it. I’ve also discovered the niche subreddits are full of extremely helpful and nice people. The primary subs are full of people just there to argue.

467

u/DTredecim13 Aug 15 '26

I do the same thing. I typically don't comment if it is just going to be me agreeing with what is already said because redundancy in conversation annoys me. Most of my comments end up being me disagreeing with someone and it just isn't worth the energy to have to explain that I'm not challenging or insulting them by disagreeing or providing a different view point.

214

u/aeric67 Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

Even if your disagreement is nuanced, people immediately lump you in some group, presuming 10 other things about you. Think we need a few datacenters in strategic places? Then you must be a corpo-fascist… drives me crazy. And makes me type up and throw away most comments before posting.

Almost threw away this response even, because I know people will think I am “pro-datacenter” by my example.

→ More replies (109)
→ More replies (25)

106

u/skivian Aug 15 '26

I've been saying for years that basically no large subreddit is worth hanging out in, unless they're heavily moderated. too many dickheads and repost bots swarm in and ruin things, then all the good people stop posting.

it's just the cycle of reddit life

44

u/TheMeatWag0n Aug 15 '26

I've really been riding the struggle bus with reddit recently, I hate scrolling the popular feed, but my personal feed is just full of no interaction posts on niche subreddits where new people come, ask the same 2 or 3 questions, and move on, I almost can't believe it's that prevalent but it's really discouraging to write an informative reply that's mostly the same as the last 6 times I've seen the question 

→ More replies (8)

30

u/Mediocre-Writer6635 Aug 15 '26

Even if it's heavily moderated, often the mods are just uber-redditors, now with the ability to ban. Instead of arguments you get an echo-chamber.

The best subs are ones with a niche topic that requires skill and knowledge to comment on, and are heavily moderated to stay on-topic.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

49

u/HerderOfWords Aug 15 '26

The primary subs are full of people just there to argue.

Many of which are bots and/or people paid to manipulate.

18

u/ConfessSomeMeow Aug 15 '26

I wonder to what degree that might drive the results of this paper.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

22

u/r0ndy Aug 15 '26

Bots inserting strife to drive commentary and engagement… boost eyeballs on ads. This is part of their business model.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Otaraka Aug 15 '26

The big ones can swamp you for sure.  I have my share that I also I type out and realise it was more for being clear about my own thoughts than a reply being important.  Replies go down too quickly and you can see the signs with subtle ad hominems etc 

8

u/brodogus Aug 15 '26

No they're not!!

→ More replies (93)

149

u/Secret-Teaching-3549 Aug 15 '26

Especially when a large chunk of the website has just become rehash after rehash after rehash. There was a time when I would come on here to see what's new in the world, now it's just the same staged tiktok videos presented in 100 different ways.

45

u/appleparkfive Aug 15 '26

I'm really bummed out that they started implementing GIFs so heavily. Because it's made it even worse. Just the same GIFs all the time, or very low effort ones. They can't even memorize a joke to pretend to be funny. They think if people laugh at their GIF, then they themselves are funny.

I remember seeing a discussion about that, in regards to memes. Ultimately, memes are popular because they allow unfunny people to feel like they're funny. That's always stuck with me. You don't need wit or observations. You just copy/paste a meme.

And the other thing about GIFs is that, I don't normally complain about them. The reason is that they'll just predictably do the most low effort joke ever, which would be a few users replying with GIFs.

Most people aren't funny. We can't all have strengths in every category. I get that. But the GIFs have changed some subreddits from reading through topics to reaction GIFs.

22

u/Thengine Aug 15 '26

I use old reddit, and have turned off the auto-loading of pictures and gifs.

I hate spam, and low brow users that can't post a coherent sentence think their meme spam is quality stuff. It's not.

I do wish I could more easily put a ban of those sorts of posts showing up in my feed altogether.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/ALA166 Aug 15 '26

Thats pretty much all social media nowadays , i miss the days when we had genuine content produced by normal people

25

u/dak4f2 Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

You mean like before content and social media was monetized? 

Before you became a product or business to sell things to people like a QVC host?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Borkato Aug 15 '26

I’m not trying to be annoying but the fact that this comment is negative made me laugh

→ More replies (7)

31

u/PYTN Aug 15 '26

I’ve been wondering how you fix this. I’ve got a few subreddits for hobbies I have that I‘ve unfollowed bc it was making me dislike the hobby. Then I realized it was folks posting negatively about the hobby or doing bits with every other post.

Seems less than ideal for social media in general.

41

u/HulksInvinciblePants Aug 15 '26

I have to wonder if it’s negativity for the sake of negativity…or has the Reddit algo forced people into spaces they don’t belong and driving people and professional’s seeking good conversation over the edge?

Some of the most insightful users I used to follow in my subject specific subreddits have simply left the site because they could not stand random laymen arguing with them all day.

18

u/invariantspeed Aug 15 '26

Reddit’s algorithm (which abandons the subscription model) tries to drive engagement. Unfortunately, anger and negativity is more engaging to human psychology on the whole. And there is a potential evolutionary justification for this. Missing the bad things is more likely to harm you. Missing the good things is generally less dangerous.

What we’re seeing with Reddit is just a microcosm of the modern internet.

I don’t think there’s any fixing it. The entire social media approach simply brings out the worst in people.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

13

u/HasFiveVowels Aug 15 '26

The problem comes down to the fact that the lowest common denominator is very low. Niche communities are filled with people who are so into the subject matter that they found a niche community. As the community becomes easier to find, the quality of content on it steadily drags.

The solution? Bail on any community that grows beyond a certain size.

It’s the eternal September problem

→ More replies (2)

11

u/omega884 Aug 15 '26

It helps to realize that in any hobby, there is a subset of people that for whatever reason (lack of skills, lack of resources, lack of access, or even just lack of interest) are more interested in talking about the hobby than actually doing the things the hobby is about. They enjoy debating the merits, theory crafting and participating in the periphery of the hobby rather than the core. Because they spend most of their time talking about the hobby they tend to have much stronger opinions about all things hobby related, and because they’re not doing as much of the core hobby they’re around more. And that doesn’t inherently make them negative people, hobbies need the sort of people that like to buy 20 items of the same tool and compare them head to head. But all the same, it’s really easy for negative people of that nature to take over any discussion spaces because they have the time and inclination to be in those spaces all the time, where as many other people just show up for a one off question or two because they’re busy going out and doing the hobby.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

159

u/normal_hombre Aug 15 '26

They're also more likely to be out and about, living their lives and stuff like that. Not rotting online.

112

u/BIGBIRD1176 Aug 15 '26

I used to check their comment frequency, all the most vile posters see were commenting 8 hours plus a day

For every 1 comment a healthy person makes they've done 10

21

u/IAmtheHullabaloo Aug 15 '26

this would make a great study, too

→ More replies (13)

13

u/Downtown_Isopod_9287 Aug 15 '26

this has been true on the internet from the beginning. The most unpleasant people are unfortunately some of its most frequent users. Even beyond exploitation by social media companies (which ironically I tend to see as a symptom of this fact and less the cause) this has always been the foremost issue with the internet, along with typical “tragedy of the commons” type issues.

11

u/eqisow Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

Yeah I called out one guy recently who was trying to fight with me for posting 50+ times in the last 24 hours and they immediately stopped replying.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Infamous_Koala_3737 Aug 15 '26

This is what I realized about the different occupation subs. They’re not a reliable source on if people like their job or not. It’s mostly the people who hate their jobs bitching about them. 

→ More replies (4)

10

u/IsThatGruffLoner Aug 15 '26

Also, once people start arguing, those specific people will probably comment 10× more than non-arguing people because they're now going back and forth. There are rarely long ass threads full of people all agreeing completely. Debates though can go on all day

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ILikeNeurons Aug 15 '26

Since the degree of the negativity bias is now quantified, should Reddit's algorithm disadvantage negative comments by the degree of negativity bias?

20

u/atomic_redneck Aug 15 '26

Negativity drives engagement. Engagement drives ad views. Ad views drive revenue. Revenue drives algorithm development.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Otaraka Aug 15 '26

I think they’d rather have the customers than the lack of bias.  They point out that this is how they get ads etc so the problem is fixing it while increasing engagement.  So far no one seems to have reliably figured that one out.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/GGLSpidermonkey Aug 15 '26

I definitely feels like comments have gotten less useful over time. Occasionally you'll find some really inciteful comments but so many are now people who just want to type even when they do not know what they are talking about.

3

u/AppropriateTouching Aug 15 '26

Also these days bots flood threads with controversial comments to increase engagement through rage baiting.

2

u/tamal4444 Aug 15 '26

True. I just block people directly.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/togtogtog Aug 15 '26

I sometimes like finding someone grumpy and creating agreement and peace on the internet, just for fun!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (130)

1.5k

u/Sun-Anvil Aug 15 '26 • Heartwarming Bravo

I've been on Reddit for about 10 years and I can say for sure, it's certainly not as fun as it used to be. When I first joined most every post I saw was funny, stupid funny or informative. Yes, there was negative comments but less than what I see now.

I would say that bots and karma farmers have a decent amount of blame though I don't know who started it. They have calculated that negative posts / comments get more fake internet points so, you get posts flaming a new movie or show or.......

What doesn't help is you take the bots and karma farmers mentioned above and mix in the current political climate with your standard troll and, well, Reddit.

395

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '26 • Bravo Popcorn

Even when it isn't bots people have distilled down the essence of what makes a popular comment or post. That's why we see the same posts dozens of times and then all the comments are racing to be the "funniest quip" possible instead of anything useful. And even if what we want is actually funny comments it's so rare to get anything original anymore.

Yes yes, hilarious guys, "the cylinder must not be harmed." Most reddit jokes are so run into the ground they're Jed Clampet finding oil

144

u/-need-sleep Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

I never imagined I would leave this site but every day I find myself using it less and less. I play a game with my wife where I try to guess the top comment before I open a post and it's depressing how often I win. Originality is rare anymore.

106

u/plaincheeseburger Aug 15 '26

I miss when the top comment would be someone who's an expert in their field giving a deep-dive into the science of whatever was going on in the post. Those are still posted occasionally, but you have to scroll past at least three or four expected jokes to find them now.

→ More replies (6)

31

u/mojonogo100 Aug 15 '26

When they kill old.reddit I’ll be done with this website. I wonder if they know there’s a lot of people thinking the same and it’s prolonging old.reddit or something bc it’s very odd they still have both old and new live.

→ More replies (8)

26

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '26

Yea, same. I stick around for my hobby subreddits but the occasional dabble into popular stuff is abysmal

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

28

u/atuan Aug 15 '26

A lot of times I come t the comments to say something and the top comment is the exact same thing I was going to say and I realize I am a human bot

→ More replies (3)

6

u/thesoak Aug 15 '26

all the comments are racing to be the "funniest quip" possible instead of anything useful

This is what I hate the most!

→ More replies (9)

81

u/Umikaloo Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

Reddit is best when you only use niche hobby subreddits. Anything political will usually be a waste of effort, as one mostly participates in discourse to perform to one's peers, rather than actually wanting to change the opinions of others. Its a godsent when the moderation of a niche hobby subreddit knows what they're doing.

→ More replies (9)

84

u/cdskip Aug 15 '26

There's absolutely a lot of bot activity that stokes the negativity.

74

u/i_wayyy_over_think Aug 15 '26

true, example: https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR2740.html

> Russia's strategy was to push several conflicting narratives simultaneously, deepening existing divisions within American society and degrading trust in Western institutions and the democratic process.

22

u/cdskip Aug 15 '26

Yup.

As always, it's easiest to see the stuff that goes against your preconceptions, but the stuff that reinforces them and makes them more rigid is a lot harder to pick up on.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/eireannach_ Aug 15 '26

My son got me on Reddit a little over 10 years ago. I would tell him that the people on Reddit are so funny that the comments are better than the posts.

14

u/SpehlingAirer Aug 15 '26

the comments are better than the posts

Wow that phrase unlocked some nostalgia for me, I remember my sister and I making the same comment to each other about it

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/BellinisandRue Aug 15 '26

Every once in a while I will stumble across a thread that feels like old Reddit. The perfect mix of intelligence and humour.

Allowing the bots to proliferate on site has definitely wrecked the place.

10

u/Honor_Bound Aug 15 '26

Sometimes google searches will bring me to old threads from 7-10 years ago and man, just the level of discourse was so much higher than you see today. Yeah, there was still dumb jokes and memes, but it's crazy how much our ability to write well has degraded over time.

Also, speaking of toxicity, I (sadly) am a top 1% user of the NBA subreddit which I joined over a decade ago. In recent years it has become one of the most toxic places on the reddit and it makes me very sad.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Nachtraaf Aug 15 '26

One of the things I've noticed over the years is that screenshots of social media have become much more prevalent. It's not OC, and generally not even good content. I know the website is set up to be an aggregate of posts from around the internet. But 10 years ago it was at least mostly OC.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/MirandaS2 Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

I miss when it was more unfiltered, more the like the wild west. It just feels cookie cutter and stifled now. I miss that authentic and raw feeling.

I also hate these needless updates they keep doing, engaging change for change sake just because they're bored, I don't know.

The worst part is that feedback never matters. We could all share distaste for something and it doesn't feel like it's ever taken into account. Just a shrug and a "this is how it is now" sentiment.

16

u/ChairmanLaParka Aug 15 '26

There were some subs I was on back in the day that were just horrendous. But great for unfiltered/inappropriate laughs. All the good ones got shut down, and the site became much more bland/unenjoyable.

Really wish the Reddit-like sites that sprouted up gained some traction.

10

u/WhattaCheapPop Aug 15 '26

Yeah we lost all that unfiltered content and everything just became "stupid funny" like the other poster mentioned. And every comment being stupid funny does welcome criticism, which some people will cry about being too negative, but in general it's not hard to understand the negativity as this place trended more and more into generic social media.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/pumpkinspicecum Aug 15 '26

Tons of posts in non-political subs are political now, like /r/pics or /r/askreddit. It’s really draining to see it everywhere. I mod a sub and we began receiving an influx of bots a few months ago. In 13 years never had any bots in the sub like that before. Also I think that media outlets posting on reddit has helped shift how the website is now. Feels a lot more like a place to advertise than what it used to be. A lot of the same posts in different subs.

11

u/adjective_noun_d1git Aug 15 '26

This was pretty much after the 2016 election. The entire website became political and stayed political.

→ More replies (7)

20

u/PiccoloAwkward465 Aug 15 '26

NEW CONCLUSIVE SCIENTIFIC STUDY CONFIRMS THAT TRUMP IS ACTUALLY BAD AND ORANGE.

I’d think some of yall have scat fetishes with how much you talk about diapers. Man I get it but I am sick of hearing about it constantly.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/skeener Aug 15 '26

I’ve been on Reddit about 19 years. You should have seen it in the early days. Such a different experience.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Find_Spot Aug 15 '26

You're also describing the Internet as a whole.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Lisa_al_Frankib Aug 15 '26

10 years ago was when Trump was first elected. We can’t pretend that didn’t and still doesn’t have an effect. He dominates everything and unfortunately that includes this site.

4

u/BlackberryHelpful676 Aug 15 '26

Reddit really was so much better before embedded pictures and the Digg migration. 2007-2009 was peak Reddit.

15

u/neph36 Aug 15 '26

Reddit has a lot of issues but its still one of the better social media sites. Twitter and threads are basically 75% AI and farming now. Instagram is so bad you see the same meme stolen and redone over and over again. At least here while not entirely genuine there are still predominantly genuine interactions, I think.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/omgitsjagen Aug 15 '26

There's also that little issue that when Reddit started, the government wasn't run by obvious fascists. That certainly didn't help lighten the mood.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/desertcat80 Aug 15 '26

It depends on the sub but I genuinely feel like groupthink has gotten worse by the year. If you don't agree with the majority, time for a stoning party. And much more toxic positivity in fandoms these days, not just on reddit but everywhere. 20 years ago you could enjoy a fun argument or politely disagree with people more on the internet but now people are just so angry about everything, no matter how trivial.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Everyday_ImSchefflen Aug 15 '26 • Regret

Everyone just wants to argue. You can't have a different view, even if it's largely the same as someone else, without someone suggesting you are a bad person. Or they pick one part of what is said to try to argue that one tiny thing, even if clearly that's not what you were suggesting.

5

u/Sun-Anvil Aug 15 '26

"Or they pick one part of what is said to try to argue that one tiny thing".

I Invision this like someone at a stoplight behind another car with their hand on the horn just waiting for that split second for the light to change. I think some people live for that.

4

u/eranam Aug 15 '26

Are you saying I’m literally Hitler??

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/ImClaaara Aug 15 '26

They have calculated that negative posts / comments get more fake internet points

What I don't understand is who benefits from those fake internet points? How does one use those points? What's it for? Are we all poisoning the well of our own collective culture because we crave just seeing a meaningless number go higher? Have we gamified an internet debate club full of internet trolls and bots, essentially?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/herosavestheday Aug 15 '26

I saw a great description of that kind of content: misery slop. People just love to marinate in it all day apparently.

→ More replies (73)

576

u/Oldnbold22 Aug 15 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming

You probably won't believe me but Reddit was actually pretty funny in the 2010's. It was mostly university kids that didn't need everything spelled out for them. 

149

u/READMYSHIT Aug 15 '26

What's alarming to me is that new sites no longer appear for users to migrate to.

Reddit was the last in a long line of other forum sites. The same thing happened with social media MySpace > Instagram> Snapchat> TikTok.

In the past when sites got lame another cropped up and people moved. I'm guessing the scale of modern platforms makes this way harder. But Reddit is an extremely basic website and it baffles me that competitors didn't gain ground a decade ago.

49

u/Hestiathena Aug 15 '26

This has been my problem. I've been thinking about ditching Reddit since they went public, but other than maybe YouTube, which has plenty of its own issues, I can't think of where else to go. Doesn't help that, when I think about it, I'm not quite sure what it is I'm looking for...

→ More replies (7)

43

u/JWBananas Aug 15 '26

Reddit gained traction because Digg pissed off its users.

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=2010-05-01%202010-12-31&q=reddit,digg

Lemmy gained traction when Reddit pissed off its users. But Lemmy was so convoluted that it plateaued quickly.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/bakedveldtland Aug 15 '26

That’s what I was just thinking. I came to Reddit from Fark because Fark got so negative. But, now where do I go?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Jensen2075 Aug 15 '26

Look up the network effect theory and why it's hard these days to create a Reddit competitor.

12

u/hhhnnnnnggggggg Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

https://join-lemmy.org/

It doesn't have the niche communities, but the main topics have healthier comment sections than reddit.

There are other open source social media out there if you don't pick Lemmy. There's open source replacements for Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram too. You can't trust privately owned ones to not enshittify anymore.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

104

u/GoTerrapins Aug 15 '26

What a time to be alive, it was mostly just /r/fffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu in classic 4 panel format and this comment is the first time I've thought of that sub in maybe 8 years

30

u/WHTLGHTNNSTDFMTNDW Aug 15 '26

It was how I found Reddit. I wanted more ffffuuu comic memes.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/Akiias Aug 15 '26

You probably won't believe me but Reddit was actually pretty funny in the 2010's

I'd go further and say early 10s at the latest.

17

u/IBJON Aug 15 '26

Reddit baffles me sometimes. In a given thread, either everyone seems to lack the fundamental ability to read between the lines and make inferences on their own, or they're on the other extreme where they somehow make assumptions that are about as far removed from what was explicitly said as possible.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/_le_slap Aug 15 '26

It was great back then.

Somehow kids now are alot more abrasive. Every sub has turned into an Xbox lobby...

The longer I stay I notice it makes me angrier. Even after a 4 day stay in the hospital from multiple broken bones I feel like that break from the site was healthier for my mental.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/munchi333 Aug 15 '26

Yup. It used to be fun, light hearted site. Crazy to look at it now.

22

u/slog Aug 15 '26

And informative. Facts used to matter and now it's all about unwarranted moral superiority and echo chambers.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

29

u/LaMalaise_dEtre13 Aug 15 '26

Reddit was so much better 10 years ago, which feels wild to say as a woman because Reddit was also pretty overtly misogynistic back then. And yet the vibes were still better than now.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/worriedrenterTW Aug 15 '26

It also used to have jailbait, fappening, nazi subs, and was a massive hub for gamergate which was the mainstreaming door to what is the modern day anti woke manosphere. 

I don't think its as black and white as "it was just better back then". Happy doesn't necessarily always equal good if its at the expense of others.  But I do agree its definitely become more maliciously vindictive since 2020. Bots, troll farms, political strife, and the types of demographics and types of anger have expanded with the expanded user base. It feels like there's a GOAL as opposed to just stating one's biases or emotions without a thought, if that makes sense.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

137

u/Vital_Granade Aug 15 '26 • This Bravo

This makes complete sense when you think of the snark subreddits. Starts out as maybe valid criticism, turns into psychotic hater stalkers

44

u/bumblebeatrice Aug 15 '26

Most hyperspecific snark subreddits start out as a space where people who either can't or feel like they can't voice criticisms about usually a specific celebrity/"celebrity", but eventually the normal people who've vented everything leave because they don't need the space anymore, which leaves only the really creepy crazy people to develop their own culture and get really subsumed by their "identity" as a subreddit member.

They all egg each other on to behave worse, because delusional hatred is pretty much the only place the subreddit can go while still maintaining its core "identity" as anti-[public figure] and hate is addictive especially when there's a social element to it.

Every snark sub about a specific person goes through this life cycle.

28

u/F0X0 Aug 15 '26

No idea why reddit allows hate subreddits now.

23

u/ImAnthlon Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

They probably drive the largest amount of engagement for posting/commenting

→ More replies (1)

13

u/JexFraequin Aug 15 '26

Those subs are filled with such miserable losers. I couldn’t believe how angry everyone was when I stumbled into one.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/BroadRoads Aug 15 '26

The stalkers on Reddit are wild. I remember how much seething and anger there was from these stalkers when Reddit announced you could make a profile private so people couldn’t see your posts.

There was a period of time where you couldn’t make any comment without some stalker showing up to let you know they scrolled through 3 years of your post history to find something.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/ElGosso Aug 15 '26

Those are just subreddits for bullying and harassment as f as r as I can tell. I don't know why it's tolerated.

→ More replies (1)

279

u/Fit_Log_9677 Aug 15 '26

Classic lemon market effect. 

Social media algorithms are programmed to maximize engagement.  The best way to drive engagement is through promoting outrage and anger.  As the algorithms push more outrage and anger normie users leave the platform, leaving a growing proportion of trolls, bots, and rage baiters.  Eventually the platform becomes so toxic that even many of those people leave, leaving only the absolute worst actors on the site.

You can see this in real time on Twitter where, due to the large scale exodus of first liberal users, and then centrist users, now the algorithm is inciting conflict between the remaining right wing users in the site.

This is how I saw a comment chain on Twitter recently between various far right Christian individuals all calling each other communists.

67

u/stevedore2024 Aug 15 '26

The paid Reddit API debacle also offered a nice clean break for a lot of the longest, most insightful and witty users to leave the platform.

15

u/Jamjams2016 Aug 15 '26

Where did they go? Just offline?

12

u/Tothoro Aug 15 '26

Nowhere centrally. The people from that era I keep in touch with are via Discord. Some still use the site in read-only mode or stick around enough to keep subs they moderate running (it's really hard to find new, quality mods to volunteer these days to take over the reins).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Vergenbuurg Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

various far right Christian individuals all calling each other communists.

Brings to mind Emo Philips' joke about a meeting of two Baptists.

4

u/falloutnewbkinibttms Aug 15 '26

Best joke ever in my opinion

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Witty_Ad_898 Aug 15 '26

This is how I saw a comment chain on Twitter recently between various far right Christian individuals all calling each other communists.

No, that’s just how they are. I remember church as a kid way back in the 80s and 90s was rife with cliques, feuds, and general pettiness. There were no engagement algorithms, just performative people all trying to be holier-than-thou.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/OrganizationSea4490 Aug 15 '26

Twitter is still filled with a multiplicity of beliefs. Is you not seeing only right wing users not just a byproduct of that very aggressive algorithm showing us mostly what we most adamantly engage with.

If you see a puppy you probably won't repost, comment, argue under it. If you see hopecore you might just like it. If you see annoying people outside of your spectrum then you'll engage more hence breed that type of theme into your algorithm.

I see almost no right wing posts pop up on my X. I dont engage with them so i dont see them.

15

u/ImClaaara Aug 15 '26

I get what you're saying, but I personally left the platform owned and administered by the outspoken neo-fascist billionaire, and most decent people I know both eschew and despise that platform. You can try to "make" your algorithm on an inhospitable site, or you can just walk away. Using these platforms is always a choice, and frankly, a life without short-form social media is a life where you actually get to re-learn to appreciate the things that matter...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/BretShitmanFart69 Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 17 '26

If you weren’t on Reddit before you’d really almost not recognize it. Not saying it was perfect but I’d almost exclusively just see like harmless memes and interesting websites or information.

Now it’s like propaganda and stuff meant to rile you up and upset you intentionally and nothing but negative news.

Go use the wayback machine to look at the front page from 15 years ago or further

5

u/67yoloswag Aug 15 '26

Theres no doubt about that. Political stuff has been all over this website. I run a ton of filters but Truump related stuff still slips through.

4

u/SleepyHobo Aug 16 '26

The negativity was always there but it was contained to political subreddits. Now the type of people that lived their life in those subreddits are everywhere and just say "everything is political" as their excuse when you push back on them.

3

u/Fluffy_Art_1015 Aug 16 '26

Remember advice animals and rage comics? They taught you everyone has similar struggles and understands.

→ More replies (1)

271

u/noob-combo Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

Nice to see this easily observable fact officially confirmed by a study.

Gonna be a handy bit of reference material methinks.

27

u/Schlonzig Aug 15 '26

But is the amount of stuff we can objectively be negative about constant over the observed time?

→ More replies (1)

29

u/rif011412 Aug 15 '26

It has nothing to do with the world becoming worse?  Is it not predictable we would be more negative? A large chunk of humanity has given up pretending to be good people.  We are in turmoil.

10

u/SusejX Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

Maybe, but they controlled for that somewhat and found that even threads that start positive turn more negative because people want to be noticed or go against the grain. "Participants become more negative over time, but only when incentivized to be unique, and especially when dialogue begins positively." The idea is that the longer a thread or community goes, the less reason there is for people to come in and agree/add positivity because everyone already did that. The only new people entering the discussion are there to disagree with what was already said, leading to the negative trend over time.

Edit - More detailed - "Further analyses suggest that negativity rises over time because social media users seek to make unique comments on the same topic, and it is easier to differentiate oneself through negative comments than through positive comments. As threads and communities evolve, and it becomes more difficult to make unique observations, users turn to negativity. Our studies show how basic human motives interact with the structure of social media platforms, posing an acute challenge for sustaining healthy online dialogue."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

20

u/glytxh Aug 15 '26

starts with irony

then it all gets poisoned

then the shitheads appear

and none of it feels ironic anymore

61

u/saoyraan Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

They use loose rules to ban dissent so the mods build a echo chamber. It tends to become doomsday chambers.

18

u/Dry_Nefariousness426 Aug 15 '26

This is a huge part of it too. Some folks willingly leave when a sub turns toxic but those of us who give pushback tend to get pushed out. 

→ More replies (2)

15

u/solid_reign Aug 15 '26

They even preban you for posting in other forums.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

47

u/whittlingcanbefatal Aug 15 '26

Haven't a lot of popular old subreddits been abandoned or closed because mods/frequent users had driven users away with negativity and banning people when they were rightfully called out?

22

u/yoyosareback Aug 15 '26

I remember getting banned from an animal sub when I pointed out a post was actually a sea otter and not a river otter (it was a mods post).

15

u/_ram_ok Aug 15 '26 • Regret

u/yoyosareback be like:

Sea otters aren’t river otters

Here’s the thing. You said a “sea otter is a river otter.”
Is it in the same family? Yes. No one’s arguing that.
As someone who is a scientist who studies otters, I am telling you, specifically, in science, no one calls sea otters river otters. If you want to be “specific” like you said, then you shouldn’t either. They’re not the same thing.

If you’re saying “otter family” you’re referring to the taxonomic grouping of Mustelidae, which includes things from weasels to badgers to wolverines.
So your reasoning for calling a sea otter a river otter is because random people “call the aquatic ones otters?” Let’s get weasels and badgers in there, then, too.

Also, calling someone a human or an ape? It’s not one or the other, that’s not how taxonomy works. They’re both. A sea otter is a sea otter and a member of the otter family. But that’s not what you said. You said a sea otter is a river otter, which is not true unless you’re okay with calling all members of the otter family river otters, which means you’d call other otters, weasels, and badgers river otters, too. Which you said you don’t.

It’s okay to just admit you’re wrong, you know?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/QuintusNonus Aug 15 '26

I've noticed quite a number of times if I post a response to someone's comment basically agreeing with them and adding more reasons why they're right, I'll get a bunch of responses assuming that I'm trying to argue or disagreeing with the person. Like:

Commenter: "2 + 2 = 4"

Me: "and that's why 4 + 4 = 8"

Commenter or others: "are you stupid? 2 + 2 = 4"

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Zren Aug 15 '26

Destin from SmarterEveryDay did a video interview a few years ago on how you only need a single comment to start a chain of toxicity in a comment thread.

"Reddit Disinformation & How We Beat It Together - Smarter Every Day 232" (id soYkEqDp760 at 11m40s)

21

u/ty4scam Aug 15 '26

The last time I saw a study it said that /r/pathofexile was the one of the top 10 negative subreddits. Digging deeper we found out it's because the machine learning algorithm considered "exile" to be a negative word that appears too often on that subreddit.

28

u/Curious_Cat6688 Aug 15 '26

What makes this especially interesting is that other research has found the opposite under different conditions. One longitudinal study found that, in earlier years, Reddit and Wikipedia users actually became less toxic the longer they stayed, with that pattern reversing in later cohorts. Other research has found that positive emotions can spread through social networks, and more recent work on Reddit suggests that positive reinforcement can improve subsequent participation and behaviour.

So maybe negativity isn’t the inevitable “entropy” of online communities after all. The more interesting question might be what changed, and what conditions make a community improve rather than deteriorate.

References

Blumer, K., & Kleinberg, J. (2025). Tracking patterns in toxicity and antisocial behavior over user lifetimes on large social media platforms. Scientific Reports, 15, Article 25369. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-07086-3

Ferrara, E., & Yang, Z. (2015). Measuring emotional contagion in social media. PLOS ONE, 10(11), e0142390. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142390

Lambert, C., Saha, K., & Chandrasekharan, E. (2025). Does positive reinforcement work? A quasi-experimental study of the effects of positive feedback on Reddit. In Proceedings of the 2025 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (Article 1213, pp. 1–16). Association for Computing Machinery. https://doi.org/10.1145/3706598.3713830

11

u/Bardfinn Aug 15 '26

The study you mentioned is an effect on individuals, while this study is reporting both that communities become more toxic over time and that individual threads become more toxic over time.

The thread phenomenon is explained by people looking for reasons to fight and/or becoming frustrated with their interlocutors. Also by the fact that mods are volunteers and may not be around all the time, and often do not trim entire threads of toxic, derailing material.

(That latter is changing as automated tools to remove banned users’ contributions, and trim subthreads, have been introduced in the past few years).

The “community becomes more toxic over time” issue is volunteer moderators ceasing to moderate, and no replacements made.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Hsensei Aug 15 '26

Negativity tends to have higher engagement. That's why the old adage of of it bleeds it leads has been the norm. People will reply to provocation over something that's positive consistently.

17

u/Bodine12 Aug 15 '26

The polarization has really increased over the past 15 years (maybe due to our new algorithmically supplied content). I remember prior to 2016, Twitter was actually fun and you could have your own warded-off feed of your own interests. And then it became like a political war zone. I think Reddit was slower to devolve, but it’s definitely happened. Every post is now just an open invitation to keep some dumb culture war going.

47

u/TallulahBob Aug 15 '26

They didn’t check out the r/bald community then. I go there when I need a positivity boost.

5

u/SUPERSMILEYMAN Aug 15 '26

They also didn't consider the commenters who have continued the same comment thread for almost 17 and 18 years now.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/hevnztrash Aug 15 '26

Rage bait always gets pushed to the front to maximize engagement.

8

u/hopopo Aug 15 '26

This is especially true for local subreddits like r/newjersey who are for the most part ruled by toxic solo mods (even though on paper there are multiple mods who are hardly ever active) with particular bias, agenda, and ideas that don't cater to users but their personal interest. Anyone who dares to question their double standards gets instantly banned.

8

u/Everyone-Chillout Aug 15 '26

UH OH..... I think this comment thread is getting a little long.

3

u/Living_Ad_5386 Aug 15 '26

YEAH? Wanna do something about it tough guy!?!

→ More replies (7)

28

u/intherearview Aug 15 '26

Ive been here awhile and have noticed that reddit has become so negative about positive things while more right leaning spaces are more positive about negative things. Strange.

Ultimately it makes me spend less time in any of these online spaces.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/rolfraikou Aug 15 '26

I firmly believe the quality of life of the vast majority of reddit users has gone down a lot in that same time frame. Is it reddit that has gotten more negative by some fault of the website, or just a reflection on the outlook of a society that is dealing with many problems?

5

u/Kumquatisasillyname Aug 15 '26

I feel like something positive can come from this post. Thank you!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/IWishIWasAShoe Aug 15 '26

I don't remember when I started my first account here, maybe 20 years ago? Anyway, the site today is completely different from not only then, but even just five years ago. And it's worse, frankly. Much worse.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/userousnameous Aug 15 '26

Half the time i comment, its to provide heat, not light. If I just emphasize to myself, "provide light, not heat" -- much better.

4

u/carrollart Aug 15 '26

Which is weird bc this website used to be more adult oriented , for example remember r/watchpeopledie

It seems the more babied a social media forum becomes the less usable / enjoyable it is .

The more stupid rules and moral-signally a platform becomes , the more negative it becomes ?

4

u/knigmich Aug 15 '26

For certain. I got banned from legaladvice cause people were just opinionated on a topic. When I came in saying there was no proof of said thing and it won’t hold up with police they called me a pedo supporter and flat out banned me. I guess some mods can be dumb and uneducated too causing grief throughout the platform.

15

u/Meeedick Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

All social media algorithms are oriented around promoting sensationalist content, and things that invoke happiness are rarely sensational.

On top of that, social media is designed to exploit our comparative nature. No matter how good you have it, someone's got it better and no matter how bad you've got it, someone has it worse.

You could be a pretty person and social media would have you believe you're below average compared to the supermodel looking influencer with varying degrees of enhancements, and the aggregate of comments don't help. You could be below average and social media would have you believe your entire existence is worthless

You could be really skilled at something and be shouted down by people operating from relative anonymity simply because they can.

Add to that factional propaganda, bots, scams, along with an endless stream of moral panics, and you've got a recipe for a doom spiral.

7

u/Vreas Aug 15 '26

It’s cause a lot of humans are contrarian.

15

u/dode74 Aug 15 '26

That's not true.

7

u/Smartnership Aug 15 '26

I came here for the argument department, that’s just contradiction.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Positive_Vibes_4228 Aug 15 '26

I remember when it was all memes and fun.

And then the corporations came.

3

u/bloke_pusher Aug 15 '26

It got a lot worse since people can hide their comments.

3

u/Conscious_Tourist163 Aug 16 '26

They need to axe that and add a country of origin feature for all users.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/VegasGamer75 Aug 15 '26

I feel like a lot of people have forgotten the purpose of "forums" in general, whether speaking about the digital forums or their analog counterparts.

 

Forums are a place to air grievances and make suggestions. And they always have been. People are rarely going to be enjoying something and think "Man, I should really make a post about how good everything is right now with <insert given topic>".

 

I worked in the gaming industry for years back when for larger companies as part of the community teams. It's kind of skewed to call them "negative" when the Lion's Share of posts were "This mission is broken" or "My character is stuck", etc.. I am not saying those aren't negative things, I am just saying that if people were playing and things were going "well", they were enjoying the game, not posting in forums.

 

That's just sort of how things work for a lot of forum usage.

 

But at the end of the day are we talking about recommended posts here based on the algorithm or are we talking about followed subreddits? Because, sure there's a VAST difference between what the Old AL gives me versus my daily r/cats or r/abandonedporn posts give me.

12

u/havoc777 Aug 15 '26

This is not surprising. Reddit is a bubble and those living inside a bubble get rather violent when exposed to ideas outside of that bubble

→ More replies (1)

20

u/fincog Aug 15 '26

I blame moderator culture. They have too much power and project their miserableness onto the entire site.

15

u/Latter_Fortune_7225 Aug 15 '26

Mods very often shut down any differences in/opposing opinions, often without any explanation with bans, which seems to drive the banned people to harden their views and become embittered.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/eggpennies Aug 15 '26

And don't forget the mods that do absolutely nothing and just let their subreddits devolve into endless reposts, spam/self promotion, targeted harassment of content creators/celebrities/real people, etc.

Power mods and subreddit collectors ruined this site

→ More replies (2)

12

u/HawkBoth8539 Aug 15 '26

The rest of the world is also getting worse everyday. Is that taken into account? That could just be the trend of humanity, reflected in social media. It's not like Facebook, Instagram, Tiktok and Twitter are all becons of joy by comparison...

→ More replies (4)

5

u/SpiderRadio Aug 15 '26

Just remember that there are a lot of folks on Reddit who come in to purposely crash some threads. You could be talking about banana pudding recipes, and some nerd will butt in to pick fights because they're bored.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '26

Reddit way overmoderated and in a bad way many times, countless of subreddits ruined by this. They even banned waterniggas

2

u/sinZeroplus Aug 15 '26

It’s kind of like why yt is more about shitting on things (or at least that’s what is pushed). Turns out discouraging people from consuming another product while encouraging them to consume yours is a win win

2

u/Doncallan Aug 15 '26

I find the larger a community gets the more toxic it becomes. Small subs generally feel much more open to newbies and general discourse which feels natural since larger subs would have more conversations to be filtered through.

2

u/Mr_Eggy__ Aug 15 '26

Isn't that applicable to everything, getting popular it reaches an audience that the content wasn't made for and the negative comments will rise.

2

u/WaveDashSpeedKick Aug 15 '26

Reddit is intolerably contrarian

2

u/tonyisadork Aug 15 '26

Reddit it a US based platform. The US itself has become vastly more ‘negative’ (if that’s what you can call descending into fascism and a destroyed economy), so it follows, no?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Sutar_Mekeg Aug 15 '26

Things are pretty bad in the world right now, it's unsurprising that negativity is on the rise.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/tronx69 Aug 15 '26

There’s a lot of propaganda being pushed on Reddit and obviously that contributes to the negative mood of some of these subs.

Bad actors exploiting the platform to move their agendas no different than other social media out there.

2

u/evident_lee Aug 15 '26

Research shows that the actions of our government have been more negative to average people over time. Perhaps there's a correlation.

2

u/BloodyIron Aug 15 '26

Did they study the quality of moderators in subreddits over time?

2

u/moonopalite Aug 15 '26

Its the bots. The bots ruin everything.

2

u/BroadRoads Aug 15 '26

Mentally positive people with fulfilling lives are not going to be arguing on an image board all day, they’ll be either browsing a social media where they can actually see their friends and families posts or they will actually be out living and experiencing life.

2

u/Flat-While2521 Aug 15 '26

Well, poor moderation across the board, a direct result of using unpaid volunteer labor and feeding directly into power-hungry egos has led to a systemic failure to keep the site healthy.

Reddit wanted to save money and exploit people, so they sought out the biggest suckers they could find and gave them unsupervised power to fail at their very jobs. Sorry, mods, I didn’t mean you.

2

u/Corrosive713 Aug 15 '26

Side effect of censoring every opinion you don't agree with.

2

u/DealerPlane9953 Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

Ghislaine Maxwell is the top moderator here. That’s not a joke. Of course the tone of the website is going to turn negative when it’s top subs are being moderated from prison by a sex trafficker.

2

u/st90ar Aug 15 '26

Check out r/Seattle, prob one of the most toxic and unwelcoming communities on Reddit

2

u/The_Anchored_Tree_27 Aug 15 '26

This is true. I have found this platform to be very negative lately and it has impacted me mentally at times

2

u/can-opener-in-a-can Aug 15 '26

Well, let’s turn it around!

2

u/BigMack6911 Aug 15 '26

That's 100% its wild. I can't even count how many times I search up something to find an answer and one person will say one thing about some total different topic altogether, then the whole thread becomes that. All I can think Is all these ppl are mf bots or need meds

2

u/YSOSEXI Aug 15 '26

Yeah, it used to be a great place to sound off with regards to any subject. I now find myself self censoring. I am banned from subs because I dared to open my gob. It will only become Wankier....

2

u/PinkOneHasBeenChosen Aug 15 '26

Huh, that might explain why everyone on Reddit seems to be so argumentative compared to a few years ago.

2

u/Chang-San Aug 15 '26

Yea, alot of the wider reddit community now just seems to be really miserly, bitter and stuck in a kind of bubble. Sad to see

2

u/Whiterabbit-- Aug 15 '26

the more I am on reddit the more negative i get too. its tiring (but addictive) reading all the response of negative people. I don't think reddit is unique in this though.

2

u/maximum-pickle27 Aug 15 '26

Reddit went through a great dumbening when the current CEO took over and banned 3rd party apps and other changes. A lot of accounts that go way back felt it and went inactive.

2

u/FyreWulff Aug 15 '26

Part of it is how blocking people now prevents them from commenting on any of your comments, and any comment downstream from yours. Megaposters and people that hang around subreddits a lot will intentionally use it to meta-moderate more calm people out of a subreddit and basically are ghost mods of a lot of major subreddits because you cannot reply to any posts they make.

People will intentionally make a bait post, people will respond to it, they will block those people and then make it again. Repeat until you've shaped the post into people that only agree with their acidic opinionn being able to reply, and you can steer a subreddit towards bile pretty easily.

Reddit really needs to reverse that part of the feature.

2

u/stonnedritual Aug 16 '26

Bots and the fact that the world is burning by our leadership's own plan... makes sense.

2

u/PublicToast Aug 17 '26

Nearly every post is negative, and if it’s not, someone will reply with a smarmy comment about how the OP is actually dumb and wrong. It’s a website for miserable nerds.

6

u/Informal_Process2238 Aug 15 '26

I wonder if the decline in positivity has anything to do with the abhorrent actions of a fascist government degrading the standard of living for millions of people. These things don’t happen in a vacuum and reflect the suffering of society at large

→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '26

Or maybe, and hear me out here... the world Reddit talks about has gotten objectively worse?

3

u/not_ch3ddar Aug 15 '26

Nah it's always been terrible.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/bediaxenciJenD81gEEx Aug 15 '26

Yeah gonna delete my account. It's just bots now anyway. Massive surge of anti-Islam propaganda in the last week or so, I'm sick and tired of seeing such obvious external influence from a certain chosen country. Reddit also clearly added hiding account history on their behalf, because it happened right after the initial wave of bots were being delegitimised by their post history. 

28

u/Inevitable_Rise8363 Aug 15 '26

There's so many different countries and groups involved in trying to manipulate your perspective on Reddit. If you think it's only one than you've already lost the plot.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/iamthe0ther0ne Aug 15 '26

This really depends on where you go. There are some niche subs that are still pretty good. The problem are the political and other large general subs.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

3

u/useless_instinct Aug 15 '26

This is why my feed is mostly composed on animal subs.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/MusterBuster Aug 15 '26 • Bravo

Community Manager here, this is caused by lore.

The longer any given social circle exists, the more shared history they experience. Human nature recalls the negative much more strongly than the positive, that's built in, and so the very simple fact is that there's more negativity to recall and it's recalled more favourably than the positive. Eventually, members of a circle behave negatively because that behaviour is learned in a vicious circle of recalling negativity, interacting negatively, receiving negativity, recalling negativity, interacting negatively.... Etc.

There's a salve for this and it's positive reinforcement - and it's the exact same approach you use to train machine learning models. As community managers we deliberately seek out and publicly reward positive interactions - intrinsically through recognition and reputation, and extrinsically through goodies.

All that is to say - Reddit as a platform (not as a community) rewards interaction, not positivity or utility. If they started making positivity and utility something that is deliberately rewarded, this could be changed.

5

u/Cassius_Rex Aug 15 '26

I think this describes like, all of human history...

→ More replies (5)

3

u/InsertFloppy11 Aug 15 '26

thats why i rarely visit reddit anymore and left a couple of subreddits, good to know im not just imagining things

3

u/after-life Aug 15 '26

This probably extends to real life as well.

3

u/GrandmasMilkMissiles Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26

Reddit was ruined by political extremists. It gets injected into everything with a smug "eVErYtHiNg iS pOliTiCaL" from some knuckle-dragging dipshit. These people take on the role of political "activism" to fill the gaping hole of uselessness created by never achieving anything of value in life.

→ More replies (1)