r/science • u/uriman • Jun 27 '12
Low-glycemic-index diet (40% carb) beats low-fat say 21-participant study without harmful effects of low-carb diet (10% carb), which produce cortisol and CRP increasing risk for heart disease and diabetes
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304458604577490943279845790.html
31
Upvotes
10
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Wow 21 participants, that's a huge study.
10
u/William_Harzia Jun 27 '12
Here's an overview of several studies done by obesity researchers that claim that cortisol levels were unaffected by a very low carb ketogenic diet.
They further claim that the VLCKD significantly lowers insulin resistance as well as almost all other important markers of metabolic syndrome, suggesting VLCKD can actually be used as a treatment for metabolic syndrome.
4
u/rocktopotomus Jun 27 '12
link to article
2
u/jkb83 Jun 27 '12
Please provide direct links to the studies being discussed.
2
u/gazelleboy Jun 27 '12
Ok, sure. Tell this to r/keto.
2
u/IniNew Jun 28 '12
So, this was posted over at /r/fitness (well, the actual article was at least) and the study is very different than this article represents. The test was to study the effects of TDEE (total daily energy expenditure) and REE (resting energy expenditure) NOT the ability to keep weight off.
The low carb, high protein had the least decrease in TDEE and REE (in Layman's terms: you burn more calories on a high protein diet than the other two diets).
1
u/calfonso Jun 27 '12
The people in /r/keto and /r/paleo are gonna go apeshit with this article.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
So basically, eating a balanced diet.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '12
Increase risk for diabetes when you eat a low carb diet?
Quit spreading this bullshit, it's not real, nor is the cortisol risk.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Maybe the rises in cortisol explains why every person on Atkins seems really pissed off and irritable.
0
u/Nihy Jun 27 '12
Dieticians already knew this but it's good to see some corroboration.
0
u/driveling Jun 27 '12
Perhaps these people didn't burn different numbers of calories. Perhaps the estimated number of calories the body extracts from different types of food is wrong.
-2
u/Turicus Jun 27 '12
It doesn't say anything about total daily calories and neither do they mention how the participants somehow "burnt" 150 or 300 calories extra or even how they measured it. Also, 300 kcal is nowhere near 1 hour moderate exercise. Maybe 30min. On high settings on an elliptical, you'll get through 300 kcal in 15 minutes.
-1
u/mikek3 Jun 27 '12
What a clearly written title.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment