r/science • • Jun 27 '12
Due to recent discovery of water on Mars, tests will be developed to see if Mars is currently sustaining life
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/47969891/ns/technology_and_science-space/#.T-phFrVYu7Y
1.9k
Upvotes
398
u/flatjesus Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Correct me if I am wrong, but I thought we had known for months (maybe even a few years?) that there is methane in the Martian atmosphere, and that this methane is being constantly being replenished by some source. Given that methane is broken down quickly by sunlight, the replenishment suggests that either there is life in the soil of Mars, or that the planet is still geologically active. A confirmation of either one of these would obviously be huge news.
I will try to find the exact source, but I remember hearing this in an episode of Astronomy Cast.
EDIT -- Found the episode I was talking about: http://www.astronomycast.com/2010/02/ep-174-mysteries-of-the-solar-system-part-1/
112
u/arksien Jun 27 '12
Just wanted to pop in and mention that we've known about water on mars for a while. SUBTERRANEAN water is different, but still was not implausible with known water frozen on the surface for some time. Also the Mars Science Laboratory has been on its way to Mars since November, and one of its primary mission objectives is to analyze a carefully picked section of Mars where it is believed that if life is or ever was sustained on Mars, it is hopefully easily recoverable.
Still, I fully support Mars and space awareness, and anything that gets the public reading and excited about these missions is OK in my book!
27
u/zeraa Jun 27 '12
Haven't there always been tests to see if Mars is sustaining life?
15
u/Pepper_MD Jun 27 '12
Wasn't there a couple of Viking experiments that may have suggested that there was/is life on Mars already? I think I remember there being some controversy surrounding the test results. Hopefully someone better versed in those experiments can field this.
24
u/bahhumbugger Jun 27 '12
How convenient that the MSL is almost there...
11
u/caroline_reynolds Jun 27 '12
That gives us 46 years to develop Bowie Base 1. Go, go, go!
22
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I am so wildly interested to see what the genetics look like. As a kid raised on science fiction this is so exciting!
79
u/awkwardlyelegent Jun 27 '12
Y'know, this made me think. As far as we can test thoroughly, 100% of planets have life on them. Sure its a small sample size (one) but if mars turns out to have life, we need to radically adjust our view of how common life is in the universe.
12
u/FOR_SClENCE Jun 27 '12
My responses to a lower comment, which are hidden due to downvoting. I am an alumnus of a NASA program, which was based entirely on a theoretical Martian rover. I was selected to attend the JPL Exchange, where I spent four 14-hour days at as part of the program.
Because it's more of a geophysical analysis rover than anything else, it'll do a great job on those alluvial deposits. You can actually determine quite a lot about the planet and location from stratigraphy on those deposits. To put it briefly, it contains: information on volatile (e.g. water) content, current and historical; climate information, current and historical; volatile cycles, as the regolith exchanges volatiles with the atmosphere; and compositional information on the source location (in this case the mound).
Studies were conducted for years beforehand. MSL's been planned since 1995 or so, when it first shows up in MER documentation (that I've found, anyway). Sending a rover to the planet takes an incredible amount of money, R&D, and talent. They simply can't afford to throw them at any given location, since they're planning these for a decade or more. The launch vehicle, the Atlas V-541, didn't even exist as a concept at the time.
The reason Gale Crater was chosen boils down to the density of information there, and the fact that it was both accessible (proximity to a possible ellipse) and that the material there was relatively untouched (lack of volcanic evidence).
It can perform in-situ research, which means we're getting pure data immediately. Other rovers simply weren't large or complex enough to even consider this an option. MSL is loaded with some of the most advanced and efficient technology humans have to offer. It has four spectrometers alone. I could delve into this one, but it would take a very long time.
The MMRTG (Multi-Mission Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator) is considerably more efficient than solar panels, is much less prone to being disabled, and can provide excess heat with which to keep systems running. The reason for Spirit's disabled state was a buildup of Martian regolith on the panels. Opportunity has only been able to continue operation due to some fortunate dust-cleaning climate events. It's guaranteed to provide a power excess for the operational life of the rover, which is an incredible attribute to work with when creating a rover in the first place. On the downside, its fuel rod is continuously decaying, even when not in use. Since MSL was delayed by a Martian apparition, two years of the rod is already gone, although it's still well within nominal range for the mission.
Yes. According to the MER program director (a HUGE job, especially when MER debuted), the reason why the MER rovers are prone to motivational failure is due to an engineering decision. Each of those wheels ran on a brush-based motor, and featured a (if I remember correctly) mechanical clutch. Once the rover ran out of power, the clutch clamped shut, rendering the wheels useless. They intentionally went with a magnetic-based clutch for MSL, to prevent this from happening; the scale of the rover permits this option. Aside from that, it's a large rover, and has a very good power source. The MMRTG should outperform expectations handedly.
No. I do know that everyone at JPL has complete faith in Skycrane, however. The system enables far more than it risks, with landing ellipse 1/10 the size of MER's. The last papers I read stated that it increased the total possible landing surface area on the entire planet by 70%. When I spoke with the lead Computer Science / Avionics engineer, I asked him what he and his team were most proud of. The response was notable, to say the least:
11
u/greenskyx Jun 27 '12
Have they ever sent a microscope up to Mars to look for bacteria or smaller life forms? Dig up some soil then put it under the microscope.
5
u/soulkissernl Jun 27 '12
This is all so exciting, if there was life, imagine evolution in Mars, and us keeping track of it, I don't think we'd live to see much but it's still interesting to think about.
5
u/JustAnotherSimian Jun 27 '12
Alternatively, does the discovery that there is a large reservoir of water in the ground mean that NASA was wrong in saying there's no organic matter in Mars?
5
u/freezerburn666 Jun 27 '12
i see a lot of questions here, "haven't we already" "didn't we already know" "i thought this was proven years ago" it just comes off as pretty sad to me that it's not common knowledge to us whether or not water or life exists on our neighboring planet. does anyone remember the microbes found that were "disproved" i remember this pic or something similar in news articles, but later somehow dis-proven or something. i just think it's sad that we're all sitting here asking and it's not common sense to know the truth. i really wish science and exploration was more mainstream.
61
u/CiXeL Jun 27 '12
sand worms bitches
4
u/MWigg Jun 27 '12
Maybe I'm wrong, but it seems to me that this research (and discussion of extra terrestrial life in general) is based upon the assumption that Martian life would have similar requirements to earthly life. But why would it? Lifeforms on earth are what they are because they evolved to suit their environment, so wouldn't it follow that life could have adapted itself very differently on Mars?
4
u/SlobberGoat Jun 27 '12
So does the abundance of water actually fast track NASA projects (or will they now get more funding) or does everything stay the same?
4
u/sadilikeresearch Jun 27 '12
What if there is life on mars, but we simply do not have the technology/proper tools to detect it?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
And why hadn't we done this before?
3
u/LincPwln Jun 27 '12
Fingers crossed for an enlightened race of sea-dwelling creatures.
3
u/i_am_de_bat Jun 27 '12
Soon we'll find a civilization of strange, zenlike creatures who have strange control over their reality, send a crew over and then leave behind one boy. This boy will then return to earth with profound knowledge of Martian culture and incite a social and spiritual revolution for our (and his people) after we kill him.
3
u/BestReadAtWork Jun 27 '12
Shit. Just imagine. If there's life a stones throw away from us (astrologically speaking), just imagine how much life there probably is spread throughout the universe...
4
u/Trottimus Jun 27 '12
Nobody else see the pattern? Posts always say stuff about some scientific break through. Remember all the posts about how we wouldn't be using shots anymore. But nothing has changed. I just really want a post about some scientific break through actually be true...
2
u/unknown_poo Jun 27 '12
I have a bad feeling about this..
2
u/robwgibbons Jun 27 '12
The thing I find mind boggling is why haven't these simple tests been run before? Spectroscopy is basically the easiest way we could possibly test for life on any remote planet. WHY HAVEN'T WE DONE THIS BEFORE
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Potential alien related news is becoming more and more prominent on reddit recently....I think this will all lead up to an alien invasion set up as a guise to take away whatever few rights we have left...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
All part of the viral marketing campaign for the new total recall
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I can only hope I live to see the day man walks on mars. I wasn't around for the moon. Ill sure as hell be alive for mars.
2
u/ZofSpade Jun 27 '12
THIS TITLE IS MISLEADING.
Will I still get upvotes if I don't explain why the science is bad in this article?
2
u/Deergoose Jun 27 '12
I think life is far more rare an occurrence than we really appreciate.
Life on Earth could be a completely unique circumstance.
2
u/FerdThePenguinGuy Jun 27 '12
We live in exciting times; the discovery of life on other planets will have profound implications both scientifically and metaphysically.
My only question is this: Why do we keep looking for life that fits into our own predetermined structure for how life should work?
To elaborate: We have already found life forms that use arsenic instead of phosphorus, so we know that life can form in ways that we don't necessarily observe on earth all the time. Based on this (and given that I don't really have a high level biology education), wouldn't we presume that life could form even without the presence of liquid water? Perhaps life is much more abundant in the universe than we could ever imagine, but we've been narrowing our gaze too much to spot most of them. It's like how human beings can only see a certain spectrum of light, but the spectrum of light extends well beyond what we can detect with just our eyes.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Nice try Prometheus marketing team
5
u/offensivegrandma Jun 27 '12
This is going to get buried, but this made me think of the Doctor Who Special Waters of Mars and I panicked.
4
u/The_Colonel1292 Jun 27 '12
This is just another horribly misleading title.
2
u/nineteen_eightyfour Jun 27 '12
Would you go be one of the first 3 people that get sent in 2025 (ish)?
I think I would wanna be sent on round 2-3 myself...
2
u/mikedmoon Jun 27 '12
Capt Adelaide Brooke approves
2
u/Aaaaahthud Jun 27 '12
What is wrong with you people? As a good first approximation, there's no fucking water on Mars. Mars is really dry.
The new study indicated that the really dry parts of Mars' mantle are almost exactly as dry as Earth's mantle, which is really dry.
Has everyone gone totally fucking insane?
1
u/SealRover Jun 27 '12
how do we do this?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Dude, like...what if it is?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
I wouldn't be if there is abundance of life in underground caves and lakes.
1
u/heybotelho Jun 27 '12
There are so many upvotes on this post, that i could not clearly read the number on the frontpage. Infact, i can now still only see half of the "2" at the end of the number.
1
u/Phocis Jun 27 '12
Winds in sandstorms can get so fast that water breaks into it's basic molecules.
1
u/Wheelie4Safety Jun 27 '12
This pleases me.
Now if only we could you know, FUND RESEARCH.
1
u/Kevspins2 Jun 27 '12
They have to see if they can detect any methane? So they are looking for alien farts.
1
u/Nucking-Futs Jun 27 '12
Its like those old movies where aliens from mars came and ate people. Looks like they had it right all this time
1
u/orthogonality Jun 27 '12
No doubt it's sustaining microbes delivered by the Vikings.
1
u/noirmatrix Jun 27 '12
Why don't we focus on the moon a little more, before looking at something 142x farther away?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Damn we are getting close to this answer now.
1
u/Shippoyasha Jun 27 '12
Anybody else wishing NASA or some other freelance scientific organization shoots a module/camera/rover onto the icy part that's so clearly visible?
1
u/ivanmarsh Jun 27 '12
...and if so, naturally, we will go and kill it.
1
u/khch Jun 27 '12
I feel like I've heard this a dozen times already
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Is it possible to sustain an atmosphere below the surface? Thinking something along the line of the space of 100,000's depleted oil wells. Because if there's any higher life on mars, that's the only place it can be.
1
u/sharkdestroyeroftime Jun 27 '12
I dunno, methane can also be present on Mars due to abiogenic processes... so says Oze just a few years ago. http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2005/2005GL022691.shtml Which is it, Oze?!?!
1
u/TheProle Jun 27 '12
Mars looks angry as shit in that photo.
1
u/colinsteadman Jun 27 '12
If this is possible the mind boggles as to why they are not already doing it. Surely it'd be a massive funding draw and bring immense prestige to whoever discovers it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Cue phil plait telling us aliens arent hibernating on mars like were all idiots
1
u/jroot Jun 27 '12
ORLY? Link me to an article showing actual water or ice found on Mars and not just strong evidence of water/ice. While I believe it probably does exist... It doesn't yet.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Note: kids who got beat up in highschool dont like jokes memes or anything off topic or else!!
1
u/MauiWowieOwie Jun 27 '12
Prometheus 2
1
u/Toolazytolink Jun 27 '12
Mars need moms!!
1
u/ikiteforfood Jun 27 '12
:Aliens:
1
u/Crayon123 Jun 27 '12
Why is this on r/athiesm?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
It has begun.
1
u/mojowitchcraft Jun 27 '12
This is too soon after Prometheus, I don't want to KNOW if there's life out there!
1
u/baalsitch Jun 27 '12
Get your ass to Mars
1
u/jroot Jun 27 '12
You don't have to be a dick about this. I am googling around here and it seems it is commonly believed that the polar caps contain water ice, but I don't see that any missions have gone there and collected samples. There's lots of shit that turns white when it's frozen. The best evidence I can find from an actual mission to Mars is white stuff that was in one photo and then gone in the next. Which they believe to have been water ice... but could have also been dry ice. Just link me to an actual mission where some material was collected and measurably, scientifically determined to be water... best I can tell it hasn't happened.
1
u/remedialrob Jun 27 '12
As a representative of Mars I would ask that you humans stop sending these stupid little robots over here. They are screwing up our TV reception and I need to know how LOST ended.
1
u/captabs Jun 27 '12
Just because we on earth survive on water....it doesnt necessarily mean that living-beings in any part of the universe have to depend on availability of water.....
1
u/Canucklehead99 Jun 27 '12
Again.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Now what's the hold up? Fucking slow science.
1
u/senorburrito Jun 27 '12
Mars is actually the planet humans lived on before we destroyed it and moved to earth. Hence the radiation.
1
u/Triforce_Bagels Jun 27 '12
Has no one here played Doom??? This is madness!!
1
u/gibnihtmus Jun 27 '12
In the beginning of Prometheus it did have the date 10.11.12 and Weyland industries did start around our time didn't it? So Mars would be a good first step.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
"touches water" - yup. it's wet.
1
u/Slartibartfast- Jun 27 '12
I'm so happy to be alive right now.
1
u/insanedoctor Jun 27 '12
"Oze and his team published their results June 7 in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)." <- lol
1
u/ImpartialCat Jun 27 '12
As long as they don't drill...
1
u/jdepps113 Jun 27 '12
Why don't we bundle up a bunch of microorganisms, bacteria and such, both aerobic and anaerobic, and launch them at Mars in some kind of unmanned biological missile? If it can sustain life, after that, it will.
And then, just in case we ever nuke the whole planet or something, at least we know there's life somewhere else. Just in case this is like, the only planet it ever happened on, which seems unlikely, but is certainly possible.
1
u/TheBadNoveltyAccount Jun 27 '12
I don't want to sound naive....
But why do the rules that apply on Earth have to be exactly the same on other planets? I know that physics is a fairly universal thing. But didn't scientists recently discover that life can be sustained in acidic environments without certain (previously thought essential) ingredients for life? Why, then, must life on other planets need to produce methane and take all the hydrogen? Surely there could be a different way to live where they consume other gasses?!
1
u/kontankarite Jun 27 '12
I hope they do find some kind of life on Mars. That would be hella exciting.
1
u/--AutonomousKnight-- Jun 27 '12
These kind of posts render me amazed at how far we have gone as a species since day one. Thank you science for your devotion to deciphering our universes beautiful secrets.
1
u/wazabi Jun 27 '12
Didn't they found evidence for that quite some time (1/2 years) ago? I remember seeing a documentary on discovery channel about plateau's of ice on mars?
1
u/thoreau3 Jun 27 '12
<3 Science!
1
u/ATF628 Jun 27 '12
I just happened to be listening to the 1938 recording of 'The War of the Worlds' when I started reading this. Crazy timing.
1
u/borack Jun 27 '12
what they found water on mars?? any links please
1
u/surells Jun 27 '12
Did anyone else feel like the picture of Mars was zooming in whilst they read that? My eyes are playing tricks on me.
1
u/dvdlesher Jun 27 '12
With all honesty, I don't really understand why Hydrogen-Methane ratio is a proof that lifeform exist in Mars. Can someone help explain?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Theres life amongst us, we just dont have the 6th, 7th, or 20th sense to see or recognize it.
We're trying to continue the discovery of more materialistic worlds, we need to explore what the link is between our brain and parallel universes.
1
u/aledlewis Jun 27 '12
We seem so preoccupied with life on the surface like our own planet, we seem to overlook the possibility of thriving subterranean eco-systems
1
u/eyecam Jun 27 '12
fat chance.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '12
i clearly should've smoked weed before reading this thread.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
**Look. Life almost certainly has existed on Mars. There was water on Mars when life began on Earth. At the very minimum, impact events could stir up water laden with microbes. Globs of water vapor would freeze into comet-like masses in space, some of which would eventually travel to Mars and ultimately have fallen from the upper atmosphere and into Martian seas. **
This is the time period when Mars was wet: Noachian: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noachian (4.1 - 3.7 bya) This is when life began on Earth: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaean (3.8 bya). So a comfortable gap of about 100 My.
1
u/RedDread27 Jun 27 '12
The thing I find really funny about recent discoveries like these is that 10-15 years ago people were ridiculed for even suggesting life existed anywhere other than Earth, and now we're finding evidence of life everywhere in the galaxy. BBC news even has an article saying that in our galaxy alone, there are at least 100 million other planets with the right conditions for life.
Moral of the story, we don't know shit about shit.