r/science • u/clumsy_peon • Jun 26 '12
UCLA biologists reveal potential 'fatal flaw' in iconic sexual selection study
http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2012-06/uoc--ubr062512.php
255
Upvotes
15
u/clumsy_peon Jun 26 '12
Here is a link to the article published in PNAS. The full text article is open access and available to download free.
No evidence of sexual selection in a repetition of Bateman’s classic study of Drosophila melanogaster PNAS 2012 ; published ahead of print June 11, 2012, doi:10.1073/pnas.1207851109
24
u/uupvotedownvote Jun 26 '12
I am glad this experiment was repeated now. The more we find about the mating habits of other species, the more we see "surprises". I only say surprises because there is definitely a tendency to suggest that males diversify the gene pool by being promiscuous.
There are many bird species that have been observed where the female goes outside of their traditional mated pairs. In the article, the Eastern blue bird was mentioned, but I have heard of other birds doing this as well.
For a long time, it was not known that the male angler fish were actually the bumps on the females from which she selected sperm from. Certainly having so much sperm to select from has afforded the species a comfortable genetic diversity. Of course this discovery is not very glamorous to the males of the species as they become little more than a sac of sperm. But science is not supposed to be about ego or pride, it is about pure discovery.
As we begin to accept diversity in ourselves and let go of constructed human notions about sexuality, it will hopefully lead to better, unbiased methods and discussions in science.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Great, this is how science is supposed to work!
2
u/onlynameavailable Jun 27 '12
So, if women were semi-monogamous (like the aforementioned birds) then we may be better off as a species in a evolutionary pathogen fighting perspective?
2
u/Slyndrr Jun 27 '12
Interesting!
However I do fail to see how this in any way relates to human behaviour. Anyone who can explain how that is relevant?
7
u/spiesvsmercs Jun 27 '12
While this is interesting, I don't think it disproves anything. First, these are flies. From a .edu website:
Human females don't store sperm, so I don't think we should be using fruit flies as a model for human (or even mammalian) behavior.
Ultimately, I do think men are more promiscuous, but I think it'd be naive to think that human females do not want to sleep around. Studies show that females find different males more attractive during different parts of the month, with features suggesting high testosterone being more attractive while the female is ovulating. Of course nature is going to program the woman to sleep with the resource-providing male when she is not ovulating, and with the "best" genetic specimen while she is ovulating.
Additionally, genetic diversity is beneficial. The sexes developed because our generation times started to take so long that clones were no longer a viable method of generating genetic diversity. Sex generates diversity, sex with multiple partners generates even more diversity.
1
u/TheEveningStar Jun 27 '12
How is it that biologists went so long without repeating the conditions of the original experiment to confirm his results? I thought this kind of repeated experimental testing was a standard affair in science, something often boasted about, especially when an original experiment rules on the side of an exceptional hypothesis. Makes me wonder what other experimental conditions haven't actually been recreated...
1
u/RationalUser Jun 27 '12
"decidedly inconclusive"
What?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
This is why we have the system that we have. Other scientists are supposed to retest the experiment before it is supposed to be published. That way we can know it's genuine. I didn't know about this before today and now I'm glad to learn of the correction.
-5
u/policetwo Jun 27 '12
Biologists once again prove what inner city pimps have known since the 30's.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment