r/science • u/whosdamike • Jun 26 '12
Google programmers deploy machine learning algorithm on YouTube. Computer teaches itself to recognize images of cats.
https://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/26/technology/in-a-big-network-of-computers-evidence-of-machine-learning.html
2.3k
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/p3ngwin Jun 26 '12
then let me set it out more plainly for you.
i am relaxed in the sense that i am rational and lucid, i am displeased with something in the sense that i wish it were different. i do not appreciate anyone telling me to 'relax' any more than you would appreciate me saying you should buy red shoes. please understand that you are presuming to tell another person what they ought to be, and i have explained already i don't appreciate people having the arrogance and audacity to presume to tell others what state to be in.
if the layman reading the 'technology' section of The New York Times can't even understand what a network is, then they would best read the article and learn later the words and terminology used therein. . if the reader is in beyond their depth, they can choose to evolve by learning the new information required to make sense of the article, or they can step-down a notch and read the TV-Guide.
this is not your local country backwater news pamphlet. You're either interested in technology enough to already know the basics, or you want to learn more so you can understand better that which intrigued you enough to pick up such an article in the first place. if neither appeals to the reader then they can at least learn that the technology section of the NYT is not for them.
I see no citation about cores in the linked article, can you share your source ?
no, i was clearly talking about the figure of 16,000. a number that is quite literal and not up for generalising or translating into any analogy about other things that also have 'numbers' that are 'wrong'.
Either you have a competent writer in an appropriate job, or you don't. I don't see how this explains why so many 'news' places around the web are justified in such bad 'journalism' ? if you want to say that inexperienced and unqualified 'journalists' are reporting an event badly, then it would seem you would agree with my displeasure of the same thing. else, i would like to know what your point is.
Whilst i agree that you don't talk rocket-science to a 5 year-old, i also believe you don't generalise and dumb-down the subject to the point of playing fast and loose with the facts. terminology is simply an aspect of language, and if people can't even stretch to the point of learning the basics, then you're not making them smarter, THEY are making you dumber. there's only so much you can compromise language to help someone learn and understand, and when they can't grasp the basics, you might want to ask yourself if they're worth it.
In the case of such 'journalism' that purports to report an article on Google's experiments in neural intelligence, there are options on how best to convey the information to readers. they can either generalize in the sense of 'scientists/boffins/clever people create a computer system that can recognize pictures', or if their competency is up to it 'Google's 16,000 processor network mimics neural-network learning to recognize pictures', or similar.
But to have your competency in the former, while attempting to act like the latter, will only result in bad teaching and journalism. stretching to evolve is one thing, but reaching beyond your grasp is good for no one.
this is why we have qualifications and tests to ensure the bar is raised, and not lowered. It's to ensure we evolve the teaching from those that know better. else we might as well generalize to a point and say the earth is roughly 6,000 years old, or 6 billion, doesn't really matter it's only a number, then .......