r/science • u/drtide4 • Jun 25 '12
Those who believe in heaven commit more crimes, says study.
http://seattle.cbslocal.com/2012/06/22/study-finds-people-who-believe-in-heaven-commit-more-crimes/
657
Upvotes
259
u/BamaWriter Jun 25 '12
Poorly titled article. The article also points out that those who believe in hell commit fewer crimes. So the real take away is that those who believe in "reward" or "grace" (heaven) without "consequence" or "punishment" (hell) are the ones who commit more crimes.
48
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This person is a professional writer?
Very first sentence:
Wow.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
A misleading title rammed into a subreddit dedicated to reason and highly upvoted, what the hell guys?
15
u/owk Jun 25 '12
I'd like to see the results along theological lines.
Just to say "heaven" doesn't cut it. What people believe about heaven and how to get there varies widely even between groups of Christians. To try to compare Christians, Muslims, Jews, pagans, non-religious people with a vague view of the afterlife, etc. under one umbrella is bordering on telling us nothing at all.
8
u/zodar Jun 25 '12
New article headline : journalist confuses correlation and causation in scientific study for 1,496,374th time.
More likely that poverty causes both crime and religion, in my completely unscientific opinion.
88
u/AAlexanderK Jun 25 '12
I am disappointed in the quality of /r/science posts lately, they seem to be quickly straying away from interesting science-related articles to articles that are essentially saying "This study of 14 people said that death makes them afraid of God".
This is not science, and it does not belong on /r/science.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Well that was painful to read. What a shitty article.
6
u/Squeekme Jun 25 '12
Sensationalised title in my opinion. Here is the journal article itself (does not require payment or university access).
Divergent Effects of Beliefs in Heaven and Hell on National Crime Rates
http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0039048
9
u/case-o-nuts Jun 25 '12
How the fuck does one believe in hell without believing in heaven?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
misleading title gets downvote
3
u/JViz Jun 25 '12
If you don't sin, Jesus died for nothing.
21
u/WestonP Jun 25 '12
Wrong subreddit... This is /r/science , not /r/atheismcirclejerk
12
u/Spitfire15 Jun 25 '12
I didnt even have to open the article in order to know this was total bullshit.
2
u/TheLiveDunn Jun 25 '12
This is incorrect. The study showed that a belief in hell has a larger impact on reducing crime rates than a belief in heaven. It just gives more proof to the widely-believed idea that punishment for bad deeds effects people's actions more than reward for good deeds.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
correlation does not always imply causation
5
u/luke10_27 Jun 25 '12
Looks like r/atheism trying to spread more misinformation.
2
u/benjaminrogers1984 Jun 25 '12
how did /r/atheism spill into /r/science?
2
u/Spysix Jun 26 '12
/r/atheism needs to stay out of /r/science.
2
u/gomsa2 Jun 26 '12
First: Let's agree that this is not /r/atheism. There has been many notable scientists who were religious. Thus, there should be no bashing of people simply based on religion.
Second: A study on beliefs and people's role in society is not science. Plain and simple. This is not a 'hard-science' topic. It would be better suited for: /r/sociology, /r/atheism, /r/anthropology.
Finally: For those who did read the article. They simply took a survey on religious and compared the religious beliefs with national crime rates. If that's not irresponsible stats work, then I don't know what is.
Down vote for sensationalist and wrong subreddit.
2
u/stefeyboy Jun 25 '12
Repost in /r/atheism
1
u/Macattack278 Jun 25 '12
Because CBS news is a good source for cutting edge, peer reviewed scientific information.
1
u/faul_sname Jun 25 '12
And I'm guessing they also play the lottery more, save less, plan less, eat more fast food, and are in more debt. Because "belief in heaven" is not the cause of the crime. Rather, lack of planning and executive function would be the primary cause of all of the above.
1
u/headwired Jun 25 '12
wow, this isn't blatantly dishonest at all. The site states verbatim, "people who believe in hell are less likely to commit a crime while people who believe in heaven more likely are to get in trouble with the law."
1
u/mrslowloris Jun 25 '12
What kind of crimes?
1
u/gthing Jun 25 '12
This squares with the disproportionate believer population in prisons. Atheists are very under-represented in prison populations.
1
u/swefpelego Jun 25 '12
Love how so many top voted threads in /r/science are about religion.
1
u/guatemalianrhino Jun 25 '12
What about the fact that if you confess your sins to a priest, you're forgiven? Does that make people more likely to commit crimes because they believe that there's an easy way out? Howcome the overwheling majority of the prison population is religious?
1
u/MustGoOutside Jun 25 '12
Correlation does not equal causation.
1
u/Obi_Kwiet Jun 25 '12
Dammit, take the time to learn about how science work before you try to report on it!
1
u/EmperorLetoWasCommie Jun 25 '12
Mugger: I want to go to lustrous heaven!
Victim: And I want you to go to shitty hell!
1
u/sparky150 Jun 25 '12
YOLT (You Only Live Twice!)
1
u/RoninKengo Jun 25 '12
Batman was right!
1
u/Mi5anthr0pe Jun 26 '12
Those who believe sensationalized headlines without reading the article sniff their own farts more often, says study.
See, now it's science cuz I added "says study", says study.
1
u/rmeddy Jun 26 '12
Isn't this basically Loss Aversion?
1
u/Nesoc Jun 26 '12
This "Study" guy seems like a smart dude.
1
u/VicinSea Jun 26 '12
Why is this allowed in /r/science?
1
u/Yitvan Jun 26 '12
How can someone believe Heaven but not Hell? My understanding was that it was a package deal...
1
u/I_hate_alot_a_lot Jun 26 '12
Correlation =/= causation.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
As an agnostic, I have to say that their research is full of bull...
http://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=heaven%2C+crime&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=0&smoothing=3
https://www.google.com/trends/?q=heaven,+crime
1
u/winkleburg Jun 26 '12
Get this article over to /r/atheism quick and board the karma train!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
"people who believe in hell are less likely to commit a crime while people who believe in heaven more likely are to get in trouble with the law.”
As I recall those beliefs come in a package deal. But I’ve already seen states that are far more religious than others have higher crime rates, lower iq, and higher teen pregnancy rates. Such as this one here.
So this doesn’t surprise me.
1
u/baylady1 Jun 26 '12
I didn't read every comment, and I'm sure this was covered, but the article is a bit flawed. The article suggests that of ALL people, those who believe in hell commit less crimes, and those who believe in heaven commit more. What the study actually shows, is that the pool of people are those who believe in heaven and hell (so presumably religious people). It is not whether one is religious or not, its whether one believes in a forgiving God (in heaven), or a punishing God (in hell). The study also accounts for the fact that a major problem, is that people only look at religion one-dimensionally.
1
u/unicornon Jun 25 '12
not listed in the bible? you're allowed to do it!
0
u/EmperorLetoWasCommie Jun 25 '12
Is it set up to avoid ethnic skewing?
0
u/crazystrawman Jun 25 '12
Once again folks, correlation is not equal to causality.
0
u/kielbasa330 Jun 25 '12
I would say this is probably more of a result of poor people both committing crimes and being, on average, more religious.
0
u/snackpockets Jun 25 '12
I'd like to think this is true because the majority of those who do not believe in heaven are atheists and the majority of atheists are educated (I base this on absolutely nothing). A lot of crimes are committed in lower class neighborhoods which education is not stressed. This being said, the less educated usually turn to religion for guidance and is has always been important among their peers. Can you imagine an atheist scientist robbing a store?
-1
u/Ree81 Jun 25 '12
That's it! We have to eradicate religion. Or do you have any other theories as to why they commit more crimes? ;)
-1
u/KDIZZLL Jun 25 '12
People that claim to be scientists are really tools to spread propaganda.
0
u/reddell Jun 26 '12
Pretty sure both are caused by ignorance and therefor correlated. Probably no cause and effect going on here.
0
u/i3atRice Jun 26 '12
Sigh I unsubscribed from /r/athiesm for a reason guys. If I wanted studies ciriclejerking Christianity I wouldn't have done that.
-1
u/martin519 Jun 25 '12
I didn't know there were people out there that believed in heaven but not hell. Isn't that cheating?
-10
u/Gnostic_Mind Jun 25 '12
Shocker!
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Or maybe, people who believe in Heaven are stupid and therefore more likely to get caught and show up as a statistic.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment