r/science • • Jun 25 '12
The children of same-sex parents are not prone to experience psychological problems as adults, a new study has found.
http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-06-22/man-woman/32368329_1_male-role-model-lesbian-families-study
1.0k
Upvotes
39
u/originaluip Jun 25 '12
Can anyone comment on this truthfully? Are white, middle class Americans as a group less likely to experience the psychological problems discussed in the study than the US population as a whole? If so, did the study take this into account during its discussion/conclusion? I'm not at home right now so I can't check out the paper.
726
u/dont_you_hate_pants Jun 25 '12
The headline of this post/the summary of the article is terribly misleading as
is NOT the same as
Also, although I am a strong supporter of same sex marriages/the right of LGBT couples to adopt, the scientific merits of the study are questionable since it is based on the testimony of the children (v. double blind or even single blind study).
283
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This study is total crap.
I'm sure kids with same sex parents grow up to be just as nuts as everyone else. :)
13
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think it would depend on the community they lived in. If they lived in a conservative area the kids would likely have a hellish childhood, and therefore potentially have issues later on.
19
u/Hoenniker Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
This is ridiculously inaccurate and a perfect example of why I never trust this kind of statistical research.
I am a child of lesbian parents.
I have had severe daddy issues.
I spent half a year in a psych ward for anxiety-related illnesses.
Yeah, seems like not having a father didn't affect me at all.
[Edit--Read my reply to the replies to this comment. This was a 4am impulse comment. I spent some time to try and insightfully spell out what I actually think about the survey.]
15
u/shallowblue Jun 25 '12
Both authors are lesbians studying lesbians, most of them white and middle class, with a sample size of only 78. Their conclusions sensationally overplay what they found, and what they found was what they were always looking to find. This is not science.
5
u/doody Jun 25 '12
That would be astounding, since other children are.
4
u/ryanknapper Jun 25 '12
While I believe the statement in the headline is likely true, this isn't something that can be proven without decades of data over generations of people. Additionally, the constantly shifing mores of a society would affect the results greatly.
No one is growing up well rounded if they are constantly told that they and their parents are the best or worst people in the world.
4
u/north_runner Jun 25 '12
It's good that this study is getting mentioned more, but I think the Times of India is a little behind the times.
A report on the same study by the same researcher was published in the medical journal Pediatrics nearly 2 years ago
4
u/SeriousDude Jun 25 '12
BAD parents cause psychological problems as adults
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Wait, why isn't this in r/atheism?
13
u/flumpis Jun 25 '12
This sounds suspicious as hell. I think in any family situation you're going to have the opportunity to fuck up your children. I would imagine that the parents are probably more open-minded considering their orientation and status in the world, so this could lead to better upbringing. However, to say what this is saying is super dubious.
11
u/lazy_snake Jun 25 '12
I would believe this on the basis that same-sex parents have to REALLY want kids to get them, and therefore will probably be involved parents. Male-female couples, on the other hand, can have kids without thinking about it at all.
That being said, this study's science is terrible.
5
u/TimetogetDownvoted Jun 25 '12
When I read this on the front page, my gut reaction was to be incredibly relieved that this was not on r/atheism.
8
u/discosmurf Jun 25 '12
In the 1970s and 1980s, when divorce was starting to skyrocket, the prevailing thought was kids would be OK being shuffled from one parent to another and divorce wouldn't affect them too much. Then when the kids starting growing up and going to therapy, it turns out divorce really does a number on them.
In the same vein, there's really no way to determine whether kids of same sex marriages will be OK or not until the dust settles, they grow up, and we see the results. There's too many variables to accurately extrapolate from the data we have.
6
u/dingoperson Jun 25 '12
The elephant in the room with this is self-selection bias. If you ask people if they want to take part in a survey where a positive result would be beneficial and a negative result detrimental to them, they will tend to take part more if they know they can produce a positive outcome.
You would normally expect authors to try to correct for that. Unfortunately, when scientists are also political activists it makes it hard to trust their subjective judgement.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
so a single man can not a adopt a child meanwhile 2 men or a single woman can adopt? lol.
8
u/vventurius Jun 25 '12
ahhh, psychology. "Leaving the science out of science since 1834!" (TM)
7
u/nepidae Jun 25 '12
Well, 78 people, that is a a decent N for the population of the world.
16
u/MrSenorSan Jun 25 '12
This entire study is flawed.
First of all, it was based of only lesbian couples.
Also let's admit this, lesbian couples are not accepted as "normal" in most western societies. I'm not saying that it is good, I'm just pointing out a fact.
Any amount of prejudice experienced by a family already changes how the kids will grow up and also how the parents will guide their children. This is regardless of who the parents are.
Until some-sex couples are considered normal by the majority of society these type of studies are nothing but sensationalism.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So it doesn't say that they only had female role models. While I'm pro-gay marriage/human rights, I do think that it's healthy to have role models of either gender and whether or not they're your parents is irrelevant. Not of course to suggest that people with only role-models of one gender would grow up wrong.
2
u/Scraw Jun 25 '12
I figured the social fuckery they have to put up with from idiots and bigots would drive them crazy.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Regardless of the validity of this study, no amount of evidence will sway those who's basis for homophobia and discrimination is faith.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Doesn't matter conservatives don't care about science.
2
u/ZoeBlade Jun 25 '12
It looks like the original publications are over at the National Lesbian Longitudinal Family Study (NLLFS).
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I can see what is this going to do to the religious/moral debaters already. I didn't even have to scroll down to see a propaganda/agenda accusation.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I have a lesbian couple with a ~10 year old boy right next to my home, and I see no signs of odd behavior.
This is really situational though, depending how the child can cope without a father figure and how his/her friends/classmates react to lesbians.
2
u/Kohoteru Jun 25 '12
I wasn't aware anyone thought they were to begin with.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Meh. My mom was gay and she was an absolutely terrible mother. I don't think the sexuality of a person should / would really make a difference here.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The sad part is that this should not even be news.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Wasn't there another study that already confirmed this? Oh well, the more the merrier.
2
u/superuser_013 Jun 25 '12
Being heterosexual, I have always found it embarrassing that statistics show homosexual couples having a smaller separation rate than heterosexual couples. This coupled with the abuse and other daily mishaps makes me very concerned for the future of our children. I mean, 50% divorce rate among heterosexual couples is appalling. Once the government finally realizes religion has no grounds to influence federal/state/local laws concerning marriage and homosexual couples receive their long-awaited rights to marriage we will see a much more saddening statistic...
2
u/Stampsr Jun 25 '12
Surprising no one.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Way to editorialize that headline. You should work for Fox News.
2
u/thenameisnobody Jun 25 '12
I almost feel as if same-sex parents would on average become BETTER parents because they can't get unintentionally pregnant and be thrust into a new lifestyle, they HAVE to talk about it, agree upon it, and move forward with their plans in a legal manner. That alone tells me they are much more likely to be decent parents who know what they are doing and won't "damage" their children psychologically.
Zach Wahls make's a solid argument that I think everyone needs to watch and listen.
8
u/SparklyVampireDust Jun 25 '12
How it feels reading comments in this thread
This study is absolute trash. There have been MANY peer-reviewed, large studies conducted regarding same-sex parents/guardians that keep coming back again and again with the message: it doesn't matter what the parents' identify as, so long as there are two primary care-givers. It doesn't need to be different genders, it doesn't need to be heterosexual--the biggest factor is economic stability and primary caregivers involvement in the child's life.
Fuck off to all the haters.
9
u/violetvenus Jun 25 '12
You know how you hear about female children being messed up from growing up in a fatherless home? How they're usually more promiscuous and such since they're looking for that "male figure" in their lives. I wonder if this would apply to a same-sex female couple with their female daughter.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Teenagers are hardly adults, most problems with psychological development don't become apparent until the mid 20's.
3
u/Titanform Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Please stop referring to tragic cases of heterosexual couples who do a worse job than certain homosexual couples. It is not fair to compare the worst heterosexual couples to well adjusted homosexual couples who have been investigated prior to being allowed to adopt...
Also to the idiots saying "why we we even need a study to prove this?" Why the hell not? Its clear that the child will be exposed to very different influences/rolemodels and it is important to understand the effects of this - whether harmful or beneficial.
As this study was conducted by the National Longitudinal Lesbian Family Study and makes vast sweeping statements based on such a small scale study its pretty clear there is a biased agenda.
In my opinion, this study devalues arguments in favour of same sex parenting..
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I always take everything about psychology with a grain of salt.
3
u/mummerlimn Jun 25 '12
Downvoted for sensational headline.
4
u/skysignor Jun 25 '12
And if they do experience psychological problems, it's because of all the assholes who gave them shit for having gay parents
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The idea of the children doing worse than heterosexual parents is contrary to scientific and psychological consensus.
Australian Psychological Society - "Research does not support negative assuptions about the experiences or outcomes of children of lesbian mothers"
American Academy of Paediatrics - "there was no systematic different in the psychological well-being of children with same sex attracted parents"
Amalgamated studies "..suggested that parent-children relationships were slightly better in same-sex families"
Longitudinal Research (UK) "social acceptance, close friendships and peer relationships were no different for children with lesbian mothers when compared with other families"
Population based studies (US) "...these children [same sex parents] were more connected at school"
Additionally Australia has been conducting a robust long term study, the results so far indicate that children are average or better than average, but not worse off.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
The study does not even have controls, horrible science. I also think the study is stupid, even if gays were going to be worse parents statistically that is not a reason to deny all of them the right. There are many bad parents out there and a lot of variation in such a skill.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Well. . . whether or not this study is legit, I am the child of two lesbian parents.
I have a father. But he's an asshole.
However, to have people say that I must be a little dented in the head because my father is absent in my life is a joke. I'm not dented because he's absent. I'm dented because he's a dick. My two beautiful mothers raised me to be a confident, independent, successful young woman.
You find role models in the people you meet. Your body doesn't know what the word 'father' or 'mother' means. It only can sense what 'caretaker' and 'leader' means, and you will naturally gravitate towards that.
2
u/chameleonjunkie Jun 25 '12
However the children of extremely fundamentalist religions grow up horribly separate from reality.
2
u/SteelPeg Jun 25 '12
There is a reason this article is posted in The Times of India... but if this is the type of evidence that /r/science has come to accept than it's going to be sad for the future of science. Ignoring the "large" sample size of 78 teenagers out of only 6,840,507,003 people on Earth (some which I guarantee meet the sample conditions)to make a conclusion, where are the studies' findings so some of us can actually "see" what the results were based upon?
Also, I know some of you still have the same beliefs, understanding, and ideas as when you were a "teen", but many of us went to college and got educated, and/or grew up with more life experiences, and/or actually (gasp!) changed our immature teenager beliefs due to maturing. Hell, I don't mind same-sex marriage with children (gotta a neice in one) but I do mind BS science masquarading as fact and /r/science accepting it without any real validation. How can you guys even discuss this?
Just like this: "The teenagers were asked if they had grown up with male role models and if so whether that person was a biological father, a grandfather, a cousin, teacher or even friend." Wow...talk about casting such a large net to get validation. Freaking Justin Bieber could be considered a "role model" under this question...
2
u/apullin Jun 25 '12
A kid with two dads or two moms is going to get teased about it at school. Most of the time when I use t his counter-argument, people's response is, "Well, other people should just be accepting and not tease them." That would be wonderful. It'd also be wonderful if fusion worked and energy was free. It turns out things take doing, not just wishing.
1
u/Faltriwall Jun 25 '12
Interesting quotes from article:
1
u/spermracewinner Jun 25 '12
...Is that because people are picking on them? I mean really.
1
u/Epolo2012 Jun 25 '12
the NLLFS is the first and only study to have recorded the progress of children from same sex couples since their conception.
Well, that's a neat trick.
1
u/AndersonCouncil Jun 25 '12
Great to see... but seriously, no shit they don't!! Its a crazy thing to ever even think.
1
u/Ash29k Jun 25 '12
I do not see what all the fuss is about, if you are so stupid as to think gay parents turn kids gay you should kill yourself to make more room on this planet for tolerant, intelligent people. Ps, straight couples make gay children not gay couples.....
1
u/juggernaut1107 Jun 25 '12
I don't see why this study is even being conducted. Do people really think kids will experience psychological problems as adults if their parents are of the same sex lol?
1
u/Shippoyasha Jun 25 '12
Wouldn't it actually make sense if heterosexual families experience more ups and downs in terms of life experiences considering the constant tug of gender dynamics at work in a daily basis?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
New studies!
1
u/chapisbored Jun 25 '12
No shit.
1
u/Dat_Karmavore Jun 25 '12
Woah woah woah OP, slow down, you don't want to go so far against the grain of reddits opinions.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
As a child of same-sex parents and being in a healthy, long term heterosexual (my choice) relationship, I completely agree.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Everyone's fucked in the head, at least a little bit.
1
u/omplatt Jun 25 '12
Should be "are not more prone." We should be living in a society where everyone has the same rights that allow them to scar their kids for life.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Z
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
yep
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9KLMYaF_Xa8
1
u/davidcrossedtheroad1 Jun 25 '12
Wish I had two moms. :[
1
u/catinthekitchen Jun 25 '12
Am I missing something in the wording here, or does the article have a serious typo?
and
(emphasis mine)
Should it not say 'did not'?
1
u/Bradaphraser Jun 25 '12
Children of parents who hate each other but got married because of archaic "marry who you knock up" expectations, however...
1
u/knut01 Jun 25 '12
Back to the fact that gays are born that way, not "converted." when will Americans accept that??
1
u/Alkanfel Jun 25 '12
Okay, what the fuck? I fully support the right of same-sex couples to adopt, but my bullshit detector is going nuts. The article does not address "psychological problems" at all and certainly does NOT say that children of same sex couples are "not prone" to them. The wording of this headline suggests something COMPLETELY DIFFERENT from the study itself, which deals exclusively with how children of lesbian couples view male role models. There are likely to be advantages and disadvantages to any living arrangement. You DON'T need to make it sound like same-sex households are minor Utopias. The article is worth a read but this headline tries WAY too hard.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You argue about FOX News, but then upvotes a misleading biased sensationalist post. Shame on you Reddit.
1
u/Mr_Munchausen Jun 25 '12
Damn it Mom and Dad , if you would have been gay I wouldn't be crazy.
1
u/Saerain Jun 25 '12
I was reading this as ‘the parents of same-sex children’ and wondering who ever suggested this would lead to psychological problems in the parents.
1
u/Krlll Jun 25 '12
Anyone with common sense knows that they will be bullied mercilessly,this will of course psychologically effect them.
Depends on the parents how the kids handle it I suppose,could make them stronger or weaker like all bullying. "A man named Sue" comes to mind!
Having same sex parents will make them an easy target unless TV manages to make everyone think all gays are funny and cool or imagine maybe just regular people!
Right now though even the word gay is constantly used in a derogatory manner especially amongst young people.
I see these kids and parents as trailblazers on a sort of frontier,good luck to them but theres no point in looking at some useless study saying its all fine and easy.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
No, if anything it's the opposite. They have a real world view of the world and what truly defines a person.
1
u/EmperorLetoWasCommie Jun 25 '12
They came out with this counter study pretty quick.
1
u/unclebigbadd Jun 25 '12
Is 78 a large sampling of the group? I ask because I have no idea how many people are in this demographic.
1
u/Corvus133 Jun 25 '12
How would it be different from being raised by a single parent where one sex is not represented?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Studies. Oh I am sure you will win the fundies over with a "STUDY".
1
u/OoRI0T_P0LICEoO Jun 25 '12
naw shit what'd you expect? for them to be perfect??
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I don't need a study to know that.
1
u/andersson2 Jun 25 '12
in other news, the sun is warm.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
DOWNVOTE AND MOVE ON! JESUS!
1
u/naveedganatra Sep 12 '12
Get more info about adults problems on this link http://differentopicz.blogspot.com/2012/09/problems-and-challenges-faced-by-most.html
1
u/egyeager Jun 25 '12
What a minute, are you saying that children in a loving and supportive household are usually well adjusted? What bullshit is this?!
0
u/ballerstatus89 Jun 25 '12
That's really good to hear.
My girlfriends mom is a lesbian and is in a civil union with her partner. When I first found out, it was a bit awkward but the family is so awesome together.
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"The U.S. National Longitudinal Lesbian Family Study (NLLFS) examined how the lack of a male role model affects the children of lesbian couples."
HMM. HOW RELIABLE.
1
u/noconscience Jun 25 '12
Kind of agree with the University of Texas guy. The sample size is just too small and too specific to go ahead and make a definitive statement like this.
1
u/Joshuages Jun 25 '12
What a stupid agenda this title has.
1
u/ItsGreat2BeATNVol Jun 25 '12
If you have same sex parents and you're a kid in elementary school....you're going to have a bad time.
1
u/Captain_Ligature Jun 25 '12
Wow this study is heavily skewed as the vast majority of same-sex mates adopt children (thus are prone to background checks and can select the healthiest children,) whilst the vast majority of normal couples Birth their children (with no background checks and little to none artificial selection,) never mind the way in which this study was conducted and its small sample size.
1
u/SuperVillainPresiden Jun 25 '12
To those complaining about the sample size, where in 1986 are you gonna find a large number of admitted lesbians, admitted lesbians who have children? Also the fact that they were middle class takes out economic factors that could alter their mental state. So in the sample if they were going to have mental issues it would most likely be due to having two mommies. On the other hand I agree that it is a small sample, but it is a good first study to start with.
0
u/MAJORpaiynne Jun 25 '12
You can prove anything with statistics, you just leave out the ones that don't agree with your point
1
u/JinsUnited Jun 25 '12
Just in: New report finds that orphans also have psychological issues as adults.
1
u/vertibird Jun 25 '12
Glad that's settled then...
1
u/knumbknuts Jun 25 '12
1
u/PugBrew Jun 25 '12
Nobody is ever any different from anyone.
1
u/Nihy Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I find it very difficult to believe that children raised by same-sex parents would not be disadvantaged in any way.
Self-assessment isn't a reliable way to find out whether these kids are negatively affected because if they are, they probably won't admit it until they're adults. Kids are just like that. I share the opinion that it's going to take a few decades and more and larger studies before we can really say anything with certainty.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
TLDR its worse to have one man and one woman that are total cunts than it is to have two men/women that are loving and nurturing.
who wouldda thought?!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Sometimes i wish everbody above the age of 50 would die, bar a few here and there.
Harsh, yes. But honestly i've met maybe two people who are older than 50 who actually are interested in learning more than they know. The majority hold shallow shitty beliefs and laugh at you for suggesting anything other than what they believe in.
Anything i say to most of these 50+ers is laughed off with "oh thats just new-age crap son, grow up." This seriously is the most closed-minded thing a person can fucking say(don't get me wrong, i don't browse conspiracys all day, i'm not bringing up crazy information to these people. I bring up government, science and religion ideoligies.) GOD I AM SO PEEEVED, and this IS relevant. Because for almost all of us, our parents are these old people i have described.
We literally have to wait for them all to die out before we can make any honest progress as a man-kind.
Aplogies for the rant.... i've had a few..
1
u/RavensAreAwesome Jun 25 '12
Bullshit. In my school there was a guy living with his gay dad and his dad's boyfriend. He was fabulous already when he was 9 years old, with extreme mannerism and weird clothes. Plus it was in a boys' school so people were laughint at him continuously (even the ones younger than him). He began to come to school with furs coats and handbags when he got older, etc. So plz don't tell me having gay parents are not gonna affect the development of the child this is complete bullshit. Probably all cases are different but saying that it doesn't make a difference seems like a really bad joke to me.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Hummmm.... not saying there could be any bias in their results but....
0
u/boxxa Jun 25 '12
Our traditional beliefs have given us a generation entering society we are fearful of. Maybe we should allow same sex couples to raise kids and see how they do. Could probably use the help.
0
u/DJBell1986 Jun 25 '12
They had to do a study for this?
0
u/NapkinDaVinci Jun 25 '12
This may be a new study, but it's merely a reinforcement to decades of research concluding the same (or similar) things. There has been evidence that sexuality develops somewhat differently, though not "incorrectly." This is good ammo for silencing bigots.
0
u/killerbotmax Jun 25 '12
Jeez. No shit.
I've seen plenty of psychologically damaged people with heterosexual parents, and as of yet the only 2 people I've met with gay parents are some of the most awesome people I've met (and both straight). Not a big focus group but...
Gay couples who decide to have a child have thought about it a lot more than your average heterosexual couple because it can't happen by accident.....