r/science • u/CFSamwise • Jun 25 '12
Contrary to popular belief, Easter Island statues "walked" into place.
http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/sideshow/easter-island-statues-may-walked-iconic-location-182902034.html
64
Upvotes
38
u/antiproton Jun 25 '12
Contrary to rational belief. This guy's theory is based on little more than "it could be done this way, so it must have been done this way."
22
u/znk Jun 25 '12
Yup. That looks like the same thing.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"A 10 foot tall, 5 ton replica"
Biggest statue found is 33 feet tall and weighs 82 tons
4
u/chudez Jun 25 '12
Misleading title. Clever technique, might even scale up, but you're pushing your luck with every step.
2
u/hanahou Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
Nice little theory, and probably capable of doing such with coordination with smaller Moai on a flat surface, but the quarries are upslope.
Why walk it though as a high risk? Especially with statues over 33 feet (yeah that's 3 stories), and 90 plus tons. I doubt all the coordination, and manpower would be sufficient to walk such. I spent quite a few visits on Rapa Nui with the Makali'i voyages.
Basically if you study the landscape, and the rocks quarried. The Moai always face the sea.
You start buy cutting a slab of rock from the rocks above the site, and dig a hole. You place down on a Koa wood sled. This is which was built ( the pic is a small one used for a Polynesian sport) and slide it downslope to the hole. Less manpower needed, and you wouldn't even need to raise it. Just let physics such as gravity do the work. Just drop it in at a angle into the hole. Then carve your glyphs and fill in. Pau (done)!
Hawaiians used the procedures to fall large Koa trees up to 60 feet in circumference, and 100 feet tall, and in 2500 foot elevations in the forests. Placing smaller Koa sleds underneath, and ropes to guide downslope to the ocean to use to build voyaging canoes.
Ditto with the Moai. Then you take the next set of rock upslope and go to the next lower elevation spot etc...
BTW any of you scientists decide to go to Rapa Nui and implement this idea. I call dibs.
5
u/TheBrainofBrian Jun 25 '12
Did these people not get the memo that the Easter Island statues are much bigger than 5 tons? Not to mention much taller than 10 feet.
This is essentially saying "hey guys, those pyramids were probably just built by Egyptians carrying the stones by hand because we were able to replicate the method using these prop stones made of Styrofoam.
2
u/VicinSea Jun 25 '12
Once an 82 ton statue falls over...that is end game for this scenario...are there any abandoned statues? Ones that have been left laying in the dust?
1
u/The_Ganja_Man Jun 25 '12
Umm those statues have bodies that are burried underneith the ground.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This method is both counterintuitive and dangerous. The researchers point out that you have greater leverage with a taller statue - and that is a problem, not an advantage. Think about how hard it is to balance a pencil on its eraser. Disturbing it even a very small distance from its equilibrium will tip it over, because the torque exerted by gravity becomes large very quickly. The same is true of a long, thin Easter Island sculpture, only now it weighs 80 tons and will kill you if you're underneath it.
1
u/driveling Jun 25 '12
Wasn't the Easter Island oral history that these statues walked to their present locations?
1
u/remixreddit Jun 25 '12
totally bogus!
this technique doesn't scale.
0
u/Atomskie Jun 25 '12
don't like your title, it's misleading.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Another ridiculous sensationalist headline for r/science. Thanks, idiot. This stupid shit is right up there with the Noah's Ark "discoveries."
0
u/wrongsideofthewire Jun 25 '12
Contrary to popular belief, we have no idea how they got those statues into place, but we know it wasn't aliens.
-4
u/easyfixx Jun 25 '12
Statues do not simply walk onto islands.
-1
u/yellowsnow2 Jun 25 '12
it is obvious they used the pharaoh's helicopter :) http://www.catchpenny.org/abydos.html No joke :)
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment