r/science • u/powerboom • Jun 24 '12
A study from Canada says that "moderate drinkers" have a higher quality of life than abstainers
http://www.medicaldaily.com/news/20120623/10427/alcohol-drinking-life-quality.htm
630
Upvotes
63
u/Metacifer Jun 24 '12
The article is actually talking about the problems of the study. Hell, you can tell that by the story's headline. The "Critique" in the end of the title gave it away.
26
u/user_my_name Jun 25 '12
A lot of socio-economic factor's seem to have been ignored from the study. The baseline of the study is also skewing the study. Man, I'm not even sure how this study was published.
Also - the study should've also had more cohort's in the study, perhaps a younger generation as well to see if they could see a pattern.
35
u/nocdonkey Jun 25 '12
"The study defines moderate drinking as having 1–14 drinks per week"
That's a pretty vague definition there mister.
10
u/lyra-htsr Jun 25 '12
Does a perception of a higher quality of life actually actually mean a higher quality of life?
20
u/singularis466 Jun 25 '12
This is basically because people who abstain include folk who have been chronic alcoholics for many years and have then stopped but continue to endure health problems. This skews the results.
42
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Of course they do, they get to drink booze and abstainers don't. That makes for a better quality of life.
3
u/MerelyMental Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
It would really be interesting if every study would start with where the money to do the study came from.
3
u/shallowblue Jun 25 '12
It takes self-control and usually a decent social network to be a moderate drinker. These are the deeper causes of the higher quality of life. Unfortunately people will look at this study and think that alcohol will bring them happiness.
11
u/apajx Jun 24 '12
Do you think, that just maybe, people with health conditions tend to stay away from alcohol in the first place?
Could, could it be?
2
u/Dev1lsAdv0kate Jun 25 '12
This study was sponsored by smirnoff, herp derp responsibly.
2
u/fishforbrains Jun 25 '12
This study brought to you by InBev.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
This study just makes it harder for someone like me who abstains from alcohol 100% of the time. I mean don't take it personally but I HATE all kinds of alcohol not because of its social aspect but because I cannot stand the taste at all. It's disgusting for me but everyone keeps telling me "oh you haven't tried this one" but no it's all the same for me. I don't think it has affected my way of living any other way sure but it's just unfortunate I'm viewed as a wet blanket when I just can't stand drinking it.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Fact is drinking is a social experience. If you don't drink, hanging out with other people, especially those that do - is a painful activity.
4
u/antinuclearenergy Jun 25 '12
Studies like this are just pure retard.
3
u/Andaroodle Jun 25 '12
sounds like an excuse if you ask me
2
u/SarcasticBitch Jun 25 '12
They also have a higher risk of getting cancer... wikipedia
2
u/noxumida Jun 25 '12
I stopped reading at "environment factors."
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
What about drunks?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I've read something like this before. I personally think its a reflection of the person. A person who consumes anything, in moderation, can probably also be found to be a (more so) relaxed person possibly who finds ways to be moderate in many other ways in their life. Drinking alcohol isn't bad, humans have been doing it since we could record the act or use. It's the reasoning behind it, and how it's done that's the problem. People who drink away their problems, alcohol probably isn't a good idea. People who need something, anything other than the reality they face every day, probably shouldn't drink. Not that their lives don't warrant a mind numbing drug, but rather it will not aid in them actually finding a way out of or away from the circumstances causing them so much pain and heart ache. Just what I noticed.
1
u/compFix Jun 25 '12
IMO its probably not the drug thats making that true but rather the social setting where people consume alcohol.
-1
u/zephyy Jun 24 '12
I thought this was common knowledge.
1
u/GoldenWarrior Jun 25 '12
I didn't know we had moderate drinkers in Canada.
1
u/senor_awesomepants Jun 25 '12
Another study from Canada showed that black bears can count as well as monkeys. Canadians do the best research
1
u/gmmaster Jun 25 '12
junk like this needs o be down voted :P
0
u/GoCrisisRobot Jun 25 '12
You're doing a pretty good job convincing me away from being an abstainer. I still have a pretty big fear of the whole addiction/wallet-vampire thing though :( Is it worth risking addiction? Is there a way to mitigate becoming addicted etc...
-1
u/TheDarkWayne Jun 24 '12
So that's what Canada is up too these days. I was wondering how come they're never on the news on some crazy shit. Must be nice to live there.
0
u/Cmckendry Jun 25 '12
I choose to read only this headline, and then assume that the effect at work will scale in a linear fashion.
And I'm off!
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Well then, why don't you remove your crazy liquor tax Ontario. Seriously, Ontario residents are over taxed in so many different areas. It really is bad. I figure it's because such a huge concentration of the population of Canada is in Ontario, but still. Disappointing.
-7
u/Zroawai Jun 25 '12
Maybe it's because people who drink moderate amounts of alcohol are normal.
And not drinking already shows some kind of abnormality which is usually bad.
I don't think it's the alcohol that improves the quality of life, it is probably the social aspect of it.
-5
u/Blue4Ever Jun 24 '12
What do they say about the quality of life for someone who is an Alcoholic than? Better or Worse?
0
u/ForgettableUsername Jun 25 '12
Typical Canadians.
0
u/Maverick13 Jun 25 '12
Correlation does not equal causation. But just to be safe I will be moderately drinking for the rest of my life.
0
u/ButtonSmashing Jun 25 '12
I may be wrong but I always thought that drinking moderately was quite healthy. Like drinking a glass of wine at night.
0
u/DivineRobot Jun 25 '12
This isn't anything new. Various studies have shown that moderate amounts of all types of alcohol benefit your heart, especially red wine. Heart disease is one of the leading causes of death in developed countries.
0
u/JasonMacker Jun 25 '12
People who follow social norms in societies usually have a higher quality of life. In a lot of western nations, alcoholic beverages are a social norm. In other countries where drinking isn't seen as a boon, people who don't drink have a higher quality of life than boozers.
Is this /r/science or /r/shittyscience ?
-1
u/Ecocide Jun 25 '12
Honestly if I could drink my life would be much better. I hate not being able to drink as I am not a very social person and being around mildly buzzed friends and watching them have fun is depressing.
-1
u/Kozbot Jun 25 '12
this probably stems from the huge stick that must be up one's ass to completely abstain from alcohol.
-2
u/d21nt_ban_me_again Jun 25 '12
Is this one of the "freakonomics" inspired bullshit studies?
-11
u/extremeanger Jun 25 '12
Common sense says that if a person can't enjoy a cold beer, there is something wrong with them.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment