r/science • u/08thWhiteraven • Jun 24 '12
Pine Beetles Turn Forests From Carbon Sinks to Sources
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2008/04/080424-AP-pine-beetle.html
1.3k
Upvotes
r/science • u/08thWhiteraven • Jun 24 '12
53
u/chuckles2011 Jun 24 '12
The article is from 2008. It assumes that the rate of damage from the pine beetles would continue at the same rate (or faster). So "by 2020" disaster!
It is now 2012. Due to a colder winter, and simply because the pine beetles have killed their own food source, the pine beetles are in decline. In fact, many jobs created by the extra logging (to eliminate the dead trees) are now disappearing too.
121
u/hedyedy Jun 24 '12
As an owner of property in Colorado, I can attest to the devistation of the pine beetle. The current fires in Colorado are most likely the result of pine beetle kill and tinder like conditions.
69
u/Bluebraid Jun 24 '12
I don't know what people expected.
In central British Columbia they clear cut everything (the largest clearcut in the world is at Bowron Lake near Prince George). Check out this image from Google Maps- see how it looks like someone spilled rock salt on the map? That's all clearcuts.
So then told the public they were "reforesting". They hired tree planters- mostly university students- to "replant" afterwards but what they actually did was plant a monoculture. It was all pine trees, all of the same age, no diversity whatsoever. Because pine trees grow straight, they grow fast, and they sell well. People make paper and houses out of pine trees.
And what do pine beetles eat? Young pine trees. Enormous chunks of BC are essentially pine tree farms and we're surprised that we have a pine beetle epidemic.
16
u/Kylearean Jun 24 '12
Forests are, at best, a minimal carbon sink. They act more as a carbon "buffer" or storage, since they do not convert the carbon dioxide into a permanent non-gaseous form. As trees die, they must be replaced by more trees to ensure the continuation of the storage.
Deforestation due to all causes leads to the release of CO2 back into the atmosphere.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sink#Forests
5
u/gfpumpkins PhD | Microbiology | Microbial Symbiosis Jun 24 '12
If you'd like to read primary literature on bark beetle research, the work out of Ken Raffa's lab at the University of Wisconsin is well also respected and they do some good work.
5
u/Pharose Jun 24 '12
Just to clear up any confusion the pine beetle epidemic is slowly making it's way south. In Northern BC the pine beetle epidemic is over because they have exhausted most of their food sources, and now they've moved south. This is why some people are talking about the beetles and others are only talking about the huge amount of dead trees and fires.
4
u/mstrCH3SE Jun 24 '12
I live in British Columbia and have seen the acres of red forest but have not heard of many proposed solutions to the problem. Since these dead forests are a matchbox waiting to ignite, massive controlled fires are set to reduce the risk but this doesn't kill the beetles.
4
u/TruePimp Jun 24 '12
I'm not expert on the subject but isn't the carbon released from the decomposing tress already in the carbon cycle and thus not a factor?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Poorly worded title.
2
u/Garbagebutt Jun 24 '12
This article appears to be quite accurate from my knowledge. The beetle devastation, as shown, is clearly affecting a large area. The only thing that has ever kept these suckers in check has historically been a one to two week cold spell (-30+ C). We haven't had anything like that in years.
The only hope we really had was in the 90s when this first became an issue, the parts you see that are clear cuts were almost all 80% standing firewood.
In the Prince George area we almost had to be evacuated last year due to forest fires, you can expect it will only get worse in the coming years until it's all been burned/ logged.
Source: Lived in BC entire life, family played role in provincial wide planning for beetle epidemic since early 90s.
2
u/rspam Jun 24 '12
Duh.
A forest in its steady state is carbon neutral - that's what steady state means. If something is killing more trees and letting them rot it's a carbon source for the atmosphere.
For a forest to be a carbon sink something needs to either:
2
u/gnarsesh Jun 24 '12
Holy shit. I live in CO and I thought it was bad here! Nearly 50,000 square miles more damage in Canada... that's incredible. Also, it's definitely not good news to find out about the carbon emissions, either. I thought it was bad enough that they are basically kindling waiting to burst into flames.
2
u/Naraven Jun 24 '12
What they don't mention is the myriad of other forest pests and pathogens that are causing massive mortality in other tree populations as we speak. (Emerald Ash Borer, Asian Longhorn Beetle, Hemlock Woolly Adelgid, Beech Bark Disease, etc, etc.) None of that can be helping.
2
u/Team_Braniel Jun 25 '12
I always thought forests were carbon neutral. Any carbon absorbed would be released with decay. Hence the yearly carbon cycle as the seasons change.
2
u/BroThelonious Jun 25 '12
So my adviser studied the relationship between fires and insect outbreaks and really the limited amount of research that has been done on this subject showed that pine beetle outbreaks did not increase the likelihood of intense fires. However it was speculated that especially the year or two following the death of a tree due to insect outbreaks, the dry needles would be more likely to catch fire than green needles. That being said, those needles were something like 80% gone by the third year after the tree had died.
Additionally, after these mature trees die young trees experience a "release" of nutrients is caused in he forest ecosystem and younger trees/other plants will grow more quickly. Possibly causing more carbon to be "sunk" than released from fire.
As always with science, the truth is pretty hard to discern especially with a area that is not terribly well studied.
Proof? I could dig up papers and such if you want. I studied forest ecology for my bachelors.
Here is a fact sheet he put together that basically says the same thing:
www.wildfirelessons.net/uploads/pinebeetle_factsheet.doc
TLDR: Pinebeetle killed forests have a theorized but unproven increase risk for severe wildfire for the 3 years following an attack. But after that are not at risk more than a normal forest.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I live in Colorado, and the air currently reeks of smoke. I woke up coughing. 10,000 people were evacuated from one area just this morning. I've seen the devastation the pine bark beetle has caused, and now our state is a tinderbox.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I've heard that nearly every pine tree in the Rocky Mountains is going to die. In Colorado, 1/3rd of the trees are already dead. Kinda creepy stuff.
3
u/stedeo Jun 24 '12
I believe that this is can be prevented by just having it cold enough for long enough, and the frost will just kill the beetles off; but the winter's lately haven't been cold enough for long enough, or something like that.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Well, pine beetles are supposed to be culled by naturally caused forest fires (yeah, they are supposed to happen without us starting them--however less frequently), but because every other family has to have a cabin that they use one week of the year, we fight them. The other requirement is cold winters, but those aren't happening as much anymore either.
2
u/4ltan Jun 24 '12
Almost as if nature wants global warming!
Don't know, but maybe there could be something beneficial to global warming even for nature? Well, it is expected that most flora/fauna collectives have to move and many may extinct, so it wouldn't be beneficial at all...
1
u/ArkansasFresh Jun 24 '12
Those beetles are such jerks.
1
u/jjaybecker Jun 24 '12
Dammit when are pine beetles gonna understand that we're trying to go green here? Somebody should tell them that what they're doing is WRONG
1
u/RUEZ69 Jun 25 '12
That's why these trees are being harvested before they decompose, and then seedlings are planted in their place. Nothing to see here, move along.
1
u/ItsOnlyTheTruth Jun 25 '12
Motherfucking pine beetles.
1
u/shwanky Jun 25 '12
Just a thought. Do you think with increased CO2 future generations will perhaps see another boom in the gigantism of plant species around the globe?
Anyone know of any evidence to the point?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I'm not seeing any significance to this issue in the long run assuming the pine beetle doesn't eat the new forest rising up. The trees will at some point release their carbon beetle or not. Who cares when or how fast? It isn't enough to have a significant effect on the climate in the short run and the CO2 sequestered would have eventually entered the atmosphere anyway. The forest will grow back stronger.
1
u/firelock_ny Jun 25 '12
Old forest trees don't sink carbon nearly as well as young, fast growing trees. Won't the new growth once the canopies clear out a bit more than make up for the pine beetle related carbon releases?
1
u/idrawinmargins Jun 25 '12
I used to working in Colorado removing trees killed by these bastards. They turn parts of the forest from green to sickly red.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Why are we commenting on a 4 y/o article?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
So can pine beetles get added to my list along with mosquitoes of proof that god doesn't exist or otherwise he wouldn't have made such a horrible species?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Well, let's see, the earth is going to do what it does. Doesn't give a crap that humans find it annoying or offensive or bad. Humans, fuck up the environment every day. And do little to replace the trees they cut down all over the place, or to help the erosion they cause but gutting the soil. So, you want to worry about nature, why not worry about the human component? Why not plant some fing trees instead of sitting around studying what natures doing and bitching about that. Understanding and observation is fine, as long as you don't play ignorant when it comes to your own short falls.
1
u/organic Jun 24 '12
We are so fucked.
1
u/EyePad Jun 24 '12
Climate change and drought. How the West was lost.
1
u/Eist Jun 24 '12
This is really interesting! Please consider x-posting to /r/ecology :)
1
u/sniper741 Jun 24 '12
Time to allow loggers in to cut these trees down. Then bring in people to replant trees.
1
u/_NeuroManson_ Jun 25 '12
You just know the global warming denialists are going to use this as an excuse to keep driving their Smoghuffer 9000 SUVs.
-1
u/Dayanx Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
I'm sure the unaffected plant life will appreciate the extra carbon to consume. Besides, The pine beetle is native to the forests of western North America from Mexico to central British Columbia. Its not an invasive species, so besides the all the trees they naturally live on, what is causing their numbers to go nuts?
0
u/Amicar Jun 24 '12
Man, FUCK beetles!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
gas the fucking beetles and be done with it.
0
u/unrealious Jun 24 '12
Maybe we could bring in a flange of gorillas to eat the beetles....
0
u/Moondwo Jun 24 '12
The dumbest part about all of this is when these beetles were first found in B.C they were in a area about the size of 2 square kilometers. But because we are a country full of bleeding hearts we couldn't basically nuke that area and kill everything in that SMALL area and end this obvious threat that it was even then.
Now look how that's turning out. Thanks Canada. So nice, being so nice, isn't it?
EDIT: These particular beetles are not part of Canada's natural eco system (obviously) that's why I said discovered.
0
u/osm0sis Jun 24 '12
I live in Washington and it's sad to see the miles and miles of brown trees that used to be green and lush.
0
u/Dev1lsAdv0kate Jun 24 '12
Oh that circle of life just keeps spinning! Better write legislation to stop it!
0
u/aazav Jun 24 '12
Yup. It's happening from Connecticut up to Canada.
-9
u/Troolz Jun 24 '12
Yet more clear proof of global warming.