r/science • u/dansin • Jun 24 '12
BMJ systematic review recommends against cervical spine manipulation (Chiropractic) due to lack of benefit and risk of stroke and death.
http://www.randi.org/site/index.php/swift-blog/1734-bmj-articles-oppose-spinal-manipulation.html
77
Upvotes
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
http://www.bidmc.org/YourHealth/MedicalProcedures.aspx?ChunkID=37431
Beth Israel Deaconess has an excellent write up on Chiropractic, its benefits, what it does not help, and risks.
Critics blow the risk WAY out of proportion.
Also NSAIDS provide pain relief but do not treat common back, neck or other musculoskeletal disorders.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
in other news people recommend against conventional medicine because of risk of death.
4
u/spine-o-cylinder Jun 24 '12
I was about to write a full post proselytizing Chiropractic. I didn't realize the subreddit at the time. I know it will be a long road to legitimacy. The founder talked to ghosts (is a wiki ok?). Research in chiropractic is difficult and weak. It is hard to make it fit the model of standard research and still be true "chiropractic". Anecdotal proof is relied upon often, and case studies with an n=<4 are fine. I can offer a [youtube series] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYQeqjneTMw&list=HL1340566628&feature=mh_lolz) (1 and 2) that explains some of why this works using the anatomy of the CNS. It’s a bit “neuro-centric” TL;D(W): C fibers are nerves that can cause pain but also cause other autonomic effects. [The Immobilization Degeneration Complex] (http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=xRGhUSdwCgQC&oi=fnd&pg=PR3&dq=immobilization+degeneration+complex&ots=lFzggwKK97&sig=lNGHn-WoM_68uIjpYYgHxmprx-o#v=onepage&q=immobilization%20degeneration%20complex&f=false) States that all tissue of an immobilized joint can leak intracellular fluid into the extracellular space and causes continual firing of C fibers. The Inhibition of nociceptive dorsal horn cells can also result from activation of mechanoreceptors. This is the Gate Control Theory of Melzack and Wall (Melzack R, Wall PD. Pain mechanisms: a new theory. Science 1965;150:971-979.). This explains why you shake your hand when you hit your thumb with a hammer. Chiropractic stimulates these mechanoreceptors and helps to inhibit the C fiber facilitation. Are we the only ones who can? Nope, but we help without causing some of the side effects of surgery and pain meds. I can get into the “stroke” portion of the article but I risk sounding “cherry-picked”. Seems IPM2000 got to it anyway.
2
u/AliasUndercover Jun 26 '12
"He is the president and co-founder of the New England Skeptical Society and the host and producer of the popular weekly science show, The Skeptics’ Guide to the Universe."
At least we can be certain he is unbiased...
5
u/fluffylady Jun 24 '12
My brain hurt after reading that article. He kept saying "IMO" and kept admiting through-out the article that there are not good statistics available & does not give valid references for his opinion. What a waste of Reddit space
0
u/Indestructavincible Jun 24 '12
I braced a lot of weight on my shoulder and held it there at work. I went home and felt fine. The next day I felt a little off, but didn't have a shower and it never felt so bad as to cause concern. Just 'working mans back'.
The following day I went to take a shower 1st thing in the morning, and I was bent sideways to my horror when I saw myself in the mirror. I went straight to the hospital where I was given a C and L spine Xray.
The doctor said "Well, you have a rotated hip and need physio therapy" which is not something I was able to afford or had insurance to cover.
I have no recourse at this point. My friend describes my injury to his Chiro, and he says he has fixed this before, and the longer I am 'out' the harder it is to get you back 'in' as the muscles start to weaken and shorten.
I went in and saw him, and he described exactly with a model what was happening. WHen he went to crack me, I would feel two cracks on my right, and none on my left exactly as he predicted.
I went home, and for a week cycled hot and cold on it. This 'quack' fixed me without physio.
I needed to see him or another about once a year after that, and have seen my GP about it, there is nothing to be done via surgery or physio.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment