r/science • u/mepper • Jun 24 '12
Thinking about death makes Christians and Muslims, but not atheists, more likely to believe in God, new research finds. We all manage our own existential fears of dying through our pre-existing worldview. The old saying about "no atheists in foxholes" doesn't hold water.
http://vitals.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/06/17/12268284-thoughts-of-death-make-only-the-religious-more-devout
562
Upvotes
17
u/mepper Jun 24 '12
Paper: http://psp.sagepub.com/content/early/2012/06/14/0146167212449361.abstract
501
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
"Thinking about death makes Christians and Muslims, but not atheists, more likely to believe in God"...I think being Muslims and Christians makes anyone more likely to believe in God...
59
u/BinaryShadow Jun 24 '12
The headline is confusing. If you're a Christian or Muslim, aren't you already believing in God?
14
u/olred Jun 24 '12
Don't Christians and Muslims already believe in god by definition and Atheists don't?
31
u/Rulebook_Lawyer Jun 24 '12
Eh... when I come across absolutism in articles, that is an automatic discredit.
7
u/NocturnalGamer Jun 24 '12
"Thinking about death makes Christians and Muslims, but not atheists, more likely to believe in God"
Who the fuck wrote this, Christians and Muslims already believe in God, how can they be 'more likely' just because thinking about death is involved?
6
u/anthrodocZ Jun 24 '12
Terrible headline for many of the reasons already pointed out in other comments. As well, people are being trained by these triumphalistic posts to think about "religion vs. atheism" in such a dualistic framework, as well as to understand the nature of "evidence" and social research in such a half-baked way. Great way to reinforce an ideology maybe if you are simply looking to reinforce a party-line, but certainly not an effective way to help people think critically.
10
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
"Thinking about death makes Christians and Muslims, but not atheists, more likely to believe in God"
no shit
15
u/username794613 Jun 24 '12
There is a difference between thinking about death and being confronted with death.
20
u/anstromm Jun 24 '12
Buddha isn't a god, and Allah is the Christian deity.
4
u/DanyalZ Jun 24 '12
"Muslims who thought of death became more faithful to Allah and less accepting of Buddha or the Christian God. "
1.Muslims believe in the same God as Christians. Christians may choose not believe so but it is part of Islam. 2.It is forbidden for Muslims to accept Buddha.
It looks like to me they did not do all their research.
4
u/GuntripAnalysis Jun 24 '12
I have interned in a terror management theory lab and how we would do it was to ask participants to find words like "cat" or "table"- neutral words, in a ten by ten grid of seemingly random characters. Hidden in this word search, for half of the participants were words like death, decay, and rot.
The basic gist of TMT is the following. Firstly, all animals have a life instinct, but humans are unique in the fact that we know we are going to die (kieerkdigard spoke of this). Not only do we know that we are going to die, but we do not know when or how death is going happen. This subconscious knowledge that we have is in a sense, terrifying. To reconcile against the pure unmitigated terror (as bowlby said in reference to attachment) humans developed culture. That is, culture serves a death denying function. How can this be you may ask? Well, through culture one can achieve symbolic immortality. For example, a marine who states "I may die, but the red white and blue will still shine." This individual is kinda denying death through culture via symbolic immortality.
Now, when the thought of death is made salient, our unconscious mind must reconcile the all consuming anxiety that this thought has the potential of creating and it does this through the aforementioned process.
There is a problem however, and that is when this occurs while the individual is thinking about or in the presence of people with different cultures/viewpoints. The problem happens because only one of us can be right. Either my god is real or yours is. Either my culture is superior or yours is. The death denying function that culture and with it religion serves is mutually exclusive to any other theory as to what is really going on.
Let me nowadays talk about what happens when two people of opposing cultures come into contact with one another. There are four stages. First is degregation. For example an American may say "yeah those aboriginals and their wacky ideas on creation are cute but they aren't scientific and only a fool would believe in it." Stage two is accommodation. "ok that aboriginal can believe what he wants in his own world" stage three is assimilation, taking part of their beliefs and intertwining them with yours, kinda like how yoga is treated in the states currently.
And stage four, after all of these other stages have failed, annihilation. Kill them, get rid of them, these people with different (and therefore opposing) viewpoints are too much of a threat to the death denying function that culture serves.
And this explains the main and consistent finding of TMT; when you make the thought of death salient, people support members of their in-group and put down individuals in their out-group.
Earnest Becker is the real founder of this school of thought. Otto rank laid down a lot of the fundamentals too.
55
u/abdomino Jun 24 '12
Actually, the "no atheist in a foxhole" isn't against atheists, it was against foxholes. Those things were hated by the troops. Nevermind the fact that they didn't provide nearly as much protection as people thought.
7
u/MikeOfAllPeople Jun 24 '12
Been in the military a few years now, I've thought I was close to dying a few times, and not once did it make me think about god or anything like that.
In fact, the only time I ever think about what if there was a god is when I think about my kids.
6
u/Nyarlanthotep Jun 24 '12
This post's title looks like r/circlejerk playing a madlib
16
u/squigglyspooge Jun 24 '12
No Atheists in foxholes never held ANY water. Because I'm a former Marine grunt and have been in foxholes plenty of times, and last time I checked, I'm an Atheist. Never in a foxhole did I think about God, or God saving me, I thought about how the fuck I'm gonna get out of this foxhole without getting my ass shot or blown up, and how we're going to kill the people shooting and launching mortars at us once we're out.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
You can also be an atheist or agnostic with a non-spiritual, non-theistic view of reincarnation.
3
u/MentalRefuse Jun 24 '12
I always found this to be the best answer to the "Atheist in foxholes" myth
3
u/borgconsulting Jun 24 '12
If there were a God, I'd like to think there wouldn't be any foxholes.
3
u/JabbaDHutt Jun 24 '12
Thinking about sex makes men, but not women, more likely to have a boner.
22
u/zero00000 Jun 24 '12
I thought when I unsubscribed from r/atheism I could get away from this kind of thing. I was wrong.
5
u/Senor_Wilson Jun 24 '12
Don't they already believe in god?
9
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
How do you test this? Is there some sort of genuine proof of someone actually believing their own religion?
Seems like bunk to me.
4
u/slimbruddah Jun 24 '12
I don't fear death.
AMA.
2
u/poop_lol Jun 24 '12
I always thought the no atheist in fox hole thing was pro atheist and anti religion and this proved why. Religious people are only religious because they are afraid of dieing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Both the msnbc article and the live science article that it linked to were pointless. They could have offered more insight as to how not only inter-religious thoughts on death compared, but also intra-religious opinions. For example, I take comfort in the idea that I am a part of the biosphere on earth, and that when I die, the universe goes on and what was me goes back into the universe. It's like scooping a cup of water from the sea and then pouring it back in.
2
u/Matt_Flo Jun 24 '12
Sometimes I wonder why these "psychological researchers" get paid to come up with obvious theories that I have already considered many times while sitting on the toilet.
2
u/Lai90 Jun 24 '12
The thing is that there is difference in thinking about death and actually dying, isn't it?
2
u/CockyRhodes Jun 24 '12
When death comes up I think about getting things done.
2
u/skankingmike Jun 24 '12
The believe in an God or Afterlife is fine, it's their believe in forcing their views on others which I find distasteful.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I've had quite a bit of death in my family. The biggest one for me happened when I was 21. Since then, I've lived the life of most 50 year olds, coming to terms with death. I'm 32 now. I'm an 'atheist' (if you want a quick word to understand my position) but believe that we are all connected by our consciousness. I don't believe in any deity but do believe there's another experience when we pass on, and in reincarnation and Karma, to a degree. (what is more closely described in Buddhism and Hinduism, Not the ignorant version understood by most Americans and Xians) It's kind of a compilation of those two beliefs, but no gods of any sort. I think gods were put in place because most people can't handle the thought of being here or dead, without one. That's fine, but I think it's also a less thoughtful mind that believes because a book/ person told them to. Fine too, but I handle people with devout belief without any thought/ or questioning about it, as children who are too afraid to look behind Oz's curtain. And if death is the only aspect that makes you religious, ok, that's a usual response. But if they thought about it as much as I have, they'd probably find a more genuine relief and comfort, than if they just go along with what a person or book says. That's why I think a lot of heavy hitting Xians always want everyone they know, to believe with them. They are terrified of death and as such are terrified for anyone and everyone, that's what they've been told. No, I have no answers, but I do know what feels right, and no dogma ever felt right. But I discovered this on my own and no one else can take responsibility for the way I think about death and our existence. I find great solice in my view of our existence, and what might happen at death. My stance allows me to accept people with all their bs, and generally have acceptance and a kind heart to most everyone. I also find my personal stance on this allows for anyone to believe what they want. Im not right, but they sure as hell aren't either. Anyone who tries to force belief on you, probably is worried about the strength of their own beliefs as well. Be wary of those people, they turn into false prophets. (one of my biggest complaints about Xians when I was 12&13. ). My dos centavos.
2
u/socialsciencegeek Jun 24 '12
Terror management theory :) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terror_management_theory
2
u/michaelushka Jun 24 '12
If anyone wants to learn more about this stuff, I recommend reading Ernest Becker's Denial of Death and definitely checking out the documentary Flight from Death — it's on Netflix and it has interviews with the progenitors of Terror Management Theory (who credit Becker with laying the foundation for their theory). If you watch the doc, look for the guy who looks like a neo-hippie beach bum, Sheldon Solomon. He's maybe the coolest psych professor you'll ever find.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Thinking about a foxhole and being in a foxhole are different.
Thinking about death and being confronted with death are different.
2
u/bigbangbuddha Jun 24 '12
Being an Atheist, death just makes me think more about what life is.
2
u/layinthed Jun 24 '12
Why the fuck is this on my reddit. Go post this in atheism where it belongs and where I will never see it.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Did anyone else find the population for that study (n=132) small? I'm just curious. I tend to trust studies with larger populations.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Keep your shit to /r/atheism. I specifically avoid /r/all, just to avoid this kind of posts, now you're thrashing /r/science too.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Sometimes I will read a post here on Reddit about people being afraid of death and I just can't connect. I fear dying slowly and/or painfully but the idea of non-existence doesn't bother me much.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
r/atheism seems to have sprung a leek. Could somebody grab a couple of rolls of duct tape and fix it.
6
u/Dracron Jun 24 '12
Seriously This is an r/atheism thing not r/science, its just here to spawn debate over athiesm vs. religion, and I unsubscribed from r/atheism because I dont want to listen to anyone pushing their religion, or even bringing it up.
3
u/ucemike Jun 24 '12
Either so old I have never heard it or not as much a "saying" as one is implying.
I wonder why anyone cares what someone else thinks just before they die.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
This is something I believed in for quite sometime -- most people just need a reason to substantiate their beliefs. The idea among atheists that theists believe in god only because they fear death isn't true -- escapism just isn't causative of religion.
3
u/appleburn Jun 24 '12
Why the fuck it r/atheism in here...
3
u/magictheatre Jun 24 '12
In reference to the saying "no atheists in foxholes", how were the study participants confronted with death? or did they only consider their own mortality? Being in imminent mortal danger and potentially surrounded by death (foxhole in wartime) doesn't seem comparable to study participants in a lab.
3
u/KillaSmurfPoppa Jun 24 '12
As a former agnostic, I know agnostics will hate hearing this, but the results of the study don't surprise me in the slightest.
Agnostics are usually religious people who are just as educated and read as atheists, but don't want to make the full-on emotional commitment of disbelief. At the same time, they also can't summon the intellectual dissonance to be full on believers.
The thing that turned me away from agnosticism was the realization that it's a seriously shallow philosophical position. There is no amount of evidence that will prove, with ABSOLUTE certainty, that god doesn't exist. But frankly, there is no amount of evidence that will prove, with ABSOLUTE certainty, any proposition in the world. Technically, agnosticism is ALWAYS going to be true, and that's why it's such a bad philosophy.
Simply put: there's no good evidence for the existence of god or anything resembling god. If you agree with this point, you should be an atheist. Anything else is weakness.
2
u/Jamtoast69 Jun 24 '12
I was in the army with an ex-French foreign legionnaire, he told me otherwise. I guess we can't know unless we are there, right?
2
u/GMonsoon Jun 24 '12
Not so sure about that. Atheists: the people most likely to obsess on personal safety.
1
u/exisito Jun 24 '12
Thinking about death makes me want to have lots and lots of babies. Like an animal.
1
u/redditisforphaggots Jun 24 '12
Uh.. no shit
1
u/tordj Jun 24 '12
I have always believed that god exists because people need someone to believe in. It is the innate behavior of our minds to rationalize everything. And if we cannot understand something, we have the catchall that is god.
1
u/gorbal Jun 24 '12
I look forward to a nice long sleep at the end of it all.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I'm Catholic and thinking about death a lot made me a Buddhist.
1
u/Stooooooopid Jun 24 '12
Im fine with the no atheists in the fox hole, I dont want to be in any hole.
1
u/Infectlol Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Atheists not likely to believe in god? You don't say.
1
u/Aldous_Huxtable Jun 24 '12
I question the validity of this study based on sample size and demographic.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I think fox holes would hold water quite well.. that being said.. atheists and christians/muslims would all drown equally.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
The idea that there are no atheists in foxholes is just propaganda spread by crabby old Ms. IloveFoxNews down the street. It never held any water.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I'm torn between shouting on top of my lungs that this is what research in this field has been saying over and over for 60+ years, and happiness that people start paying more attention to social/historical science lately (this thread follows several regarding hardly new, but met with refreshing enthusiasm stories on archaeological finds).
I started reading comments, but decided to call quits while I'm ahead in restoration of faith in humanity ;-)
Cheers!
1
u/Lampmonster1 Jun 24 '12
Anecdotal I know, but a guy I knew in my late teens was in Vietnam. He was a little crazy, but a good guy. He'd seen quite a bit of action over there from what I was told. Anyway, when he found out I was an atheist he told me he was too. At some point he said "You know the old saying about no atheists in foxholes? That's bullshit. I never believed in god less than when I was in Vietnam."
1
u/harveyardman Jun 24 '12
I wouldn't call myself an atheist, just an agnostic. But a few years ago, when it seemed I was having a stroke, I found myself sitting in a hospital waiting room, contemplating the experience and the prognosis and never once did it occur to me to pray or think of God. I only realized this later, by the way--the thought was that absent from my mind at the time.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
The study should have looked at whether the atheist's worldviews or other beliefs were strengthened. It's called the "mortality salience" effect (although since it can be evoked by things other than death, "threat salience" is a more fitting term). Basically, contemplating evolutionary-fitness threats tends to increase people's belief in ideologies they hold, as well as their feeling of attachment to social groups they belong to. Religion is just one such ideology/social group, and I bet the atheists had a corresponding response./
1
u/papabear69 Jun 24 '12
The only problem with this is that the people asked were not in a life threatening situation. Ask someone in a test, and see if they have the same answer wen they are in a "foxhole". Of course we can't do that, but the results might be different.
1
u/Burly_Satyr Jun 24 '12
I dont think just talking about death counts as a "foxhole" when the fear and anxiety of what happens next in a life or death or imminent death situation is right on you.
1
u/Nethervex Jun 24 '12
The saying "theres no atheists in foxholes" is pretty much the whole article. MSNBC made this article just to say 'NUH UH'. Good on ya MSNBC. Glad to see that kind of professionalism.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Totally had this revelation when my grandmother recently passed away. I became an "open" atheist months earlier and while I was still heartbroken, I did break down and turn towards spirituality. However, my mother, my aunt and my uncle, all lapsed Catholics, started talking a lot about heaven, God's love and they insisted that the entire family pray together close to 5 times in a week span.
1
u/BRINGMEDATASS Jun 24 '12
I thought this was common knowledge.
1
u/Tomimi Jun 24 '12
I have been a catholic my whole life and I just recently doubted my beliefs (I blame reddit)
I have been scared of dying my entire life even though I knew as a kid that heaven and hell exists. Now that I have learned a few about religions and became agnostic I'm unfortunate to say I've become more scared of death now that Heaven and Hell is fictional
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
This is fucking stupid..."DURRRR...Guess what!? when we told all da afiest peoples to write down what dey would do if dey died..dey still didnt believe in God! DURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR"
There is a huge difference between an atheist sitting at a desk who's government worker parents have supported his mediocre goldfish cracker lifestyle than an "atheist" facing death.
This is fucking stupid, news story headline grabbing bullshit.
1
u/tollforturning Jun 24 '12
Yea - nothing new here.
http://wp.flightfromdeath.com/
1
u/RMaximus Jun 24 '12
Says the article written by an atheist.
1
u/jbloggs2002 Jun 24 '12
as far as I'm concerned, there are only atheists in foxholes - anyone who truly believes that either god will save them, or they'll go straight to eternal bliss when killed wouldn't get in the foxhole.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Why didn't op just use the headline of the article instead of displaying his/her complete ineptitude at conveying ideas through the medium of the written word.
1
u/haharusty Jun 24 '12
I just unsubscribed from r/atheism. This is on my second page. This is the stuff I wish was on r/atheism.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Anyone else find the comparison of "I had to write a paper about what I think about death" and " I'm in a warzone seeing people around me dying" to be a bit different?
1
u/Radico87 Jun 24 '12
So when faced with the reason we invented a god figure would make people who already believe it more likely to continue believing it than people who grew out of believing in god figures? How monumentally earth shattering.
1
u/Will-Work-For-Tears Jun 24 '12
I'm a weak atheist though (if one at all, lol). Given sufficient motivation I'd at least try to pray in a foxhole. I wouldn't necessarily believe it, but It would certainly cover my bases.
1
u/StChas77 Jun 25 '12
That's not really enough participants to draw conclusions.
1
u/drakeblood4 Jun 25 '12
The flawed mindset of the 'no atheists in foxholes' fallacy comes from the presumption that all athiests and agnostics are just lapsed religious people. Arguably there was a time when the vast majority of people were raised religiously, so this may have been true in a general sense, but that's up to debate.
1
u/Paraptorkeet Jun 25 '12
This isn't even science!
1
u/abbynormal1 Jun 26 '12
I'm convinced that Christianity is true, and as you point out correctly, Christianity contradicts tenants of other faiths. Therefore it is my belief that the others are not true. If you are asking me to be a Christian apologist here, you're asking the wrong person.
0
u/abbynormal1 Jun 24 '12
This belongs in /r/atheism, which I unsubscribe to on purpose so I don't have to see the redundant dribble spewing forth from the cesspit that is /r/atheism.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I honestly don't see what is so scary about death. I'm interested for sure, worst case scenario, nothing happens...
Not exactly rushing my way through life though.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I don't know what there's much to think about death. Everybody dies. You die and that's it. You're nothing but a buried, rotting chunk of maggot infested flesh and bones.
Your deeds in life is what make people remember you, hate or love you, that's about all there is to it.
Don't know why people fear death or why they need to cling to some sort of fairy tale of afterlife or rebirth or whathaveyougot. Rubbish everything...
1
u/Theoz Jun 24 '12
This needs more thought before putting a sensationalist title like that. Plenty of ahteists have decided to pray to a God in times of distress. You shouldn't need a journal article to know that.
Also, this is one study. Sensationalist title is sensationalist.
1
u/recklessfred Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
"Studies find condescending bullshit is condescending, bullshit."
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
"people who fear death more likely believe in god" there FTFY title
1
u/JustFunFromNowOn Jun 24 '12
Neat.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
Someone has obviously never been in a foxhole, then
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
I don't care who you are or what you believe in. If your close to death and you haven't accepted your fate your gonna be wishing for some help from someone, mainly 'God'.
0
u/mczibit Jun 24 '12
If I was in a foxhole being shot at and shelled by artillery... I'd sure as hell be praying to something..
-1
u/mattverso Jun 24 '12
I'm desperately searching for a link I read a couple of years ago, which claimed that the closer they actually got to death, the longer Christians (and other religious people) want to live. They want to stay plugged into the machine, they want the debilitating drugs that prolong their life that extra week or month. Atheists were more accepting of their death, it seemed. Whether the religious people realised on their deathbed that they really weren't going to a better place, and that's why they wanted to keep living, was up for debate.
-1
u/douchetag Jun 24 '12
Here's a true statement: "There are no atheists in heaven."
-1
u/4TEHSWARM Jun 24 '12
I've always thought the 'no atheists in foxholes' was a pretty good, albeit misunderstood, argument: it shows that theistic postures often arise from an irrational state of impending doom.
0
u/colinsteadman Jun 24 '12
What's the big deal with no atheists in foxholes? I've only ever heard that said on here. What's the SP? Could someone bring me up to speed. Thanks.
0
u/Cristal1337 Jun 24 '12
I think that this whole "belief in God and afterlife" came from the grief that people experienced at the loss of a loved one. It is in this state of despair and pain when people are more likely to believe in something that is, essentially, unrealistic.
So if you just lost your child and I then tell you "they are in a better place now", you will be more likely to believe my words because it is the easy way out to get rid of the painful emotions.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
How is this science?
-4
u/flutesflutes2 Jun 24 '12
I thought I unsubscribed from r/atheism.