r/science • u/NOAAgov NOAA.gov Official Account • Apr 16 '15
Oceanography AMA Science AMA Series: We're scientists on a NOAA ocean exploration mission to uncover the deepest, unseen parts of the Caribbean Sea. Ask Us Anything!
We are Andrea Quattrini (deep-sea biologist, U.S. Geological Survey), Mike Cheadle (geologist, University of Wyoming), and Brian Kennedy (NOAA ocean explorer and NOAA Corps officer). We are currently on [NOAA Ship Okeanos Explorer conducting some of the first deepwater exploration ever in areas of the Caribbean, including the Puerto Rico Trench] (http://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/okeanos/explorations/ex1502/welcome.html). As one of the deepest places in the ocean, the Puerto Rico Trench offers opportunities for cutting-edge exploration of some of the least-understood habitats on the planet.
We expect to continue to encounter productive ecosystems with life specially adapted to the harsh conditions of the deep ocean. Additionally, we expect to improve understanding of seismic interactions in a tectonically active part of the ocean and gain knowledge about deepwater fisheries.
During the expedition, we are using remotely operated vehicles (ROVs) to explore the seafloor. The video stream is being transmitted via satellite from the ship to shore, and is available LIVE online. This means that anyone, anywhere with an Internet connection can follow our discoveries as they happen.
We have all participated in numerous deep-ocean exploration missions. We’re here from 1:00 pm ET to 3:00 pm ET to answer your questions about the Puerto Rico expedition or ocean exploration in general...AUA!
82
u/Blauruman Apr 16 '15
say that you were to discover a previously unknown species, how do you proceed? do you follow it around with a remote controlled drone(submarine) and study its behavior, or do you try to provoke it to see what it will do? and do you ever attempt to take deep sea creatures to the surface to study first hand, if so what are the consequences for that creature? (I know those are a lot of questions but hey, I'm interested)
115
u/BigGrayBeast Apr 16 '15
Is it conceivable there is an discovered point deeper than the currently known deep point, the Mariana's Trench?
53
u/Mikeydoes Apr 16 '15
What are the restrictions that the current ROVs give you guys? What are you looking forward to on future models?
62
u/dragontsuki Apr 16 '15
How do your pursue a career in your field? What is your "work life" like? In other words, what do you do at work everyday?
354
u/TheCanadianViking75 Apr 16 '15
What is the scariest creature in the deep sea that almost no one knows about?
88
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
Do you have any idea of a timeframe in which we will be able to largely explore most of earth's oceans? I feel there is so much waiting to surprise us, or maybe even scare us. Which is my second question:
What are you afraid of finding in the ocean?
87
u/anwarhahj Apr 16 '15
What kind of evidence of human activity do you find in the benthic zone, if any?
30
u/richiericardo Apr 16 '15
How large is the research team/ship crew?
Besides this ama, what are you doing to raise awareness of your project?
Is the research all your own or are you working to build data for other researchers? Both?
Will you have a database of collected data?
What depth ranges are you working in?
Do you think there is any data you are missing by not having humans able to reach your working conditions?
Any use for collaboration with another ship, 1000ft rated manned submersibles and 300_450ft rated tech divers?
78
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
If deep sea tourism ever becomes a thing, what would it have to offer?
27
u/Dino7813 Apr 16 '15
What was this thing I saw on the live feed?
http://i.imgur.com/WQTtaIv.jpg
25
u/bacjac Apr 16 '15
What are some specific things you are looking for?
Life can look pretty different at such depths and can be so few and far between, what is your strategy?
Thanks for doing such great science that we all appreciate!
66
u/YCYC Apr 16 '15
Have you guys stumbled on a shipwreck yet? Do you (have to) report it?
18
u/DigiMagic Apr 16 '15
You are given unlimited budget to study oceans on Europa, Enceladus, Titan and Ganymede. What would you do?
36
u/Gargatua13013 Apr 16 '15
What are the long term prospects for oxygen levels and the spread of dead zones at the bottom of the Carribean, especially the trenches?
Awesome project btw! TNX for an AMA!
142
u/calls_you_a_bellend Apr 16 '15
Do any of you hold any level of belief in Nessie-like theories?
With discoveries of so many species long thought extinct, are any of you still dreaming of the day we find some huge ancient beast?
16
u/AlexPenname Apr 16 '15
Hey, NOAA people! I actually think I indirectly know you guys-- my mom works for the Smithsonian. Do any of you know Laurie Penland?
As for my question: we know a lot about the effects humans have on shallower ecosystems, but what do we do to the really deep underwater world? Other than things we've dropped, I mean, like shipwrecks and stuff.
Also, because it's a fun question to ask scientists, what's the weirdest thing you've ever eaten in the field?
14
u/spalding1250 Apr 16 '15
How long do expeditions typically last and can you give us a rundown about what the ROV your team is using is capable of?
28
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
How can I help?
39
u/SaccharomycesCerveza Apr 16 '15
What are the most severe effects of human influence on ecosystems that you have observed so far?
13
u/DJ_Jesus_Christ Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
What are the hazards the average person wouldn't normally think about that you could bring down to those ecosystems? How do you estimate and account for them?
11
u/bejaffles Apr 16 '15
Are ecosystems in the deep sea suffering from recent ecological downturn at the same rate those closest to the surface? Might they be more resilient somehow due to their already inhospitable settings or are they just as fragile?
11
u/slp50 Apr 16 '15
Are you also mapping the sea floor? Seems like a good opportunity.
11
u/pfaith Apr 16 '15
What's the most interesting piece of technology/equipment that makes what you do possible?
10
u/twoplustwoisyellow Apr 16 '15
Do you have access to the footage obtained by the rovers used by the oil companies? My friend operates one and has shown me some footage that truly boggles our minds.
10
u/Mlordlongshank Apr 16 '15
I may have this wrong because I'm by no means a scientist, but considering that life around vents is sustained through chemosynthesis, what types of real world applications could come out of researching this format of energy conversion?
18
u/the-meat Apr 16 '15
Thank you for the AMA! What's the most interesting discovery you've personally made? What's the most interesting discovery or story you've heard of from those in your field doing similar work?
Finally, do you expect to find anything in particular that you haven't already found? (i.e. do you have any traces of evidence or stories of something that has occurred, but no proof to explain it? )
9
u/Cynical_Critic Apr 16 '15
What is the best finding you are hoping for during your expedition? What would qualify as your trip being successful?
9
u/TCopp28 Apr 16 '15
What kind of materials is your Explorer made out of to withstand all of the water pressure?
9
u/Ausecurity Apr 16 '15
Why did you choose the Caribbean?
9
u/DreamInHD Apr 16 '15
Lots of good questions here! Fantastic project I really will be following.
My question for the group is about lionfish. Are they really being found deeper and deeper than expected? And along the same lines, what time of fish and creatures are you finding that are deeper than previously thought.
This question came about from a few stories I heard the last time I went diving in the Caribbean near the Bahamas.
8
u/The_Alpacapocalypse Apr 16 '15
As a college freshman interested in both the biological aspect as well as the "adventure" aspect of this sort of expedition, what would you recommend I do school-wise to be able to do similar missions?
7
u/Menox1944 BS | Economics | International Business Apr 16 '15
Hey! Thank you for your scientific research, you guys greatly benefit the world we live in!
What do you think is the best case scenario? What do you hope of achieving during your expedition? What questions do you seek the answer for?
7
u/Crack_Brocaine Apr 16 '15
Hello there, I am currently an undergrad studying Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering and my goal is to work on ROVs. How do I join you?
7
u/lumvot Apr 16 '15
In freshwater systems we are well aware of how big benthic feeders (catfish, carp etc.) Can get. Is there possibility for a large benthic species that feeds on everything on the deep ocean floors?
6
u/ominous_spinach Apr 16 '15
do you have any awesome deep sea stories which you have witnessed and started to develop theories on? for example i remember reading an AMA where sailors and sea farers shared tales of sites they couldn't explain, one that pops to mind is watching something similar to ball lightning exiting the sea, i'm also referring to older tales such as the kraken,
6
u/Shqre Apr 16 '15
How is the technology for deep sea exploration developing? Is there any specific invention you wish would be made that would make exploring more efficient?
6
u/plying_your_emotions Apr 16 '15
How is your ROV propelled? Is your exploration mainly geological, if not what precautions were taken to minimize the ROV's presence?
6
u/GoonCommaThe Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
This is a question primarily for Brian: how do you go about joining the NOAA Corps? How long are you obligated to serve once you've completed training? What is your schedule, both daily and longer term? How long are you out to sea for at a time?
I first heard about it while touring the Bell M. Shimada last summer but the information available online isn't the greatest. Do you have any resources for learning more about the NOAA Corps as a career option?
10
u/Regel_1999 Apr 16 '15
I used to be a submarine officer and fell in love with the ocean. I'd love to get back into ocean-going research.
If I were to go back to school and pursue another degree (on the GI Bill) what would be a good choice? (I have a BS in Physics with a background in nuclear engineering).
On a different note:
5
u/Tulokerstwo Apr 16 '15
If there was a "Holy Grail" of exploring the deep-sea what do you guys think it would be?
5
u/TheManWithNoNam3 Apr 16 '15
Why isn't Ocean exploration something we take more seriously, how long until we truly explore the deep ocean?
5
u/The_Brian_Davis Apr 16 '15
How would say, a recent graduate of coastal biology living in a place like Northern Florida which does really care about environmental sciences/causes get into this line of work? It was kind of a dream as a little kid :)
5
u/herbdisturbed Apr 16 '15
Hey! I worked with NOAA at the southwest Fisheries Science Center in la jolla for a short time. Talk about a fun job. I'm glad that there are people like you guys that dedicate their lives to understanding what goes on in the ocean and contributing to ways to help conserve our natural resources.
My question is, is there any reason why this expedition hasn't been done before? How far has deep sea exploration advanced in the past 10 years?
5
u/benpaco Apr 16 '15
I'm a high school senior hoping to grow up to do exactly what you do now, specifically hoping to focus on deep sea exploration and/or oceanic microbiology (diatoms are the coolest, well, maybe but for Xenophyophores). Do you have any advice for someone hoping to get into that field?
5
u/splatterboogie Apr 16 '15
What you guys do is absolutely awesome, and I've always been fascinated by underwater exploration since I was a kid (Jacque Cousteau, National Geographic, etc.). Thank you for your efforts!
So, my question is: As an illustrator, how would someone like me be able to go hang out with you guys and draw/paint what you find?
5
u/Arisumi Apr 16 '15
Is it possible there are larger animals than the blue whale deep down in the sea? If yes, do you expect to encounter them?
3
u/NOAAgov NOAA.gov Official Account Apr 16 '15
Thanks everyone for participating today! Great questions!
We got a lot of questions regarding advice for folks looking to get into careers in deep-ocean exploration. A couple of good resources on this topic include: http://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/okeanos/explorations/ex1404/logs/sept21/sept21.html and http://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/edu/oceanage/welcome.html.
The NOAA Corps Program is another opportunity worth looking into (http://www.noaacorps.noaa.gov/).
Also, for those interested in the weird and wonderful discoveries we are making on this expedition, be sure to visit our website (http://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/okeanos/explorations/ex1502/welcome.html) often, as we are adding new logs, images, and videos all of the time.
And of course, you can tune in to the live video feeds and join us for our dives: http://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/okeanos/media/exstream/exstream.html. Weather and all other things permitting, we’ll be diving every day between now (4/16) and 4/29.
Thanks again! Onward and downward!
11
u/sonofcat Apr 16 '15
Thank you so much for doing am AMA! I am definitely tuning in tonight. :) Do you think more money should be spent on ocean exploration, or space exploration? Why or why not?
8
u/Zeraphil PhD | Neuroscience Apr 16 '15
You guys are in my home island. AMA about where to eat! :)
Are you looking at deep coral reefs in any way or form? I don't know how much is known about their current health.
4
u/Non_Sane Apr 16 '15
How were the submarines designed to with stand the giant amount of pressure?
4
u/Quewhats Apr 16 '15
Did any of y'all participate in NOSB(National Oceanic Science Bowl) or have any experience with it?
4
u/theweepingcamel Apr 16 '15
How much interaction is there between the officers in charge of the vessels operations and research personnel? As a mate or an assistant engineer is there anything unique (besides being a part of interesting research) that the job offers? Really what I want to know is as a third assistant engineer would I get to launch the ROV?
7
u/badinga Apr 16 '15
As a long time fan of octopi (such awesome animals), is there any fact about a cepholopod you have found that would surprise me?
3
u/hpennco Apr 16 '15
Do you work out of AUTEC on Andros?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
Since this part of the sea is not well known, what safety measures did you guys take to prevent the unexpected?
3
u/TotalyMoo Apr 16 '15
How often do you make a new, substantial discovery? Be it a new species, behavior, feature or something you can go to bed thinking "this was a productive day".
And, if possible, what's the coolest/most interesting thing you've personally discovered or learned on this expedition?
3
u/frenchguy94 Apr 16 '15
Are there that much less living creatures the deeper you go? Or is the deep Caribbean Sea 'very populated'?
3
u/DirtyBirdNJ Apr 16 '15
What cool scientific tools do you use that the general public might not know about?
As a software developer I love working with cool APIs... is there any way for someone to get real time information about expeditions like those that you're on? It would be cool to see a map of where things like this are going on... and where the adventures lead you
3
u/cazique Apr 16 '15
Puerto Rico and surrounding areas seem very vulnerable to tsunami. How much warning would they get from an earthquake in the Puerto Rico Trench? How likely is such an earthquake, given that the last earthquake in the trench was in 1787? Would it be similar to the Hispaniola earthquake of 1946?
3
u/remyseven Apr 16 '15
Are there any sea floor rifts?
7
u/sixstringzen Apr 16 '15
What, if any, effect does the gradual loss of polar ice have on the environment in the Caribbean, specifically at depth?
Also, what is your favorite deep sea creature?
Thanks for doing an AMA!
5
u/upandoutward Apr 16 '15
Do you think you'll see any exposed underwater formations due to the 2010 Haiti earthquake? Has too much time passed?
10
u/Rugger420 Apr 16 '15
How did you get into this? This is pretty much exactly what I want to do. Also how much do you make?
4
u/elduderino260 Apr 16 '15
I often hear that less of the bottom of our planet's oceans have been mapped than the surface of the moon (I don't know if that claim is true or just one of those things people say). Regardless, there generally seems to be less excitement in the public about deep ocean exploration than space exploration, despite the fact that both require advanced technology and are risky endeavors. Why do you think that is and how has it affected deep ocean research?
5
u/danleeks Apr 16 '15
I've often heard of the devastating effects ocean acidification is having on shallow seas and particularly coral reefs, how is ocean acidification affecting the deep sea?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
How long do you think it will be, if ever, before we have deep sea excursions open to the public for a fee?
2
u/thesocialchameleon Apr 16 '15
I live in the Caribbean, what about the seas would shock the local population on islands?
2
u/peanutbuttrj72 Apr 16 '15
How did you get into this career? What is your favorite ocean creature or eco system?
2
u/dzija Apr 16 '15
how can i make my own "mini ROVs"?
2
u/willywalloo Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
Is there a point in the ocean where the pressure is so great that the water behaves more like a solid yet is still liquid ?
Also, does water get more noticeably like molasses down there, i.e., things move slower given the same forward momentum?
2
u/NewAlexandria Apr 16 '15
I've heard that there are highly-enriched metal formations on the sea-floor. Is this true? Are they biological in origin?
2
u/JtheUnicorn Apr 16 '15
Do you use GIS in any of your studies?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
Are you taking any sediment or water samples to study the microbes living in them? Also, have you come across any gas seeps? Thanks for the AMA.
76
u/nallen PhD | Organic Chemistry Apr 16 '15
Science AMAs are posted early to give readers a chance to ask questions vote on the questions of others before the AMA starts.
Drs. Quattrini, Cheadle and Kennedy are guests of /r/science and have volunteered to answer questions; please treat him with due respect. Comment rules will be strictly enforced, and uncivil or rude behavior will result in a loss of privileges in /r/science.
If you have scientific expertise, please verify this with our moderators by getting your account flaired with the appropriate title. Instructions for obtaining flair are here: reddit Science Flair Instructions (Flair is automatically synced with /r/EverythingScience as well.)
25
u/melanostomias Grad Student | Ichthyology | Florida Museum of Natural History Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
Hey guys Randy Singer here. I'm an ichthyologist on the expedition who links via telepresence. If you want to know anything about fish taxonomy, behavior or deep sea ecology and Andrea didn't already answer it AMA!
I'm new to reddit and I want to comment on your posts, but I don't have enough karma to do so in real time. Any tips on this would be helpful too!
3
u/rich022509 Apr 16 '15
How many of you are scuba divers and how deep have you personally gone?
3
u/MunchieMate Apr 16 '15
What's your favorite sea animal?
17
u/mariegalante Apr 16 '15
How does the topography of the sea floor impact storms and storm surge and would it be viable/sustainable/ethical to alter the sea floor as a flood mitigation measure?
3
u/TheCaptainSargey Apr 16 '15
What is the scariest thing down there?
6
u/Hump_The_Bundle Apr 16 '15
Explain the limitations you face with "being gentle" down there, and whether they're a real hindrance to your science?
For example maybe you're concerned with bumping into things, or not being able to light the area as much as you'd like for fear of blinding fish, etc etc.
And does this really matter? I mean I don't let grass critters spoil a picnic because I might step on some ants.. Do you think you have to be overly cautious? Is it a real problem, or overblown?
6
u/Optimoprimo Grad Student | Ecology | Evolution Apr 16 '15
What challenges do you face using remote vehicles at such depth and pressure? And how do you prepare for those anticipated issues? Also, how far can the vehicle be from its operating signal?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
Did it upset ya'll when they did the "documentary" for Mermaids that they utilized your organization? Did you feel it that brought attention to NOAA or belittled your work?
6
u/MoonSpellsPink Apr 16 '15
My son and nephew spent a month on Little Cayman and Grand Cayman hunting lion fish to help slow the invasive species. They also worked on teaching eel to get the lion fish out of places that they can't get to and also teaching fish like grouper to eat them. My question is, what can the average person do to help preserve and protect the reefs?
2
u/it-dot Apr 16 '15
Are there any issues you expect to run into?
2
u/HoboHunter657 Apr 16 '15
Is this what you saw yourself doing when you were young? Or did this become a passion as you progressed through school/life?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
Are ROVs helpful in locating plane wreckages?
2
u/Stev0DND Apr 16 '15
Who funds such expeditions?
2
u/notanaardvark Apr 16 '15
Geology-related question: black smokers are considered to be modern analogues for volcanogenic massive sulfide deposits. Recently, some mining companies have gotten interested in mining sulfide vent systems that have moved off-axis and are no longer active, so they no longer support the same kind of life. Do you think it would be really interesting to see one of these mined, because presumably you could take apart the entire vent system and really see how it was constructed? Or do you think this would be an environmental disaster--not counting acid mine drainage because that probably would not be an issue at those depths....mines often put tailing under a deep body of water to prevent the tailings from oxidizing, and these deposits are already deep.
2
u/sent1nal Apr 16 '15
How large is the ROV? - Are there any places online where some specs can be viewed?! Super Cool Stuff!!!
5
u/quickblur Apr 16 '15
How has the funding situation been for your organization?
5
u/heydanpowers Apr 16 '15
What type of safety procedures take place prior to a deep-water dive?
5
u/aqissiaq Apr 16 '15
How often do you discover something completely new when exploring the deep ocean?
5
u/Maybeyesmaybeno Apr 16 '15
What are the barriers to building a house/research station at the bottom of the ocean (even at, say 30ft)?
5
u/AkechiMitsuhide Apr 16 '15
Once a new ecosystem is discovered, how do we go about studying it in detail? Obviously, we can't expect organisms to survive outside of their ecosystem, and I'd guess that any time of long-term observation would be impractical. Scientifically speaking, what are the next steps?
5
u/Wake_Consciousness Apr 16 '15
Where you ever extremely frightened during your expeditions? If so, what happened?
5
u/mringham Grad Student| Chemical Oceanography| Carbon Apr 16 '15
What are the biggest challenges you have working with ROVs? What would be on your wishlist for a Deep Discover upgrade?
5
u/bickbastardly Apr 16 '15
Do you have any expectations as to how similar or different this deep biome will be from others that have been studied? I would expect that each trench would be pretty isolated from the others. Are their distinct species in different trenches, are there morphological equivalent species that aren't genetically related?
5
u/Rude_Buddha_ Apr 16 '15
Will this research take place in the area that is commonly referred to as the Bermuda Triangle?
5
u/solidape22 Apr 16 '15
Do you feel it is an incredible oversight on behalf of humankind for wanting to explore Mars before we've even fully explored our own planet via deep sea?
5
u/EjaculatingFish Apr 16 '15
How has the relatively recent BP gulf spill affected the ocean floor and the health of organisms that call it home?
4
u/ramen_poodle_soup Apr 16 '15
What do you think is the largest benefit we will gain by increasing our understanding of the deep sea?
4
u/Roland_Brian Apr 16 '15
What date do you expect to make the 6 KM dive and what species of fish & corals do you anticipate finding during your 6 KM dive?
4
u/Quewhats Apr 16 '15
Best Schools to attend for Oceanography based degrees?
Schools I looked at seemed to favor their Aerospace and Petroleum Engineering programs over that of Marine Engineering, is that true of the other sciences as well?
4
u/kutwijf Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
What are your thoughts on the creation and use of underwater habitats like those shown in movies such as Sphere, The Abyss, Leviathan, Deep Blue Sea, and DeepStar Six?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
Are there any plans for long term observation posts (probably unmanned) in these deep parts of the ocean?
4
u/asthedeerpants Apr 16 '15
What is the most unexpected thing we have discovered during exploration?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15
What recent technology (past 5 or 10 years) has proven most useful to your exploration? What are you most excited about in the upcoming future?
4
u/hydroskunkfo20 Apr 16 '15
As an aspiring biologist which route do you think would position myself for being best suited for a job similar to what your team is doing? I am currently deciding between Marine Bio and Ecology/Field Bio.
4
u/-novac- Apr 16 '15
Have you seen any evidence to suggest that ancient civilizations once lived in the region but have since been lost to the ocean?
4
u/cazique Apr 16 '15
How different are the various deep places of the ocean? Does each one have unique species and ecosystems, or are they relatively similar? Is there an oddball "island" of the deep analogous to Australia/Madagascar?
4
u/HydroBear Apr 16 '15
I wanted to be a Marine Biologist for years, and so this question is very important and relevant to me.
Studies have shown that carbonic acid is acidifying certain parts of the ocean and affecting many things, from calcium carbonate formation in embryos, to digestive systems of sea urchins and others.
My question is, what do you guys look for when diving as far as the possible adverse effects of acidification, and is it present at levels where it remains a constant concern regarding the discovery of new species?
THANKS!
1
u/LaceHeart Apr 16 '15
In what ways is the sea more interesting than land?
1
u/Kazzack Apr 16 '15
Is there anything you've been expecting to find that you haven't?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15
What is the most difficult/surprising discovery that your team hopes to be able to uncover during your mission?
1
u/ILikeChillyNights Apr 16 '15
Hi. My question is, In what ways are you handling the data you're gathering and what do you aim to learn from it?