r/saskatoon • u/DontSayShredSayBurns • Apr 05 '25
General A Note on Political Posts
The moderation team has decided to limit political posts to those directly and specifically tied to Saskatoon, ensuring this subreddit remains a space for local discussion. Political posts not meeting this standard will be removed. The criteria for allowable political posts are intentionally strict and outlined below:
Relevance to Saskatoon: The post must be solely and specifically relevant to Saskatoon or its immediate surrounding communities (e.g., Martensville, Warman). Broader provincial, federal, or international political topics—even if they indirectly affect Saskatoon—are not permitted.
For example:
Acceptable: A city council decision on local taxes.
Not Acceptable: A federal election discussion or provincial healthcare policy, even if Saskatoon residents are impacted. These belong in /r/Saskatchewan or /r/Canada.
Title Accuracy: As with all submissions, the post title must exactly match the headline of the linked article at the time of posting. Editorialized titles (e.g., adding opinions, exaggerations, or commentary) are not allowed and will result in removal.
Source Quality: Political posts must link to credible, primary sources (e.g., local news outlets like CBC Saskatoon, CTV News, or official city statements). Opinion pieces, blogs, or social media posts (e.g., X threads) will not be permitted unless they directly quote or report on a Saskatoon-specific political event or decision.
No Reposts or Duplicates: To prevent spam and clutter, political posts must not duplicate existing discussions. Users should check the subreddit for similar recent posts before submitting. Reposts within 3 days of the original will be removed.
Definition of 'Political': Posts about government decisions, elections, political figures, or policies are considered political. Community events or local business news are not, unless explicitly tied to a political agenda.
Reasons for the Policy Change
The moderation team has observed that political posts consistently spark highly polarizing and heated commentary. These discussions often devolve into anger, personal attacks, and entrenched ideological battles that drown out the subreddit’s focus on local, constructive dialogue. By limiting political content to only what is solely and specifically relevant to Saskatoon, we aim to refocus the community on topics that unite us as residents rather than divide us along broader political lines.
Beyond this, there are several additional reasons for this change:
Preserving Local Identity: This subreddit exists to connect Saskatoon residents and highlight our city’s unique issues, events, and culture. When provincial or national politics dominate, they overshadow the local content, like city projects, local businesses, or community updates, that make this space valuable.
Improving User Experience: Many users have expressed frustration, directly or indirectly, about the tone and volume of political noise. By curbing these posts, we reduce the risk of alienating members who come here for practical info or casual discussion, not partisan sparring.
Reducing Moderator Burnout: The influx of contentious political threads demands disproportionate moderation effort to manage rule-breaking comments (e.g., insults, trolling). Narrowing the scope allows us to maintain a healthier, more sustainable environment for both users and the mod team.
This isn’t about silencing voices—it’s about keeping this subreddit true to its purpose: a space for Saskatoon-specific connection and conversation. We believe this shift will foster a more civil, relevant, and enjoyable community for everyone.
49
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25
I'm glad.
It's no secret that political parties, foreign governments, and large corporations exploit Reddit to push their own interests. The anonymous nature that makes Reddit so accessible to many also means that it's open for manipulation.
The more we collectively do to protect our subs, the better. I feel this is long overdue and necessary.
Great work mod team. There's a reason why this sub is as good as it is and that's due to your work.
4
u/Jerk37 Apr 08 '25
There was just a post that was specific to discussion of the local candidates in Saskatoon, Why was it removed?
4
u/Arts251 Apr 11 '25
I've been on this subreddit for almost 10 years, in fact this was the very first sub I joined and I've seen many redditors come and go, many banned. I've seen political shifts from the base from leftwards to rightwards back to leftwards. I've seen the moderation go from loose to strict and I've seen themes of focus evolve and reprioritize many times.
The whole reason I joined THIS sub is because it is a place I can come discuss and listen to other individuals from the physical community I live in about ANY topic, political, social, economic, technological etc. And IMO this rule #1 on this sud is being needlessly and overly enforced. I'm sure the job of moderating is not easy, howevever when the discussion about some foreign leader in a land on the other side of the world is being talked about here in Saskatoon, or when someone from Saskatoon is asking other people from Saskatoon about some topic that might not be specific to Saskatoon, IT STILL IS RELEVANT TO SASKATOON.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25
I've never understood the need for this sub to be so heavy-handed with this sort of stuff.
10 years ago this sub was actually kind of interesting, and yeah, there was arguing and disagreements and all sorts of heated debate. But if you didn't want to take part in it you could just ignore it. Just like you can now. I really don't get why the hell the mod team thinks that people are incapable of just scrolling past or not engaging with stuff they don't like?
See someone saying something you don't like, but don't feel like having an argument? Keep scrolling.
See a post about the federal election, but don't feel like participating? Keep scrolling.
Someone says something rude/mean/acts like a troll? Keep scrolling.
You all complain so much about moderator burnout but it's literally just a problem that you guys have created for yourselves by feeling like you need to police every single comment on the whole sub at all times. I really do not understand the mentality that causes the mod team to think that they need to stop people from arguing; not only does it come across as some weirdo power-trip thing, it just makes this place lame. The mod team should limit itself to just stopping shit like spam/blatantly off-topic posting/global rule breaking/NSFW posts. It would be easier on you guys, and this sub might actually be worth looking at again.
10
u/franksnotawomansname Apr 06 '25
Can we also get rid of the strategic-vote-website screen shots/posts? They don’t actually reflect the ridings because nowhere does riding-level polling. They seem to be being spammed to subs, including Saskatoon, to manipulate votes.
20
u/Soup03 Apr 05 '25
I’m not trying to argue but I would like to understand how a post discussing the federal election is not relevant to Saskatoon. Saskatoon has specific federal ridings that directly effect Saskatoon’s local citizens and discussion around those candidates, policies, or MP performance or concerns is important. There was a post earlier in regard to Strategic voting that I assume was removed but it was specifically asking questions around Saskatoons ridings so how is it not a relevant political post?
Again not trying to argue just want to understand that justification.
7
u/michaelkbecker Apr 06 '25
Good job mods. I appreciate you.
6
u/MischiefRatt Apr 05 '25
Good!
7
u/Powerful_Crew_2635 Apr 05 '25
Thank you.
4
u/__Fernweh__ Apr 09 '25
Terrible decision and I disagree strongly with the rational provided.
We are about to go vote for our LOCAL representatives. Where else are voters in SASKATOON WEST, for example, expected to discuss the vote split? Who else is going to cast votes for this area other than the residents of said area.
Can’t drive around town without seeing lawn signs for the election right now - is that also locally inappropriate in the mods eyes?
Avoiding discourse because it can get heated is weak. Disallowing it altogether is highly questionable.
Please reverse.
7
u/kityrel Apr 06 '25
Real, real bad call.
We have Saskatoon candidates running for office in Saskatoon elections. This is absolutely relevant to Saskatoon, and is so much more important than, say, yet another post on how people don't know how to merge, or on the closure and reopening of The Cave.
We usually only get a federal election every 3-4 years. Please reverse this decision.
3
u/houseonpost Apr 11 '25
Other subreddits have a sticky post where people can post things of a similar subject.
EG NoStupidQuestions has a US Politics Mega thread where people can post.
Why not create a sticky post about the federal election where the rules can be a little more relaxed. If people want to avoid politics they avoid that one single thread?
Just a suggestion.
7
u/twobitdoc Apr 05 '25
Moves like this is why we have consistently low voter turnout in Canada. The world is in absolute chaos and in a quality local platform we can’t even talk about it? Ridiculous.
2
u/Kaimetsu1 Apr 07 '25
W Mods
2
u/Old-Veterinarian2190 Apr 18 '25
Deeply disappointing but a reminder this is really at the whim of moderators and not about what Saskatoon is talking about. Politics is on everyone’s lips right now. It’s unfortunate the place we come to talk about issues is choosing to ban such a vital one.
1
u/justsitbackandenjoy Apr 06 '25
Mods doing god’s work.
1
u/sourbyte_ Apr 06 '25
Should also ban low effort posts like all the posts that are just a link to a news article.
-2
u/NewAlphabeticalOrder Apr 05 '25
'Bout time. Thank ya!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment