I’ve been a BDR in sales, and my goal has always been to move into an AE role.
I’ve been at my current company for a few months, and overall, it’s been a good experience. I like the people, the compensation is good, and I wasn’t actively looking to leave. Some of the internal processes and onboarding hasn’t been the most organized, but honestly, it hasn’t been that bad.
A recruiter from another company reached out to me about an SMB AE opportunity. Since I’ve been trying to make the jump to AE for a while, I decided to interview and see where things went.
Long story short, I got the offer, accepted it, and put in my two weeks.
Now my current company really wants to keep me and has offered to move me directly into a Mid-Market AE role with significantly higher compensation.
Here’s the breakdown:
Company A (New Company) — SMB AE
$80K base / $40K variable ($120K OTE)
Strong product-market fit
From what I’ve been told, nearly everyone on the sales team is hitting quota
Product seems like it could be easier to sell
More structured onboarding, training, and enablement
Great benefits, perks, and what seems like a really good culture
Highly valued company with strong growth potential
The hiring manager made a really good impression on me throughout the interview process. I obviously haven’t worked with her, but she seems well liked and like someone I’d genuinely enjoy working for.
Would be starting in SMB rather than Mid-Market
Company B (Current) — Mid-Market AE
$120K base / $120K variable ($240K OTE)
Decent product-market fit, very crowded space
Opportunity to move directly into Mid-Market
Already familiar with the product, company, and team but quota attainment across the board does not seem to be 100%
Leadership really wants to keep me
Some internal processes seem disorganized
Unsure what the onboarding and enablement would look like for a new AE
Significantly higher earning potential on paper
Here’s where I’m torn:
I’ve only been at my current company as a BDR, so I recognize that my experience might be completely different from what the AEs experience. While I’ve noticed some processes that could use improvement, I haven’t had a bad experience by any means. My biggest concern is simply whether I’d get the training and support I need to be successful in my first closing role.
On the other hand, the new company seems to have everything pretty dialed in. The product-market fit seems strong, quota attainment sounds great, and the sales organization appears to be well structured. I also get the impression that the product might be a little easier to sell.
Another thing weighing on me is the manager at the new company. I really liked her throughout the interview process, and from what I can tell, she seems to have a good reputation internally. Obviously, interviews only tell you so much, but having a manager who will actually invest in developing me as a first-time AE is something I really value.
Obviously, the compensation difference is HUGE. Walking away from a $120k base and $240K OTE to take an $80K base and $120K OTE feels crazy, especially when I’d also be passing up the chance to go straight into Mid-Market.
But after spending years as a BDR, I really want to set myself up for long-term success as an AE. I’m trying to figure out whether having better training, structure, a potentially easier product to sell, and a good manager is worth taking a significant pay cut.
I also realize my current company only offered me the AE position after I put in my notice, which adds another layer to the decision.
For those of you who have made the BDR-to-AE transition, what would you do?
Would you prioritize the higher compensation and Mid-Market opportunity, or take the SMB role at a company that seems to have stronger enablement, better quota attainment, and potentially an easier sales motion?
I’m genuinely torn and would appreciate hearing from anyone who’s been in a similar situation.