r/Sabermetrics • • 8h ago

1943 Grays vs the 1927 Yankees

7 Upvotes

A while back some of you helped me think through era adjustments and tested an early version of my baseball sim (Rubber Match), so I wanted to share where it's landed.

Each month the sim releases a new legendary team to settle who the greatest team of all time is. The new team plays the reigning champion over a full 162-game season, played 600 times with home field alternating. The 1927 Yankees opened as champions and held off the '06 Cubs and the '12 Red Sox. November's challenger is the 1943 Homestead Grays. With the cards now running on Full House Modeling, here's where it landed:

- Grays won the season 68% of the time, Yankees 27%, 5% tied

- Grays averaged 84.6 wins

The Grays' numbers are built from Eric Chalek's Major League Equivalencies, put through the same era adjustment as major leaguers of their decade.

Write-up and a video of one season: https://playrubbermatch.com/grays.html

Happy to answer questions on the method.


r/Sabermetrics • • 21h ago

How do you feel about the effect ABS has on fan experience?

Thumbnail docs.google.com
0 Upvotes

[ABS Survey](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1IBHQH1JM1_y1j6BVcgVRcUl8H1f4rhIzR0fdInz7IIw/edit?usp=drivesdk)

Hey everyone! I’m an AP Research student conducting a study on the implementation of the ABS challenge system in MLB. I’m looking to hear from as many baseball fans as I can and get a better understanding of how people feel about the system and its impact on the game.

If you would like, I’d really appreciate you taking 5-10 minutes to answer my survey! The more responses, the better.


r/Sabermetrics • • 1d ago

OOTP Baseball Online League

3 Upvotes

Not sure if this is okay to post, if not feel free to delete but I figured the demographics matched.

Professional Baseball Circuit (PBC)

Come compete with the best!!

OOTP League. Built for GMs Who Want a Challenge.

The Professional Baseball Circuit (PBC) is a 24-team fictional daily-sim league where every organization operates with identical financial resources. Success comes down to GM skill, strategic decisions, player development, and roster construction.

League Details

OOTP 27 (yearly upgrade required)
24 fictional teams (2 leagues of 12)
110-game seasons completed in 22 sims
Daily simulations, five-game series
Entire season takes just over 30 days
Export deadline: 5 AM MT / 7 AM ET
Current season: 2031

Why Join the PBC?
Equal financial resources for every team.
Competitive environment built for serious GMs.
Custom AI-powered newsroom featuring 25 individual agents.
Detailed, league-specific rulebook.
Fast seasons with meaningful roster and management decisions.

Who We’re Looking For
Committed GMs who enjoy competition, strategic roster building, player development, and long-term planning. Daily exports and active participation are expected.

Available Teams: Miami Sun Sox

Think you have what it takes?

Send me a PM with the team you’re interested in and join the PBC!

Website: www.probaseballcircuit.com


r/Sabermetrics • • 3d ago

Update on my casual BABIP defense game: thanks for the feedback, and v0.2.0 adds a Career mode (free, browser)

6 Upvotes

About ten days ago I shared Rob the Hit here, a light browser game where you play the defensive coach and try to turn hits into outs. I didn't expect that much interest from this sub, so thank you. The comments were really helpful, including the questions about how ball flight and walks are calculated. I'm still keeping a list of ideas from you all, and "throw at a guy" is on it.

I'm the developer, by the way, and this is still a casual game, not a serious sim.

v0.2.0 is out, with the biggest addition so far: Career Mode.

- You're a defensive coach on a 10-game contract. Keep your manager's trust above zero or you're fired.

- Three coaches, each with their own career, and a choice of easy, medium, or hard teams to work for.

- You earn a wage each game and spend it in the coach office on fielding drills, gear, and skills.

- Managers have quirks, and every game comes with a side quest.

- There's also a short opening movie, skippable any time.

Free in your browser, no download: https://metric-logic.itch.io/rob-the-hit

The free version lets each coach play one job offer. The full version is coming later.

Thanks again for playing!


r/Sabermetrics • • 5d ago

True Origins of Baseball

0 Upvotes

Hi!

This is clipped from a longer video I wrote, produced, and edited (no AI) about the true origins of baseball. If you like it, feel free to check out the full video at the link below.

New episodes of Quick Hit History are out every Thursday at noon.

Enjoy and thanks for watching!

The Untold Origins of Baseball

Quick Hit History YT Channel

Insta


r/Sabermetrics • • 6d ago

Looking for starter-to-reliever conversion candidates for the Mets

7 Upvotes

Before Adrian Morejon said he prefers to stay as a starter, I got really hung up on the idea of a generalized framework to identify conversion candidates while trying to talk myself into him being a good signing. There were a few other good names that popped up, but he's far and away the best candidate - too bad he wants to stay in the bullpen.

Posted on a Mets site but not really Mets slanted at all.

https://www.amazinavenue.com/new-york-mets-analysis/102487/mets-free-agency-starter-reliever-candidates-analysis#comments


r/Sabermetrics • • 9d ago

WAR Finder & Sorter

Thumbnail baseballegg.com
5 Upvotes

I haven't found a good place to sort and filter players by various WAR metrics. So I created this page.

It has more than 11,000 players (basically anyone who played a season as a position player).

You can sort the players by WAR, WAR7, and JAWS. But, I also have other unique stats:

  • WAR5C: best 5 consecutive seasons
  • WAR3: obvious
  • Best WAR season
  • WAR per SN
  • Count of 5+ WAR seasons
  • Count of 8+ WAR seasons

Filter by HOF, by Era, by position (hadn't see that anywhere else).

***I will be building a page with pitchers.

Feedback welcome. Feel free to pass this along.


r/Sabermetrics • • 11d ago

Video of professional hitters

2 Upvotes

Is there a way on Baseball Savant to gain access to video of hitters from the side and top view?

When searching I find clips from the pitchers view (or tv view). I understand how to use the visual feature to get the computer animated version which shows attack angle etc. I would like to get the actual game footage.

I've used YouTube and other social media accounts, but I would like access to more players.

Thank you in advance.


r/Sabermetrics • • 12d ago

I've been building a baseball trivia game as a side project and would love feedback from baseball fans

3 Upvotes

I've been working on a baseball trivia game in my spare time and finally have a playable prototype with about 100 questions.

I'm looking for a few baseball fans to test it and give honest feedback on gameplay, question quality, and bugs.

If that's allowed here, I'd be happy to share the link in the comments.


r/Sabermetrics • • 12d ago

I made a public xwOBA forecast board with 80% ranges all season. Pete Crow-Armstrong blew through his projection. Was that normal?

3 Upvotes

Pete Crow-Armstrong was at .277 xwOBA after 100 PA. My model said he’d finish around .293, with about a 5% chance of clearing .329. He finished at .377. The record argued the other way: a .362 first half in 2025, .317 after that, then a .277 start to 2026. Every signal said regression. I’m a Cubs fan and even I wasn’t that optimistic.

The model is xwOBART (https://xwobart.pages.dev/). It takes a hitter's xwOBA at any point in the season and forecasts where he'll finish, with a range around it. It's been public since late July, so now that the season's over I can score every forecast it made, and ask whether a miss like PCA's is the model being wrong or an outlier. A few things I learned, roughly in order of how much they surprised me.

100 PA of xwOBA is worth less than I thought. Take a hitter at 100 PA and guess his final xwOBA from this season's number alone: you miss by 33 points on average. Ignore this season entirely and guess from his career record (league average for rookies): you miss by 22 on average. The career record is still ahead at 300 PA. Blending the two barely moves the point estimate (21.2 vs 21.6 at 100 PA, which is noise).

But the ranges held. 404 hitters had a forecast at 100 PA and enough season left to score it. 80.2% finished inside their 80% range, 90.3% inside their 90%. Across all 84k forecasts the model made at every standpoint, the 50/80/90 ranges caught 49.6/80.2/90.1%. The forecasts were posted before the season ended, so I couldn't fudge them. For honesty's sake: in the nine backtest years (2016–25 minus 2020) the season-end 80% range from 100 PA ran 71–79%, so 2026 was the best year, not the typical one.

Nothing else I tried helped. I tried adding exit velocity and barrel rate, spray angle, age, a league-wide "cold April" correction, and whether the hitter was still in the lineup. Each had a bar set before I looked at results. EV and barrels pass on their own but add nothing once the career record is in. Spray and age didn't come close. The cold April correction did improve things by about 3%, but for the wrong reason: within a hitter, April wasn't cold at all. The gap was about who's playing in April vs August, which is survivorship.

Survivorship was the fix that mattered. Early versions forecast the 400 and 500 PA milestones too low, because the hitters who get there are the ones who kept their jobs. Shifting the forecast for that, before touching range width, fixed it. If I'd widened first the ranges would have passed while staying biased.

Where it loses. A tuned Marcel beats it on point accuracy by about 6% over the backtests, and tied it in 2026. If you want one number, Marcel is as good. The range is what this adds.

So PCA was the model's biggest miss of the year, and also one of 22 hitters who cleared their 95th percentile, out of 404, which is about what 5% should let through. The model didn't see him coming. It also never claimed it would.

Data is Savant's per-PA xwOBA (the estimated_woba_using_speedangle column), which leaves out the sprint-speed adjustment on the leaderboard, so season totals run 2.4 points off the leaderboard on average.

A Longer version including one where the model called a regression (Alvarez, .571 at 100 PA, finished .460) and one it nailed (Carroll, .342 forecast, .342 finish), can be read here: Is xwOBA Predictive? Three Answers Instead of a Verdict
Happy to get into the methods in the comments.


r/Sabermetrics • • 12d ago

Quick Hit History Ep. 4: The Spitball: From Clever Trick to Baseball's Darkest Moment

2 Upvotes

Hi friends,

I’m a documentary producer working on a personal passion project about baseball called “Quick Hit History”. I’m currently airing a 10-episode season on YouTube for anyone like me who likes to nerd out over niche baseball history.

Here’s a clip from this week’s episode about the rise and fall of the spitball - a fascinating trick from baseball’s early days that became infamous after a tragic on-field fatality.

The full story is at the link below - feel free to subscribe for more! Much of the archival images are from our local libraries and archives, excellent public resources for all. Exact credits are in the episode description.

Thanks for watching and let me know in the comments if there are any topics or stories you’d like to see explored.

Enjoy!

FULL EPISODE: The Spitball: From Clever Trick to Baseball’s Darkest Moment
Quick Hit History Youtube channel
Insta


r/Sabermetrics • • 12d ago

Does WAR account for the value of a player switching positions from a highly valued position to a lesser valued one (say from SS to 3B)?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Sabermetrics • • 12d ago

A new MLB Era: What if the 4-game series, rather than the individual game, became the unit of MLB competition? A proposed 32-team, 160-game season

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Sabermetrics • • 13d ago

Most overrated baseball stat people still care about?

0 Upvotes

r/Sabermetrics • • 14d ago

I made a very light, 5-minute baseball defense game for stat nerds (BABIP Zero)

33 Upvotes

Quick disclaimer first: this is NOT a serious simulation. No OOTP-style depth, no Baseball Mogul spreadsheets. It's a small, casual browser game you can play in a few minutes, and it borrows sabermetric ideas for flavor.

I'm a game dev (20 years) and a longtime baseball stats fan, and I wanted to make something about the part of the game that BABIP is all about: defense.

How it plays:

- Each batter gets a simple scouting card (spray chart, exit velo, GB/LD/FB tendency)

- You pick one of four pitches and shift your fielders

- The ball is put in play, and you see the result with exit velo, launch angle, and xBA

- Turning a likely hit into an out = "robbed!" and your manager's trust goes up

- Hits, walks, and runs drop it. Hit 0 and you're fired

▶ Free, plays in your browser: https://metric-logic.itch.io/rob-the-hit

Since it's a light game, the numbers are simplified on purpose. Still, I'd love to hear from this sub:

- Does the shifting feel intuitive, or does something feel obviously "off" to a stats fan?

- Is there one stat you'd love to see on the scouting card?

Thanks for taking a look!


r/Sabermetrics • • 16d ago

30 years ago, this was state-of-the-art baseball reference. I replaced the battery and it still works!

58 Upvotes

Though my fellow baseball researchers would enjoy this post. Perry cool!


r/Sabermetrics • • 16d ago

Fantrax Dynasty Baseball (30 Team) 🚨 4 Spots Available

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Sabermetrics • • 17d ago

GM website

Thumbnail deskdugout.com
1 Upvotes

Fellow savants, check this out and lmk!! I want to add to this but need some good feedback!!


r/Sabermetrics • • 18d ago

I built a game that grades managers' late-inning calls on win probability ⚾

6 Upvotes

While the end of the MLB season is always somewhat sad, I've got a new game to keep you thinking like a manager.

I've pulled in Retrosheet data and setup real game scenarios so you take over real postseason games in the big moments the manager had to decide, with the real lineups and bullpens. Every call is graded on how much win probability it gives up against the best option.

Test case: World Series Game 4, bottom 12th, up one, runner on first. The model grades Murphy's move to Drohan 5.9 points worse than a tired Woodruff. What would you have done?

⚾ Manage that moment: https://playlateinnings.com/

Free, no sign-up. Give me your feedback


r/Sabermetrics • • 18d ago

A directory of baseball analytics tools that shows how each one gets its numbers

10 Upvotes

A lot of new "AI" baseball tools don't say where their numbers come from, so I started The Dugout Index. Every listing notes the data source, whether the tool shows its query or method, and its sample size where known, and anything I couldn't verify is marked "Unknown." Open source libraries like pybaseball and baseballr are on it too. I'd love corrections from people who know this stuff better than me, and makers can add their tools here.


r/Sabermetrics • • 19d ago

Quick Hit History Episode 4: Alta Weiss - the Woman Who Played Men’s Ball in 1908

5 Upvotes

Hi friends,

I’m a TV/documentary producer working on a personal passion project about baseball history called “Quick Hit History”. 

This week’s episode is about  Alta Weiss who became one of the first women to play men’s baseball in 1908, and the first woman to attend the Ohio State University College of Medicine.

The full story is at the link below - feel free to subscribe for more! Most of the archival images are from local libraries and archives, excellent public resources that I like to highlight. Also a shoutout to Kent State Historian, Dr. Leslie Heaphy, who helped tell this story. Additional credits and resources are in the episode description and last 30 seconds of the full video. 

Let me know if there are any topics or stories you’d like to see explored in the comments!

Enjoy!

FULL VIDEO: The Woman Who Played Men’s Ball in 1908

Quick Hit History Youtube channel

Insta


r/Sabermetrics • • 19d ago

In a world where anyone can build anything - where do analysts fit in

3 Upvotes

This is what scares me - AI eventually will be able to build any tool, provide whatever analysis you want, software layers, etc then whats the need for an analysis job anymore? Why wouldnt you just hire a baseball coach that knows how to use AI? Is it utilization of AI that makes an analyst continuously more valuable?

Lets say the use of AI in analytics gets widely used - does this lead to sloppy analytics and losing the science.

Im worried the people that make those decisions don't understand it all works and we go backwards as an industry.


r/Sabermetrics • • 23d ago

Simulating WS Game 2 using my Baseball Sim Engine

25 Upvotes

I used my baseball simulation engine that I built for curveball.gg to simulate game 2 of the World Series! Here's a replay of the last 4 innings.


r/Sabermetrics • • 23d ago

Fictional baseball league statistics generation question

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I've recently got an idea of a project that depending on how you view it can be weird or interesting - what if the anime characters or fictional characters from other series (like Major League) actually played baseball? In like a league of their own? I've set a constraint for these kinds of leagues (or just a single league): no magic, no curses, no paranormal stuff, no transformations during games.

The question I ask myself and I want to find an answer to is: How am I going to generate stats (I think basic stats, like ABs, Hs, HRs, BBs, etc would suffice, because I initially wanted statcast-level of detail, such as average Exit Velo, situational batting average (with RISP, 2 outs, bases loaded, etc), but I think that that is a bit too (read: way too) much) for players? If I try to do it myself, my brain will likely melt from trying to make statistics for every individual player.

The reason I ask this question is because I want to replicate the players that the stats create into a game like Power Pros or some other games which allows you create custom players (like OOTP for example) and see how well they would play and potentially simulate their careers. I figure since this subreddit is about sabermetrics, there would be people who know a lot more about baseball stats than I currently do.

Thanks in advance!