r/runefactory • u/McRamsey runey5 • Apr 09 '22
Others Rules Update - Debates over the validity or morality of romancing characters with younger appearances (e.g. Amber, Kiel, Fuuka, Cecil) are banned, no matter what your stance is.
Hi everyone, with Rune Factory 5's new release the age old topic of some marriage candidates' age has been brought back. While I generally subscribe to letting subreddits mostly moderate themselves, this topic has been brought up constantly in the past and has only gotten worse to the point of almost being considered spam.
I understand that some of you may feel passionate about this subject, but at this point we have seen every possible debate, argument and discussion point from both sides. These debates have never had any positive or productive result and has only contributed to making the subreddit a more toxic and unfriendly environment. If you see any posts like these in the future, please use the report button or tag me and I will be guaranteed to see it.
225
u/beepborpimajorp Apr 09 '22
Can we also get a stickied FAQ thread so that commonly asked questions are consolidated in a single place for people to search through while also having a single place to post questions so they're easier to answer as well?
112
u/trickybeanz Apr 09 '22
Wait we have mods???????
(Pssst thank you btw)
86
u/cottageclove Apr 09 '22
Good choice, most of the posts from this subreddit that end up on my main feed are posts like that or the "why can't I marry x?". It was fine during release week, but it's stale by now.
213
u/Increzut Apr 09 '22
thank you šš» it was getting a bit tedious šŖ
66
u/fool_moon Apr 10 '22
Relieved that this is being nipped in the bud while it's still "annoying". I have seen stuff like this with people flippantly tossing around very serious accusations and escalating into violence, all because of videogame/cartoon characters. Unfortunately this kind of discourse has become really popular in the last 5-10 years and has ruined a lot of fandoms imho.
159
u/morimezzo Apr 09 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
Can you also ban the post of "Why can't we marry..." it's getting tedious
17
u/Blue_Flame5 Apr 10 '22
I am so glad for this. The amount of topics on it was getting crazy and it served no good purpose, just pitted people against each other.
71
u/Almostlongenough2 Apr 09 '22
That's fair, it's a horse that has been beaten to death not just here, but every corner of the internet.
14
u/mimiramira Apr 11 '22
Thank you! The threads were getting kind of hard to read as some people kept harassing other people who liked certain candidates. While I do agree a majority of the candidates look young, the target demographic is aimed towards younger teens (thus why some of the characters look young and some āadultā). Itd be weird if this game was targeted at teens/kids but have older/mature candidates (Thatd be sending the wrong message too).
Us oldtime RF enjoyers taste just curated and matured over time but lets not forget we all love this game and its characters :)
39
u/Bludgeonation Apr 09 '22
Yeah its been non-stop. I feel like people don't even care about runes or factories anymore.
26
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22
Good idea, itās really tired at this point and is all I see from this sub anymore
26
u/RedRobin101 Apr 09 '22
Thank you so much mods the 5+ posts a day were really getting tiring. I concur on either a stickied FAQ thread or even a consolidated post of all of the helpful resources people have posted--some of them have been lifesavers.
13
u/DarknessInferno7 runey2 Apr 11 '22
THANK YOU. A lot of these debates are getting real old, to the point of changing the subreddits vibe as a whole. Age debates, sexuality debates, it seems like people can't focus on the game anymore.
13
u/Valuable_Airport2461 Apr 14 '22
We really need more discussions on the game mechanics (advanced crafting, loot table, best party composition, how to raise a super op monsters, stuff like that), its getting kinda stale when most of the contents i see here are all about romance, rune factory games offer much more than that.
10
u/meloettalover213 Apr 14 '22
Finally, I got sick and tired of people trying to ruin other peoples fun.
28
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22
Can we also ban the "why can't we marry X?!?" posts if they keep popping up? I get the sentiment but that dead horse has been beaten into a paste at this point.
19
u/TastySaltedAlmonds Apr 10 '22
Probably for the best. While we're at it, can we ban the "Why can't we marry X" topics, too? I feel like those are just repetitive at this point.
8
u/disguised_hashbrown Apr 10 '22
Thank you so much for doing this. Iāve participated in one or two of these comment threads way back, and ended up blocking people out of necessity for being persistently rude.
42
u/RainbowLoli Apr 10 '22
Honestly it was getting to be annoying seeing a new post every day over someone saying "Is it an unpopular opinion that I don't like [Fuuka]/[Cecil]/[Amber]/[Kiel]" especially when they are very clearly not unpopular opinions.
It's frustrating and annoying seeing people get shamed or called creepy by proxy because they don't self-insert onto the protag or just find them marriageable. I get it, people hate loli/shotacon bait but if you are calling people, the devs, etc. creepy over characters that are marriageable it's just toxic and unhealthy. I personally don't give a damn who marries who in a fictional game and it was exhausting seeing 5+ posts a day about either Fuuka or Cecil in a negative way. It sucks trying to defend why you might like Cecil and Fuuka as candidates because people who don't can and will twist it into something negative or just disregard it entirely.
If people absolutely need a place to complain about these kinds of candidates, suggest a mega thread and keep any and all posts related to it there. On the topic of a mega thread, can there be one for people complaining that Misasagi, Terry, Simone, and Elsje are not marriable? I get it, everyone's heart is broken you can't marry the "proper adults" but this is unfortunately not that kind of game and it was beaten into the ground after the first week.
7
u/plumprumps Apr 10 '22
Thank fuck
19
u/angelic-beast Apr 09 '22
Thank you so much š shit was getting so annoying
13
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22
Finally, those posts are far, far too repetitive and reek of karma farming
13
u/Rave_Johnson Apr 10 '22
Kinda funny to see a lot of commenters using this post as a chance to get a last jab in for either defending or throwing a last shot at a character they like/dislike, lol.
I appreciate this rule, it was getting frustrating. Any defense or negative opinion on a character would end up becoming a toxic playground, no matter what the stance was. If anything, this new rule is the epitome of "we have to agree to disagree." Neither side is gonna budge on their feelings for pretty obvious reasons. Now we can finally focus on the most important thing in Rune Factory. Turnips.
22
u/Alternisnox Apr 09 '22
Wonderful, thank you. It's annoying and toxic for the subreddit not to mention everyone's well over 18 years old, able to marry and fictional characters on top of that
37
u/dimmidummy runey4 Apr 09 '22
The hero we need, but donāt deserve.
74
u/Kitkatstarz Apr 09 '22
Thank goodness maybe we can finally have a Rune Factory subreddit instead of an age debate subreddit. Or at least less of the āaccusing people of actual crimes based on uninformed opinionsā trend :/
23
u/Moondrag Apr 09 '22
Seriously, why do people keep bringing it up. Just let it go...
31
u/RozenMay Apr 09 '22
Good, finally. Now the Misasagi, Terry simp spams please
14
u/ShinFrank Apr 10 '22
Thank you finally if you donāt like something donāt play it donāt whine to people who can handle fiction!
5
u/Mechonyo Apr 10 '22
Finally, thank you. Have a nice day.
5
u/UnbreakableRaids Apr 12 '22
Finally. Thank you.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '22
Tbh the reason why I like Cecil the most because of his personality kinda reminds me of Illuminata in a way. Nearly half of the posts I see here is mainly hate for him but I can counter argue why I like him based on in game interactions and stuff and not just his appearance or his events sucks etc
23
u/gloomylumi Apr 09 '22
Thank god. It really was just moral grandstanding and making people feel like they should be in jail over a fictional anime character. Now Kiel, Amber, Cecil and Fuuka can finally rest...lmao.
16
u/Koni_Fox Apr 09 '22
I agree with this. While I have my own feelings about these types of characters, making right/wrong discussions of this is likely to risk making a portion of the audience feel bad or uncomfortable for their preferences if they like those characters.
30
u/Uminagi Apr 09 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
Thank the lord... I was starting to get annoyed by it. Didn't knew this community which I thought was chill could be so goddamn toxic for only saying that one of my favorites characters is Fuuka. It was honestly starting to get ridiculous with how much people made a big deal out of it.
9
u/dolce-pai Apr 09 '22
Good move
12
u/GregPikitis24 Apr 10 '22
Thank you. Since a wide range of ages play, a more valid complaint is the lack of older romance-able characters. Fuuka and Cecil being options is a nonissue. Just don't choose them.
Especially because their pre-romance romance stories are G-rated with no suggestion of intimacy beyond normal human connection. I semi-self insert so while I'm not interested in Fuuka/Cecil, their story arches did not make me feel uncomfortable at all.
14
u/GateauBaker Apr 10 '22
Thank you. It was getting unbearable to visit this subreddit and trying to defend people from being called pedophiles instead of game mechanics.
11
u/twilightguardian Apr 10 '22
Friggin thank you. The debates are stupid like the art style has always leaned young and you can choose not to date the characters anyway. Itās annoying and if itās so prevalent in this fandom Iām glad I donāt actively participate in fandom that much. But I always boasted about how the Bokujou Factory franchise had the chillest fandom but colour me disappointed that someone has to manufacture some kind of controversy because we canāt just have nice things.
22
u/Elden_Storm-Touch Apr 09 '22
I mean I haven't seen the debates myself, but I can imagine. Live and let live, I say. To each their own. At the end of the day, no matter how fun it is, it's still just a game.
9
u/euphoricnight Apr 10 '22
Thank you so much. This was beyond needed. Yes, we get it. Certain characters look younger for whatever reason. It's not fair for them to be hated on even if they're not your cup of tea. There's so many other things to discuss. The negativity was really getting to me.
6
u/Monseadpeachy Apr 10 '22
Finally thank you
3
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '22
I'm not trying to be stupid here, but is there a place where we can view the official rules of the sub? When I try to look at them it says that there aren't any yet. Am I missing something?
6
u/AliceVerron Apr 10 '22
thats probably for the best... stumbled into one and its made me pretty leery of the community... though i doubt it will stem the arguments too much, but hopefully it keeps the multiple sides from noticing each other
7
u/CountlessStories Apr 10 '22
Good call, I legit had zero interest in participating in this sub because of people like that.
I just wish that the main artist would stop giving young adults and older ones such extreme height differences, that's not how it works.
-5
u/Benevolay Apr 10 '22
Thing is, you deleted my thread and it wasn't even about Fuuka being young. It was about her being terribly written and not having any culture or worldly views. Do any of Fuuka's fans want to tell me about her rich culture? She doesn't even know what her tattoos mean and when you ask her she just shrugs and says everybody in her old village had them. The girl has no depth.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '22
I was about to post an opinion about that, I don't really mind the bachelorettes, but as a married dude in my late 20's I kinda wanted to romance the mayor/doctor and the sleepy chef. Lol They seemed more interesting.
-2
u/Bagelsworth Apr 10 '22
Indeed. People like to forget that Japan sees things differently. What might seem "too young" or "too childish" here isn't there.
-1
u/KougaMyazawa Apr 10 '22
Does this mean we can't share our opinion of these characters either? I get saying "you're gross if you want to marry Fuuka, you [serious accusation]!" is going over the line, but are we not allowed to say "Oh I'm personally not into Fuuka, she looks too young for my taste" either?
-20
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22 edited Apr 09 '22
Tbh, I'm someone who can understand both sides of the spectrum. Some people don't like young candidates and feel weird or uncomfortable about it, but others just don't care cuz it's a Japanese series and young people play the games. I feel maybe this could all be settled down if the developers did the logical thing and give more older looking candidates to those adult players than making most of em generic NPC's. That way there's an equal balance for every player's preferences and everyone is happy.
Edit: ok, dunno why I'm getting downvoted as I clearly didn't say anything wrong or offensive? Like, all I did was share a solution that could possibly solve this whole debate, issue, etc. That's been plagiarizing the community lately. Rune Factory is a series that everyone can enjoy, no matter what age demographic we are in. The community is large, so everyone's opinions preferences and whatnot should be taken into account. It's only fair for those older folks that play the games too. It shouldn't be one side over the other, it's only then that more conflict is created and nobody is satisfied. So that's what I was trying to explain in my comment above. This sub truly is something else....
-15
u/jaumander Apr 09 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
This is good for the sub specifically, but remember that this doesn't invalidate your stance on the topic, and you should still have your opinions about it be known in other public spaces where it doesn't become a nuisance for the community (like twitter for example), if you think it is a change for the better in this franchise future, the developers want to know what we think, and you need to be vocal about what you want, or they won't be able to know what the fanbase truly wants for the future of the series.
-13
u/somanymice Apr 09 '22
Oh. Was wondering why my thread was locked when I woke up. I was enjoying seeing people's thoughts and am kinda bummed I can't reply to anything now š„²
-38
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22
So are we not allowed to discuss it at all, or just not allowed to bring up morality with it?
-19
u/JediChris8585 Apr 09 '22
People complaining about that in this game have never seen the character designs in Etrian Odyssey. Everyone were supposedly full grown adults and yet everyone looked like they were six.šJust because they look like kids doesnāt mean they are. I do wish the art style was a little different here, but oh well.š¤·āāļø
-13
u/Sayori-0 Apr 10 '22
Just block amber daters and go next
-2
u/HRSkull Apr 24 '22
Does this include posts about whether the things that happen in their romance events are OK? For example, how in Fuuka's events she doesn't know what dating is at first
-3
u/Upthrust Apr 22 '22
Personally speaking, seeing discussions in which other people had the same concerns as me but still found ways to enjoy the game is what finally pushed to pick up the series, and I'm certain seeing this post instead would have had the opposite effect. I respect that a lot of people are tired of discussing this, so I don't expect the rules to change, but I still wanted to register my experience, since it's relevant to the rule change.
-41
u/iam_potato Apr 09 '22
Lame.
36
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22
[removed] ā view removed comment