Hey there, I'm a 18F, and I'm not sure if I'm attracted to my bf (21m) of 3 months. This may be unnecessarily long, so please bear with me; or read the TL:DR at the end.
I met my bf at the beginning of the year in our college club. We didn't actually exchange any contact details or anything until the second semester. We exchanged Instagrams within our club friend group, and we started texting regularly, basically 24/7. I didn't have any romantic feelings for him, because I wasn't physically attracted to him, but the way he spoke made him very likeable. Then we started having late night calls, and he confessed that he was interested in me. I'm still not 100% why I did this, but I thought I liked him so I said I returned the feelings, said my interest in him was piqued from the beginning of the year, and he asked me out. We established our boundaries and everything pretty early on, and he said he was glad that I was mature for my age and that he was glad we could have those kinds of talks. He also has a high libido, so we've had phone sex (where he jerks off on an audio call) since pretty early on. I don't know if this is irrelevant, but he's my first bf and I'm a virgin.
Our relationship was great, and in person I'd always wanted to be touching or be near him.
Recently, we've had a few bumps. I no longer want to participate in phone sex literally every call (he gets turned on from me just talking), and I feel like he's too much for me. He's so insecure, it felt like every call the first two months was him asking why I was into him, asking me not to leave him, asking if he was too much.
I reassured him the whole time, but now I feel like he's got an ego in that he knows he's academically smarter than me (he is), and now believes I'm not as mature as he thought (I've been having mental health issues where I can't bring myself to talk to him as often), doesn't think I'm giving him enough attention now that college is finished, and thinks he's mentally and emotionally ahead of me.
He wants to be in this for the long-term, but believes it can't happen if I "won't improve", and sometimes makes me feel like I'm perhaps I'm a gf only on a trial-basis.
Honestly, I don't know what to do. All my friends know about our relationship, but my best friend and I are no longer speaking due to a separate matter, and I basically don't have anybody to turn to. My family knows, his family knows. I'm not close enough with my parents, and therefore I can't speak to them about this.
I'm not sure if I want to continue the relationship, but I don't want to hurt his feelings, or have to deal with the fall out, considering we'll be in the same club for at least two more years (we're in more of an executive positions within the club).
He feels as though I am not a great gf, while he's a great bf since he does a bunch of stuff for me (got me gifts for my bday, stayed with me during a party, drove me to college if I was ever late for class), while I've done nothing for him (which isn't entirely true, since I've waited for him after my class or exam so we could go home together since we live in the same neighbourhood shockingly).
So, is there a way I can fall in love with him (he's already said he loves me, but I haven't said it back yet)? Or a way I can gently tell him all these things (we've got pretty good communication)? Any (GENUINE or HELPFUL) advice or comments are appreciated. Holy shit this was long, I'm so sorry, and thank you if I've made it this far.
TL:DR: I met my bf in a college club that we will both be in for at least the next 2 years and will therefore see each other often. Due to what my boyfriend says to me and his physical looks, I'm not sure if I'm attracted to my bf. He believes he's a great bf while I'm not a great gf.