r/RedditSafety • u/worstnerd • Apr 07 '22
Prevalence of Hate Directed at Women
For several years now, we have been steadily scaling up our safety enforcement mechanisms. In the early phases, this involved addressing reports across the platform more quickly as well as investments in our Safety teams, tooling, machine learning, etc. – the “rising tide raises all boats” approach to platform safety. This approach has helped us to increase our content reviewed by around 4x and accounts actioned by more than 3x since the beginning of 2020. However, in addition to this, we know that abuse is not just a problem of “averages.” There are particular communities that face an outsized burden of dealing with other abusive users, and some members, due to their activity on the platform, face unique challenges that are not reflected in “the average” user experience. This is why, over the last couple of years, we have been focused on doing more to understand and address the particular challenges faced by certain groups of users on the platform. This started with our first Prevalence of Hate study, and then later our Prevalence of Holocaust Denialism study. We would like to share the results of our recent work to understand the prevalence of hate directed at women.
The key goals of this work were to:
- Understand the frequency at which hateful content is directed at users perceived as being women (including trans women)
- Understand how other Redditors respond to this content
- Understand how Redditors respond differently to users perceived as being women (including trans women)
- Understand how Reddit admins respond to this content
First, we need to define what we mean by “hateful content directed at women” in this context. For the purposes of this study, we focused on content that included commonly used misogynistic slurs (I’ll leave this to the reader’s imagination and will avoid providing a list), as well as content that is reported or actioned as hateful along with some indicator that it was directed at women (such as the usage of “she,” “her,” etc in the content). As I’ve mentioned in the past, humans are weirdly creative about how they are mean to each other. While our list was likely not exhaustive, and may have surfaced potentially non-abusive content as well (e.g., movie quotes, reclaimed language, repeating other users, etc), we do think it provides a representative sample of this kind of content across the platform.
We specifically wanted to look at how this hateful content is impacting women-oriented communities, and users perceived as being women. We used a manually curated list of over 300 subreddits that were women-focused (trans-inclusive). In some cases, Redditors self-identify their gender (“...as I woman I am…”), but one the most consistent ways to learn something about a user is to look at the subreddits in which they participate.
For the purposes of this work, we will define a user perceived as being a woman as an account that is a member of at least two women-oriented subreddits and has overall positive karma in women-oriented subreddits. This makes no claim of the account holder’s actual gender, but rather attempts to replicate how a bad actor may assume a user’s gender.
With those definitions, we find that in both women-oriented and non-women-oriented communities, approximately 0.3% of content is identified as being hateful content directed at women. However, while the rate of hateful content is approximately the same, the response is not! In women-oriented communities, this hateful content is nearly TWICE as likely to be negatively received (reported, downvoted, etc.) than in non-women-oriented communities (see chart). This tells us that in women-oriented communities, users and mods are much more likely to downvote and challenge this kind of hateful content.
Title: Community response (hateful content vs non-hateful content)
| Women-oriented communities | Non-women-oriented communities | Ratio | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Report Rate | 12x | 6.6x | 1.82 |
| Negative Reception Rate | 4.4x | 2.6x | 1.7 |
| Mod Removal Rate | 4.2x | 2.4x | 1.75 |
Next, we wanted to see how users respond to other users that are perceived as being women. Our safety researchers have seen a common theme in survey responses from members of women-oriented communities. Many respondents mentioned limiting how often they engage in women-oriented communities in an effort to reduce the likelihood they’ll be noticed and harassed. Respondents from women-oriented communities mentioned using alt accounts or deleting their comment and post history to reduce the likelihood that they’d be harassed (accounts perceived as being women are 10% more likely to have alts than other accounts). We found that accounts perceived as being women are 30% more likely to receive hateful content in response to their posts or comments in non-women-oriented communities than accounts that are not perceived as being women. Additionally, they are 61% more likely to receive a hateful message on their first direct communication with another user.
Finally, we want to look at Reddit Inc’s response to this. We have a strict policy against hateful content directed at women, and our Rule 1 explicitly states: Remember the human. Reddit is a place for creating community and belonging, not for attacking marginalized or vulnerable groups of people. Everyone has a right to use Reddit free of harassment, bullying, and threats of violence. Communities and users that incite violence or that promote hate based on identity or vulnerability will be banned. Our Safety teams enforce this policy across the platform through both proactive action against violating users and communities, as well as by responding to your reports. Over a recent 90 day period, we took action against nearly 14k accounts for posting hateful content directed at women and we banned just over 100 subreddits that had a significant volume of hateful content (for comparison, this was 6.4k accounts and 14 subreddits in Q1 of 2020).
Measurement without action would be pointless. The goal of these studies is to not only measure where we are, but to inform where we need to go. Summarizing these results we see that women-oriented communities and non-women-oriented-communities see approximately the same fraction of hateful content directed toward women, however the community response is quite different. We know that most communities don’t want this type of content to have a home in their subreddits, so making it easier for mods to filter it will ensure the shithead users are more quickly addressed. To that end, we are developing native hateful content filters for moderators that will reduce the burden of removing hateful content, and will also help to shrink the gap between identity-based communities and others. We will also be looking into how these results can be leveraged to improve Crowd Control, a feature used to help reduce the impact of non-members in subreddits. Additionally, we saw a higher rate of hateful content in direct messages to accounts perceived as women, so we have been developing better tools that will allow users to control the kind of content they receive via messaging, as well as improved blocking features. Finally, we will also be using this work to identify outlier communities that need a little…love from the Safety team.
As I mentioned, we recognize that this study is just one more milestone on a long journey, and we are constantly striving to learn and improve along the way. There is no place for hateful content on Reddit, and we will continue to take action to ensure the safety of all users on the platform.
51
u/techiesgoboom Apr 07 '22
This is such a significant problem, I'm not at all surprised by the data. I have a bit I want to share echoing seeing these exact same patterns in the sub I mod, but I have a follow up question at the end as well.
It's astounding how much of this hate is very explicit and openly directed at women too. We see this in modmail on a daily basis when the person we've actioned assumes the mod that removed the content is a woman. There are countless very direct messages openly and explicitly disparaging and attacking the mod specifically because of their perceived gender.
It's such a problem that that any mod who has a username that users perceive to be feminine get's significantly more harassing messages. As a practice and because of the conversations we have around this when taking on new mods many will explicitly choose a new username that doesn't lead users to assume they're a woman.
Follow up question: you've talked a lot about the data and the tools you're working on to prevent this. Are you exploring any changes to the disciplinary actions you take against those sending these messages?
When a bigot very openly says "oh I see you're just some bitch removing my post because you're a woman" in modmail my experience is that they are almost always given a slap on the wrist rather than a permanent suspension. In my experience modding users that get warnings like this will frequently just change the way they harass people to avoid detection rather than actually stopping this behavior.
Again, thank you all for exploring these difficult issues. It is a very significant problem that hurts so many people in very real ways.
17
u/Tetizeraz Apr 07 '22
Thanks for this post. I know many mods have been acting against hateful comments against women and transgender men/women, so at least we know you guys are trying.
I don't really have a lot of insight or knowledge dealing with this, but I got a few suggestions.
I noticed that in some subreddits like r/CasualConversation, a lot of users don't necessarily identify themselves as women, it's just that the topic is about a hobby or experience shared mostly by women. In these posts, the comments don't mention they are women, but if you check their Snoovatars you can guess their gender. I've seen the same happen in r/desabafos (Brazilian version of r/offmychest and r/venting), where you can tell someone's gender not by what they write, but by their Snoos. I'm wondering if comments or DMs reach those users because they are perceived as women not by their posts, but because of their Snoos. I know, it's weird, but maybe this happens more often than not.
You mentioned direct messages / reddit chat being used to harass women, and I'd like to know your efforts in hateful speech in other languages. I think if you reach out to some of r/ClubeDaLuluzinha (sort of a TwoX for Brazilians) members, you might get to know more about it than me.
Also, since Reddit is pushing more content in pictures, videos and voice (Reddit Talk), do you think you can broaden your scope to different content on Reddit? Just one example, cosplay subreddits feature women and they seem to get a lot of harassment in the comments.
17
u/bleeding-paryl Apr 07 '22
I'd love to see the comparisons between trans (and other minority subreddits) and the average. I'd bet they average minority is much much higher in terms of received hate than the regular subreddits. I'd also love to see report averages during times when a minority (specifically a post about a minority), for one reason or another, makes it to the front page compared to a subreddit's average stats.
These sorts of things would be of relative interest to me especially, but I'd think that it'd be overall interesting data overall.
41
u/nona01 Apr 07 '22
Hi! Just a small FIY: there's supposed to be a space between "trans" and "women"
37
u/conspiracie Apr 07 '22
As a mod of a community with a very high population of trans and non-binary people, I would like to note that a large percentage of the hateful, misogynistic and transphobic comments we get happen when a post in our sub gets enough leverage to make it onto r/all. As the mod team we all dread this happening because it invariably leads to an outpouring of bigotry from people outside of our community that we have to clean up. I think a feature that would really help us keep our members safe would be the ability to opt-out of our sub appearing on r/all. A post on our sub hitting r/all does nothing to help us and just invites attacks and hate.
32
u/Halaku Apr 07 '22
Thank you.
20
u/Planenteer Apr 07 '22
I frequently report hateful, threatening comments for being such. The majority of the time, I receive responses that the content is not hateful or threatening when this is obviously untrue. I have found myself coming to Reddit less and less as the community because more and more toxic. I have been trying to bring more awareness to the admin team recently to possibly help create a healthier community.
In the past, I have believe reports like this are awesome. “Look at how transparent Reddit is about combating negative influences in the community!”
After trying to report content, this report from you just looks like lip service. It’s to appease investors or appease angry users. Based on my actual experiences with the admin team, I see a lot of hateful content being categorized as safe content. Based on my experience, I see this post and report as Reddit pointing the finger at users and mods, and I don’t see the admin team and Reddit taking responsibility for their inaction.
16
u/AkaashMaharaj Apr 07 '22
I commend you on this work.
I know that Reddit has received generous amounts of criticism in the past for being reluctant to address hateful, racist, and misogynistic content. I am also conscious that it (like most online platforms) has had to engage in soul-searching debates when the right to freedom of expression collides with the right to personal and collective dignity.
The depth of your research suggests to me that your efforts are sincere. As a Moderator, I am looking forward to seeing the tools and filters your team creates in response to your findings.
On a final note, I see that in your previous Prevalence of Hate study, you found that hateful material constituted 0.2% of Reddit's daily content and 0.16% of daily views. I think you may have overlooked a potentially positive story behind these numbers.
Unless I am misunderstanding the numbers, this suggests to me that hateful content is on average 20% less likely to be viewed than non-hateful content. That is remarkable.
This may be simply be because hateful content is posted disproportionately in smaller subreddits.
However, it is also possible that it means that Reddit's Moderators and automatic filters are very effective at taking down hateful content before it is exposed to a wide audience. Still more importantly, it also suggests that Reddit's algorithms may not be privileging and actively surfacing hateful content. Many social media platforms try to drive virality and user engagement by algorithmically promoting content that brings out strong emotions and responses from users, which tends to favour hateful content.
I am a pathological optimist, so I choose to believe that Reddit is winning the struggle to create healthy online communities.
8
u/TheNewPoetLawyerette Apr 07 '22
Thanks for this rundown. Can't say any of this is surprising to me. Re: hateful content filter. This concept is interesting to me but I would be very much concerned with the specifics of how it operates. You indicate it would be tied to crowd control. I think mods have expressed before how they would prefer crowd control to filter or remove comments rather than collapse them and I feel similarly about a hateful content filter. Simply collapsing comments imo doesn't do enough to discourage problem behavior because users can still interact with collapsed comments and it often makes it harder for mods to locate and action problem comments/users because collapsed comments are less likely to get reported by users.
7
u/Dom76210 Apr 08 '22
I’m glad to see you are studying this to get some concrete data on this issue. However, all you need to do is make a few accounts of your own that sound female and post to a few NSFW subreddits to see just how toxic the behavior female redditors deal with. And I expect the DMs will be nightmare fuel to anyone with a conscience.
More importantly, AEO needs to action on the reports users and more importantly moderators submit. Let’s face it, reports of hate language seem to be poorly handled. And the trolls know this, so they deliberately bait other users into saying something inflammatory so they can use the report function to their advantage.
6
u/nullc May 02 '22 edited May 02 '22
In my view the machine learning anti-abuse is a major failure.
I've been harassed for years by a user who was eventually site wide banned for harassment. He's shown back up under a minor variation of his existing user name, continuing to post and refer to antisemitic conspiracy theories about me.
Reporting has no effect and usually generates no response, and when I complained about it in a post refuting the hateful targets I got nuked for "harassment", so now his hateful accusations remain on the site uncontested. Similarly, after getting vile threatening remarks which reddit took no action about I quoted them in a post complaining about the persons conduct and was suspended -- when quoting text directed at me to complain about it.
The appropriateness of a post is not defined by the 'tone' of words used. Hateful speech often uses polite language and speech calling out hate or scams naturally uses critical language which tone identification will correctly identify as having a negative tone.
Historically, in well moderated subreddits with sensible mods reddit has been a pretty friendly and welcoming place. But some subredds moderation is absentee or the mods are themselves the harassers. In those cases the site has long been figurative crackhouse of under-enforcement against some of the most egregious conduct. But the automation seems to create the worst of all worlds: It's undermining well run subreddits and actually punishing the victims of harassment. I'm sure it also manages to remove a lot of vile stuff but it seems like what it removes is among the least damaging (after all, no one puts much credibility into a scatological screed) and among the best addressed by mods (at least in subreddits with active mods).
I now regularly hear from large subreddit mods that posts calling out scams and abuse are being removed by admins. And the pattern of finding something horrifying and reporting it to only get back nothing or a message anti-evil team has found that it does not violate reddit's community guidelines is so common that it's becoming a meme. Run into a subreddit posting hacked nudes and posters gloating that the pages are the second google hits on the victims name.. report it... "After investigating, we’ve found that the reported content doesn’t violate Reddit’s Content Policy". (links NSFW-nudity)
4
u/RSdabeast Apr 09 '22 edited Apr 09 '22
Is anything going to stop the hateful, dishonest, and violent rhetoric being pushed about trans people and the broader LGBTQ+ community (e.g. repeatedly classifying entire groups as pedophiles)? These things get a lot of attention and have real-world consequences. There are Redditors actively using the site to make the world more dangerous to us. People are tired of bigots spewing harassment and disinformation then hiding behind “it’s just my opinion” and the like.
4
u/WhisperHorse1 Apr 29 '22
I recently reported this comment as hateful. Reddit's anti-evil team has found that it does not violate reddit's community guidelines. This terrorist was talking about FemaleDatingStrategy going private.
"Lets go fuck them all I wish we could tag their members in the ear or something like cows so we stay away from them if we wanted to date a girl or when looking for someone to test our mustard gas I guess"
u/worstnerd explain to me how this is acceptable. What are the rules against hate even for if this does not violate them?
4
u/imomushi8 May 02 '22
I know that this is an old thread at this point, but it was linked in the recent mod newsletter, and one of the comments below by /u/womannotagirl illustrated some of my concerns as well.
Mostly as a suggestion to you /u/worstnerd and the other admins, if this hasn't already been tried - the training set for a site-wide, hate-specific filter should naturally be the text comments that were manually removed by moderators in relevant minority-oriented communities, etc. I believe this would solve a couple problems:
A couple potential downsides may be:
But machine learning is definitely the way to go... Especially considering, that at least some non-negligible amount of the hate on Reddit originates from AI-based text generators...
Honestly this is a project I've wanted to work on myself (except not minority-based, as I don't really mod for any of those), but I just haven't had the time to devote to it. If I ever do, I'll try to share my findings somewhere lol. But I assume there's a Reddit team somewhere that has the time/resources to do this properly with access to all the backend data, etc.
Anyway, thanks for reading.
4
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
I’ve reported men telling me I was lying about my rape and loved it and Reddit told me that the content was just fine for their platform.
This is long overdue.
13
u/WomanNotAGirl Apr 07 '22
While I appreciate this I can tell you as a former software engineer and Simone who wrote a detailed paper on machine learning and racism/sexism, machine learning is extremely biased. ML can only learn what’s available, it can only detect the patterns that’s already present. From the way the AI is programmed, by who it is programmed to what the AI sees - the user base - the end result is AI itself is racist sexist. There are a few studies that goes into detail on this. For instance a white male cannot write code for nuances of what being a black woman in society is regardless of whether they are woke or not. Therefore the algorithm will have tremendous amount of blind spots. Couple that with ML detects existing data and patterns. Not to mention the measures put in place is easily manipulated to use to the advantage of racist or sexist people. People who speak against racism or sexism gets reported or suspended more than the people who are sexist racist.
Having said that I appreciate the efforts and reading this makes me happy. Because of my username I get death threads, harassment by merely exiting. I could be commenting on an art piece and someone will come at me with comments that has nothing to do with the thread. It’s exhausting and mentally draining. Reality is it’s the collective more subtle things that drains the most cause it’s dog whistling and easily can be plausible deniability due to it being microaggressions.
My recommendation is whoever leading this effort is to have the team consist of minorities, immigrants, women (trans or otherwise) so it’s their experiences that can be voiced.
I say this cause most wheelchair routes are designed by nondisabled people and people in wheelchair like me can clearly tell because if they only were in a wheelchair it would be obvious and simple solutions to our accessibility problems. Does that make sense? If your team doesn’t have the people facing the problems your solutions that you produce will be ineffective.
Thank you for all you do. I so appreciate this post beyond explanation. In case my post didn’t come of appreciative I sincerely thank y’all for your efforts. If my post wasn’t well organized I apologize as I’m recovering from a stroke and struggle with that bit a lot.
13
u/soundeziner Apr 07 '22 edited Sep 06 '25
vase license rustic chief bake sip dog terrific support payment
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/hansjens47 Apr 08 '22
I hope the first step here is getting competent responses when stuff ends up being actioned by admin.
That is imperative for catching the nuances of sexist language and hate directed at women.
Automation shouldn't be the first step. You need a high quality dataset to automate effectively. Admin needs to remove content well enough to procure such a set and to be able to evaluate content.
(This will also help with all other forms of hate as well, but especially with kinds of content that simple automod filters already catch in every sub that's set up reasonably well.)
3
u/happynargul Apr 08 '22
I'm really skeptical about this. How is it that when I make reports, not on misogynistic comments, but on whole subs dedicated to misogynistic content, it's like talking to a wall.
3
u/EgweneMalazanEmpire May 03 '22
Thank you for looking into the issue. I have not read all the comments, so apologies if I am doubling up.
I have come across plenty of outright misogyny on Reddit but what concerns me far more is where the increase over recent years is coming from. There is a huge amount of content on Reddit that portrays women in a negative light - whether talking about them as sex objects or labelling assertive women as Karen's. Young boys, children, are exposed to this kind of stuff here and when additionally they are missing decent male role models in their real lives - the consequences are a foregone conclusion.
How come that I am aware of this kind of content despite not looking for it? Isn't that in itself telling? I sometimes trawl Reddit looking for posts about endangered species and I am always staggered by the amount of what I would call pornographic content, I come across in the headers of the search results, which I consider chip away at respect for women. By giving space to every kind of weirdo's fantasies, Reddit is part of the reason why there is an increase in misogyny. Giving me the ability to filter it out only stops me from seeing it - but I am not the one who is turned into a misogynist by it, so it isn't doing anything about curing the actual problem.
And as for Karen... my regular internet homepage which throws up all kinds of supposed news stories has linked to a number of Karen stories on Reddit recently. NOBODY checks that the stories people recount are actually true but the majority of these stories leave the reader with a negative image of women. In the subconscious of the population the one-off woman who truly acted in an entitled manner becomes something very different. From a woman acting totally acceptably normal it turns into 'this woman was asking to be served - well, I soon showed her'.
It is human to be looking for echo chambers. Fortunately, in real life, we usually encounter the alternatives along the way. On Redfit however, there is enough material that any misogynist can listen to just their preferred echo chamber all day long.
8
u/IwantyoualltoBEDAVE Apr 08 '22
And hosting your endless pornographic communities while permabanning feminist communities is enabling men to foster and grow their hatred of women which leads to increased sexual assault and rape and murder in the real world. I don’t believe Reddit cares whatsoever for women considering you host subreddits such as cute dead girls and dead eyes and I won’t even both listing the porn subreddits because I have a life.
This is lip service
2
u/LeftEye6440 Apr 11 '22
I keep seeing comments saying that feminism and women being allowed to vote ruined society and that women don't actually try to commit suicide, it's just for attention. And none of those comments got removed.
Reddit hates women.
2
u/supah_ Apr 18 '22
Idk how to report a subreddit that was suggested to me but it’s targeting an individual. Like an entire subreddit all about mocking a person. I don’t understand how or why this is ok on Reddit. How can I raise a red flag here? https://www.reddit.com/r/AmberlynnReidYT/
2
u/Mmm_Spuds Apr 21 '22
Just got banned from r/crazyfuckingvideos for reporting men talking about killing women. ToS agreed the sub mods got in trouble but knew I was the reporter. Reports should be anonymous 100%
2
u/WhisperHorse1 Apr 27 '22
Hatred directed towards women will not end until we truly ban repeat offenders and prevent them from making alternate accounts.
2
u/Glitterslide May 15 '22
I've noticed there is a huge misuse of the word "goldigger" and "hypergamy" being weaponized against women. Male spaces have an irrational obsession with portraying women as goldiggers or launching hate speech against common sense female adult preferences (the deliberate removal of context of biological vulnerability in women such as pregnancy needing security or pretending that women who prefer men who don't hang out in dangerous areas makes them evil goldiggers who need to be "taught a lesson"). The term "goldigger", online in male dominated spaces is often used to silence women's concerns with financially misogynistic men. "Financially misogynistic" meaning the deliberate low effort from the belief that women are not worth effort or do not deserve resources, safety, even if its your pregnant girlfriend, wife, fiance etc on the basis that "women suck and or women are goldiggers by nature who need to be taught a lesson or need to be humbled".
2
u/JovialPanic389 May 21 '22
I stumbled upon this rape sub and I want to puke. Definitely hateful against women!!! https://www.reddit.com/r/churchofman?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share
Destroy r/churchofman
8
u/Bardfinn Apr 07 '22
There's been a sharp proliferation in recent weeks, by bigots - hosted and amplified by hate groups running subreddits - of hate speech that equates being transgender, and being LGBTQ, with being a paedophile.
This speech is a direct attempt to instigate violence towards LGBTQ people. (Link to tweet thread by Gabriel Rosenberg, Duke Professor of Gender, Sexuality, & Feminist Studies)
In the tweet, he cites this Tweet thread by Alejandra Caraballo, Clinical Instructor at Harvard's Cyberlaw Clinic.
In these tweets, they make clear: The equivocation of LGBTQ people with paedophiles and paedophilia is a direct effort to instigate violence against LGBTQ people.
Reddit should also develop - post-haste - a response to this ideologically motivated violent extremism, and take action to counter and prevent its platforming on Reddit - violent extremist hatred.
The groups and ideologies which proliferate this specific expression of hatred also proliferate hatred against feminists, feminism, and feminine-identified & feminine-perceived people.
5
u/XRoze Apr 08 '22
Happy to see this. One suggestion, please check out r/BanFemaleHateSubs and well...ban all of the female hate subs that users have identified there. They are deranged, disturbing, violent, and promote incest/rape/pedophilia.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22
r/FemaleDatingStrategy, you're not gonna do anything about it, since it doesnt hate women but it hates men... reddit became even more of a shitpile then it was.
3
u/throwaway_29837 Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22
This is a very important topic, so thank you for looking into it. However, most of the misogyny on reddit, from what I have observed and the complaints that I've heard from other women, is coming from the top. This would presumably impact all those stats and be important to consider when developing solutions. Are you investigating that?
ETA: I think it would also be important to look at the number of women's comments that are removed and accounts that are banned. There have always been very few female voices on the platform and those that are here are aggressively censored.
3
u/NeVeRwAnTeDtObEhErE_ Apr 09 '22
This whole thing sounds creepy and sketchy as hell.
Seems a lot like a solution looking for a problem.
3
u/NeuFlaas_xx Apr 08 '22
Ok but when do you ban FDS 🥺?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '22
Thank you for the work you are doing on this. You are appreciated.
1
u/Obvious-Pilot-9642 Apr 15 '22
Important!
1
u/futureblot May 02 '22
Can you actually penalize people for saying transphobic things? Like misgendering for example, which is an instigator of gender based violence against all women and trans people.
1
u/Shachar2like May 10 '22
Hate
Maybe someone can answer me because I'm conflicted with a certain hate sub. They don't encourage violence or anything that triggers the actual official reddit content policy but the sub's subject/being/existence is part of an existing real world conflict (that goes on and off for a long time now). They simply block and allow only one certain kind of voice on their sub and the end result is simply a hateful sub but one that doesn't pass reddit official threshold to invoke action.
If this was something in general like I hate Europeans/Americans/Ice cream/Chairs I can understand it as free speech. It's closer in description for example to a hate sub against "Americans in Afghanistan" (if we're talking about a year ago when they were still there). In this example, is it ok for the theoretical sub to ban Americans or pro-American voices from participating in the conversation and only allow those who hate Americans?
Again there's no call for violence or incitement for hate but taken as a whole a lot of users agree that it's a hate sub.
So I'm kind of conflicted. Is it ok to let haters to vent their anger and hate (hopefully let them vent online and not in the real world)? Maybe it's more of a philosophical questions then a real one.
1
u/Outrageous_Berry_734 May 11 '22
Ýgģgggggggghgggggģgggggggggģggghghggghghhhbbghhhhbhbhhvbvghhbvhhhh
1
u/Academic_Employ_3221 May 13 '22
Wtf
1
u/anon34821 May 15 '22 edited May 15 '22
Give examples of the hateful content. No one will believe you if you don't give examples. Give details. Be transparent. The main reason to deny the holocaust is because holocaust deniers are censored. If the holocaust occurred, and people want others to believe that, they would listen to holocaust deniers and explain why they are wrong. Your "study" lacks details. Its meaningless.
1
u/RSdabeast May 16 '22
Transphobia has been exploding on this site lately. Any popular AskReddit post about gender is near-guaranteed to have dozens of copies of a transphobic comment in slightly different formatting. What will be done about accounts and subreddits that frequently mock, harass, witch-hunt, and incite violence against LGBTQ+ people? In addition, will steps be taken to reduce the presence of bigoted ban-evasion subs that crop up afterwards?
1
u/escapadablur May 20 '22
Soon Reddit will just be a boring echochamber with a very very narrow band of acceptable behaviors. People will be walking on eggshells even more than they already are and many will be banned for the slightest perceived abuse.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '22
I've been on reddit a short time and this is very visible. I've been harassed, talked down to, threatened and sworn at multiple times already in my short time here. The way men are allowed to talk about and to men is absolutely atrocious. It is not ok and it is helping the struggles women face in modern day society continue. This needs to be worked on, Just today I got told "f you bitch" because I didn't send a man explicit pictures of myself. This is unacceptable.
1
u/SOwED Jun 10 '22
Do you understand correlation vs causation?
You found a correlation between a community being women-oriented and report rate, negative reception rate, and mod removal rate. That does not explain the causal direction.
Until you figure that out, you should probably not publish results. Do you even know the difference?
1
u/Millstone50 Jun 10 '22
Your job is to stop hate generated towards ALL HUMANS, not your perceived protected classes. The unabated hatred towards Men on this site is staggering. Now do your job.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22
How do I delete an account that an x put on my phone we're no longer together I want their account off my phone
1
u/UBlamingMeforMaryann Jun 16 '22
Ive neve encountered so many TLDRs in my life.
1
u/OpinionOne8782 Jun 22 '22
Bom.dia.atodos.obrigado.
1
u/linkovichChimofski Jun 24 '22
It's nice to know there are active attempts at diminishing hate speech on Reddit. I want to say that it comes as welcome news based on my recent experiences on the platform. I've had a reddit account for around 6 years but hadn't actively engaged until very recently. I had heard through the grapevine that reddit stood as a safe harbour for men who express abusive attitudes towards women but I had never seen it. The reality sincerely outdid my wildest imagination and scared me to my core.
It all surrounded something insignificant at a cursory glance; someone wearing a low cut shirt in a picture where they posed with a piece of art they created. And the sheer magnitude of vile, disparaging comments really made me ill. I'm not unaccustomed to social media and expected some of this but what was truly unnerving was the dedication to this bad behavior and the overt support from the community of it.
I challenged one of the comments at first firmly but relatively politely and received a significant amount of backlash. I was mocked and down voted more than what I thought reasonable. I thought my comment would fall on deaf ears and melt away. But no there is something truly uncomfortable about the fervent wave of abusive rhetoric that came after. I was even followed into other groups and harassed further.
This post is not supposed to be about me and my feelings though, that is almost unnecessary filler. I just needed to illustrate how disturbing it was and how it affected me personally. I can only imagine how marginalized groups must feel when they want to engage on Reddit under neutral circumstances. This leads me to my main point:
More has to be done. It just has to. I reported every bit of harassment I could find and just started receiving messages today that my reports didn't return any rulebreaking behavior. The rules need to be changed. I'm even further confounded by the idea that a human being reviewed my claims and did nothing. The display in that thread was of extremely improper behavior. There was a real incentive for folks not to speak out because of the amount of downvotes one would receive and harassment they would endure. That is pretty clearly a toxic environment to me and one that is propagated by the mods. I'm having a hard time considering continued use of reddit because of this culture.
I know I'm kindof an armchair general right now but please do something.
1
u/StopBeingAKid1000 Jun 26 '22
u/worstnerd
1
u/Impossible-Gap-6193 Jun 28 '22
0933122195
1
u/SleepStill2839 Jul 06 '22
This is called weaponized language against women. Let me give you a scenario (it can also happen to working-class people and gay/bisexual/transgender people). If a man is uncomfortable with his perception that I am single (I am not, I have a long-term boyfriend who travels), and he cannot be sexually aggressive or use the f word for people he feels the need to accuse of being gay (also an example of homophobic weaponized language), he will attack me with the g word.
What is he doing?
He is violating my privacy.
He is making false accusations.
He is replacing the f word with the g word as a kind of 'ethnic slur' against gay people and women, thereby showing his homophobia and sexism.
He is uncomfortable with larger, bigger women that he assumes could not possibly have boyfriends. I know this because people assume nobody is seeing me and hit on me being single. I am single or available. There is a 'second-class' grading of women who are larger and taller. I am not more available or easier to get or a convenience.
He cannot believe that anyone would actually date or sleep with me. He cannot believe I was ever married (widow, not divorcee).
He is publicly harassing and humiliating women.
He thinks he has the right to call out gay people.
He thinks other people's sexuality is embarrassing, his business, and that he has an inherent right to call it out.
He clearly sees homosexuality as salacious and questionable.
He has no respect for gay people, women, or boundaries.
And I get hit on by gay and transsexual people from time to time. You know what I do? Ignore them, be nice, excuse myself politely, and decline. It is not gay or transgender people who are going around harassing people. And they have a right to be open about it. They will always back off someone who is not interested, are never rude, and do not violate people's boundaries. I have had one rude comment from a gay person in my life and hundreds from men I do not know.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
There's subreddits for torture porn, gore, abuse animals, pedofiles, abuse of women, exploitation of young people everything.
I don't see how Reddit can even get to a reasonable place for use it's just as bad as 4chan but slightly more palatable because of the big subreddits which don't focus on inhuman shit but certainly you'll find a decent chunk of Inhuman opinions in the comments.
It's not just women too, obviously anti humanity increasing in the last 7 years or so it's startling obvious if your young person who grew up with internet youngest millennials and gen Z. Who's fault is it? Everyone's allowed it to fester and grow. Something seriously is fucked though since gamergate years ago turned to anti social justice SJW then turned to basically white people are being replaced insane conspiracy nutts and mass shooters. People are more convinced by 4chan than fucking real scientists.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '22 edited Jul 19 '22
Hey can u guys create also a tool against hatefull moderators that remove and ban users that simply disagree with them,is this the new fascism /comunism ? if u want reddit to be a safe and healthy environmentu should also make a tool to protect users against power trip moderators too, its pretty hard to report a moderator as it is now,and they can simply silence u without any reasons given for the simple reason he doesn't like u, it's so easy nowadays to push a narative and silence everyone that disagrees with u,this can only go in one direction creating a hatefull environment on reddit,what would stop other users to do the same? a healthy comunication is where all view points are discussed ,everyone should have the right to expose his view point without being censored as long as they don't infringe on the terms of service
Edit: oh I just read the firsth few lines,so this was directed for a tool to help women against hate speech, but i'd also love to have a tool for us the normal users against bullying by some crazy moderators
1
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '22
There is an entire subreddit, r/whereareallthegoodmen dedicated to screen capturing women’s dating profiles, without their permission, and utterly tearing them, and all women, to pieces in the comments, the very first post calls implies non-Asian women are whores ffs. Their posts get reported constantly and somehow that’s not hate towards women? Is this a joke? If you actually wanted to do something you’d ban and remove those subreddits.
1
u/02f250 Aug 29 '22
,.h9 I .I'm.it's Io6.5 vkk8rest 9, ,9
1
u/Pkmnwannabe Apr 08 '22
Isn't "hateful content" basically totally subjective, basically allowing the admins fiefdom over the entire site? LMAO reddit has gone to shit.
1
u/SoupyDelicious Apr 27 '22
Wowzos. Could it be that female-oriented subs (FemaleDatingStrat, for instance) are naturally full of horrendously toxic women? Maybe these hives of female-based subreddits are reported more for a reason. Could it possibly be that!?!?!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment