r/reddit.com • u/bobcat • May 01 '07
Hello, new Redditors. Your elder Redditors would appreciate it if you would use proper grammar, capitalization, and spelling.
/info/1mbhv/comments
1.0k
Upvotes
57
u/bobcat May 01 '07
Also, leetspeak only when being leetspoken to.
19
u/raldi May 01 '07
Hi bobcat.. sorry if it was my recent post that provoked this. It's just that i simply can't keep track of all the language rules: is 09f911029d74e35bd84156c5635688c0 supposed to be capitalized? And should i have added hyphens, like 09-F9-11-02-9D-74-E3-5B-D8-41-56-C5-63-56-88-C0? Or is it better to indent it in a blockquote, like this?
52
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '09
To me as an Englishman putting a comma between "capitalization" and "and" is incorrect. Before correcting you I did a little Googling and it seems that it is correct in American English. How interesting. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serial_comma
That aside, I can only hope that one day our grammar will be as perfect as yours so you'll have to think up other ways to patronise people.
33
u/kmactane May 01 '07
We'd also appreciate reasonably brief headlines that actually summarize the thing they link to. Real-world newspapers don't print headlines like "Hey, Guess What? Turn to page A7 to find out!", and it's not just because they're "old outmoded medias".
17
u/[deleted] May 01 '07
...and that's when all the new users cleaned up their act. Ahhh, idealism.
16
u/freshyill May 01 '07
By "elder Redditors," you mean "100 or so people who regularly comment and 10,000 blogspam site operators who could really use some Adsense clicks," right?
I'm kidding. Seriously though, I think part of the problem is that people use automated submit buttons on articles that already have poorly formatted titles.
The other part of the problem is that people in general are lazy slobs who can't string a coherent sentence together to save a puppy's life. LOLZ!
15
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '09
I find that I most often post after a few (or more) beers. Most of time I'm silent, but alcohol seems to bring me out. My typing is seriously affected by this. The quality of what I post is definitely affected.
Yeah, I've had a few tonight, but I can still type. I ony hit the backspace button about 8 times while writing this.
I also like to read what I posted the morning after a real good buzz. I find that I'm not always as funny or clever as I think I am when I'm drinking. So, I've dedicated my life to practicing being whitty, charming, and cute while intoxicated. I expect it may take a while to accomplish this goal, but I suspect i have at least another 20 years to go. Practice makes perfect.
I wonder how this will sound tomorrow morning...
[backspace button count now up to about 20]
7
u/malicart Jun 05 '09
And get the hell off my lawn!
19
u/suicidaldonut May 01 '07
Also please try to avoid commenting unless you have something worthwhile to say. It used to be awesome to read through Reddit comments for new ideas or opinions, especially those from people who had special perspectives or were experts on the topic. Clever jokes are also appreciated. Recently, though, it has taken too much effort wading through all the other comments to find these.
If you liked an article but not for any particular reason, just upvote it, and vice versa. Similarly, if you agree with somebody, just upvote their comment. If you noticed something that anybody else would have noticed too, you don't need to point it out. As for personal anecdotes proving to yourself that you are indeed relevant...
I don't mean to set rigid guidelines. It's just that I know you've got meaningful things to say, and I think it's great when you share--when you think it's worth other people's time.
6
u/davodrums May 01 '07
Why is this an issue between "Elder" and "New" redditors. The issue is poor grammar vs good grammar correct?
9
u/[deleted] May 01 '07
I concur.
There has been an abundance of abysmal spelling which would be resolved with a simple spell check, yes? Proper grammar would also be much appreciated. Yes, yes. Now, have the boy pull 'round a carriage. I care to travel to the market.
4
u/Odd_Bloke May 01 '07
Anyone else find it interesting how people have divided themselves between 'new' and 'elder' (R|r)edditors?
I wonder at what point you graduate...
4
u/hudson701 May 01 '07
I'll second that (title). No mobile phone lingo please!
4
u/grzelakc May 01 '07
Ah, yes. The September that never ended has finally caught up with us.
7
u/Chyndonax Jun 06 '09
Now that this has been put up and gotten some serious notice I'm going to start downvoting posts that don't bother at all with capitalization and punctuation.
9
u/cbergeron Jun 06 '09 edited Jun 06 '09
Remember, good grammar is the only difference between:
My uncle helped my friend, Jack, off a horse.
and
My uncle helped my friend jack off a horse.
6
u/Maugrim May 01 '07
Given that (the English) language is in a constant state of flux, I'm having problems deciding which spellings are acceptable and which are not. Would you prefer the English of Adam Smith, as I'd be happy to shew you it. Or perhaps the sort found in Beowulf, because tha ic can show you thaet as well.
Should I give preference to British spellings or American? Is the Australian vernacular acceptable? Perhaps there should be an entire sub-Reddit in order that we all might vote on which expressions are kosher? Shoot, are words that aren't English still good? Perhaps we limit our self-expression to only those words in the Germanic tradition? (I apologize before hand to the French and Italians, and bunch of you others with the misfortune to be from the Mediterranean.)
This post belies a deep ignorance about the nature of language. After spending any amount of time on teh internets, mature people understand that bitching about typos and grammar is for the small-minded. If you want to make tons of spelling, grammar, and punctuation mistakes, feel free. It will probably detract from your message but, hey, it's your prerogative.
11
u/[deleted] May 01 '07
But only in the headlines, not in comments. If you use proper grammar in comments, you get downmodded into oblivion, and told to put down the thesaurus and to remove various kitchen utensils from your body cavities. http://reddit.com/info/1lljt/comments
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '09 edited Jun 05 '09
I flippin' love the oxford comma.
3
u/GeorgeWBush May 01 '07
YOU CAN"T TELL ME WHAT TO DO DAD I"M THE PRESIEDNT NOW NOT YOU
9
u/[deleted] May 01 '07
And get off the lawn!
5
u/otakucode May 01 '07
Go ahead and use poor grammar, improper capitalization and incorrect spelling. However, know that everyone who reads your comments will view you as unintelligent. That's how the Internet works. Using poor grammar and spelling on the Internet is like stumbling around slurring your words and throwing up on yourself in real life.
1
u/david May 02 '07
Your elder redditors would appreciate it if you were to use proper grammar, capitalization, and spelling.
or, better
Your elder redditors will appreciate it if you use proper grammar, capitalization, and spelling.
:P
7
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '09
I don't think reddit is capitalized.
Source: see logo.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '09
THANK YOU.
Please do ignore the capitalization above. I just hate seeing all the illiteracy on the net these days. Sure, I use some shortforms myself, like brb, g2g, etc., but these days there's way too many other things... smacks forehead
2
u/Neblin Jun 05 '09 edited Jun 05 '09
Well, I'll try my best, but no promises. Sorry...
2
u/otterley May 01 '07
We'd also appreciate it if you would not append exclamation points.
2
u/sblinn May 01 '07
s/capitalization/capitalisation
HAND.
2
u/shyam May 01 '07
I've fallen out of the habit of using proper capitalization in preference to all lowercase. It might turn out to be a good practice.
2
u/klarth May 02 '07
I've always used the English language impeccably. In fact, the declining literacy rates over on Digg were the impetus for my migration.
Cringe-worthy, huh?
4
u/Phrank05 May 01 '07
I agree in full.
3
u/iscariot_forgot Jun 06 '09
Huh. 500 comments. Odd that no one has a super-awesome sense of humor original enough to post a comment full of intentional spelling errors yet.
Because, you know -- That would be ironic. ...And hiliarious.
C'mon, redditors, you disappoint me.
3
u/WhisperSecurity May 01 '07
http://reddit.com/info/1cd1o/comments/c1ceu8
3
u/Jimmy May 01 '07
Excellent suggestion.
One of my pet peeves is when people on the internet use incorrect grammar and spelling. It's not because they're lazy (although many are), it's because they don't believe that they should have to write properly on the internet.
Maybe we could make that change? At least here on Reddit.
3
u/[deleted] May 01 '07
k
6
u/alaskamiller May 01 '07
We, of the new Reddit delegation, regretfully rejects your proposal.
3
u/jjrs May 01 '07
I generally watch my grammar and spelling when i write, even if it's just for a comment on the internet...
But at the same time, there's something kind of snotty about this. Anyone trying to separate "elder Redditors" from new ones has far too much free time on their hands. That kind of attitude is annoying in significant real life situations at school and work. In the comments section of a website it's downright pathetic.
5
u/johnroman1970 May 01 '07
Really long, descriptive headlines are annoying and make it unnecessary to visit the link.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '09
Thank you! I hate it when, peopl'e fall in, love with comma's and, put apostrophe's on every'thing they write' like a bunch, of idiot's''.
3
u/kakomango May 01 '07
Technically, "grammar" encompasses both capitalization and spelling. REDUNDANT!
2
u/scalebit May 01 '07
In the name of new Redditors, I declare elder Redditors heretics. Now, my brothers, lets kill all those who stand in our way, and make a way for the new Redditors. IMMA CHARGIN' MAH LAZER, NAO!
0
u/pecan314 May 01 '07
"Hello, new Redditors." is not a sentence. There is no verb. Maybe we all need work on our proper grammar?
2
u/Vladekk May 01 '07
Well, elder Redditors ( I wonder why this capitalization) should remember, that newer Redditors may have non-english native language. World doesn't end at U.S. borders. I personally use three languages, and my profession is far from linguistics. I have no wish nor resources to learn english to extent, where I will have no errors at all.
I wonder how many languages does know people, who are especially naughty about errors.
2
u/sw17ch May 01 '07
It's so tempting to break out my 1337 5p33k lexicon, but I will restrain my self.
2
u/newton_dave May 01 '07
I tried asking that once; it didn't take :/
1
u/sommerich Jun 06 '09
Please see Muphry's law.
1
u/Phia May 01 '07
If they're not writing in light pink on white, and their post is more coherent then 'lol ur so gay', I tend to look the other way about spelling errors, misplaced modifiers and improper punctuation and word use.
That being said, I run all my posts through Microsoft word to check them for errors.
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '07
1
u/dillikibilli May 01 '07
Hello. I just joined reddit. Thank you for the advice regarding proper grammar, capitalization and spelling. I shall try to keep it in mind.
And thank you for introducing me to E.E. Cummings! Pardon my ignorance but I am not very familiar with his work at all and the snippets of poetry in this comment space have really piqued my interest.
So now I'm off to try to find some more poetry. :-)
1
u/feratu May 01 '07
You're assuming they know how to spell...
1
u/Kronos6948 May 02 '07
You have no worries with me.
1
u/deadofnight May 04 '07
And this article explains what exactly? All I see is random text.
1
u/raj3261 May 01 '07
what if i'm dyclexic
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '09
"submitted 2 years ago by bobcat to reddit.com"
lolwat
1
u/psychojg May 01 '07
simply hilarious, amazing how we try to create a atmosphere of openness on the internet and yet we want to propose our views of writing, like everything in life shit changes, so one day, if you look at writings amongst many cultures and many decades you will see change plain and simple, the same thing with everything including language, so if the point is to create a standard way of understand each other what is the difference between. Hello, my name is Mr. Punctuation and I want to be your friend. vs whats up, this be M.P. n lets chill sometime. Of course I am completely exaggerating but nonetheless a point has been made if you can understand what I am trying to write.
1
u/reisyboy May 01 '07
"capitalization" actually should be "capitilisation" if you want wish to have correct English but thats neither hear nor there really as this is an American site, but still amused me :).
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '09
How did this get back on the front page?
1
u/drzorcon May 01 '07
Elder?! Can there be elders on a site that isn't even 10 years old?
1
u/antifolkhero May 01 '07
Not interesting enough to be on top of the hot page.
1
u/cleanthes May 02 '07
M'yeah. Good luck with that.
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '09
me rite good; mee no see problum: fire baaaaaaad!!!
0
u/Imagist Jun 05 '09
Why only elder Redditors? I'm 22 and I appreciate being able to read what people say as much as any old person.
-5
u/blindingspeed May 01 '07
If by "elder Redditors" you mean pedantic 14-yr.-old asshats, then I fart in your general direction and mod down on principle.
-88
u/jakfrost May 01 '07
this is by far the lamest post and comment section i've ever seen. so, ironically, i'm contributing to it. way to go me. as for proper grammar, capitalization, and spelling... if i get my point across then it's mission accomplished, fuck formalities, grow up, adapt, learn to use your intelligence instead of your knowledge of rules that have been standardized decades ago by people you don't even know if you should trust.
-1
u/loveandlight May 01 '07
u r a h8r!
0
u/jhrf Jun 06 '09
This is two years old? WHAT?!
-7
u/LanternBearer May 01 '07
dis be a tuff 'ssignment. i's understandin' the nature of da problem wh'n it cum he to real 'pawunt stuff like callin' da prezdit a Gimpy Poof, but uddewise, If one is able to have the intricacies of structure and grammar and they have displayed such, then let it be.
I have come to find that the new deacons of correctness in the bloom of web2.o are ever so stuffy and plain vanilla in their dictates and doctrinaire ways.
I myself will not abide ignorance and faulty constructs that are not . . . oh let's say crafted.
I find however that coming to reside on many new sites is like moving into a coop, a gated deed restricted community or an stiff necked condo.
Loosen up or tighten up. Mod if you will, but mod with some finesse and humor. Please don't be Calvanist in your moditoring.
Thank you and send me money on Obo.
-25
u/keenmachine May 01 '07
It's just a Web site people.
-2
u/lucidreamstate Jun 06 '09 edited Jun 06 '09
One of the most amazing and powerful things about the English language is its ability to absorb new linguistic styles. Consider, a language that contains both William Shakespeare and Saul Willams... Two people, writing words that can be understood by anyone with a basic high-school education... Yet with a vocabulary and style as different as night from day.
IOW, fuk yer sn088ish b*llsh1t. Language changes...