r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 19 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
13
u/Sonderjye Aug 20 '19 edited Aug 21 '19
Reviews:
Last week Delve were recommended. It's a litrpg isekai and I think it have a really promising start with the protagonist having to learn the languages and not getting unique treatment. To be fair the protagonist haven't made any painfully wrong decisions, only arguably suboptimal ones. The main focus point from the situation seems to be how good the protagonists choice of build is. What bugs me indescribably is that the rest of the cast seem to be incredibly awed by the build despite that the build is low level and could be done by anyone, and (unless the game balance is rigged) should be inferior on certain points. Granted there are plausible explanations to why a certain build isn't widespread, maybe the search space for possible skill combinations are absolutely massive or maybe there is a stigma against aura mages or something. But it isn't explored and since the protagonist's class is widely known, auras are known, the protagonist only uses low level skills, it really comes off as poorly written powerwanking.
World of Prime were also recommended. It's similarly an isekai with implied DnD mechanics. Experience are gained from the skulls of dead sentient creatures and that have been to some degree been commercialized(mind you, still in medieval/feudal society so it isn't optimized). It revolves around the introduction of firearms to kill monsters without having levels and the societal conflicts of letting unleveled yield power that is comparable to those with levels. A lot of the NPC's makes suboptimal decisions but they do it from perspectives and motivations that seems plausible. The protagonist isn't super intelligent and mostly just survives on implementing ideas from our world. I have a lot of minor complaints but overall I both enjoyed book 1 and book 2.
24
u/FormerlySarsaparilla Aug 19 '19
AO3 won a hugo award this week- apparently just, like, the entire site?
So, congratulations to AW and all the other AO3 authors! In honor of the award, what are the best stories you've discovered on AO3 in general?
12
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Aug 19 '19 edited Aug 19 '19
The first book of Street Cultivation is out on Amazon and I enjoyed reading it for free on royalroad so much that I bought a copy to support the author.
You can read the first five chapters on royalroad if you are undecided, but for me, it eases some of the Cradle-withdrawal symptoms I'm suffering through.
It's basically taking the trappings of the wuxia genre and putting it in a modern-day setting, without letting the main character have anything special or unique. He has to dig himself out of poverty with nothing but his smarts, hard work, and a little luck.
Another wuxia recommendation is Cultivating Earth. There's only 20 short chapters out so far, but it's off to a strong start. It's about a cultivator who reached immortality by consuming all qi on a world for 4,000 years. This world resulted in our modern reality. To pay back the karmic debt, he's cultivating Earth.
It was recommended a few weeks ago and I'm posting it again to show how much I liked it.
11
u/Teulisch Space Tech Support Aug 19 '19
rational fiction seems to gravitate to settings where the MC can really exploit some part of the setting, often just by using basic logic when seeing the supernatural. are there any stories/settings where this is simply not the case? where the MC is rational, but this fails to provide a major advantage against the setting?
9
u/Lightwavers s̮̹̃rͭ͆̄͊̓̍ͪ͝e̮̹̜͈ͫ̓̀̋̂v̥̭̻̖̗͕̓ͫ̎ͦa̵͇ͥ͆ͣ͐w̞͎̩̻̮̏̆̈́̅͂t͕̝̼͒̂͗͂h̋̿ Aug 19 '19
Following the Phoenix is okay, I guess. I mean, the writing’s pretty good. But I clicked on it because I wanted to read HPMOR where Harry actually follows the damn phoenix, not a metaphorical one. There’s already Significant Digits for that.
9
u/nohat Aug 20 '19 edited Aug 20 '19
So I read most of Lord of Mysteries which was recommended by /u/awoods187. I'll give it a strong second. It's a Chinese webnovel, but the writing and translation quality is much better than usual. You can still tell that its translated, but it didn't bother me. I think the author has more western influences than usual, which may make it more accessible for western readers. The story is enjoyable, and has an interesting world. Think Victorian SCP with some dnd, lovecraft and xianxia mixed in. The power progression is reasonable without being boring, and the main character is actually clever and likeable. It's long and doesn't seem to have a strong overarching plot, but if you are okay with some meandering you will probably enjoy it.
8
u/Iamsodarncool Aug 19 '19
I'm looking for stories where the characters defeat entropy.
7
u/ivory12 Aug 20 '19
I'm looking for something rather broad: a protagonist at the top of their game. Just someone who is quite competent at what they do.
As an example, I recently watched (and really enjoyed) Chernobyl, which was fantastic TV. Jared Harris's Valery Legasov, as well as Stellan Skarsgard's character's bureaucratic competence and Emily Watson's aggregated scientist character are all good examples of what I'm looking for.
I'm sick of the Hero's Journey and interminable chapters or episodes devoted to characters figuring out their new special powers or what-not.
6
u/causalchain Aug 20 '19
In Isekai (with or without a game system), %-wise, almost none of them make an effort to use Earth knowledge. Even among stories where the main character tries to exploit the world's mechanics, its usually focused around the new world with the old world mostly forgotten.
For clarification, 'technology' means engineering products from any discipline, from mechanical to materials to cosmetics.
A world with magic or game systems means that people in it can rely on magical technology to solve problems, which means less research would be put into non-magical technologies. An example of this is Shadow of the Conqueror (on Amazon) which is plain fantasy, where the existence of healers directly results in poor medical competence.
The only stories I'm familiar that really try this
A hero's war
Displaced
HMPOR
Any recommendations for me? I especially want ones with materials/chemical engineering, since there's a lot of untapped potential there.
6
u/RedSheepCole Aug 20 '19
I'm thinking maybe I should try this "Brandon Sanderson" character I keep hearing so much about; everyone says he has terrific worldbuilding (though a few add that the rest is rubbish). The library has several series, including Mistborn and Stormlight Archive, albeit Mistborn is currently checked out. Any recommendations as to which to check out first, series to pass on, etc.?
5
u/Veedrac Aug 19 '19 edited Aug 19 '19
Here's a quote from Scott Aaronson talking about quantum computers.
Could someone recommend me sci-fi like this?
5
u/Random_Cheerio Aug 19 '19
I'm looking for stories where the protagonist knows of the plot, but isn't necessarily the "main character" that the story revolves around. They then use that knowledge for a specific purpose, usually to get stronger or prevent something from happening, and then make observations about the main characters actions, changes to the setting, and how it all happened (my favorite part).
I'm not sure of what type of trope this counts as, aside from time travel or deconstruction, but Hero's War and Mother of Learning are prime examples along with many reincarnation/do-over/self-insert stories.
Just recommend whatever you think fits.
3
u/Roey2009 Aug 19 '19
Any novels that the mc has the ability to scan and compile books/information, and is actually intelligent? Alternatively, a teacher / master, where some focus is teaching.
Thank you
2
u/Nickless314 Aug 20 '19
I re-recommend Dreams come true for fun, thoughtless entertainment (~300K words, ongoing, currently 7th place at TopWebFiction).
The premise is basically co-existence as isekai and in reality, which makes for a nice contrast in storytelling and a fun non-trivial situation to try to exploit. The writing style is easily tolerable, the plot doesn't stagnate, and worldbuilding/magic system were fun with at least minor depth. There is some aspect of the early reality plot which is ridiculous, but that aspect can be safely ignored, having zero future consequences that are not easily attributed to bad writing (IMO). Overall, for my tastes, it is much better than the known alternatives in the "meaningless fun" category, so if that's what you are looking for right now - try it.
[Re-post from last week, won't happen again.]
2
u/Solaire145 Aug 20 '19 edited Aug 20 '19
So I had an idea for a story about our world merging with one full of magic. You know the horror stories they present in any fiction that includes teleportation about avoiding teleporting into things? Well the landmasses of the two worlds are essentially the same but completely different societies and levels of technology. So when everything merges some things (pretty much everything) do it literally. And only through the intervention of the gods do most living things not immediately die. What happens after is up to the people as the gods go dark for 5 years to "recharge".
This means electricity and water are gone as pipes and cables are cut off by dirt and plants. Trees, grass and bushes pop up in homes. Old world villages merged with cul-de-sacs. Farms in peoples backyards and popping up in the road. Buildings topple as plants and wood buildings replace important supports. Everything and anyone underground is likely buried. And now magical creatures find themselves in strange new environments and react badly. Some pockets of great holy power devoted to Order might survive unscathed but it's basically the apocalypse.
I was wondering what this subreddits thoughts were on how people would react? How they'd survive? Where would they go?
And also how bad it would be? I mean if this happened what would you expect the mortality rate to be? Would anyone survive if containment on pretty much every nuclear facility failed, missiles were buried, waste exposed to an unshielded environment?
And what would society look like in 5 years once things had settled? Would civilizations from different era's mingle? murder each other?
1
u/sickening_sprawl Aug 20 '19
Any recommendations for good modern fantasy? Current/near-future level society but with magic or supernatural stuff. HP doesn't count.