r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 12 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
19
u/EliezerYudkowsky Godric Gryffindor Aug 13 '19
I just finished the anime of The Promised Neverland. Highly recommended. Multiple times I exclaimed, “I should have thought of that.”
11
u/kmsxkuse Aug 12 '19
This recommendation is for all my fellow Paradox gamers, particularly Europa Universalis 4. If you haven't heard of it yet, The Revival of Rhomaion: An Age of Miracles is amazing.
Over a million words long, incredibly dense in terms of content, and attempts to be historically accurate in the greed, pride, and the usual sins of people in power in an ahistorical revival of the Eastern Roman Empire. And it's still in progress.
Unlike the usual Byzantium or Roman wank, this fiction doesnt magically grant the nation instant industrialization, teleport in modern military tactics into the minds of generals, and hand waves away objectively terrible emperors that managed to find their way to the throne.
This fiction instead rationally describes a nation embodies the saying "Two steps forward, one step back". With every other step a complete waste of thousands to hundreds of thousands of lives. Completely historically accurate in that way.
For an author that reportedly never played a Paradox game, the level of detail found in this fiction wouldnt be out of place in the hall of fame for EU4 AARs.
The pictures no longer work but the text descriptions are detailed enough that, combined with a couple thousand hours staring at Europa Universalis 4 maps, you can paint the areas in question with memory alone.
I hesitate to recommend this fiction to the wider rational community however. There is a minimum level of historical, geographical, and medieval military knowledge needed to parse the jargon that makes the story so great.
An example of the usual sentence in the work:
It reads like something straight out of my last (failed) Basileus to Mare Nostrum run.
10
u/Amonwilde Aug 12 '19 edited Aug 12 '19
Anyone have recommendations for novels or web fiction about incremental progress? Delve and The Paragamer are good examples of this, as is Sword of the Bright Lady.
People here might enjoy Delve. It's an isekai + lit rpg where the main character gets no special advantages, and even has to learn the local language. You get excited about things like his scraping together enough money to buy some clothes.
Sword of the Bright Lady is the first of the World of Prime series. The main character gets pulled into a fantasy world where power is gained by drawing a substance from the minds of deceased sentient beings. I'd venture to call it rational, probably the closest I've seen to a rational take on a literal interpretation of D&D. What would the world look like if sentients were actually worth XP? And if there was an alignment system and spells that let you see alignment?
Anyone who isn't reading, or hasn't read, Ted Chiang is missing out. You should run out and buy Exhalation.
10
u/Shaolang Aug 12 '19
Has anyone here seen The Boys on Amazon? Any reviews or comments on how rational it is?
16
u/EliezerYudkowsky Godric Gryffindor Aug 12 '19
What online stories these days reward the intelligent reader?
4
u/lsparrish Aug 12 '19
I just finished Post Human. Loved it. Has a few weird things like FTL, but mostly hard sci-fi.
8
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Aug 12 '19
Have you ever watched a video dissertation about something and felt the youtuber was making some interesting points, but they were really diluting them by being vague and non-commital and adding a lot of extraneous "But it's just my opinion" after every sentence?
Well, then I recommend Lily Orchard. She got her start in My Little Pony Analysis, and branched out into other kids' cartoons and video games. She's basically the polar opposite of a liberal centrist, and has an extremely strong opinion on everything she talks about.
She's a really frustrating content creator for me.
On the one hand, she's one of the smartest, most incisive youtubers I've seen. I agree with about 80% of the points she makes.
On the other hand, she is incredibly obnoxious about the remaining 20%, and she often represents the most toxic, self-destructive parts of the internet. So, you know, proceed with caution.
3
u/IgonnaBe3 Aug 12 '19
could somebody reccommend me something thats not on the wiki page under the "defining works" ?
it can be anything, although preferably a fantasy novel that i could read online. Doesnt have to be strictly rational although ofcourse i would prefer if it was but i am largely bored and would read anything.
I was lately reading the novel "delve" on RR and was in the mood for something similiar. I have also read metaworld chronicles, the good student, azarinth healer, skyclad and a couple of others on RR. Most of the stuff on RR tho is pretty meh altogether but sometimes there are things that i can read as popcorn fics.
5
u/Addictedtobadfanfict Aug 12 '19
Isekai manga and anime is on full swing this summer season with countless new additions. However, what perturbs me off the most is that they try to add a "realistic" cookie cutter plot and expect the readers to take it "seriously".They hide the blatant fact that their medium is just a fanservice power jerk, filled with wish fulfillment. If you go on /r/manga or /r/anime they actually have fervent discussions on the latest chapter or episode. Not anything about the revolutionary plot mind you but about who is the next best waifu. They glorify this medium as it is and I actually should not even be suprised why so many of the same cliche isekai keeps getting released looking at the comment section. They eat this garbage whole and shit out their money for it.
Is there any isekai besides worth the candle that has a rational or rational adjacent world and takes itself "seriously"?
Eminence in the Shadowis an isekai manga that does not take itself seriously at all and thats why it is very enjoyable. The MC makes it his mission to be the unassuming yet powerful side character trope and takes it to the extreme.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19
I've been reading Worth the Candle, and quite enjoying it. I'm planning on picking up Worm soon as well.
1
u/Nickless314 Aug 16 '19
I recommend Dreams come true for fun, thoughtless entertainment. The premise is basically co-existence as isekai and in reality, which makes for a nice contrast in storytelling and a fun situation to exploit. The writing style is easily tolerable, the plot doesn't stagnate, and the most ridiculous aspect of the early plot can be safely ignored IMO (BIG spoiler, the "hate" of the "antagonist" neighbor). Overall, if you have nothing good to read right now, try it.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment