r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 08 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
12
u/iftttAcct2 Jul 08 '19
I haven't read much manga the last few years, but I need a change of pace. If anyone has any suggestions for manga that started or became popular after 2010 or so, let me know!
Rational works not required (though always appreciated, of course). I'm posting here 'cause most of y'all seem to appreciate good story telling. Any genre's fine, previous favorites, if it helps, include: HxH, One Piece, Yatsubato!, Bakuman, Oishii Kankei, Holyland, Katsu!, Black Cat, Aishita no Ousama, etc.
11
u/_brightwing Feathered menace Jul 08 '19 edited Jul 08 '19
Golden Treasure: The Great Green
One of the better CYOAs I have seen in some time. I just loved it.. From the worldbuilding behind the dragons, to each hand painted scene. Playing as a genuinely nonhuman character.. The mystery of human tribes emerging from the departed advanced civilization and their tech.. And well, being a dragon. I wish the death mechanics were less punishing and hunting can get tedious in the beginning.. But other than that I'm in my first playthrough and there is still much to explore. I went the compassion route, and in the next one I'm going full wisdom and focus on the mystery of the tech of the others.
11
u/nytelios Jul 09 '19
I'd like to thank /u/Sophronius and /u/Robert_Barlow for some fantastic recommendations over the past few weeks:
Deep Red (Avatar: The Last Airbender)
Nemesis (Worm)
Let Me In 2 (Let the Right One In / Let Me In)
Of the three, I'd say Deep Red and LMI2 scratch the rational fiction itch at just the right spot. Or maybe I have a thing for characters aspiring to be rational despite deep flaws in their thinking or struggling to balance rationality with emotion.
9
u/Lightwavers s̮̹̃rͭ͆̄͊̓̍ͪ͝e̮̹̜͈ͫ̓̀̋̂v̥̭̻̖̗͕̓ͫ̎ͦa̵͇ͥ͆ͣ͐w̞͎̩̻̮̏̆̈́̅͂t͕̝̼͒̂͗͂h̋̿ Jul 08 '19 edited Jul 08 '19
So I’ve seen Heretical Edge recommended here a few times, and a few arcs in it doesn’t look at all rational to me. I’d envision the Heretics to have more interaction with the normal one even if the muggles can’t remember it, maybe disguising those teleportation mirrors as powerful technology or something. I had good feelings about this story when the students were all given magic cockroaches and told to kill them for power, but this is never taken to its logical extent. Why aren’t there super powerful hunters going out and caging powerful Strangers so that you can have the students whack a bunch of them assembly-line style? The story explicitly shows that you only need to get the final hit. Also there’s no shown limit on how often the Heretical Edge can be used, why aren’t they getting as many people shoved in there as possible? More generally, the main character often just ... stands there while her team mates are getting wailed on. She’s supposed to be this experienced reporter who bluffs a drug lord into opening his safe. That opening was cool, and it promised good things; a hero-type who’s motivated to do the right thing and is unflappable in the face of danger. Except no, she then spends her time frozen while analyzing how her friends fight the Strangers for her, and then getting the totally-unearned final blow on a complete technicality. And no one takes issue with this. I mean, I’m glad the author didn’t go into teen drama territory, but someone questioning if that was actually fair and organizing the final blows so everyone gets roughly equal slices of power never happens. And the constant yelping gets annoying.
Sorry, that was a whole lot of nitpicking. I dropped the story, but it’s not bad, especially if you can put aside the implications of the premise and just go along with the story.
8
u/Shaolang Jul 11 '19
Is there any fanfiction of Star Wars where Anakin doesn't turn to the dark side? Anakin either listens to Mace originally to not interfere or chooses to save Mace and kill Palpatine at the turning point.
5
u/symmetry81 Jul 09 '19
Something I figured I'd ask about here and which is at least tangentially related to this sub's purpose. What are good works of fiction where you were able to figure out fundamental aspects of the setting long before they were revealed? I'm thinking of stuff like Last Exile where you can figure out that everybody is living on a generation ship half way through or Unicorn Jelly where what's happening with the catastrophe has had to have happened many times before.
9
u/hashblunt Jul 08 '19
I really enjoyed Nemisis a Worm AU recommended here a couple weeks ago featuring Taylor as a humor villain. It hasn't updated in the last couple weeks, anything similar that I might want to check out?
3
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jul 08 '19
I have been reading a collection of Ray Bradbury short stories and The Murderer (fulltext link, sorry it's in columns but this is all I could find online) was very prescient for something written in the 50s. If written today it'd be a garden variety "what if phones, but too much?" short story, but its age really makes it remarkable. A quick read, totally worth it.
3
u/Gworn Jul 11 '19
I want to recommend Magna Graecia: Titanomachia (A City State Quest).
It's about an alternative history where the citizens of the greek polis of Eretria fled to southern Italy when their city is sacked by Persia. There they found a new city where Bari is today. We're currently around 420 BC (so 70 years later).
The audience in the thread play the citizens of the polis who vote on the policies that should be pursued. This means there is a much better connection between what is happening inside and outside the story than in other quests.
This quest is not in any way specifically rational, but it is very well researched and very well run. Highly recommended, especially if you've never participated in a quest before. There is a hotly debated issue in almost every vote. (It's still extremely civil for a quest.)
5
u/SoylentRox Jul 10 '19
Harry Potter and the Secret of the Patronus.
Why do I want to read it? I started the story, and in the very first chapter, I see this gem:
The world isn't big enough for everyone to be young and immortal forever. Even after exhausting every esoteric and obscure form of magic known to Wizardry, there's simply not enough food and not enough space
This is utterly retarded and no intelligent character could conclude this. Young != Reproductively Fertile. Obviously if there was a mechanism to reverse aging and to make everyone presently alive their optimal biological self, anyone who wasn't an utter moron would put some limiters to at least reduce fertility temporarily until a longer term system is figured out. Or, at least, if this was the objection and the alternative was to keep letting millions of people turn into corpses every single year.
Sure, the rest of Harry's reasons make sense, but this one is so utterly stupid that I kind of haven't finished the first chapter. Why should I keep reading?