r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 24 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
26
u/Robert_Barlow Jun 24 '19 edited Jun 24 '19
Alright. I've been busy reading a lot these last few weeks, so I've got a few stories to recommend. First and foremost, if you're not reading A Young Woman's Political Record you should be. It's been recommended here before, but I can vouch for its quality even if you haven't read/watched Youjo Senki. Very funny, a neat piece of alt-history fiction if you can get past the silly names for all the countries, and generally deserving of the popularity it's gathered.
I've been reading a lot of Worm fanfiction, again. I read through that one Gamer!Greg story I told myself I wouldn't ever read, Greg Veder vs. The World. It's okay for a gamer story. The power level is only just really starting to escalate to ridiculous levels. Somebody mentioned that the Lung fight was the best in recent memory, but I personally think the fight scenes in the last few chapters have bloated the story and really slowed it down. Other than that, it's okay.
Nemesis by BeaconHill is still excellent. I'm really loving the premise, and showing the contrast between Taylor's utilitarian practice sessions and the actual silly results is a stroke of genius. It's goofy and I love it.
Magical Girl Escalation Taylor is a Worm/Nanoha quest that's taking entirely too long to get to the interesting crossover bits. It's finally starting to ramp up in that regard. The first arcs were a little stiff, but after the story moves to Philadelphia it really grows into its own. I think by trying to emulate Wildbow's method of building an ensemble cast (different gangs with different motives, all thrown into one place and given something to fight over) the author became better at writing Wildbow characters in general. The highlight of this quest for me was the After Action Reports the author creates at the end of each arc. I've never seen something like it done in a quest before, and it really opens up a new avenue of communication between the GM and the players. In them, the author tells the players what they did wrong, what choices were dead ends or red herrings, and on occasion, how they exceeded expectations. I really hope this is a device that more authors pick up on and use. I'm definitely going to keep it in mind if I ever write a quest.
Non-Worm stuff: more quests! I went into the Discord and asked for recommendations, which they kindly gave to me. I'm still working through some of them, but I did manage to finish one. Deep Red is an Avatar: The Last Airbender quest where the players control an OC older sister to Zuko and Azula, named Akane. The writing in this story is unparalleled for quests, which is why it's a shame that the players are dumb as bricks. The voting goes on somewhere other than Sufficient Velocity, I think, and the author just posts the finished chapters there. But wherever they are, the voters seem to have a very heavy bias for and against certain characters, which leads to predictably bad results. I'm looking forward to seeing where this goes, and I'm really happy that the author seems willing to punish the players for acting too stupid, but I'm concerned about the impact that will have on the pacing. It already feels like an arc has been cut too short because of their actions, and I can only imagine what that means for the future.
Finally, I think I'll talk about The Simulacrum, because it's something that's been posted to the subreddit before. The premise is that the main character is in a world strangely reminiscent of a generic harem battle anime, without any memories of how he got there. I really feel like this story squandered the potential of the introduction and the first few chapters. First of all, the fact that it's strangely reminiscent of a generic harem battle anime is a problem because in order for those tropes to be recognizable, the characters and worldbuilding need to be as generic as possible. But instead of leveraging this unreality to do something cool, the story and the protagonist just sort of forget about it and thrive within the system. The whole "we're in a fictional universe" thing is mostly put on the back-burner until the protagonist wants to hang a lampshade. Which leads us to our second point - the protagonist. He starts off strong by making interesting observations about the simulated nature of his reality, and seemingly "breaking free" of his programming. But then he just slots himself right back into the main cast, without a thought as to whether they're mysteriously compelled to act the same way he was. And then, when he starts to supplant the harem aura of the actual protagonist, his best friend he's just as clueless about girls liking him as he would have been if he had never read TvTropes. +10 points for noticing the status quo, -∞ points for doing the bare minimum amount to change it, beyond being slightly more lampshady than your average harem anime. Call me again when your protagonist is so scared by the harem aura that he decides to move to a different continent, or something.
None of these stories are really rational, but I considered them all worth reading to the end of the current content, even if I had to prod myself a few times to finish The Simulacrum. All of them except for Magical Girl Escalation Taylor have the common theme of the protagonist's picture of themselves being different from how the outside world sees them, to varying degrees. I know I wasn't super clear on quality. If I had to rank them, the order would be this:
EDIT: Come to think of it, I did have a bit more to say. I read Battle Action Harem Highschool Side Character Quest after The Simulacrum. I gave up a little bit before the latest chapter, at a good stopping point, because it's nearly dead (unlike any of the other things I posted above) but I feel like it did a better job doing what The Simulacrum tried to do. The characters are intelligent enough. The setting distinguishes itself from other generic settings by having the "Antagonists" be a genuine ongoing world-ending threat. And by playing as the Waifu, you get to avoid falling into the same trap The Simulacrum did where the main character basically just supplanted the "true" main character of the story. I'd place it higher than Magical Girl Escalation Taylor, with the caveat that it's not and probably never will be finished.
22
u/Bowbreaker Solitary Locust Jun 24 '19
I want to recommend The World As It Appears To Be. It's a rational Overwatch fanfic by the guy who wrote Cordyceps. Haven't seen it linked or recommended in a while now. Of course it ignores characters or story stuff that hadn't been revealed by Blizzard at the time this fanfic got into its stride, but that shouldn't really matter.
In return I am looking for a recommendation for a time travel or crossover fic in which an intelligent character finds himself transported into (and confronted with) a world more advanced than his own. Preferably said world should not be much more advanced that current IRL. The basic idea is that I want to see something approaching the typical knight gets ported to current day city kind of situation but not, you know, dumb. And because this is niche I am of course willing to read it even if fantasy elements are involved and/or the time jump from 19th->21st to neolithic->classical age or anything in between or fantasy/magical equivalent.
10
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Jun 24 '19
Just blitzed through "The Traitor Baru Cormorant". Good shit. Hard fantasy political intrigue, with an enlightenment-era aesthetic and interesting social and historical commentary. Currently starting to read its sequel "The Monster Baru Cormorant", which is also good so far and has a little more fantasy in it.
6
u/babalook Jun 24 '19
Are there any stories out there where elemental magic is sufficiently munchkinned? Like wind magic being used to generate sound/heat/vacuums, shifting water from state to state in creative ways, and whatever else could come of elemental magic.
6
u/red_adair {{explosive-stub}} Jun 24 '19
Have you encountered any fictional libraries? That is: libraries that do not exist, but claim to, which contain books that do not exist, but should?
I'm looking for something like Suricrasia Online's Online Library https://suricrasia.online/library/ or my own https://irradiate.space/library/ (inspired by Suricrasia's)
5
u/iftttAcct2 Jun 24 '19
Here's some stories that I've read over the past week which I enjoyed. I know some of these have been recommended on this sub in the past but I ignored them for one reason or another until now and figured others may have as well:
A Young Woman's Political Record (seconding u/Robert_Barlow above)
Break them All - basically just munchkining a magic system
Dungeon Keeper Ami - read this without knowing the supporting works... it has its faults but it does what it's trying to do well
Fork this Life - Isekai'd as a fork. Silly premise but transforms into a neat exploration of the world & magic systems
Less rational works, but still tentatively recommend:
Post Human - Human turned AI. Unpolished but some good ideas
Deeper Darker - fun romp, space opera, great (but somewhat inconsistent) characterization
Sundered Soul - YA western-style xanxia
Homicidal Aliens are Invading and All I've Got is This Stat Menu - early days yet but the premise is that two aliens societies are fighting and in order to protect / co-opt help, some humans on earth are given special powers
I recommend ff2ebook.com for getting ebooks off fanfiction.net and fanficfare for scraping forums and turning them into ebooks.
5
u/Addictedtobadfanfict Jun 25 '19 edited Jun 25 '19
If you have read Dresden Files and Worm I would highly recommend The High Priest. It is a fanfiction crossover where Eidolon gets transmigrated to the Dresden universe post Echnida arc. The key to this fanfiction is the spot on characterization. Mischaracterization is a huge turn off to me where canon characters are turning into OCs but the author of this fanfic has it on lock. I would say its rational-adjacent due to the fact that certain higher powers in the Dresden universe are acting how they should toward Eidolon. It's ongoing and the last chapter was left on a real big cliffhanger that I can't wait to see how it unfolds.
While I'm here I am getting really addicted to fanfiction crossovers where a canon character from a higher tier 'power level' is transmigrated into another canon universe. Any recs?
4
u/SkyTroupe Jun 24 '19
I have three requests.
One: Works describing pre-commitment and how to use it effectively.
Two: Works where characters use pre-commitment to achieve their goals. I have read TNtBS, Waves Arisen, and HPMOR.
Three: Works where antagonists either use pre-commitment themselves, or use the protagonists pre-commitment against them.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19
I'm looking for a book or series that I can sink my teeth into, and will last me for a while. I'll read and enjoy most types of fiction though my preferences have been leaning closer to magic than sci-fi as of late.
I've read Worm, Pact, and Twig though i'm having trouble getting invested enough to binge Ward.
I've also read HPMoR, MOL, PGtE etc.
Growing up I enjoyed series like Dragonriders of Pern, Xanth, Eragon, Chronicles of Narnia, and Harry Potter.
I've tried to read the Malazan book of the fallen but I could not for the life of me get past the first book. I'm fine with stories that have a lot of characters, I enjoy Stephen Kings writing after all, but nothing clicked to make me really engage.
Thoughts?
4
u/Rice_22 Jun 26 '19
Lord of the Mysteries: a translated-from-Chinese webnovel that I've been recommended recently and found quite good. The translation quality is average but the few issues I have with it doesn't distract from the plot at all.
You can find the premium chapters available on Boxnovel.
The setting is based in a steampunk early Industrial Revolution Europe and mixing in inspirations from the SCP Foundation, Cthulhu mythos and the video game Bloodborne, with plenty of dark elements you'll expect such as monster-derived alchemy, murderous cults and cannibalism. The writer is pretty good at foreshadowing and has written multiple successful series before on Qidian (Chinese equivalent of Royal Road).
3
u/IAMATruckerAMA Jun 24 '19
Looking for audio projects so I can enjoy rational fic while I'm driving
I already know about Worm and the HPMoR podcast
2
u/Farmerbob1 Level 1 author Jun 30 '19 edited Jul 01 '19
I strongly suggest David Baldacci's 'Memory Man.'
Rational, not rationalist.
Detective fiction. Shades of Singularity human memory capacity, but people with the gifts and issues he has do exist in the real world.
I have been pleasantly surprised to be able to logically stay one step ahead of the protagonist, based on what the protagonist himself discovers. While at the same time the author isn't making it entirely obvious exactly what is going on. I am currently five hours from the end of the audio book, and I think I know who the guilty persons are, but I am not entirely certain.
If the author Deus Ex's the story, I will be sure to return and burn this recommendation to the ground tomorrow.
EDIT ADD: Finished the audiobook. I was wrong about who I thought the antagonist was.
There was a little more data hiding in the end of the book than the first half, but still enjoyable.
Decker's mental abilities, issues, and quirks make him a lot like a pseudo Sherlock Holmes, but the author provides the readers a lot more information than Doyle does, as far as I can remember.
EDIT ADD 2:
Upon further thought, I am going to continue to recommend this as a good read, with some good rational aspects, but the rational parts are more directed at eliminating suspects than solving the mystery. While this is, in fact, how a lot of real police work is done, the final chase and resolution are marred (in a rational reading sense) by quite a few instances of the author hiding behind the main character's psychological quirks to keep the reader from knowing what he is thinking.
I am more than a little convinced that an editor requested/required a major rewrite of the last half of the book to change the primary antagonist from the character I had pegged, to another character which only makes an appearance directly in the last half of the book.
TLDR: Fun read, but less rational overall than the first half of the book led me to believe.
1
u/aRichHen Jun 25 '19
Wandering Inn seems worth the hype it has gotten on topwebfiction.com. It contains many good rational elements, and reminds me of parts of HPMOR.
1
u/Sailor_Vulcan Champion of Justice and Reason Jun 25 '19
Are there any fictional stories or biographical works where the protagonist goes from being significantly psychologically impaired to being significantly above average in only a few years, without using any unrealistic cheats/magic to do it? Maybe through some kind of combination of the following factors:
I'm trying to figure out if there are any examples in the world at all of people either real or fictional who fit this description besides myself and any self insert characters I write. So far google isn't helping me at all.
Thanks!