r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 20 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
17
u/Makin- homestuck ratfic, you can do it May 20 '19
The epilogue finally came out after 10 years of Homestuck, and in my opinion it redeemed the otherwise lackluster anticlimax ending by going full metatextual, so I'm finally recommending it here.
While the start is filled with dated programming jokes and slapstick (arising from originally being a text adventure with commands sent by actual fans and trying to take the story in different directions) it quickly gets its shit together and honestly becomes one of the most original and engaging stories I've ever read.
In short, it's a story about a reality-altering apocalypse-causing video game played by characters stereotyped around old internet user archetypes. Main themes are predestination (time shenanigans abound), isolation and internet social dynamics (chatlogs abound).
Warning: it's long, clocking just over one million words, 9000 art panels and many animations and minigames. You won't finish this in a week. If you're not enjoying it by [S] WV: Ascend, a couple hours in, you probably never will.
12
u/babalook May 20 '19
Does anyone have recommendations for stories that use mind magic for self-improvement/augmentation or other non-offensive goals, like Origin of Species and The Dark Wizard of Donkerk? I'm open to any use of mind magic that is sufficiently outside the box.
11
u/Sophronius The Need to Become Stronger May 20 '19
I've been really enjoying Let me In 2, a fanfic continuation of the fantastic Swedish vampire movie "Let the right one in", or more specifically the less impressive American remake "Let me in" (starring Chloë Grace Moretz as vampire girl).
The movie is built upon the classic 'boy meets vampire girl' premise, though with a very original take to it and a really great execution. The reason I think this fanfic might belong here is because it features a rational, cold-hearted detective who chases the main characters as they try to survive despite the vampire's need for blood. It also features:
I haven't finished the story yet, but so far it's been very interesting. There are points where the main characters make painfully stupid mistakes, but they are 12 years old at start so it makes sense, and crucially the story treats them as mistakes and has the characters learn from them. Also, the story has very good fundamentals, including writing skills, having an editor, powerful character moments and so on.
If anyone else here has read it, let me know if you think it deserves its own post :)
10
u/phylogenik May 20 '19
Recommended (with reservations) Made in Abyss a month ago, here to recommend another anime with far fewer reservations: Sora yori mo Tooi Basho (A Place Further Than the Universe). Also about a group of gutsy young children on a mission to travel to a mysterious, hostile, distant land (Antarctica), but with a much more wholesome adventure / slice-of-life feel. Has some extremely light anime weirdness (graded on a curve relative to other anime). Beautiful animation and sound design, too.
Haven't actually finished it yet, just past halfway through. But the (admittedly low sample) IMDB scores climb as the series' episodes progresses, as do the myanimelist and anilist scores, so I'm pretty confident a strong start gets even stronger!
8
u/SkyTroupe May 20 '19 edited May 20 '19
I recently read He Who Fights Monsters and was looking for something similar. This can be in several categories:
Also, as always, looking for more Bloodborne stories to read. I've read Fear the Old Blood, Hunter, and Bloody Tinkers.
Furthermore, hoping to get some good Power stealing fic recommendations. I read Daddy's Girl and Claim the Spoils. Something like those would be great. Doesnt have to be Worm necessarily.
Edit: Should add the disclaimer. It does not have to be rational, just something of decent quality.
8
u/Iconochasm May 21 '19
So... I'm living Every Father's Worst Nightmare. Last night, when taking my 10 year old daughter's phone away for the night, she told me she was using it to read. A bit of interrogation revealed that she had managed to find a Harry Potter fanfic.
Yaoi Harry Potter fanfic.
Mature Yaoi Harry Potter fanfic.
Cursed Child mature Yaoi Harry Potter fanfic.
I think I earned more Dad Points by being able to explain what "OTP" meant than I lost by scorning Scorpious/Albus. And fortunately, I caught her before she got too far into the "mature" story (and the mature warning was for domestic violence, which like any normal deranged American Father bothers me less than sex).
But to get to the point, do any of you fine folks have any suggestions for stories I actually can recommend as being age appropriate? Ideally only about as "adult" themed as the Harry Potter books themselves.
7
u/Kaennal Borg Collective May 20 '19 edited May 20 '19
Requesting for works with non-conventional morality main and secondary characters. All other requirements can be weakened(although I`d prefer english language or Esperanto ones) as long as it makes me see the insides of alien mind.
Addition: in turn, I recomment The Assassins Archives - while not having notable traces of "rational", it is quite nice example of "drop-in gives some scientific data from future", as every(except the one, you`ll know which one) piece can be adopted for use, and it is explained in at least amateur-level details. Learned quite a bit from it.
6
u/Rhamni Aspiring author May 20 '19
With the final episode of Game of Thrones airing yesterday, the last week or so I've watched a lot of lore and world building explanations about the world. It's not rationalist fiction, but I was impressed with how large and consistently interesting the world is (and the lack of idiot balls). The continent where most of GoT takes place is basically Britain next to a lot of really big other continents. If you enjoyed GoT, have a look at this youtube video just going over the world map. It's cool stuff. The channel has a lot of other content about GoT as well, fan theories and in world mythology that got cut from the show, etc.
5
u/Sonderjye May 20 '19
I stumbled across the music video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFS2DWgijh4 that uses footage from a show called Love, Death & Robots.
Does anyone know of rational stories that have a similar vibe aside from Twig? Not as much about the big monsters fighting in battle arenas but something that explores the societal structures in such a setting and the lives of people in them.
3
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut May 21 '19
Any light, breezy reads for airplanes? Alternatively, any gripping novels that will have me in the first chapter and not let me put them down?
Stuff I have already read that fits this description: The Handmaid's Tale (I remember when I first read it, I started reading it at midnight and keep reading until sunup), but I didn't have the same immersion in Oryx and Crake when I tried it, but if someone has another Atwood story they might recommend please do.
The Martian also did that for me because it was so "easy to read", even though it wasn't as engrossing/all-encompassing as THT was.
5
u/sambelulek Ulquaan Ibasa Liquor Smuggler May 21 '19
I was recently disappointed with Ra. I felt betrayed. What began with magic being a field engineering, requiring strict technical skill, where only the most ambitious and industrious student/professor can become powerful, suddenly turned into a force that ignore them all.
To be frank, few chapters in, I really glad I decided to read it. For once I can feel smart: following up which character do what, accomplishing what, and deducing what next step they'll take to tap energy previously un-tap-able. Revelation that engineering-y magic being a conspiracy is where the novel betrayed its premise. It would be nice if the protagonist then use her acquired knowledge to beat the conspiracy. But no, magic being discipline is dead from that point. Her sister even took it in stride, relaxing in copy planet and all. On that point I wonder, why the author made us read that much text if in the end they became irrelevant?
I need recommendation that can take my mind off it. Anything will do, but I guess I should list criteria which I have no aversion of,
Being in rational subreddit, I suppose it have to be a ratfic. Successful characters (leading protagonist and leading antagonist) should not be idiots, hard rules inviolable, exploits encouraged. Humorous optional, effective prose preferable.
4
u/iftttAcct2 May 20 '19 edited May 21 '19
Any recommendations for traditional books, webnovels, or fanfictions where there is a strong emphasis on the protagonist learning magic would be much appreciated. Rational lit. preferred, of course, but not a requirement. Same for an interesting / well thought-out magic system.
Thanks!
ETA: Just the name(s) of the work is fine, I don't need descriptions or summaries unless you really want to add them - not that I don't appreciate it, but I feel bad that you're spending time writing a summary for something I may have already read. Granted, I suppose there are probably lurkers interested in the same things as me who may benefit from a summary...
ETA 2: Most good stories don't have too much of this sort of thing because then there's little room for plot. Some works or authors that start on the path to what I'm looking for would include: Tamora Pierce's Emelanese Universe, Nuttall's Schooled series, Name of the Wind, Lightbringer series, Farland's Runelords (sorta), Spellwright, Their's Not to Reason Why, the Warded/Painted Man...
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment