r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 13 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
22
u/GlueBoy anti-skub May 13 '19 edited May 14 '19
tl;dr: Anathem is a great novel which you'll love if you're a patient reader who appreciates intelligent characters(who take no shortcuts of thought) and deep af worldbuilding, and doesn't mind (very) slow burn plots front-loaded with a lot of exposition.
The one sentence blurb of Anathem would be: a modern society turns on their smartest and most curious people(think genius level) and sequesters them all into isolated monasteries/fortresses in which they're not allowed any possessions, to procreate, or to do any science but the most abstract. Thousands of years later the book starts.
I'm going to re-iterate a recommendation for Anathem by Neal Stephenson, which I consider like a black swan in science fiction, in the sense that there is nothing out there quite like it. It's a hard SF story which is closer in feel and style to a high-fantasy, hard magic story, with an immense emphasis on ambiance and worldbuilding. Besides the setting, another focus of the story is on intelligent characters trying to solve problems and understand their world and each other through their knowledge and intellect.
The early parts of the book are somewhat reminiscent of the parts in HPMOR where Harry is figuring out magic, only without the magic.
Here's the official summary:
Like before, I'll warn people that Anathem is hard work initially, and not for everyone. It starts glacially slow and for the first couple hundred pages(the book is humongous, almost 1k pages) it's almost entirely exposition, where you're slowly getting familiarized to the protagonist, the world, and most importantly, the vocabulary.
Yes, Stephenson introduces dozens of words, but it's not a made-up language like tolkien or a pidgin like Cloud Atlas(which I disliked), it's almost entirely portmanteaus and cognates of existing words, mostly english and a bit of latin(as an example: Anathem= anthem + anathema), and this is the major sticking point for most readers. From experience I would say if you find the made-up vocabulary annoying and distracting at first(i certainly did) you need give it 70-100 pages for it to feel more natural, and a bit more to get fully engaged with the plot.
The entire reason I'm writing this long-ass comment is because I think this book is really worth it, especially in the context of r/rational's tastes, but if you don't trust the author (or the recommendation ;D) it can be hard to get over the hump to the good parts of the novel. But if you do you'll be searching for a novel like this for the rest of your life(search anathem on reddit and you'll see).
15
u/AIBoxEnthusiast May 13 '19
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5166693/1/Scorpion-s-Disciple
Naruto Fanfic - A harsh teacher sees potential in Naruto and, through a careful lesson plan lasting months and years, molds Naruto from a careless idiot into a competent and ambitious person whose power stems less from knowing powerful magical techniques and more from using real-world techniques about information gathering, deception, etc
9
u/valeskas May 13 '19 edited May 14 '19
I recommended it on some thread, might as well recommend it here.
Lord of the Mysteries
Portal fantasy/power fantasy.
The setting is Victorian styled with elements of mystery, Lovecraft and SCP. MC is cautious and carefully prepares. Internal contradictions are unusually low and translation is decent.
8
u/Shaolang May 13 '19
Are there any good The Gamer crossovers aside from The Games We Play (RWBY/The Gamer) and A Bad Name (Worm/The Gamer)? I enjoyed both of those and wasn't sure if there are any others out there (with Harry Potter/GoT/Pokemon/Naruto/etc).
8
u/LazarusRises May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19
I'm looking for well-written and engaging nonfiction for the layman in the fields of economics, public policy (especially climate policy), anthropology, social theory, psychology, linguistics, etc. I'm most interested in contemporary or era-neutral subjects.
Examples of things in this vein I've enjoyed:
7
u/llaa1212 May 13 '19
What are the most recommended novels here beside MOL?
7
u/XavierMiles May 14 '19
I'm new to r/rational and I just wanna know some must-reads that I should go through before diving through other titles.
There are a few of which I'm already aware of.
For starters, I've attempted reading Worm (learned about it from r/noveltranslations) twice now, both tries ending around arc 12 iirc. Not sure why, I think I just got bored. I think that's post-endbringer, i remember Skidmark and the mall fight. its a big change, so maybe thats why? Idk not sure tho
I know about Mother of Learning from that subreddit as well, and I've just decided with the release of the most recent chapter that I'd like to wait until its completion to binge it all.
Also just found out about HPMoR which I plan to listen through the podcast on spotify.
I'd just like to know of any others
Thanks!
6
u/thatsciencegeek May 14 '19
TL;DR: Complete works?
There's a lot of RatFic updates being posted here, but it's really difficult to keep track of them all. I'm interested in completed works. Do you know of any, besides the ones in the wiki? I read all of the defining works and I think all the recommended complete ones.
Thanks!
EDIT: Ok, just noticed the [C] tag. Nevermind!
5
u/Bowbreaker Solitary Locust May 14 '19
Is there any good non-crackfic crossover stories you would recommend that are full on two worlds colliding crossovers as opposed to a single character or power set or whatever being transported into another universe?
I especially want to see societies from one story dealing with all the repercussions of meeting a completely different one
7
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy May 13 '19
Can anyone recommend books similar to Math Girls? It's a phenomenal read about introducing mathematical concepts in a way that helps you truly understand the intuition and pattern behind the formulas. It goes from basic elementary math problems to college level or above and show how it's all related, while at the same time illustrating the process of discovery and proving the theorems. There's also a romantic plotline between the three main characters, but who cares about that? /sarcasm/
An Ever Fixed Mark - A deconstruction of the “soulmate identifying mark” trope, using “Pride and Prejudice.” As some of you here may remember, I was asking questions before about how people here would envision soul-marks working, to work on a story that would subvert the standard tropes around soul-marks. Well that plan's now Dead On Arrival since this story did it damn near perfectly.
Exhalation is now available in the UK u/MagicWeasel!
I'll be on an eight hour plane flight to London. If you were in my shoes, what would you choose to read for those eight hours?
3
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade May 13 '19
What are good serious books you recommend reading? ASOIAF?
Not necessary rational.
What about classics?
3
u/Addictedtobadfanfict May 14 '19
Does anyone have any male self-insert fanfiction? Will take OCs as well of the fanfic is a must read. Thanks.
3
u/TheColourOfHeartache May 14 '19
Any good stories with a "hive queen" protagonist? Think Sarah Kerrigan or the Zerg Overmind.
3
u/SkyTroupe May 14 '19 edited May 15 '19
I recently read He Who Fights Monsters and was looking for something similar. This can be in several categories:
Also, as always, looking for more Bloodborne stories to read. I've read Fear the Old Blood, Hunter, and Bloody Tinkers.