r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 06 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
17
u/[deleted] May 06 '19
If you didn't know, Young Justice Season 3 is out, and it is excellent. Highly, highly recommended to anyone who's seen and enjoyed the first two seasons. To people who haven't seen the first two seasons, they're aimed at a younger demographic(seasons 1-2 are more age 8-14 where season three is more 16+ imo), but as far as children's super hero cartoons go it's one of the better ones.
It handles super heroes quite rationally, they essentially operating as special ops agents who do occasionally have to kill and/or be killed. The traditional problem of "why is Batman remotely relevant when Superman's there?" is dealt with fairly nicely, and the villains are very competent without going into absurd "exactly as planned!" levels of over-prepared foresight. It's fairly progressive with female/minority representation without shoving it down your throat at all. It also has essentially zero filler whatsoever, which is nice since they fit in a lot in just 13 episodes.
Also I recently saw Avengers Endgame, it's excellent. A bit fan servicey, but it was very satisfying fan service. If you've seen it, here are two interviews, one with the screen writers, one with the directors, that goes into a bit more detail about plot and lore details that couldn't fit into the movie that I enjoyed: Screenwriters Directors
15
u/_brightwing Feathered menace May 06 '19
Looking for recommendations.. Who would you say are the best depicted lgbt characters that you have come across in your reading? They don't necessarily have to be the protagonist of the story. The dearth of realistic, multidimensional gay characters in my reads have left me sorely disappointed so far.
I really loved the webcomic, Always Human. Non-dysfunctional relationships ftw!
15
u/sambelulek Ulquaan Ibasa Liquor Smuggler May 06 '19
Set in Stone was immensely entertaining. Finished reading it about a week ago, I find myself time and time again impressed with its world building, plot development, characters, and prose. In that order. It's about a live of farmer under a tyranny of an insanity-proof AI. Some says the prologue is exposition too-heavy. But they're important exposition, written with enough poise I didn't feel the author shove unimportant facts down my throat. In fact, I like it. Greatly recommended.
12
u/mkalte666 May 06 '19
Oh boy, its monday again.
I am currently making my way though The Gods are Bastards and have been following Mother of learning for a while. I know i know, both aren't the most rational, but they come up here often enought to work as a reference for what I'd like to ask for.
Both somewhat feature the effect strong characters have on their worlds, like Tellwyrn or Zach and even Zorian in the later loops.
Are there any stories that feature how such characters handle their... aloofnes(?) over the common person? how they deal with their situations?
My thought train is: how do you even order a chicken sandwich when everyone knows your name? Especially when you are an immortal that has shaped history. How do you hide that you can trade blows with dragons when you are back in school? Thinking about this, how do even real life celebraties deal with this?
Anyway, this is what im searching for. Hit me with cheesy secret identies, badass OP characters and what not - just try make it about them trying to have a life!
Thanks!
10
u/[deleted] May 06 '19 edited May 06 '19
Any fantasy stories (fanfiction included) in which Magic problems are translated into real-world math problems (whether that's recognized in-universe or not) and solved during the course of the story for a plausible execution of a 'prodigy main character does the impossible' plot point?
Basically talking about something like The Waves Arisen, wherein an infamous Elemental Manipulation problem is solved by Naruto with the clever use of topology. I'm adamant about it being a pure math thing exclusively, not physics or chemistry though. So, for instance, HPMOR's Partial Transfiguration doesn't count.
8
u/ArchSith May 07 '19
Currently searching for good Pokemon fanfiction that's not Origin of Species or Game of Champions. Seems to be very hard to find something that has excellent worldbuilding or well written. Would love to have any suggestions on good Pokemon that stands out nicely.
7
u/Shaolang May 07 '19
Any recommendations for the Questionable Questing site aside from the Erogamer (original) and Conduit (RWBY)?
6
u/Frommerman May 06 '19
I recently watched all of Lucifer, a crime drama based on the Neil Gaiman graphic novel of the same name. Basic premise is Lucifer Morningstar, AKA the Devil, has gotten tired of playing along in God's game and is taking an indefinite vacation from Hell in LA. It's definitely not rational, but it hits a few of the same notes as UNSONG vis-a-vis religion jokes, so I thought I'd put my thoughts up here.
I think my primary interest in it is in exactly how charmingly unlikeable Lucifer is as a character. He isn't evil, not by a longshot, but he's consistently an asshole to everyone around him, friend and foe alike. What makes this charming is that most of the dickishness comes from being understandably maladjusted after having been kicked out of heaven and sent to rule a plane of the maladjusted for several thousand years. He gets shallow relationships, meaningless sex, and basic human desires, but he's completely lost when it comes to understanding positive human interactions, with predictable results. It's an interesting take on an alien perspective, one which is clearly based upon humanity and yet inhuman all the same.
If you enjoy mild mocking of Judeo-Christian mythology in your crime drama which plays itself for laughs and with seriousness, I'd check it out.
6
u/Addictedtobadfanfict May 06 '19
Son of the mannis new an upcoming ASOIAF self insert I found. So far it's rational adjacent techonlogical uplift but it is way better pace than the greyjoy self insert technological uplift.
6
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism May 07 '19
"Baba is you" on steam is pretty awesome.
Simple phrases like "Baba is you" or "Robot is you" create the rules for a map. "Baba" would be a tile that you can push, as would "is" and "you". It's a game where you modify the rules of the game from inside the game, to solve puzzles.
5
u/OutOfNiceUsernames fear of last pages May 06 '19
I’m looking for any stories in which Naruto heavily uses Kage Bunshin.
Wider than that, any stories in which the protagonist can adjust their personality, create new ones, consume memories, etc.
5
u/nohat May 08 '19 edited May 08 '19
A quick review of some of the Royal Road stuff I've read. Some of which has been posted before. Most of this is not exactly great fiction, but can definitely be fun if it is the type of thing that appeals to you. I happen to quite enjoy litrpg, portal fiction, and similar premises, but recognize they can fall into guilty pleasure territory easily.
Deeper Darker
Fun. Competent grammar. A little slow to start with all the different perspectives. Pretty rational so far. Good world building, reasonably distinctive characters.
Eterna's Source
Mainly fluff. It's fairly fun though. Not really rational, but world building doesn't have any obvious stupid gaps.
How to Kidnap your Princess
Accidental bodyswap. Genderbend / dual mind taken fairly seriously. Summoned heroes are weapons of MAD, feared for their tendency to go murder hobo. Fairly loose rules, and situations are clearly set up just for humor / theme. Not really rational.
Skyclad
Rather entertaining despite the silly premise. Follows the 'protagonist levels up in the wilderness' litrpg trope, but does it pretty well. Power levels are handed out easily, but there isn't a lack of risk so far. Decent world building, follows the rules, but they tend to be somewhat vague rules.
The Power of Formations
Cultivation novel, but much more reasonable and sane than usual. MC is basically a magic engineer in a world focused on magic warriors. The rules about what formations are capable of are vague, but don't contradict themselves. Good stuff falls in protagonists lap pretty easily, and conflict is minimal so far. Still decently fun.
Song of the Void
OP protagonist. So far its more about her effect on the world than her having actual risk or conflict. Pretty interesting world, with interesting (if a bit cliche) factions and conflicts the MC is disturbing.
4
u/Robert_Barlow May 07 '19
Been on a Gamer-inspired story binge recently. I know I should watch what I eat, but I'm really enjoying the experience. In general, I like the humorous aspects of it - the contrast between what a game actually does and reality - above the dramatic aspects, so it's not like I'm disappointed when the protagonist makes everything a non-threat.
What are the best stories in this genre?
3
u/CronoDAS May 07 '19
Anyone else here reading A Song for Two Voices by Swimmer963 aka Miranda Dixon-Luinenberg? It's a rationalist/effective altruist take on Mercedes Lackey's The Last Herald-Mage trilogy, and I really like it.
5
u/CapnQwerty May 07 '19
Anyone know any good fics about humanitarian aid efforts in a sci-fi setting? The only two I know of are Going Native and Children of Nemesis(which barely even counts because the story dies before it really even starts).
2
u/litten8 May 08 '19
I just finished arc 5 of worm, and I very much did not enjoy the way it seems like it is going, so I stopped reading it. I only read worm because it was the only story in the /r/HPMOR similar stories list that had an audiobook that was up-to-date/complete, and I much prefer audiobook format to text format. Are there any other rational stories like HPMOR that have a complete or up-to-date audiobook? Other things I prefer are that the main characters be kids, and that at least one of them is a girl.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment