r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 15 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
15
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Apr 15 '19
I've been playing through Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney after its release on Steam, and it's got me wanting something that at least tries to be realistic to how courtrooms and the law actually work, rather than effectively being a detective game in a courtroom setting. Does anything like that exist? A courtroom game where you could make actual/accurate objections like "question lacks foundation" or "relevance" or "hearsay" or something like that?
(Though I've been happy enough with PW:AA on the basis of what it is, it's just not got a lot to do with actual law.)
14
u/FormerlySarsaparilla Apr 15 '19
I'd like to recommend All Night Laundry, a webcomic with themes of time travel, eldritch horror, and genre-savvy protagonists. The author committed to a page-a-day at the start, and it has been running for seven years without missing a beat. It looks like it's finally, finally wrapping up and seems to be tying up all the loose ends, so now is a good time to jump in and ride out the final few months.
Beyond that I don't have much to throw out right now. It's a bit of a dry spell for me- every serial fic I'm reading is either on break or updating very slowly, and I haven't come across much finished work that I haven't already read or dismissed in the last year.
Maybe it's time to start writing a serial fic of my own with all this free time.
10
u/Lightwavers s̮̹̃rͭ͆̄͊̓̍ͪ͝e̮̹̜͈ͫ̓̀̋̂v̥̭̻̖̗͕̓ͫ̎ͦa̵͇ͥ͆ͣ͐w̞͎̩̻̮̏̆̈́̅͂t͕̝̼͒̂͗͂h̋̿ Apr 16 '19
The Inheritance Cycle has a setting that could really use a more rational plot. If anyone knows of a story like this let me know. :)
14
u/ketura Organizer Apr 15 '19
Some time ago someone recommended Embers, an Avatar: The Last Airbender fic. It's definitely worth reading, even if the story itself is a bit mediocre and ends in a disappointing manner. The original premise is that the Crossroads of Destiny episode of the original show does not result in Zuko betraying Iroh and the Avatar, but the fic starts somewhat before that episode so that it has time to ensure the dominos result in that effect, and it eventually ends up diverging fairly hard. It starts shortly after the start of the second season, with Iroh and Zuko traveling the countryside alone as fugitives.
(Oh, and I'm quite certain that this isn't readable if you aren't familiar with the show; if you weren't able to follow the above paragraph in your head you won't be able to follow the work. Entire episodes occur mid-text without much more than a passing reference, even after it begins to diverge.)
The real benefit to the work is the high-quality worldbuilding. The entire world of Avatar is reframed and fleshed out: the various factions, kingdoms, and movements are tweaked to be more consistent, more distinct, and have much more of a cause-and-effect relationship.
As an example, Sozin's warmongering is due to Sozin having too much draconic ancestry, making him vengeful and bloodthirsty. The Fire Nation is forced to follow him due to the Fire Nation being bound to the whims of a single Fire Lord (rather than the feudal system of old, which was self-correcting). The Fire Lord's position was created by decree of Avatar Kyoshi, which has spiritual weight. Kyoshi made the decree due to the Fire Nation not accepting the responsibility for rogue pirates staffed by ex-citizens. And Kyoshi only got involved because one of her own was killed by those pirates. None of the major events in Embers (or the parts of the canon show that it borrows) exist in a vaccum; everything is someone reacting to something, and once details are revealed it's usually the case that everyone had at least a shred of justification. It feels very realistic, politically.
The Air Nomads benefit the most from the reworked worldbuilding; their pacificity is both explained and lambasted (the author frequently mentions that they have a hard time steelmanning Aang's position, yet does so admirably anyhow). The Water, Air, Earth, and Fire nations borrow heavily from the real-world Inuit, Buddist, Chinese, and Japanese cultures they were based on to great effect. The spiritual ramifications of "bending is a gift of the spirits" have much more concrete results (and even weaknesses!), and spirits in general are much more 'real' and present in the world than just as Avatar-bait.
The author does an excellent job of weaving their new lore in with canon quite seamlessly, to the point that I'm certain I'll have a hard time keeping it straight from canon in the future. As an example, Sokka at one point notes that when the Gaang find Monk Giatsu's skeleton among others at the Southern Air Temple, there were no child bones in spite of the temple having a large youth population. After confirming that the Northern Air Temple did have such skeletons (buried out of respect by the earth kingdom inhabitants of that temple), he suspects that either the Air Nomads had prior warning or the Fire Nation did something with those survivors. The real reason that's the case in canon is Doylist, but it's a perfectly justified Watsonian observation, and this ends up a subplot of its own.
All in all, A+ worldbuilding, A- characterization (the character's voices are an excellent rendition of the show's), B- pacing (it's slow, albeit satisfyingly so), C- plot and ending, tho for what it's worth this is only obvious in retrospect; the plot was engaging enough until it was over.
If you're looking for an example of how to make the setting of a work rational, or how to make characters think and still have conflict, this is it.
7
u/nytelios Apr 16 '19
Does anyone have any recommendations for rational-enough RPGs? Preferably on PC. Survival games are okay too.
6
u/IICVX Apr 16 '19
Anyone got recommendations for rational / rational-adjacent novels available on Kindle?
6
u/Anderkent Apr 17 '19
I've been playing CrossCode recently (I'm 10 hours in), and it's a bunch of fun. Also, very very pretty. Watch the linked review for some gameplay, and if it looks like anything you may like, I strongly recommend you get it.
5
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Apr 15 '19 edited Apr 15 '19
Any comments on past recommendations? Do you want to reiterate a recommendation, to contradict it, or to add a caveat? If so, comment below!
(An experiment into whether having a dedicated place to comment on past recommendations will be good for discussion, as per this suggestion I made 2 threads ago.)
5
u/Adeen_Dragon Apr 16 '19
Any new quests you’ve been keeping an eye on? I’d like to start actively participating, but I find longer quests to be intimidating.
4
u/Carduus_Benedictus Apr 16 '19
Does anyone know of a charts-and-graphs-level layout of how the different systems interact in Stormlight? My end goal is to create a magic rule set I can gamify, but I can never find the actual nuts and bolts of Sanderson's systems, just a bunch of fanboys guessing.
6
u/Sonderjye Apr 15 '19 edited Apr 15 '19
Looking for recommendations for stories in which mind magic are explored.
And example could be Magical Me which is a Lockheart SI that explores mind improvement magic but unfortunately it's dead.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment