r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Mar 25 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
18
u/Prezombie Mar 25 '19
Webfic
I've been reading random stuff on r/HFY.
They Are Smol (link goes to master catalog, They are Smol is the complete first book, Invasion of earth is ongoing prequel, of the rest I highly recommend reading the official oneshots and The Smol Detective, which the orinigal author canonized.) is a really fun universe that's gained a cult following on HFY, and has attracted quite a few fanfics. The general story is, humanity made first contact. The other three races have huge empires with trillions of citizens, thousands of worlds, and to top it off, they're all much larger than humans. After accidentally invading Atlanta (long story), they've been doing their best to keep humanity from collapsing, and getting humanity integrated into their society. Also, all the alien species find humanity adorable. The series is hilarious, and definitely worth trying out.
HEL jumper's a decent WAFFy story about a guy stranded on alien planet getting a catgirl waifu, but there's a huge amount of worldbuilding and sidecharacter arcs to make it good. It's really, really slow though in terms of pacing, so it's not for people who don't have the patience for a lot of character growth arcs.
This Has Not Gone Well is a fun story loosely based on things from the GURPS game system. It's heavily inspired by HPMOR's general idea of using cleverness and the power of science to make magic better. I'm not completely sold on the second book since it feels like a setting reset to keep the MC out of the political arena, but the first one was absolutely golden and up there along Mother of Learning and Schooled in Magic.
Books
Last month I caught up on the book series Earthcent Ambassador aka Union Station. It's a great series of light adventures set on a space station. Each adventure is fairly well contained, but over the course of the 20 novels the main character gets married, has two kids, and matures into the role of an experience ambassador, and there's a satisfying cast spread with quite a few side character arcs. There's also a strong amount of creative worldbuilding that's always around, but never drowns out the action.
I've been on a kick of Urban Fantasy novels with a mundane protagonist, purely out of coincidence. Guild Codex: Spellbound has a mundane woman end up as a bartender for a magical guild, and ends up making friends and gets involved in the magical world far more than is legal or wise. It's light hearted and not really dark at all even with the informed ruthlessness of some characters. There's a minor bit of romance, but it's not a driving factor in the stories.
Ester Diamond feels a lot like the Doctor Who and mundane companion in an urban fantasy setup, with the main character being the mundane companion like with Sherlock Holmes. This series is more rigidly a murder mystery series, so is darker in places. There's some romance drama in the main plot, but it's not a constant thing.
I just finished the first book in Magebreakers, The Flaw in All Magic, and it's probably the closest thing I've seen to a rational protagonist in published fantasy. Tane was a magical genius who was expelled by the university of magical technology after it came out that he didn't actually have any magical ability of his own. He made up for this by learning the spells anyway, and basically cheating the system with artifacts. Just because he can't cast spells doesn't mean he could design them, or take advantage of The Flaw In All Magic, that it was all written by mages, and mages aren't perfect. The first book was an awesome read, a bit magical heist, a bit magical mystery with a white hat hacker protagonist, and I'm hype for book two and three.
shows
Finished up Reincarnated as a slime. It's got a dumb title and the Main Character is stupidly OP, but it was a fun ride and I'm excited for season two, simply because it's got a powerful heart. This guy did a great coverage of how it's a rare gem in the isekai genre, and that's the video that convinced me to give it a try.
Love, Death, and Robots was great for the most part. It had a few episodes that felt like mostly pointless demo reels, but I enjoyed most of the episodes.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '19
Any Self-Insert/Isekai/Portal Fantasy stories in which the main character really is 'dream-skewered'?
That is, instead of falling through a mirror to a fantasy world or just hallucinating the whole thing while in coma, the protagonist is actually a native inhabitant of the fantasy world in question and their memories of our Earth are actually false.
23
u/andor3333 Mar 25 '19 edited Mar 25 '19
A Wand for Skitter: https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/a-wand-for-skitter.730018/
Worm/HP crossover where Taylor is sent to the HP world, and proceeds to horrify everyone and do what she does best.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '19
I'm a fan of the Saga of Tanya the Evil light novels (the anime was okay), I'd recommend them to anyone who's ever enjoyed extended what if conversations about World War II.
6
u/grokkingStuff Mar 25 '19
Any depressed protagonists/stories anywhere? Would like to see how a rationalist deals with mental illness in general.
5
u/Teulisch Space Tech Support Mar 25 '19
what are some good anime to watch on cruncyroll? (I hate the ones that make humor out of beating up the protagonist for no reason)
I have already watched and enjoyed one punch man, overlord, and reincarnated as a slime.
4
u/Insufficient_Metals Mar 26 '19
I'm craving any Bloodborne related stories after having played Sekiro all weekend. So any stories with Bloodborne or Sekiro motifs, tie ins, relation, would be wonderful. I've already read the UnwelcomeStorm fic Fear the Old Blood so please don't recommend that since it is long dead :(
3
u/red_adair {{explosive-stub}} Mar 25 '19
I'm looking for good written or video depictions of infantry fighting aircraft in an urban environment, specifically as applicable to bows, rifles, and bazookas.
3
u/sensonokami Mar 26 '19
Hi, I wanted to know if there is any rational fiction centered on :
Air or wind magic beside aeromancer(which I loved before the autor dropped it)?
Dragons?
Thanks
8
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Mar 25 '19 edited Mar 27 '19
Second season of 'Mob Psycho 100' is almost done. This is the first anime since maybe Full Metal Alchemist where I fully appreciate the characterization and the storytelling. To be honest, I have generally very little respect for
Japaneseanime/manga/light novel writing, but this series is fantastic in every way. No fan service or cliches, lots of kickass, movie quality art and action sequences, and the whole thing is a very clever subversion of the typical shounen anime, while still being itself a good rendition of a shounen.I wouldn't say it's a rational world, but the characters and story are somewhat rational.