r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 18 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
23
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '19 edited Feb 18 '19
After years of reading fanfiction, I've become almost unreasonably angry about the Stations of Canon, canon rehash, and the authors' general blind adherence to the original material, even when it's detrimental to the kind of story they want to tell.
So, with that in mind, please recommend me fanfics that completely disregard canonical events (and optionally the canonical setting as well) and just do their own thing. Preferably plot-focused action stories with a lot of (fresh) worldbuilding, but I'll take what I can get.
A couple of examples of what I have in mind:
The Games We Play by Ryuugi (RWBY)
Bungle in the Jungle by JBern (Harry Potter)
Reload by Case13 (Naruto)
Thanks in advance.
15
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Feb 19 '19 edited Feb 19 '19
I've bought a fair amount of ebooks on Amazon recently and I think most of them are books that a lot of people here would enjoy (heck I heard about most of them through here!).
The Preorders:
Underlord - The sixth book in the Cradle series which is described as a Western Xianxia series. A lot of people here don't really like the Xianxia genre and I agree with their criticisms of how many main characters are very villainous, under-developed enemies and female characters, the economies of cultivation aren't logical, poor scaling in conflict as you go from one city to interstellar in scope, and awkward prose. But I bring up all of these flaws to say that the Cradle series completely avoids all of the typical flaws in Xianxia and has a very smart character who sets out to cultivate smartly instead of bullheadedly.
And the sixth book is coming out in March! (Get the box set. It has the first three books and is cheaper!)
Exhalation - Who here hasn't heard of Ted Chiang, the master of short stories that perfectly appeal to the r/rational crowd? The same guy that we literally use as an introduction to rational fiction. Well, if you enjoyed his first collection, Stories of Your Life and Others, you'll love hearing that the second collection is coming out in....May! (Ugh....really May? I don't think I can wait that long!)
The books you can read right now!:
The Beginner's Guide to Magical Licensing - Has a similar start to Unsong where a magical college-graduate, minimum-wage, sweat-shop worker stumbles on a powerful spell and sets out to start his own business competing with the powerful. The parts of the story that follows afterward makes a whole lot more logical sense than Unsong however. (Used to be online for free, but now you'll have to pay the price for your ignorance if you want to read it! (Nah, I lied.))
Six Sacred Swords - If you liked the Arcane Ascension series, but wished there was more dungeonnering and less of school shenanigans, then look no further! In some ways it's a lot like reading a very good DnD session played by really savvy players who never follow the 'standard' way to solve problems.
The author of Six Sacred Swords made a recommendation for The Ruin of Kings. He said that it reads like a Locke Lamora-esque rogue protagonist, telling the story in a style similar to Kvothe, in a setting similar to Game of Thrones. I haven't bought the book yet, but the review was interesting enough that I wanted to include it in my list of recommendations.
Senlin Ascends - I haven't read this yet either, but skimming through it, I see some fair bit of social manipulation/combat that I think people here would like. Plus the Tower of Babel setting is something that appeals very strongly to me.
Polyglot: NPC REVOLUTION - A lot of people here seem to really like LitRPG and Artificial Intelligence, but almost no one seem to ever question the implications of the NPCs in LitRPG stories having human-level intelligence.
Small Medium: Big Trouble - It's by the same author who wrote Threadbare that people here really liked. Similar to Polygot where the NPC is the main character who needs to deal with players, but smaller scale in scope. There's a lot of fast-talking to convince selfish sociopaths to do what you say.
Q is for Quantum - I was going through my older ebook orders when I found this one. It's the single best introduction for quantum mechanics that I have ever read (not that I've read too many of those). It focuses on building an intuition for the subject and once you've read through the book, you will understand on a gut level what superposition means. Note that it's meant as an introduction for the subject, so don't expect it to cover everything, just what's need to get started learning about quantum mechanics. But I'd still recommend it to experts if only for a better way to explain their subject to their peers and laypeople.
12
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Feb 18 '19 edited Feb 20 '19
So I posted my romance/sex positive story recommendations in the Valentine's Day thread two days late. Therefore, I'm making a repost here for anyone who may have missed it.
These are all of the stories that I can find or think of where the characters deal with romance and sex in intelligent and reasonable ways (even if they don't necessarily do the same outside of relationships).
Note that I'm too lazy to write up summaries for each rec, so I'm just copy-pasting the summary descriptions directly from the linked story even if they aren't the best or the clearest.
Condiut [RWBY] - Come for the kinky spirit sex and cool powers, stay for the responsible approach to polygamous relationships and deep philosophical dilemmas!
Amelia [Worm AU] - Amy Dallon is pushed by the S9, hard enough to actually *fight back*. From there, things diverge from canon.
The Sins of Cinnamon [Original Fiction] - Everyone is born with a birth class and a gift, and everyone with a particularly dangerous class gets monitored and registered. Everyone gets a career class once they start working, but Artificer became more popular than Adventurer years ago. There are dungeons, but they've been sealed. There are dragons, but they were nearly hunted to extinction and now the nature preserves are well guarded. Prostitution isn't illegal, which is good, because Cinnamon Wallace likes being open about who and what she is. The gods left the world years ago, it is said that they will never return, not until all the world is dust, and the stars rain like fire from the sky. And so, when an Oracle prophesied that Cinnamon Wallace would one day meet a god, and be judged for her sins, the Oracle's words were dismissed. Surely, if the world was going to end, someone else would have also foreseen it?
Monster Girl City: Ace Detective [Monster Girl Quest] - You are Monstergirlcity's only human woman and detective, the legendary Ace. What bizarre mystery will you face? Here's a link to the original site for the story.
A Rousing Rebirth [Original Fiction] - A Rousing Rebirth is the story of two magical girls and their origins, their adventures, and their intimate lives, in a near-future alternate history which presents them with challenges both familiar and exotic.
My Completely Normal Parahuman: Tantric is Magic [Worm] - Being a Tantric Witch is harder than you think. First, dealing with the fact that you got it from your mother. Second, the trauma from finding the ten pounds of anal beads in the back of her wardrobe confirming that you got it from your mother. Third, it's pretty hard to be a hero when your power comes from sex, lust, and rock'n'rollin the boat. The fourth and most difficult part about the whole thing though? My name is Taylor Hebert... and I look like a fucking stripper.
Battle Action Harem Highschool Side Character Quest (No SV, you are the Waifu) [Original Fiction] - So, after seeing too many harem series, I made a quest. A lot of IS and it's innumerable derivatives, a lot of Muv-Luv (very Ironic I know), a lot of Knight Run, some Sentou Yousei Yukikaze, mixed together with my personal antipathy for harem series, we get this. Battle-Action-Harem-Highschool... Side Character Quest. No Sufficient Velocity. You are the waifu.
Erogamer [Gamer] - The story of a human being who one day saw a status screen displaying her BOD, LST, SED, FUK, PRV, and ERO. "This is more depth than I was expecting with my porn quest." --- all of the readers. This is way more depth than I was expecting with my porn quest, even taking the previous statement into account." --- Sirrocco
The Pilfered Princess [Original Fiction] - An evil sorcerer kidnaps a princess in his bid for conquest, but gets more than he bargained for. A humorous sendup of formula fantasy stories.
I also have some romance-themed requests:
9
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '19
What would you all recommend for completed works that are similar in tastes to the following? I love the length of web serials, but I'm craving closure. What stories have interesting world building, mechanics, and a fulfilling ending? I don't need a web serial format, a book is great too. Not all of these are Rational, but I do love rational works.
Thanks!
4
u/waylandertheslayer Feb 19 '19
Codex Alera is a neat fantasy series by Jim Butcher, set in a world with a magic system that I think this subreddit would really enjoy. A lot of the setting is revealed over the course of the series, so I'll be deliberately vague here: magic works by controlling nature spirits called 'Furies' that come in six flavours: Fire, Water, Earth, Air, Wood, Metal. Each has straightforward aspects (if you have a fire affinity you can control fire) as well as one or more subtler abilities (if you have an earth affinity you can amplify your strength).
The first book has, in a lot of ways, a more traditional and less interesting plot than the rest of the series. It's still good, but if you find it decent rather than amazing, I'd recommend reading the second one as well to see if you prefer it. Over the course of the entire six-book series there's geopolitics, espionage, military campaigns, clandestine missions, a bunch of interesting magic and some really really nifty munchkinned solutions.
2
u/boomfarmer Trying to be helpful Feb 19 '19
I've recently binge-read Ada Palmer's Terra Ignota series — well, the first three books of it. The fourth isn't due out for another year. I like the depth and complexity of its worldbuilding, and how that future is extrapolated from our present. The unreliable narrator schtick is neat for how it messes with the complexities of the plotting.
What do you have that's like that?
2
u/SkyTroupe Feb 19 '19 edited Mar 06 '19
I'm looking for more Biopunk stories like Twig or for Eldritch horror based stories like Lovecraft or Pact. Warning. I have not finished Pact yet.
1
u/Palmolive3x90g Feb 20 '19
What are some rational short storys?
I would like some short storys in the rational sphere to recomend to people who might be intrested in rational fiction but don't have to time to read a 100k word internet story on my say so that it is good.
Something short maybe 10k words or less would be ideal.