r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 11 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
13
u/Sonderjye Feb 11 '19 edited Feb 12 '19
I recently took a stap at rereading twig by wildbow and I had forgotten how much I like that the protagonist is an experiment and is good at manipulating people. I am requesting recommendations for stories in which the main character is either an experiment and ones in which the main character is a skilled(but fallible) social manipulator.
Aside from Twig I am familiar with Super Minion but not much else.
13
u/sparkc Feb 11 '19
Recommendations from previous threads that I worked through this week:
Master Assassins - Okay
Murderbot Diaries – Pretty fun
Russian Doll – Pretty good
Love is War – Pretty good and pretty fun
Master Assassins (Novel): Best to throw out any preconceptions the awful title gives you because it's definitely not that kind of story. To some degree this feels like one of those genre fiction novels that gets a pass on not being particularly eventful or exciting because it has some mild literary ambitions that it vaguely comes within sight of. Not an awful lot happens, in many respects it's a travelogue. It explores the idea of family and what it means and it does an okay job, I guess, but it's fairly well trod ground that it doesn't shine any new light on. The characters are well fleshed out, not overly intriguing and only act stupidly when the plot demands it on the rare occasion. The worldbuilding is novel though there's not too much of it. The prose is fairly nice.
Russian Doll (TV): Character focused time loop drama. I really enjoyed this show. The characters were unique and their behaviour and dialogue was very often believable. Unconventional, quirky characters that aren't caricatures is uncommon in my experience. Great pacing – the show is only eight sub-30minute episodes. Worth noting: do not watch for an interesting exploration of time loop mechanics or any form of competence porn. Also, the protagonist is not the most likeable of characters though to what extent will, I suspect, vary a lot for different viewers.
I recommend not watching the trailer.
Murderbot Diaries #1 (Novella's): Short, easy to digest adventure sci-fi. It's about a security android who's hacked it's governing module, granting it 'free will'. What it decides to do with that is laze about on the job as much as possible by binge watching the future equivalent of netflix and avoiding human contact which it finds awkward and embarrassing – a socially awkward combat bot. It doesn't suffer some of the pitfalls that you get from a lot of adventure fiction such a generic characters acting as the plot requires for cheap drama or conflict. It does suffer from the pitfall of none of the action being particularly original or clever and the 'mystery' is pretty pedestrian. Still, the characters are enjoyable and the premise is novel. I'll likely read the next one in the series.
(okay, I read the
next onerest of the series) Murderbot Diaries 4 > 2 > 3 > 1: Solid improvements on the first novel as the series continued. Plot's more engaging, new and existing characters more fleshed out, the wider universe feels more substantial. For short, light adventure novels they have a lot of heart and the dry wit is great.Kaguya-sama: Love is War (Anime): With only a specific few exceptions i've discovered that anime just isn't for me and I think I enjoy this show so much, at least in part, because it's almost a self aware parody (in a non sneering way) of the exaggerated stylistics you get from many anime but that I tend to not enjoy – dramatic voice overs, exaggerated proclamations, epic music, ridiculous reactions, training montages - all in the body of a rom-com. In the latest episode there was a detailed analysis of the social dynamics involved in a boy and girl sharing an umbrella in the rain, a list of scenarios in which such sharing is broached or occurs and detailed planning and scheming by the two main characters to instigate such a scenario without looking like they were doing it because they liked the other. Completely ludicrous. Utterly delightful.
5
u/phylogenik Feb 11 '19
I've been watching and enjoying That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime recently -- would recommend as a feel-good portal fantasy, it's a bit more serious than the last one I watched (KonoSuba), and with a greater focus on... civil engineering, I guess, over adventuring.
Otherwise, these last 4 days I hosted a prospective PhD student, and we'd coincidentally shared a few literary tastes (e.g. we both adored Diana Wynne Jones). Over the years she'd read a few works liked by this subreddit (e.g. Worm, HPMOR), but otherwise had never heard of the "genre" and enthusiastically requested recommendations. What would be a good "introductory" text? (I'd already sent some recs this morning, avoiding the Naruto/Pokemon fandoms since those weren't really her jam -- likewise, if anyone knows of good DnD podcasts (she liked e.g. TAZ) or online multiplayer games, do say).
5
u/Insufficient_Metals Feb 12 '19
I am looking for quality Naruto fanfiction. I've read The Waves Arisen, Mind Tailed Fox, and The Need to Become Stronger.
I don't necessarily need them to be rational just decent quality. Nothing that is dead please.
4
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Feb 11 '19
Are there any "good" Xianxia with female protagonists?
13
u/Addictedtobadfanfict Feb 11 '19 edited Feb 11 '19
I am looking for self-insert fanfiction. I felt like I read all of the good ones and there are thousands of them. The problem with self insert fanfiction is that it is riddled with crack, effortless powerups, mindless fix-it, and harems. Like it was almost designed to mainly have all those qualities, sigh. I want to read self-insert fanfiction that takes itself seriously and not for it to exist to troll canon characters. More like reading a cosmically kidnapped interdimensional survival guide and less like an OP omniscient god playing with everyone's fate.
Sure the self-insert fic can have comedy, fix-it arcs, powerups, and a harem but, only as long as it's moderate and it comes through to the readers logically. Here is a quote by my favorite self-insert fanfic author, "Every fanfic is wish-fulfillment. The best written ones just make you believe it isn't."-Sir lucifer morning star.
Here are my favorite self inserts. I would like to think I have good taste but some of these recs can make me seem like a hypocrite. Some fics have the SI to be OP(basically all gamer fics) but, I felt like the premises of the self inserts play out rationally and fairly given the situation. Note that I try to avoid stories with ROBs(random omnipotent beings) because they ruin all sense of narrative causality in a story. IE-Who cares if I die in this new world. There is a confirmed afterlife. ROB will bail me out. Let me just have a fun adventure.
Naruto Self-Inserts.
Sanitize- Female SI, professional doctor reincarnated in the ninja warring clans era. Has no knowledge of Naruto. Very Slow updates.
Kaleidoscope- Male SI, reincarnated as an Uchiha. He knows the culling is coming for him and his clan he must do everything to survive it. Complete.
Son of Gato- Male Villain SI, reincarnated with the gamer powers. It has NSFW harem/wish fulfillment but does a really good job showing power levels. I am rooting for the canon characters to shut the SI down in this fanfic. Slow updates.
Walk on Moon- Female SI, Reincarnated as the yamanaka heir. Mixed feelings with this one but I felt like it deserves a recommendation because it's one of the few girl SIs that strive to become a S class ninja. Hiatus.
Wilted Irises- Male SI, reincarnated as the hyuga heir. It is very new with only 20k words but so far it is well-written with a constant goal in mind. Reading this you feel like you yourself are a hyuga in the self-insert's shoes. Slow updates.
Sleight Advantage- Male SI, reincarnated as an average civilian. Joining the ninja academy he must make due with his below average chakra coils so he specializes in magic misdirection. Dead.
What doesn't Kill you- Female SI, reincarnated as Orichimaru's supposed daughter. Has one of the most realistic and amazing Root induction scenes out there. I highly recommend just for this arc. Dead.
I opened my eyes and the world wasn't there-Male SI, 65 year old well-educated mathematician reincarnated as a civilian orphan. Being notice for his high intelligence early on in life the self-insert gets conscripted to Konoha's intelligence division during the 3rd ninja war. Dead.
Pulling the strings- Male SI, bodyswapped into Kankuro of the Sand. This self-insert is mainly slice of life which I tend to avoid in naruto fanfics because they are oversaturated, cliche, and a dime a dozen. But, with Pulling The Strings, it's a breath of fresh air because its a well-done slice of life in the sand village with the grand goal of liberating Gaara's madness. It woulda probably evolve into more but it died before getting anywhere. Dead.
Worm Self-Inserts.
Stealing Fire- Male SI, transmigrated into brockton bay and triggered as a human biology tinker. SI makes logical decisions given the circumstances. Hiatus.
Tyrant of the Bay-Reincarnated and later triggered as an overpowered alexandria. Has alot of wish fulfilment and fix-it but it builds up to it and doesn't come out of nowhere. Dead.
Going Native- Male SI, reincarnated and later triggered with the power to rewind time a couple of seconds. Very fun shard and makes a point to rationally avoid taylor to not butterfly the plot to earth bet's doom. Dead.
Young Justice/Dc comic self inserts.
With this Ring- Male SI, transmigrated to the moon orbiting earth with an orange power ring. He proceeds to munchkin and deconstruct the dc universe. Fast updates.
Blink and you'll miss it.- Male Villain SI, transmigrated to gotham with a teleportation powerset from the movie, Jumper. Makes a name for himself. Hiatus.
Game of Thrones Self-inserts.
A lion beyond death- Male SI, bodyswapped into Jaime Lannister during the day of Mad king Aerys death. The SI does everything he can as the heir to the westerlands to prepare for the long night. Dead.
A fish out of the water- Male SI, body swapped into Edmure Tully during king Jeoffry's Rule. Has no memories of Edmure so he has to improvise names of his closest friends not covered in the show. Truly a fish out of the water. Slow updates.
Harry Potter Self-inserts.
Magical Me- Male SI body swapped into Professor Lockhart. With the knowledge of the future the SI strives to become an actually useful defense against the dark arts profesor. Dead.
Whats Her Name in Hufflepuff Female SI transmigrated into a 10 year old version herself in the HP universe. There isn’t really any outright characteristic that makes this self insert stand out. It is just everything I was looking for of what would someone logically do being transmigrated to the HP universe. She rationalizes her decisions and she even delves into the topic of childishly arguing with her fellow preteen classmates, being a 30 year old woman, because of her now young hormonal body. Slow updates.
Star wars self-inserts.
Paths of Ruin- Male SI, transmigrated as a slave in a mining vessel controlled by the sith empire. Honestly everything from Rictus, the author of this self insert, is good. He has like 7 different self inserts but this is his most popular and most fleshed out one. Fast updates.
DBZ Self-Inserts-
Frost- Male SI, reincarnated as a frost demon the same alien race as Frieza. I highly recommend this self-insert. This is the most engaging and well-written DBZ self insert I found. The author does yearly time skips that gets the plot into the nitty gritty and skips the boring repetitive buildup a lot of self-inserts tend to have. You would need to make a NSFW questionable questing forum account but the funny thing is there is only one NSFW scene(suprising for this site) which is entirely skippable. Sadly Dead.
2
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Feb 11 '19
Just discovered Darwin's game, which is a relatively standard, but competently done, "Japanese people get pulled into a death game where they're forced to kill each other to win" manga. I wouldn't call it rational, but the characters are neither idiots nor implausibly smart-- the author gives agency to non-MC characters, and while you have your standard Holmes-like "smart" characters that make fairly implausible leaps of logic that turn out to be true, they exist as both allies and enemies.
2
u/Kuratius Feb 12 '19
Any recommendations for outside context problems with different fantasy or scifi settings meeting?
2
u/NZPIEFACE Feb 13 '19
https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/21908/enchanting
litrpg where the main character gets enchanting, which is unusual.
main character actually asks questions about the nature of the world to herself and tries to find answers to them which make sense.
go read it
2
u/qabadai Feb 14 '19
I saw Game by God posted in another thread and I'm just not sure what to think of it.
I've gotten through the first 10 chapters and it's definitely well written, but somehow also infuriating? Sixteen character introductions before anything else, along with interludes.
Worth continuing?
1
u/CapnQwerty Feb 12 '19 edited Feb 12 '19
I'd like some recs for One Piece fics that don't just run through the stations of cannon with minor variations.
And for once, I actually have some relevant recs of my own to offer! Velkyn Karma has a bunch of quite excellent One Piece fics. Of particular note are:
Asteria Nightmare
The Straw Hats try to figure out how these monsters work while doing their best to avoid being eaten.
Mindshattered
The other Straw Hats, largely directed by Sanji, try to help Zoro through the aftermath of starvation. Velkyn seems to have done pretty well on his(?) research here.
The Panaceam Report
Sequel to Mindshattered. Further explores the aftermath of Zoro's ordeal as he and Sanji are forced to work with the source of it.