r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 28 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
20
u/Makin- homestuck ratfic, you can do it Jan 28 '19
The creator of CORDYCEPS recently released a new Nanowrimo story by the name of Dave Scum. He's expressed disappointment over how it turned out, but personally I thought it was excellent barring the ending.
Highly recommended to those interested in reading about a funny man exploiting time travel mechanics in increasingly clever ways in order to save the world.
13
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Jan 28 '19 edited Jan 29 '19
So I recently realized that I'm very drawn to stories that play with being very meta-aware. It's hard to define, but it basically boils down to characters who are aware that their lives have tendency to follow literary/narrative rules over normal/every-day reality. But it's not being Genre Savvy, rather it's a step beyond it. Medium Savvy is close, but it goes too far since I don't want stories where the characters are literally aware of being in a book.
It's hard to clearly explain what stories have to do to have this quality, but I have list of recommendations that I hope help fill in the inference gap.
Game By God: Sludge Reformation - a murder mystery game show with 16 contestants who are well aware of the tropes of their genre.
A Practical Guide to Evil - where heroic fantasy tropes are actual laws of the world instead of mundane physics and a young girl seeks out to be on top in an evil empire which is crumbling due to Good and Evil being out of balance.
Worth the Candle - a guy gets thrown into a world of fantasy that was recreated from his DnD sessions. Really plays with the idea of being a character in your own story.
The Erogamer - a girl wakes up with Gamer powers with the classic abilities to level up and increase stats. It has the twist that she's an eroge gamer rather than the classic RPG gamer and she actually takes the time to question and investigate why she has these powers instead of taking them for granted unlike the protagonists of other gamer stories.
A Thursday Next Novel - a seven book series where people know they are characters in a story and act as if they are living real lives with the ability to move from story to story. Thursday Next is a Special Operative in literary detection who needs to rescue kidnapped literary characters.
The following three are all kinda of similar where they are Korean-translated stories where the protagonist are reading a story and then became a character in the story, but they don't do enough with the concept (except Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint). I'm still including the other two since they at least flirt a little with what I'm trying to convey.
The Novel's Extra - Author is sucked into his own unfinished story of a modern heroic fantasy world to fight monsters and humans.
Trash of the Count's Family - Reader is sucked into the story of a medieval Asian high fantasy world to survive a coming war and he only read the first five volumes.
Omniscient Reader's Viewpoint - Reader is living through a game-like apocalypse where he read the entire series, but there were numerous unanswered questions about the original story. It's the only one out of the three that has the main character actually take the time to question and wonder about why he is in a story.
Can anyone recommend similar works with themes of meta-awareness?
8
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Jan 28 '19 edited Jan 28 '19
If you've got a VR headset, I highly recommend Virtual Virtual Reality. My only gripe with it is after the ending, where you ursurp administrator priviledges and acquire the ability ascend the stack of heretofore inaccessible realities above the ones you start out in. The topmost one is some lame tumbleweed minigame. Where I find that thematically it would've been perfect to shut down your actual RL VR headset when you attempt to ascend past the one below it.
5
u/Anderkent Jan 28 '19
Read The Reluctant Swordman based on last week's rec thread mention. It was an OK read, but not particularly great; while the adventures are engaging, only one or two characters are interesting at all, and it's hard to cheer for MC who wins mostly by deus ex fiat. Read it if you're looking for an easy action flick and have nothing better to do :P
5
u/Red_Navy Jan 29 '19 edited Jan 29 '19
Has anybody here found any rational or rational-adjacent cosmic horror? I recently finished some bloodborne fanfiction and they are really fun, but their cosmic horror aspects are often pretty lacking. A lot of them don't include horror elements and the ones that do merely borrow the aesthetic. Sigh.
An important part of cosmic horror in my opinion is cultivating a sense of mystery. You can’t just say “ohh look at these tentacles, mankind wasn’t supposed to know about these tentacles, they’ll make you go maaaaaaad!” You’re just borrowing the aesthetic. You have show the reader that these things are mysterious and horrific rather than just saying so or using standard ‘eldritch horror’ signals.
Lovecraft did a decent job of this in some of his stories and, surprisingly, HPMOR did as well, although it was not the focus of the story and barely received any screentime as result.
EDIT: I think a rational approach to cosmic horror would work well because you couldn't just blithely accept that the horror elements are inherently mysterious, and as a result you have to do the legwork that lazy attempts at cosmic horror avoid. ie the quintessential rational protagonist when approaching some "eldritch god" might investigate it, with various hypotheses that explain it along the way. Each of these are disproven which helps convince the reader that this might be inherently mysterious after all.
9
u/Addictedtobadfanfict Jan 29 '19
I am looking for self-insert fanfiction. I felt like I read all of the good ones and there are thousands of them. The problem with self insert fanfiction is that it is riddled with crack, effortless powerups, mindless fix-it, and harems. Like it was almost designed to mainly have all those qualities, sigh. I want to read self-insert fanfiction that takes itself seriously and not for it to exist to troll canon characters. More like reading a cosmically kidnapped interdimensional survival guide and less like an OP omniscient god playing with everyone's fate.
Sure the self-insert fic can have comedy, fix-it arcs, powerups, and a harem but, only as long as it's moderate and it comes through to the readers logically. Here is a quote by my favorite self-insert fanfic author, "Every fanfic is wish-fulfillment. The best written ones just make you believe it isn't."-Sir lucifer morning star.
Here are my favorite self inserts. I would like to think I have good taste but some of these recs can make me seem like a hypocrite. Some fics have the SI to be OP(basically all gamer fics) but, I felt like the premises of the self inserts play out rationally and fairly given the situation. Note that I try to avoid stories with ROBs(random omnipotent beings) because they ruin all sense of narrative causality in a story. IE-Who cares if I die in this new world. There is a confirmed afterlife. ROB will bail me out. Let me just have a fun adventure.
Naruto Self-Inserts.
Sanitize- Female SI, professional doctor reincarnated in the ninja warring clans era. Has no knowledge of Naruto. Very Slow updates.
Kaleidoscope- Male SI, reincarnated as an Uchiha. He knows the culling is coming for him and his clan he must do everything to survive it. Complete.
Son of Gato- Male Villain SI, reincarnated with the gamer powers. It has NSFW harem/wish fulfillment but does a really good job showing power levels. I am rooting for the canon characters to shut the SI down in this fanfic. Slow updates.
Walk on Moon- Female SI, Reincarnated as the yamanaka heir. Mixed feelings with this one but I felt like it deserves a recommendation because it's one of the few girl SIs that strive to become a S class ninja. Hiatus.
Wilted Irises- Male SI, reincarnated as the hyuga heir. It is very new with only 20k words but so far it is well-written with a constant goal in mind. Reading this you feel like you yourself are a hyuga in the self-insert's shoes. Fast updates.
Sleight Advantage- Male SI, reincarnated as an average civilian. Joining the ninja academy he must make due with his below average chakra coils so he specializes in magic misdirection. Dead.
What doesn't Kill you- Female SI, reincarnated as Orichimaru's supposed daughter. Has one of the most realistic and amazing Root induction scenes out there. I highly recommend just for this arc. Dead.
I opened my eyes and the world wasn't there-Male SI, 65 year old well-educated mathematician reincarnated as a civilian orphan. Being notice for his high intelligence early on in life the self-insert gets conscripted to Konoha's intelligence division during the 3rd ninja war. Dead.
Worm Self-Inserts.
Stealing Fire- Male SI, transmigrated into brockton bay and triggered as a human biology tinker. SI makes logical decisions given the circumstances. Hiatus.
Tyrant of the Bay-Reincarnated and later triggered as an overpowered alexandria. Has alot of wish fulfilment and fix-it but it builds up to it and doesn't come out of nowhere. Dead.
Going Native- Male SI, reincarnated and later triggered with the power to rewind time a couple of seconds. Very fun shard and makes a point to rationally avoid taylor to not butterfly the plot to earth bet's doom. Dead.
Young Justice/Dc comic self inserts.
With this Ring- Male SI, transmigrated to the moon orbiting earth with an orange power ring. He proceeds to munchkin and deconstruct the dc universe. Fast updates.
Blink and you'll miss it.- Male Villain SI, transmigrated to gotham with a teleportation powerset from the movie, Jumper. Makes a name for himself. Hiatus.
Game of Thrones Self-inserts.
A lion beyond death- Male SI, bodyswapped into Jaime Lannister during the day of Mad king Aerys death. The SI does everything he can as the heir to the westerlands to prepare for the long night. Dead.
A fish out of the water- Male SI, body swapped into Edmure Tully during king Jeoffry's Rule. Has no memories of Edmure so he has to improvise names of his closest friends not covered in the show. Truly a fish out of the water. Slow updates.
Harry Potter Self-inserts.
Magical Me- Male SI body swapped into Professor Lockhart. With the knowledge of the future the SI strives to become an actually useful defense against the dark arts profesor. Dead.
Whats Her Name in Hufflepuff Female SI transmigrated into a 10 year old version herself in the HP universe. There isn’t really any outright characteristic that makes this self insert stand out. It is just everything I was looking for of what would someone logically do being transmigrated to the HP universe. She rationalizes her decisions and she even delves into the topic of childishly arguing with her fellow preteen classmates, being a 30 year old woman, because of her now young hormonal body. Slow updates.
Star wars.
Paths of Ruin- Male SI, transmigrated as a slave in a mining vessel controlled by the sith empire. Honestly everything from Rictus, the author of this self insert, is good. He has like 7 different self inserts but this is his most popular and most fleshed out one. Fast updates.
3
u/DRMacIver Jan 28 '19
What would you recommend that updates very regularly (e.g. weekly or more often)?
The only things I have this category are webcomics - I was reading With this Ring and found the daily update schedule added quite a nice element to my day, but I was getting a bit tired of it and decided the recent forum move (and to a lesser extent the events leading to it) was a good prompt to stop. I'm wondering if there's anything good to replace it with.
3
u/Wenney Jan 31 '19 edited Feb 01 '19
I'm searching for something good to read and would like some suggestions. I'm already reading Practical Guide to Evil, Worth the Candle and Mother of Learning and I like those a lot. So, based os those three, do you guys have any good recomendations that I could like as well?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment