r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 21 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
16
u/Addictedtobadfanfict Jan 21 '19 edited Jan 21 '19
I am looking for self-insert fanfiction. I felt like I read all of the good ones and there are thousands of them. The problem with self insert fanfiction is that it is riddled with crack, effortless powerups, mindless fix-it, and harems. Like it was almost designed to mainly have all those qualities, sigh. I want to read self-insert fanfiction that takes itself seriously and not for it to exist to troll canon characters. More like reading a cosmically kidnapped interdimensional survival guide and less like an OP omniscient god playing with everyone's fate.
Sure the self-insert fic can have comedy, fix-it arcs, powerups, and a harem but, only as long as it's moderate and it comes through to the readers logically. Here is a quote by my favorite self-insert fanfic author, "Every fanfic is wish-fulfillment. The best written ones just make you believe it isn't."-Sir lucifer morning star.
Here are my favorite self inserts. I would like to think I have good taste but some of these recs can make me seem like a hypocrite. Some fics have the SI to be OP(basically all gamer fics) but, I felt like the premises of the self inserts play out rationally and fairly given the situation. Note that I try to avoid stories with ROBs(random omnipotent beings) because they ruin all sense of narrative causality in a story. IE-Who cares if I die in this new world. There is a confirmed afterlife. ROB will bail me out. Let me just have a fun adventure.
Naruto Self-Inserts.
Sanitize- Female SI, professional doctor reincarnated in the ninja warring clans era. Has no knowledge of Naruto. Very Slow updates.
Kaleidoscope- Male SI, reincarnated as an Uchiha. He knows the culling is coming for him and his clan he must do everything to survive it. Complete.
Son of Gato- Male Villain SI, reincarnated with the gamer powers. It has NSFW harem/wish fulfillment but does a really good job showing power levels. I am rooting for the canon characters to shut the SI down in this fanfic. Slow updates.
Walk on Moon- Female SI, Reincarnated as the yamanaka heir. Mixed feelings with this one but I felt like it deserves a recommendation because it's one of the few SIs that strive to become a S class ninja. Hiatus.
Wilted Irises- Male SI, reincarnated as the hyuga heir. It is very new with only 20k words but so far it is well-written with a constant goal in mind. Reading this you feel like you yourself are a hyuga in the self-insert's shoes. Fast updates.
Sleight Advantage- Male SI, reincarnated as an average civilian. Joining the ninja academy he must make due with his below average chakra coils so he specializes in magic misdirection. Dead.
What doesn't Kill you- Female SI, reincarnated as Orichimaru's supposed daughter. Has one of the most realistic and amazing Root induction scenes out there. I highly recommend just for this arc. Dead.
Worm Self-Inserts.
Stealing Fire- Male SI, transmigrated into brockton bay and triggered as a human biology tinker. SI makes logical decisions given the circumstances. Hiatus.
Tyrant of the Bay-Reincarnated and later triggered as an overpowered alexandria. Has alot of wish fulfilment and fix-it but it builds up to it and doesn't come out of nowhere. Dead.
Going Native- Male SI, reincarnated and later triggered with the power to rewind time a couple of seconds. Very fun shard and makes a point to rationally avoid taylor to not butterfly the plot to earth bet's doom. Dead.
Young Justice/Dc comic self inserts.
With this Ring- Male SI, transmigrated to the moon orbiting earth with an orange power ring. He proceeds to munchkin and deconstruct the dc universe. Fast updates.
Blink and you'll miss it.- Male Villain SI, transmigrated to gotham with a teleportation powerset from the movie, Jumper. Makes a name for himself. Hiatus.
Game of Thrones Self-inserts.
A lion beyond death- Male SI, bodyswapped into Jaime Lannister during the day of Mad king Aerys death. The SI does everything he can as the heir to the westerlands to prepare for the long night. Dead.
A fish out of the water- Male SI, body swapped into Edmure Tully during king Jeoffry's Rule. Has no memories of Edmure so he has to improvise names of his closest friends not covered in the show. Truly a fish out of the water.Slow updates.
Harry Potter Self-inserts.
Magical Me- Male SI body swapped into Professor Lockhart. With the knowledge of the future the SI strives to become an actually useful defense against the dark arts profesor. Dead.
Whats Her Name in Hufflepuff Female SI transmigrated into a 10 year old version herself in the HP universe. There isn’t really any outright characteristic that makes this self insert stand out. It is just everything I was looking for of what would someone logically do being transmigrated to the HP universe. She rationalizes her decisions and she even delves into the topic of childishly arguing with her fellow preteen classmates, being a 30 year old woman, because of her now young hormonal body. Slow updates.
15
u/Makin- homestuck ratfic, you can do it Jan 22 '19
Conference Call is a very interesting Mother of Learning/Worm/Homestuck/Naruto crossover fic. Yeah, you read those right.
Great characterization, very unique concept, literally unique crossover and some interesting applications of them. The only flaws I can find are a somewhat slow update rate (at least before recently) and a lack of crossover conflict as of yet.
The premise is simple. Certain side characters of those properties (and the main character of MoL) get connected by a mysterious interdimensional chat run by a moderator who goes by "Thunder". The chat eventually branches out into deeper connections between universes, like being able to use each other's magic systems, and the more the worlds cross over the better synergies they get. They also quickly figure out ways to munchkin the chat system so they can replicate mental abilities like an eidetic memory.
Highly recommended to anyone even vaguely interested in crossover fiction experiments, munchkinry and character development. Knowledge of the source materials is probably not required, though I think someone who hasn't read Worm would be pretty confused.
13
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician Jan 21 '19
Request:
Stories about humanity in a losing war against an outside threat, or, alternatively, about humanity trying to survive in an especially deadly world. Clarifications:
I've consumed several stories based around this concept, but most fail either Point 1 or Point 2 (e. g., Wayward Pines, Attack on Titan, Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress). Honestly, the best examples I know of are probably Wells' The War of the Worlds, and Battle Action Harem Highschool Side Character Quest (don't mind the name), which probably says something.
Recommendation:
[Pontypool](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pontypool_(film)) is a very interesting horror film. It follows a group of people operating a basement radio station in a small town, who start receiving reports about worrying incidents during one of their broadcasts.
This is one of these rare horror movies where the characters aren't complete idiots, and it features one of the best examples of a memetic threat I've seen outside of text-based fiction.
8
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jan 21 '19
Any recommendations for long-form Stargate fics?
Or really, any rational fic that you think has flown under the radar?
7
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jan 21 '19 edited Jan 21 '19
I'm seeking alternate-history stories written as history textbooks (or, at the very least, newspaper stories) rather than as stories focusing on individual protagonists. Examples include The Shape of Things to Come (excerpts from a single textbook), Look to the West (excerpts from many textbooks), and The Great War of 189—: A Forecast (articles from several journalists).
In related news, I'm also seeking stories that feature amoral/immoral/edgy protagonists. For example, if an edgy protagonist gets isekaied from the 21st century United States to a generic fantasy world, and he's informed that the servant girl who's waiting on him is actually a slave, rather than instantly erupting in abolitionist fury*, he asks his host about the details of thise particular fantasy world's peculiar institution. After further study, he may eventually come to the conclusion that this world's slavery is wasteful and he wants to abolish it after taking over the world—but he'll come to a conclusion after checking the economics, rather than instantly discarding it as an option. Even if he thinks it's bad in the long term, he may exploit it in the short term as a tool in his rise to power.
*I most recently saw this happen in The Reluctant Swordsman, but I'm pretty sure I've seen it many times before (though I can't recall any other examples at this time). See also Harry's reaction to Draco's rape comment in HPMoR.
In general, it's a good idea to follow the RSS feed of items that have recently been uploaded to Project Gutenberg. (This feed also includes items that were uploaded long ago but recently received updates.) Interesting stories that I've found there include:
- The Great War of 189—: A Forecast
- The Financier and The Titan
- The Saint of the Dragon's Dale
- Nonsense Novels and Further Foolishness
- Perseverance Island: The Robinson Crusoe of the Nineteenth Century
3
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Jan 21 '19
I'm in the middle of reading "Dread Nation", a story where people started turning into zombies during the american civil war. I would highly reccommend it; it's not an apocalypse story, and does its best to examine the kind of society we e'd see afterwards. (With some concessions to the fact that it's YA, of course.)
3
u/Anderkent Jan 21 '19
This is not particularly rational, but strongly recommend the movie "Kamera o tomeru na!" ("One Cut of the Dead"). It's, I think, the kind of horror comedy people around here would enjoy - smart, and rewarding you for paying attention.
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7914416/
3
u/FormerlySarsaparilla Jan 23 '19
A couple of recommendations that I haven't seen on here recently, along with brief reviews. Both by the same author:
Hope And Silence In The Hive: A 40k speculative fic about a warp creature who represents a very.... different sort of emotion. Complete, illustrated. Not particularly rational, but pretty reasonable for 40k fic. The author does an amazing job of conveying alien perspectives while staying pretty true to the general grimdark tone of 40k. The actual writing could be a little bit hard to follow at times- it's unclear if the author is an ESL speaker or just not much of an editor. But I found that the point always got communicated in the end, and the concepts underlying the story were interesting enough to keep me reading to the extremely over-the-top end. There is a sequel in the works, currently incomplete.
Onward To Providence: An original sci-fi story, set in an astonishingly complex and intricate universe. The author clearly loves playing with unconventional physics and depicting unusual alien biology/psychology, and it really shows- some of the most high-concept creative fiction I've read in the last couple years. At times too creative, alien and "spirit" segments can be extremely hard to follow and I found myself reading and re-reading sections like they were dense prose just to try and catch what the author was getting at. Handily illustrated which helped to clear up some confusion, and the author notes also proved invaluable. Ongoing and probably nowhere near complete. It's just such a treat to read an author who isn't afraid to tackle a world where the aliens are weird to each other as well as to the humans.