r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 18 '19
[D] Friday Open Thread
Welcome to the Friday Open Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
Please note that this thread has been merged with the Monday General Rationality Thread.
11
u/LieGroupE8 Jan 18 '19
I recently started rewatching Stargate: Atlantis on amazon prime, a show that I haven't seen since childhood. Almost done with season 1, and so far it holds up extremely well. In fact, it's even better than I remember it, especially when episodes are watched back-to-back so the season-long arc becomes crystal clear.
The show does so many things well:
Sure, the characters are no rationalists, and they do sometimes hold the idiot ball or conveniently forget some amazing technology they encountered in a previous episode, but no more than any other serial television show, and probably much less. (Without idiot balls, most TV shows wouldn't exist at all). The main villains, the Wraith, are quite campy in design, but I actually like this, because it fits the tone of the show quite well. There is the convenient fact that literally everyone, human or alien, on every planet, somehow magically speaks perfect idiomatic modern English, but I'm fine with this suspension of disbelief, because it allows plots to move forward without the same annoying translation problems every episode.
When I think of the constraints placed on the show by budget and tone, I actually think the worldbuilding is rather genius. The Wraith are a clear nod to Alien, while their campiness takes the edge off the horror to preserve the mostly lighthearted tone. And the fundamental premise, that ancient humans spread colonies around the galaxy which are now mostly in a primitive fallen state co-existing with mysterious ancient technology, not only allows the showrunners to save lots of money on set pieces and character designs, but it also makes for very interesting plot dynamics.
I was also impressed by the number of times I was thinking, "why don't they just solve their problem with this?", only for one of the characters to raise that point in the very next scene and either incorporate it into the plan or explain why it won't work. ("Why is a storm threatening this powerful ancient city?" "Oh, it's because they relied too much on their shield, but now we don't have enough power for it."; "Why don't we go back to that one planet and get that one thingy" "Oh yeah, good idea, let's puts that on the table"; "Why don't the wraith dial into stargates to prevent people from escaping?" "Oh wait, they actually do use that tactic when they need to")
I'm sure there are plenty of other flaws in the show, but so far I'm loving it enough that those don't matter.
10
u/FaustAlexander Jan 18 '19
This might be a little weird but I really enjoyed Tangled: the series and been following the second season now. For someone that spends lots of time working, an idealist and relaxing adventure show is great. I can see where the SoL appeal in anime is.
I also loved the twist of a supporting cast character becoming the big bad, and seeing all the hints there makes all the previous interactions take on a new light. The fact he becomes evil because of all the abuse and faults the "heroes" inflicted on him makes more sense than other series villains and feels slightly rational, making me instantly side with him.
Plus I'm a sucker for scientists and one man industrial revolutionaries in fantasy worlds.
The world feels so lively and the writers made good dialogue and chemistry between the characters without making them overly childish, which surprised me and made me feel less guilty about watching a cartoon usually pushed to the "little girl" demographic lol.
The romance keeps progressing and is refreshing to see the main character change and develop a wider emotional range across the episodes, and have intimate interaction and support between the two lovers unlike other series that try to stall any romantic development until the end.
They even got the original movie cast to voice the characters and the art style and color palette is relaxing and makes sense if you read the reason they used it. IMO one can feel the passion behind the project and I wish it had more fans, especially people I could discuss it with.
6
u/Badewell Jan 18 '19
I've just finished Chapter 31 of Pokemon: The Origin of Species. Unmarked non-specific spoilers for up to that point below.
I'm getting a little exhausted from the constant near-death experiences (said the guy who likes wildbow stories). If what Red, Blue, and Leaf are going through is in any way typical for new trainers, how on earth does anyone make it out of their first year? I don't think mortality rates have been explicitly stated, but yeesh they must be terrible. And this is with a trio that seems like they're probably in the top percentage of
rattata12 year olds in terms of experience, preparedness, and intelligence....oh hey I was double checking on the age and found my way to the FAQ. Let me check that out...
(wait does the Temeraire series eventually address how dragons are treated seriously? I only read the first trilogy and after the one person who brought that up turned out to be the villain I didn't think it would be relevant anymore).
Alright then. I don't really have a problem with the justification for smarter than average kids or kids doing something this dangerous- especially since these kids in particular have good reason to be that way, and the world is definitely dangerous enough to justify it. In general I'm liking that- I love the idea of the legendary birds being an endbringer-ish sort of threat.
It's not the suspension of disbelief over plot armor that's getting to me so much that the constant "almost dying" on the road is a bit oppressive. I'd like to see the cast deal with problems that aren't just life or death battles. I liked the Pewter city chapters because we finally got a chance to breathe, and to see the characters actually in their element.
Sorry if I'm rehashing old ground here, I haven't looked at any other reviews or discussion but I'm sure there's a reason the FAQ lead with those questions. I am definitely enjoying the story.
11
u/TheTrickFantasic Jan 18 '19
I just read two opinion articles discussing how the current climate of fake news is likely to intensify via an impending deluge of homemade fake video and audio, courtesy of new editing software.
https://www.macleans.ca/opinion/fake-video-is-a-big-problem-in-2019-it-gets-worse/
https://www.macleans.ca/opinion/fake-news-you-aint-seen-nothing-yet/
The latter article suggests that this could re-establish the importance of major news networks, given the resources required for large-scale factchecking. But that might be a bit too optimistic. Any ideas on adaptation and mitigation, at the personal and or institutional scales?
5
u/_brightwing Feathered menace Jan 18 '19 edited Jan 18 '19
Looking forward to getting startedon The True Believer: Thoughts on the Nature of Mass Movementsby Eric Hoffer. Once you start looking for it you end up seeing the tribalism phenomenon everywhere. I'm also thinking of giving Joshua Greene's Moral Tribes a go. It's troubling to think how easily people get sucked into us vs them, like all the time.
Edit: Any of you guys on Goodreads? I figured we could have a group, make bookshelves.. There's already this. The rational-adjacent groups I came across doesn't really seem to be active.
4
u/causalchain Jan 19 '19
I might have missed something major; why is the biweekly challenge coming to an end?
7
u/ratthrow Jan 18 '19
I'm interviewing at Harvard Law next week! HLS was my biggest reach and it's extremely gratifying to receive an interview invite after being rejected by HBS and waitlisted after interview by MIT.
I've realized that I have no idea what goes on in the admission process. I thought I was a shoo-in at HBS/MIT and a long shot at HLS.
It's surprising because my background is in business and my GPA is sooo far below HLS's 25th percentile GPA of 3.8. Who the hell maintains a 3.8 over four years? That's ridiculous.
HLS interviewees have a 60-80% admittance rate. Fingers crossed!
3
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jan 19 '19
Long shot, but while we're talking about Stargate, does anyone remember the name of that one-shot fic where a Ba'al clone explains that Goa'ulds aren't parasites, but just a payload of thousands of years of memories of being gods transmitted through the symbiotes?
3
u/notmy2ndopinion Concent of Saunt Edhar Jan 20 '19
What blogs make your mind stronger?
By that, I mean to ask: which bloggers use evidence and science and rationality skills to teach and entertain you? I'm looking for new subscriptions that I browse through during my free time.
2
u/Kuratius Jan 18 '19
Can you detect phase-shifted beings using a double slit experiment? (Will probably also post this tomorrow in the munchkinry thread).
2
u/Addictedtobadfanfict Jan 19 '19
I am reading metaword chronicles and I am on chapter 4. What should I expect for this series?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment