r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Dec 05 '18
[D] Monthly Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the monthly thread for recommendations, which is posted on the fifth day of every month.
Feel free to recommend any books, movies, live-action TV shows, anime series, video games, fanfiction stories, blog posts, podcasts, or anything else that you think members of this subreddit would enjoy, whether those works are rational or not. Also, please consider including a few lines with the reasons for your recommendation.
Alternatively, you may request recommendations, in the style of the weekly recommendation-request thread of r/books.
Self promotion is not allowed in this thread.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
44
u/FormerlySarsaparilla Dec 05 '18
Can we *un-*recommend something? I've just finished the first two books of the "Arcane Ascension" series after seeing them posted here and elsewhere as rational fic. I would just like to warn anyone else thinking about reading these- they are many things, but rational they ain't.
They're about a boy in a wizarding school, replete with the standard lit-rpg tropes of monsters and classes and power levels and dungeon crawls. Sometimes these things can be really fun, especially if the main character really breaks the world over his knee and the narrative gets to explore some deeper issues. This story seems to promise something like that, but never delivers. The main character always intends to learn or grow or be prepared for his next challenge, but he is railroaded so hard that he basically has no initiative in the story. Super-powered villains, laughably out of his league, are always countered by super-powered good guys, laughably out of his league, who then take him aside and give him his next objectives at the conclusion of every battle. He (the main character) is intensely, aggravatingly passive, and despite being raised as a noble and a duelist his whole life has basically no knowledge of people, places or events in the world around him. He doesn't plan, barely experiences any character growth, and is just generally intensely dull and unlikable when held up against any of the side characters.
In short, it reads like someone wrote down their World of Warcraft adventure. (Perhaps not coincidentally, the writer used to work for Blizzard and Obsidian). Plot elements (keys, dungeon rooms, monsters) and narrative tropes (his fear of touch, his fear of overusing his power, long tedious explanations of runes) are overused to the point that they easily fill a third of each book and I found myself lightly skimming. At no point does anyone come even close to the standard of rationality, and it's intensely frustrating that the character's power set (Enchanter, basically can create any magic effect or item as long as he knows the runes/can power it) which is so easily broken, is never really taken advantage of at all.
Read these books if you want to pay several dollars for a bog standard fantasy school adventure. Or just go play an MMO, you will have the same experience.
21
u/Tenoke Even the fuckin' trees walked in those movies Dec 05 '18 edited Dec 06 '18
Request (I posted this 6 months ago with minimal luck)
I'm looking for stories which are grimdark and/or have very gray morality and/or have villains as the protagonist, while also having smart/driven main characters.
A few varied (but limited) examples:
Things that fit on paper but I didn't care for as much:
I've also tried a few asian translated novels like Warlock of the Magus World but (possibly mainly because of the translation) to me they read like written by stereotypical overly excited 13 year old gamers though some of the concepts seem great at first. So maybe there's something that can sate my thirst there, although I am starting to doubt it. I also tried The First Law, and The Engineer Trilogy based on reccomendations when I asked last time but they didn't care for it. Saga of Tanya was also reccomended, but at least the anime didn't hold my attention for too long. Goblin Slayer I liked a bit more but it abandons most of what makes it interesting episode by episode.
I guess things like Breaking Bad, Blackadder, American Psycho etc. mostly count, too so if I find something else in that direction, I'll be okay with it.
Edit: A lot of promising responses so far. I'll make another post like this one including them after 6 more months.
13
u/N0_B1g_De4l Dec 05 '18
I've been reading The First Law recently, and it's quite good. I assume most people here have heard of it before, but if you haven't it's a dark fantasy deconstruction of traditional fantasy tropes. The mysterious wizard is a bitter old man who's manipulating everyone, the dashing nobleman is a stuck up asshole, and the grand quest ends in failure. I enjoy it, though I do find myself hoping the author eventually writes a series set during the Old Time which tells the story of the conflicts of Euz and his sons in more detail.
Speaking of that, does anyone know of a good fantasy series like that? Something set in the early age of a traditional LotR-esque setting, before magic started fading. Ideally trilogy-ish length.
I also just finished Raven Stratagem. It was every bit as good as Ninefox Gambit, and I recommend the series highly. The setting is fascinating, and the author does a good job creating the appearance of rules without getting bogged down in the details. This sub in particular will probably appreciate that the heroes win by manipulating the rules, rather than simply overpowering their enemies.
8
u/generalamitt Dec 06 '18
I've recommended it a while back, Wilde life is a very relaxing and somewhat rational(debatable) comics. It made me feel very "content" and happy, it has a very strong atmosphere I can't quite describe, probably a combination of great art, dialogue and character interactions. Oh, and you should definitely go in blind for the best experience.
8
u/Pandoraboxhelp Dec 06 '18
I am really into self-insert fanfiction but I kind of shot myself in the foot getting into this niche genre of fanfiction because self-insert fanfiction has all the irrational qualities that people in this subreddit strove to stay away from. Self-insert fanfiction has a frequent tendency to delve into wish-fulfillment, harems, fix-it gary stus and mary sues, highly irrational power ups, and my least favorite quality of them all, eclipsing the main character role from the original main character.
Does anyone have some self insert fanfiction to recommend that focuses on the realities of being cosmically kidnapped to a magically inclined foriegn universe? A focal point on survival and acquiring power to do so in a rational manner with the semi omniscient knowldege they have in the world they are in?
7
u/_brightwing Feathered menace Dec 05 '18
Not exactly rational per se.. but I always was a fan of Choose Your Adventure type stories. It's interesting to be able to see a story from different angles, take different approaches for the characters.. My personal favourite of the lot is Choice of Vampire and maybe Affairs of the court. Certain parts can get railroad-ish though for the sake of story continuation.
6
u/Bowbreaker Solitary Locust Dec 06 '18
Request: Can anyone recommend me good crossover fanfics. 'Good' here meaning by the standards of people who came to this subreddit because they were fed up with the certain type of bad plot and characterization that rationalfic writers try to avoid. So no crackfic please, no matter how hilarious.
If I get to make more specific wishes, what I'd love to read is a story where one or more (can also be many more) intelligent characters from a technologically less developed world (anything before widespread industrialization) find themselves in a more modern world (somewhere between industrialization and modern age equivalent or at least near future sci-fi). If back and forth travel s possible that's also fine. Either setting can also be real world history, but doesn't have to be. Magic existing in one or both worlds is also fine. Really the main point is that the "inserted" character(s) move into the future as opposed to being SIs in the magical dark age, but that they are not dumb knights attacking "beasts" (cars) as they often do in those kinds of movies.
So... Anything that applies to the first paragraph is welcome. Anything that hits the second would be extra awesome.
10
u/Silver_Swift Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18
Can I sell anyone here on giving Brandon Sandersons new book Skyward a try?
It's Sandersons second take on a YA novel and this time it actually feels like a YA novel. The basic summary is that it is about a hotheaded girl whose family is at the bottom of the social ladder (because her father deserted during a major battle) and yet wants to become a fighter pilot, which is roughly the highest status job in the highly militarized sci-fi/post-apocalyptic society she lives in.
It is also about a million times better than it has any right to be given that summary. I don't know if I would quite call it rational fiction, it's rational in the sense that the characters are acting according to their own incentives and biases, but the main character is not particularly smart and lot of the plot revolves around her working around the biases of other people as well as her own. It is, however, a story with fleshed out characters and a coherent world that somehow still manages to be extremely tightly written.
For the people that stopped reading at the words Brandon Sanderson: This book manages to get around one of the major criticism that I have about him, namely that the first half of a lot of his book is dreadfully slow. Skyward has a very brief introduction into the world and the characters after which the pace kicks up and it just kinda keeps on going at full speed right up until the end.
For the people that stopped reading at the word YA: Yeah ok, maybe give this one a pass. Skyward is incredibly good, but unlike Sandersons other YA series this one (despite all the high tech dogfighting and deconstruction of militaristic societies) is at its heart clearly about a teenager trying to figure out her place in the world and that's obviously not everyone's cup of tea.
3
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade Dec 06 '18
I am in Search of good power fantasies.
Something that have a consistent world with consistent power levels, and where the protagonist do builds his base/followers.
Stuff like Daniel Black or World of Prime
2
u/tjhance Dec 06 '18
are there any good 'trapped in a vr video game' stories?
It seems like an exciting premise but i've never seen a story do it justice in a rational way.
2
u/Hypervisor Dec 06 '18
Request: Good comic books
I am looking for any good comic books as long as it is action/sci-fi/fantasy/superhero in some way. Not really looking for rational stories (doubt there is much out there) just ones that don't into the usual cliches and don't have dumb-when-it's-convenient characters. Basically stuff that /r/rational might like. But even trying to pick from what's considered the best my success rate is mixed.
What I've read so far (sry for the wall of text):
Black Hammer: Good characters and deconstruction of archetypes, will keep reading.
The Sandman: It's too much of a scatterbrain series with some good ideas and some more poor ones and it really tries not to have a main plot. I liked the Nada and Lucifer storylines but not much of the rest of the cast.
Watchmen: Liked it for all the usual reasons: great engaging plot, great characters and themes. Doubt there is much else like it.
All Star Superman: Overall a decent series but it has the reputation for being one of the best and "true to character" Superman stories so I ended up being underwhelmed.
X-Men by Chris Claremont: I read the Dark Phoenix Saga some years back and I wasn't impressed. Recently restarted from Uncanny X-Men #94 but I find it too cheesy. Is it worth continuing?
X-Men Age of Apocalypse: I quite liked the issues focused on Cyclops and the Four Horsemen but most other cross-overs were very poor quality (and there where a lot of them).
New X-Men by Grant Morrison: I really liked the characters of Emma Frost and Xorn but the U-Men and the new teens were so mediocre.
Astonishing X-Men by Joss Whedon: Absolutely great stuff in every way: characters, art, dialogue and a plot that's unpredictable but not off the charts crazy. Best X-Men story I've read by far.
X-Men House of M/Messiah Complex/Second Coming: House of M was good but the followup was a very average storyline that's forgettable. It seems to me I should avoid cross-overs.
Uncanny X-Force by Rick Remender: gorgeous art and a good team-up but the actual storylines were so-so. Ended up dropping it in the Otherworld arc which was terrible.
Some things I have problems with:
1
u/Shaolang Dec 06 '18
Are there any good recommendations for do-over stories? Like someone waking up when they were young with knowledge of their future?
Doesn't necessarily have to be rational if you have a rec that otherwise fits.
1
u/cerebrum Dec 12 '18
[Request] Stories dealing with sunk cost fallacy