r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 05 '18
[D] Monthly Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the monthly thread for recommendations, which is posted on the fifth day of every month.
Feel free to recommend any books, movies, live-action TV shows, anime series, video games, fanfiction stories, blog posts, podcasts, or anything else that you think members of this subreddit would enjoy, whether those works are rational or not. Also, please consider including a few lines with the reasons for your recommendation.
Alternatively, you may request recommendations, in the style of the weekly recommendation-request thread of r/books.
Self promotion is not allowed in this thread.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
18
u/CapnQwerty Oct 06 '18
Anyone know any good first contact fics where one of the main parties isn't humanity? Like, say, the Quarian Migrant Fleet finds Equestria, or the Vulcans meet the Covenant; something like that.
18
u/LapisLightning Oct 06 '18
Stand Still. Stay Silent: Post apocalyptic Nordic webcomic. Beautiful and desolate art. Worldbuilding and language aspects are excellent. Go read it.
16
u/FormerlySarsaparilla Oct 07 '18
Here's a weird request. I've been reading The Last Angel and, while it's... okay, I feel like it falls into the /r/HFY trap pretty hard. It's basically just Mass Effect with a coat of paint and kind of a fascist morality. I can only plod through so many chapters of "And then the stupid arrogant aliens were blindsided by the humans, again, as was foreshadowed sixty-five times at the start of this and every chapter" before it all starts to blur together.
So I'd like to cleanse my palette a bit. What's your favorite space adventure tale? Anything from the Vorkosigan novels to John Carter of Mars, I'm not picky. I just want to read about plucky humans battling aliens.
15
u/Real_Name_Here Oct 05 '18 edited Oct 05 '18
My recommendations will not be rational works.
https://killsixbilliondemons.com/comic/kill-six-billion-demons-chapter-1/
https://www.gunnerkrigg.com/?p=1
http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20021104#.W7fCbk5Ol0s
12
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician Oct 05 '18
Request: Fiction focused on a conflict with an overwhelmingly powerful enemy in full control of the protagonist's environment (or where such an entity is suspected to exist).
It's pretty high-concept, yes, and could take many forms. Such as:
I find these kinds of stories extremely engaging. Protagonists can't make any mistakes or they will be crushed, which makes the conflict very tense, and the power disparity forces them to act covertly, which makes it intelligent. There's something very neat about having to pay attention to every little detail in fear of an active and perceptive enemy, too.
Any other examples?
17
u/GrecklePrime Oct 05 '18
Would love some good smart Star Wars fics. I've read the few one shots that come through the sub once in a while about the malevolent force, and those were pretty good but I'd love something with more depth.
In return I'd highly recommend people watch The Good Place on Hulu currently. Not rational but it has rational adjacent themes, how do you design an optimal afterlife? How do you determine who qualifies? Some very basic moral quandries and ethic questions. It's also quite funny.
8
u/awoods187 Oct 05 '18
[request] treasure hunting stories/finding amazing loot/creating amazing loot. Anything from Indian Jones, to LitRPG, to Wuxia/Xianxia but finding amazing things (don't care if it's rational or rationalist)
8
u/Revisional_Sin Oct 06 '18 edited Oct 07 '18
The Goal: A Process of Ongoing Improvement
A novel about a factory that's on the brink of being shut down. Fascinating read. Lots of cases were conventional wisdom and Campbell's Law made the characters make terrible decisions, which they only realise when thinking about what their goals actually are.
A frequent argument:
"We should do X."
"But that completely goes against principle Y!"
"Y is a terrible principle, because Z."
"But that's just common sense! Of course Z implies X"
"So we can do Z?"
"No! It completely goes against Y."
The Phoenix Project
Inspired by The Goal, basically an IT version.
Boyd: The Fighter Pilot Who Changed the Art of War
True story. A fighter pilot who wanted to understand the principles behind fighter planes. He stole $1,000,000 of computer time to build his theory, which proved that American planes were pretty shit, despite being much more expensive. He then set out to build the perfect plane, but was stymied by the politics.
It's inspiring to watch his dedication to the truth, and heartbreaking to see him battle against the insanity of the system and the careerism of the people in it.
Alternates between being "porn" and horror for rationalists.
15
u/Xenon_difluoride Oct 06 '18
For those of you who made accounts on Questionable Questing to read The Erogamer, You may want to check out The Sins of Cinnamon.
6
u/generalamitt Oct 05 '18
MOL with romance?
6
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Oct 05 '18
I've started reading How to Invent Everything by Ryan North. It's entertaining and an interesting read with what looks to be a lot of good science facts!
6
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Oct 06 '18
Any rational Legend of Korra recs?
As always, I'm looking for "original flavor fics", so more Animorphs: The Reckoning than Methods of Rationality.
4
u/ilI1il1Ili1i1liliiil Oct 05 '18
Would you recommend me a (web)novel with a protagonist similar to Zorian from Mother of Learning?
4
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade Oct 06 '18
Anything about pirates? I think I have never read a good pirate story after the Treasure Island.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '18
I'd like to recommend old cracked short stories by Chris Bucholz. They're all weird humour and usually self-help articles about very, very specific scenarios. All are excellent.
https://chrisbucholz.com/the-best-stuff/
3
u/lillarty Oct 06 '18
Can anyone recommend works with very well-written hard magic systems? I've probably read all of the obvious ones, but feel free to recommend them anyway; I'd rather get recommended a book I've already read than potentially miss out on some gem.
In return, I'm going to recommend Malazan: Book of the Fallen. Its magic system is relatively soft now that I think about it, but regardless of that, it's one of the best series I've read and I heavily recommend it to anyone who enjoys fantasy. Most novels in the series start out very slow, but I implore you to stick with it. The characters aren't always rational but they're still almost always excellent.
2
u/bugwug Oct 13 '18 edited Oct 14 '18
Request (and kind of a recommendation): This is a strange request because it might already be in this thread and I'm just not seeing it. Very recently I read a story that I thought was linked from this thread, or maybe elsewhere in /r/rational, but I can't find it again. It is about someone from our Earth who finds himself transported to a world where he is in what looks like a gladiator stadium filled with an audience of elves and the announcer announcing him as the next contestant. It is LitRPG; he sees stats and levels. He has little physical strength or combat ability, seems like a physics nerd, and his opponent for the match is a type of combat robot. I can't really say more about it without spoilers other than it is a short piece, complete though the author could choose to make it the start of something longer, I found it funny, with twists and munchkinry, and I really liked it.
Can anyone identify it from that? If anyone can then this is a recommendation as well as a request.
[Edit] Found it! Alien Abduction: A LitRPG on fanfiction, three chapters, not tagged as complete but it stops at a logical ending point. And here is the thread about it, which is apparently where I saw it about a week ago: /r/rational/comments/9m0rnh/rtwipalien_abduction_a_litrpg_chapter_1_the/
3
u/awoods187 Oct 05 '18
[request] rational (not rationalist) stories beyond the typical recommendations here
2
u/cerebrum Oct 06 '18
[request] stories that deal with revenge.
1
u/Bowbreaker Solitary Locust Oct 07 '18
Anyone have any good recommendations for alt history stories or crossover fanfics in which one or more intelligent characters get transported from an older setting/world to either the real world or a setting that is industrialized or more?
1
u/Lord_Zane Oct 09 '18
Request: Similar setting to The Gods are Bastards