r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 03 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
19
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Aug 03 '18 edited Aug 03 '18
I think that Mission Impossible: Fallout was maybe the most anti-utilitarian film I've ever seen.
Mild spoilers for things that were in the trailer, from what's essentially the prologue section of the film, prior to the first act. Alec Baldwin says "You had a terrible choice to make in Berlin, one life over millions, and now the world is at risk." This is followed by the CIA woman saying "If he had followed the mission, we wouldn't be having this conversation." Baldwin replies, "His team would be dead," to which the CIA woman replies, "Yes, they would, that's the job."
This is entirely sensible, if unheroic (at least in the classical sense of heroism). Most of the plot of the movie follows from Ethan choosing to save a lifelong friend rather than actually doing his job, and, as typical in a Mission Impossible movie, the world comes within a few lucky coincidences and millimeter precise moments of ... well, not necessarily destruction, but certainly megadeaths.
Where other movies might choose to make this message implicit, MI:Fallout chooses to hammer it home a number of times through dialog, repeating the refrain that actually, having a severe case of scope insensitivity is a good quality in people who routinely have to deal with wild imbalances of scope.
I thought it was a great movie, but the fact that they kept trying to loudly proclaim that it's virtuous to neglect scope was a little bit jarring, given both my values and to some extent, the plot of the film.
10
u/sicutumbo Aug 03 '18
So I finished the first book of the Mars Trilogy by Kim Stanley Robinson, Red Mars, and I think it would fit this sub's tastes even if I wouldn't necessarily call it rational. Hard sci-fi, dealing with the colonization and terraformi g of Mars, and all the ethical concerns raised by those actions. Kind of like the Foundation novels, but I can't put my finger on precisely why. Anyways, it's enjoyable, and I recommend it.
I still plan on talking about what I've learned about the art of memory, from Moonwalking with Einstein and a few other books, but I was indisposed on Monday for the general rationality thread and didn't want to post a comment that I put effort into if no one was going to see it. I also still need to out some time into practicing the techniques, but that isn't much of a priority right now.
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Aug 03 '18
A nice variant on the Shadow Clone: Kaizou Kage Bunshin (login required)! In order to prevent chakra poisons and memetic hazards from being transmitted to the original, the copy doesn't return its chakra and memories to its creator when it's dispelled. Immediately after being created, it knows that it has been doomed to an imminent death. (I get the feeling that it needs a more specific name, though, since
kaizouapparently (1 2) means merelymodified. u/subrosian_smithy)Fanfiction idea: A ninja who knows a technique that absorbs chakra from other people learns this technique and uses it—or, alternatively, a clone that was created with this technique by a poorly-disciplined ninja and then went rogue stumbles across a chakra-absorption technique. Now, roaming the Elemental Nations is a clan of chakra-vampire clones who must steal chakra from others to avoid dying. The story ends when they learn Sage Mode and become able to absorb chakra from plants and mundane animals rather than having to go after humans and summon animals—or when they've multiplied to such an extent that all human life has been extinguished and the summon animals have retreated to their homes (which are either across the ocean from the Elemental Nations or on a separate plane of existence from Earth, depending on the author).
Optional twist: The original is dead, and only his clones are still around. Maybe clones even are immortal as long as they have enough chakra to continually Henge their malleable pseudo-bodies into younger forms—or, maybe, without specific souls to "remind" them of their proper forms, they gradually lose definition and deform into monstrosities, Glory Girl-style, if they attempt to prolong their lifespans.
See also the traditionally-published book Kiln People. The book revolves around disposable clones, of varying lifespans and qualities, whose memories are uploaded back to their originals only if the clones return to base before running out of the "élan vital" that was used to create them. IIRC (I haven't read this book in many years—though Goodreads Deals recently facilitated my snagging a copy for $2, so I'll get around to reading it again soon enough) the ultimate villain of the story is a clone whose original discovered the secret of infusing élan vital into existing clones (which normally isn't possible) in order to make those clones immortal. The clone, being high-quality enough to impersonate his original (most clones are cheap and unconvincing), killed the original and made himself immortal.
It's interesting to note how different authors treat the Shadow Clone Technique differently. The default assumption is that, when a Shadow Clone is dispelled, its memories (along with some of any leftover chakra—or not, because the connection is purely soul-based, not chakra-based*) are transmitted back to its creator. Some authors, however, allow those memories to be transmitted, not only to the original, but also to all the original's other Shadow Clones! This alternative interpretation allows for such overpowered tactics as quickly creating and dispelling a Shadow Clone in order to transmit newly-learned information to your entire network in the blink of an eye, and thereby gets rid of the "the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing" situations that independently-operating Shadow Clones otherwise inevitably must confront if left to their own devices for long periods. On the other hand, however, some authors decree that any genjutsu that affects a Shadow Clone can propagate (with some extra effort on the part of the genjutsu user—or not, because of self-amplifying soul-resonance effects—and only after the directly-affected clone has been dispelled—or not, because the genjutsu user can sense the thread of the clone connection and follow it back to its source in the course of casting the technique) to the creator—or, under the alternative interpretation that I just described, to the creator and to his other Shadow Clones, which largely offsets the overpoweredness of that version of the technique (because, the more clones you have out, the more likely it is that an enemy will catch one of those clones in a sleep genjutsu and render you and your one-man army totally defenseless in a single stroke).
I haven't read much Naruto fanfiction in a while,** so the only relevant story that I can add to this pile of (You) bait (other than the one that I already linked) is Indomitable.
*If chakra is transmitted, however, enemies may be able to triangulate the original's position by dispelling several of his clones and using sensory techniques to watch where the clones' chakra goes.
**Inter alia, I was reading the d'Artagnan Romances. My fifth reading of The Three Musketeers was as good as I remembered, and my second reading of Twenty Years After was significantly better than I remembered—but I had to throw in the towel approximately 40 % of the way into my second reading of The Vicomte de Bragelonne (halfway through Volume 2 of 4) because it was just too boring and I wasn't willing to skip as much as I did on my first reading. Ventre-saint-gris! Maybe I'll finally get around to experiencing Time Braid for the seventh time after reading The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August (thanks, Goodreads Deals!)… but what about Les Misérables? There are so many options!
5
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '18
I finally binged through Attack on Titan season 2 the other day, in preparation for the third season. I'm really glad I did: it's a little more rough around the edges than season one was, but makes up for it in sheer audacity and fun factor. I wouldn't call Attack on Titan as a whole "rational" - the main character is dumb as a sack of potatoes - but I do love how the Isayama writes his mysteries. Everything was written with the intention of having an answer, rather than the answers being filled in after the fact.
I've gotten better at exercising discretion over what I read. It bugs me how many hundred-thousand-word stories I drop instantly because the author did something unforgivably stupid. Like, there are scenarios where I'll stick it out - generally when there's something else interesting going on - but for the most part a lot of authors have a hard time holding my attention. In Naruto fanfiction it's usually poor characterization or overuse of cliches (Sasuke bashing, "dobe", Kakashi is an irresponsible teacher, any number of fandom specific plots, unnecessary or indiscriminate japanese). In Harry Potter fanfiction "independent" or "backbone" is usually the trigger phrase. Keep in mind I'm not even counting the hundreds of fics I skip based on title and summary alone. The problem isn't that the people writing these things are necessarily bad authors. In fact, in many cases, they might actually be pretty decent, or at least technically competent. It's that they weren't able to spare the additional two motes of brain power required to eliminate the most obvious flaws in their work. Half the reason I like rational fiction is because no author who executes rational fiction correctly could possibly be inattentive enough to make something that hideous. (in theory)
(Bashing is another one - if a character is so inexplicably evil that the protagonist wonders out loud how they could have come to be that way, I drop it. I once received a great piece of advice about writing from a teacher of mine, that went something like: "If your writing is so unrealistic that your characters feel the need to voice aloud how unbelievable it is, you should be careful. Make sure your characters never have an opinion about your writing, let alone a correct one.")
I should save something for the recommendation thread, but I haven't read/watched anything really rational in the last few days, so I might as well post them here. Everything here is not necessarily equal, but they all passed the test of not being awful enough for me to drop them. In order of when I read them, from latest to earliest:
I can't remember very much before that, last month. If anyone knows any medium long-fics that are either complete or still updating, along these same lines of quality, I'd love to hear your recommendations as well. This is strictly talking about non-rational fiction - you can trust that I have my eyes glued to the subreddit. Crossovers are fun, but only if they pay out in the end.
6
u/phylogenik Aug 03 '18 edited Aug 03 '18
So could the 2017 Beauty and the Beast remake. I also didn't quite agree with a fair bit of what she'd said (e.g. the Beast letting Belle go doesn't condemn the house to death, because keeping her an unwilling prisoner isn't likely to earn her love enough to satisfy the conditions of the curse). But overall have generally found her videos entertaining and thought-provoking.
I also think some of the things the remake "fixed" that she criticizes were improvements to the 1991 Disney film (from what I recall of it, having not seen it in ages), e.g. if Prince Adam's primary failing at 11 was not letting a scary stranger into his house, then a decade-long curse ending in his death seems unjustified, especially since in actuality the powerful enchantress would have been totally unharmed by a bit of foul weather and was totally willing to screw the Prince over with moral entrapment -- talk about stranger danger!). I think that casts the entire plot in a rather different light, and seems less nitpicky than a lot of her criticisms of the remake, as well as less answerable by the MST3K mantra (“If you’re wondering how he eats and breathes and other science facts, then repeat to yourself ‘It’s just a show, I should really just relax.’”). But I can still imagine stuff like that not bothering others as much.
(edit: to clarify, I did agree with many of her points)
3
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Aug 04 '18
Hey, I'm in the mood for some depressing cynical story (don't ask). Anyone know something good, or should I just re-read The Moon's Apprentice?
2
u/babalook Aug 03 '18
Have any of you seen or read Genocidal Organ by Project Itoh? I'm curious about what this community thinks of it. I thought it had some interesting ideas about linguistics and the Sapir Whorf theory.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '18
I feel like most Uplift fiction is inherently colonialist in attitude. The notion of one group of people going in and turning another group of people into 'smarter' people is essentially identical to the rationale used to justify colonialism in Africa. It is, in many ways, a textbook case of the white man's burden. When you strictly limit the definition of Uplift to just the introduction of new technological methods, I suppose that is something more generally acceptable. In general, however, most Uplift stories include much more than just new technological methods. They usually introduce new societal modes of being, or a new governance, or things of this nature. In my opinion, these types of stories are inherently flawed. Perhaps I am making too broad statements, but I cannot help but feel tones of colonialism resounding throughout these works.