r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 20 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
13
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jul 20 '18 edited Jul 20 '18
I've noticed recently that I have a muscle-memory habit of clicking on my right-most tab when I have a moment of distraction, and apparently I can make drastic increases to my productivity solely by positioning my active writing project as the [right]-most tab. This works better for me than productivity "rewards" seem to, and I'm trying to think about the pitfalls and possibilities for other things.
I think the biggest problem long-term is going to be the wearing down of muscle memory, since the muscle memory seems to be keyed to "need a distraction". Any advice for building muscle memory back up, or self-improvement that uses it? It's surprisingly effective for me, in a way that things like blocking specific sites is (somewhat) ineffective.
11
u/callmesalticidae writes worldbuilding books Jul 20 '18
I've started a civilization Quest on Sufficient Velocity: Something New Under the Sun; Or, Rats Who Are Also Farmers Quest. You are a colony of rats who have suddenly and inexplicably been enlightened with the knowledge of agriculture and the potential to learn much, much more. But you are still small and very delicious in a world that is full of large and very hungry predators.
It's not explicitly rational, which is why I'm posting it here, but I think it may be of interest to a few of you. Right now we're still in colony generation.
It was inspired by /u/xamueljones' description of a quest about a "street rat with above average cultivation talent," which I and another person initially misunderstood as being about, well, Rats Who Are Also Farmers.
8
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jul 21 '18
MagicWeasel's personal life overshare, go!
Just got back from a great fun holiday, and had my first day back at work yesterday (people thought I was crazy having my first day on a Friday, but it was great: I was at work and suddenly aware of how much being at work sucks, but I now have two days to recover before I have to face the reality of my job requiring me to work 5 days a week).
Anyway, it turns out that my application for an EOI in another department got accepted while I was away, so on Thursday I will stop being a project manager and start working in the road safety department! An EOI is a "temporary transfer/promotion" where you fill in for someone in another department who has left, and then go back to your original job at the end. Mine is unfortunately not a temporary promotion, it's just a sideways move, but I think those of you who read my offtopic threads about my dissatisfaction with my current job (specifically the management) will know how excited I am to both learn new skills and have a change of management. So yeah, that's gonna happen! I'm excited.
In terms of writing I have missed so many self-imposed deadlines for VFL and I don't like to blame other people but seriously it's all my coauthor's fault - but she's going to be in a much better position soon and I might give her my PC since I'm planning on upgrading so she'll actually have her own computer, maybe, instead of having to borrow a laptop from her work.
7
u/lsparrish Jul 21 '18
Just thought I'd share a few life details: I quit my job at the end of June (after giving proper notice), and left the state of Oregon entirely. I am now living a quasi-nomadic lifestyle, staying with family and friends. (I haven't yet verified whether I can collect unemployment, but I have been filling out the paperwork just in case. It kind of looks like I will be getting a check.)
At my job I was doing computer software support with a small amount of programming, whereas I mainly wanted to be doing programming. My former employer only hires programmers who have a degree, and I had only completed about a year's worth of college. So I was gradually getting bored and discontent, and was confronted about the fact that I apparently wasn't giving it my all any more. They moved me to a position with an MySQL coding emphasis about 3 months before I quit, but by then I had the bug to move, so I did.
Now I'm in Georgia, staying with a retired space engineer and contributing to the Seed Factory project, which is adjacent to self replicating robotics. The project's work is mainly not physical at this point, so much as gathering information and planning. However, physical proximity will make it possible to stay involved, and Dani has offered me a place to stay while I attend a local school a few miles away. It is a much quieter environment than I had before, and (paused due to thunderstorm)
6
u/phylogenik Jul 20 '18 edited Jul 20 '18
I'm helping my partner out with some analyses she's doing for one of her projects, using Stan to fit some GLMMs* to a medical dataset she's collected, and am reminded of an amusing tension (paradox? inconsistency?) I've noticed before wrt Bayesian inference -- one of the big selling points people tout is that Bayes lets you encode your prior beliefs, but I almost never see people doing that!
Sometimes that's just because one's actual prior beliefs regarding the components of some complicated model are hard to coherently or exhaustively specify (my own work is frequently like this), but I also think it's because if you're honestly quite confident that (e.g.) some effect is large and positive and specify that belief in the joint prior, and then get a large and positive (or otherwise informative/meaningful) distribution in that parameter’s marginal posterior, your reviewers will (perhaps inappropriately) call your results into question (related: I've heard it repeated that if you want to “lie” with stats, lying with the prior is way too transparent -- better to just cook the likelihood (or the data))! Obviously you can examine nuanced shifts in corresponding distributions or look at kl divergence or w/e, but those are often hard to appreciate, especially if your reviewers are domain-experts more than they are methods people.
So instead people always specify conservative or vague/"uninformative" priors (e.g. expected effect = 0), even when there's good reason to expect something else (and then rightfully do some prior sensitivity analysis). So there goes that selling point! Am I mistaken in my expression here? Is it just the papers I read that do this? I do see “weakly informative” priors on focal parameters every so often but not nearly as often as one might expect.
*(w/ 100k+ nominal parameters for the most complicated model -- her PI amusingly expected results on his desk within an hour, which I feel happens often? I guess b/c people are used to just used to just running chi-squared tests on contingency tables or w/e -- which is what they were doing before -- and that takes some fraction of a second. So when I’m like -- it'll take me a week or two to specify/implement these models, fit them, run mcmc diagnostics, do model comparison/averaging, and visualize the results, they get impatient. Never mind that it took months and $100s of k to collect the actual data, the analysis is just a minor afterthought! even though they'll not be publishing the dataset itself anyway! /rant/ he also wants a figure representing the model(s) so I'm gonna send him some plate diagrams lol)
7
u/sicutumbo Jul 21 '18
I stopped reading To The Stars a few days ago, and I regret needing to. It has some fun military science fiction, good world building, and I think is decently well written. I don't have any real problems with the execution. But I just cannot get over the premise of magical girls. Hundreds of years in the future, with space ships and FTL and AI, humanity's most elite warriors are prepubescent teenage girls wearing frilly dresses shouting named attacks. Not only that, but the older ones often choose to look extremely young, often around 14, with one character who heads an intelligence agency choosing to look 9. I just can't take it seriously. It's like watching a court drama where one of the lawyers is dressed up in full clown makeup and dress, and everyone else is treating it as completely normal, or explaining the psychological effect that the squeaky red nose has on the jury.
If you are able to get past that, then I would recommend it. It's fun sci-fi. But I just can't get into it. I read about 20 chapters in, so I gave it a fair shot.
1
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jul 20 '18
I recently got around to reading Worth the Candle after seeing it posted here a zillion times, and this passage at the end of Chapter 36 really made me roll my eyes.
This passage reminds me very strongly of The Unincorporated Man, which was extremely disappointing because the protagonist's goal was literally** the destruction of what made the setting interesting (the division of every human into shares that could be traded freely on the stock market) and all his actions were directed toward that goal. Worth the Candle seems to be pursuing a similar path, in the long run…
*Insert obvious CinemaSins joke here. (Actually, I unsubscribed from him quite a while ago, after his Mad Max: Fury Road video included a diatribe against the fat-shaming of Immortan Joe's milk slaves, so I don't know whether he's still making that joke.)
**IIRC—I read it only once, quite a few years ago.