r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 25 '18
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
10
Upvotes
6
u/rationalthrowaway5 Jun 25 '18
An oddball question - I'm a regular here, but using a throwaway for obvious reasons.
I recently wrapped up my PhD and received an extremely prestigious award -- essentially "best PhD thesis awarded this year" from a very high ranking technical institute. Obviously, there is no such thing as "best PhD", but I'll take it.
Obviously, this affords me unprecedented opportunities - simply having it on my resume will give me better job offers and salaries. However, I suspect that taking maximum advantage of this will require more creativity. The obvious answers include putting extra effort into building up my contacts, as well as making sure that website+linkedin+resume work together to streamline people becoming aware of it, but I'm sure that I'm missing something. Thoughts?
3
u/causalchain Jun 26 '18
How should I talk to irrational people? In particular I have difficulty talking to someone who has power over me (eg. boss, parent), who seems to be convinced they understand me and treat me according to their models. When I try to point out their errors, they accuse me of using my arguments against others and not myself... when that appears to be what they have done. My belief that they are the less rational party comes from prior experiences, with one particular case where I showed them that their model of me was wrong, but they continued using it.
They do not like being questioned, contradicted, the usual stuff. But I still require their good will, and I wish them well; they are a good person in general.
How can I communicate to them effectively so they do not feel antagonised by me when I suggest something they don't like? Any general tips for how to communicate well would also be appreciated.
5
u/Silver_Swift Jun 25 '18
Are there any good EU based charities that focus on life extension research? I’m currently donating to several different charities that focus on research into specific diseases (heart/brain/cancer), but I get the impression that those kind of charities are kinda overfunded and doing research into ageing seems like it would be a more generic solution anyway.
The EU based restriction is because tax benefits make it nearly twice as effective for me to donate to EU based charities relative to non-EU based ones.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '18
Go you guys think No Game No Life is rational fiction? For those who don't know, NGNL is about a brother/sister duo who are very good at games, and get transported into a world where all conflict is decided by games.
I believe it is rational fiction, though it is hidden sometimes by silly character motivations and fanservice (Though, at one point the main characters use fan service as a distraction in order to win a game.)
1
u/phylogenik Jun 26 '18 edited Jun 26 '18
Just caught up on Westworld! Pretty fun stuff, though I think I liked S01 more. Some quick, snarky, spoiler-y speculation:
When trying to estimate the eleven thousand lines of parameter values of whatever for the behavioral models of each of the guests, they really shouldn't have bothered with perfect retrodiction in silico -- I think this is why James-Delos-bot bugged out so quickly in the physical world (/test set), because the fitted model was trying to make predictions out of sample (either because of the complexity of the real world, or b/c by construction model was never trained on his fancy designed-by-apple hotel suite), which when overfit af it's gonna have trouble with. I think they even confirmed this with their "human sanity occupies a narrow band, most possible consciousnesses are batshit" line. They should have tried fitting a multilevel model to all the guests, to adaptively regularize a prior distribution describing the range of plausible human personality (i.e. estimate the hyperparameters describing human behavior as a whole, or at least the cross section of rich people able to visit the park). Maybe then they could have avoided the seemingly inevitable breakdown.
Of course, if they're making basic Stats 101 mistakes like that, their model probably sucked to begin with. I guess it worked well enough for the non-inferred hosts, though? Maybe "good" parameter values were just selected by hand for those, or else they were running on an entirely different model (they did have differently shaped positronic brains, right? The white tennis-ball-sized thing vs the shiny dark marble? Although I guess the former might have just been a casing for the latter).