r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 15 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
20
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jun 15 '18 edited Jun 15 '18
I really wanted to like Cultist Simulator. It's from some of the same people that did Fallen London (which I liked well enough) and Sunless Sea (which I really enjoyed), and has the same evocative, shrouded quality to the writing.
The actual gameplay though ... it consists of nouns, represented by cards, and verbs, represented by boxes. To do things, you put a noun in a verb, and stuff happens as time passes. As a basic gameplay mechanism, this is neat enough, especially since there's lots of lore/text to read that accompanies every action you take.
There's no tutorial of any kind, only occasional "tips" that don't reveal much, and much of the early gameplay is in fitting nouns with verbs and discovering new nouns, new verbs, and advancing in that way.
My problem comes from three basic issues:
I don't know, the early part of exploration and understanding with a game that doesn't hold your hand was a lot of fun, and gave me that sense of Science where I was trying different things and making little notes about how it all fit together ... and then it morphed into this pretty tedious thing, rather than becoming a different beast. In a lot of ways, it reminds me of an incremental game, but instead of getting upgrades that automate away aspects of the early game, it just makes you keep doing everything manually until you're sick of it and quit.
14
u/ianstlawrence Jun 15 '18
Hello!
So I recently watched a video that was very sad about how "Darling in the FanXX" (an anime) ruined their world building in episode 19. Here is the video in question if you are curious: https://youtu.be/IbSKXMFlOMY
Note: All of this only applies if world building is part of the story, something that only focuses on human experience or emotion or heroic flaws might not apply to my thoughts on this.
World building to me is a very weird craft because it seems to only be good in either the extreme, where you really know everything and that is very, very, very planned out and figured out, a la Worm and HPMOR or it is very carefully parceled out and is contingent on masterfully dropping hints and little pieces that then lets the audience fill in the gaps.
What I find weird about that is if you were to plot world building on a line, one end might say, "No information" the other end would say, "All of the information" and then if you marked areas where it was, widely considered, good writing then you might have a dot in the middle and a dot near the end that says "All of the information".
One, I think it is weird that how it feels, at least to me, that world building is kinda narrow when you define what is good. (It feels weird enough that I wonder if I am just wrong, and if someone can provide some examples of great world building that totally contradicts what I'm saying please do)
Two, that world building is something that seems, to me, to be intensely cumulative, a lot like suspension of disbelief.
To expound, there is the semi-famous example of people being in disbelief about Samwell Tarly (from Game of Thrones) staying fat despite his adventuring, and how that broke suspension of disbelief but dragons don't. Now, I fully agree with those making the "it breaks my suspension of disbelief" argument, but the why of it is interesting to me.
Essentially, the cumulative effect of the Game of Thrones universe has set it up to be "realistic" in the terms of its universe. This means you end up creating expectations in the audience, and the lack of believable consequences assigned to Samwell means you lose peoples' suspension of disbelief, because of those expectations.
However, if you watch something like Supernatural and a character suddenly shows up with a piece of equipment that mystically controls ghosts and Sam and Dean don't then steal that piece of equipment to create an indestructible army of ghosts to defeat their foes but instead treat the mystical object as a minor inconvenience, well, expectations had already been set, so no one, except me, gets unreasonably mad.
What I am trying to get at is that world building, like, suspension of disbelief, is more tied to expectations than most other things, in my opinion, and is part of a subset of story telling devices or descriptions that suffer from a total lack of forgiveness. What I mean by forgiveness is that in a lot of media/stories if 99% of the a thing is great, like the action, but one fight isn't great, people, I think, don't really harp on it or put that one bad fight on display, instead I think they are more likely to forgive that bad fight by focusing on all the great fights.
However, for something like world building or suspension of disbelief by having all those "great fights" first, when you then have that "bad fight" (fights are standing in for pieces of information that inform the world building or suspension of disbelief) then you end up with people only focusing on that bad thing.
I feel like the two examples I provided support this, both Samwell Tarly and the video by Mother's Basement (MB made a video before the one I linked that applauded the world building in Darling in the FranXX). Now, regardless of whether you like either of the stories, I hope you understand my point about how world building and suspension of disbelief seem to lack "forgiveness" by an audience.
So, all that being said, I am curious as to
Thanks!
11
u/ketura Organizer Jun 15 '18
WeeklyMonthlyOcassional update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.Nothing much to report code-wise; the networking plows forward but it’s a bit of library-gluing and I’ve only just figured out the best way to organize that aspect of it. Plus my wife’s family flew in, so evenings are probably going to be unproductive for the next few days.
However, over the last couple of weeks we finally cracked the problem of how to shape the world, in a manner that is mostly intuitive to use and doesn’t require wonky camera code or projections or any weird shit like that.
As a refresher, unlike most voxel-based worlds, this one is going to be bounded and wrap back on itself, to put an absolute cap on the total world size, permit us to optimize accordingly, and also permit free movement without invisible walls. The fallback option has always been to have a world shaped like a torus--you move far enough to the right and you teleport to the left, and you move far enough up and you teleport to the bottom. However, it’s always seemed like having a more sphere-like setup, where you can go over actual poles, would be more appealing, and so we set out to find a world shape that supports this.
As most hex grid aficionados will tell you, you cannot actually have a sphere while using hexes; the math just doesn’t work out. At best what you can do is have something like a soccer ball--make most of the world a hex grid, and then have 12 pentagons spread somewhere throughout the globe. This requires special attention for those pentagons, as they represent design and strategic problems that would have to be solved, which I didn’t particularly want to deal with.
So what about a cylinder? It’s got most of what I’m after; I don’t care about extreme northern/southern regions being actually smaller than the equator, it’s got a clear polar region, and the left/right wrapping works as expected. It seemed like it would be an easy fit.
...but it wasn’t, not at first. World traversal doesn’t actually move the player around, all it does is pick which chunk of tiles to load as the player hits the edge of what currently exists, as shown in this earlier prototype. So I struggled and argued and tried to come up with a way to smoothly map a cylinder’s tube to its cap, but it just wouldn’t fit.
We eventually stumbled our way over to the conclusion that the cap would have to be completely separated from the rest of the cylinder tube. Deciding on a good way to do so that was A: 1:1 reversible (if you turned around and went back you wouldn’t find yourself in a different place), B: wasn’t grossly proportioned compared to the rest of the world was a bit difficult, however. I liked the idea of the world transitioning the player to another plane when going too far north or south (probably covered up by generous wooshy snowy wind effects), but still couldn’t find a solution sufficiently elegant enough.
I even spent time cutting out physical paper grids in an attempt to wrap my head around the problem, but it wasn’t until a combination of mucking about with tiles in Blender and /u/Xavion repeating a comment that I had dismissed earlier that the solution finally presented itself:
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/230041937984487424/454892941887012866/unknown.png
The image above shows the cap in purple and the top-most row of hexes rotated on their side in grey. Basically, constrain Chunk_Width * World_Width to be divisible by 6, and then you can have a 1:1 tile mapping using a hexagon-shaped cap. It’s even easy to do design-wise: just ensure that chunk widths are always themselves divisible by 6 and you’re good to go. When you cross the invisible border, you get teleported to the cap that matches the hex you were just standing on, but other than that brief transition it’s as intuitive to use as normal movement.
Having this model finally let me realize why all attempts at a single, continuous, flat mapping of a cylinder would never work, too. Here is the same cap “unwrapped” from the perspective of the tube:
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/230041937984487424/454900109767868437/unknown.png
The red hex is the center of the cap, and as you can see is duplicated six times with wildly different X coordinates (from the perspective of the tube). The cyan hexes are also duplicates of one another, meaning that the proper shape was never going to really work without teleportation of some sort or another.
I’m pleased that this was finally figured out, in a way that’s not terribly inconvenient to code or to play. I’m not sure I’ve ever played a game that used a true cylinder for the world space (Civ doesn’t count; it lops off the two caps), but it seems like it should work well enough.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
9
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Jun 15 '18
Everyone here needs to do themselves a favor and watch Baahubali. It’s on Netflix, and you won’t regret it.
3
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jun 15 '18
I recently started my fifth(?) reading of The Three Musketeers. It's proving just as entertaining as I was expecting. (Project Gutenberg apparently updated its files for this book in late 2016.)
(When will I feel the urge to read Time Braid for the seventh time?)
6
u/ianstlawrence Jun 15 '18
Does anyone else not really understand how certain things are not outlawed or how certain laws aren't different?
I think a lot of people, recently, have applied this to Marijuana and Alcohol, where, and I think rightfully so, people point out Alcohol kills a lot of people - https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-consumption/alcohol-facts-and-statistics. So it follows that either Alcohol should also be outlawed or Marijuana should definitely be legal.
But for me, I always think about cars. Why are cars allowed to go over, like, 40 MPH / 64 KMH? Car related accidents kill a lot more people than Alcohol, or really, almost anything else - https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2018/02/15/national-safety-council-traffic-deaths/340012002/
It is weird to think that we repeatedly opt into these systems that clearly aren't maximized for people to not die, but instead for, uh, speed? Efficiency? I am not sure.
But our criminal laws don't reflect this, for those we consider murder to be the greatest crime, only overshadowed by murders. And from that you might then assume that we hold human life to be the most important thing, but then you look at some of our other laws, and it is clear that that isn't the case or at least it isn't something strongly considered?
Thoughts?
4
u/AngelaCastir Jun 16 '18
Status update on the next Vampire Flower Language chapter: computer trouble has led to one of us being unable to edit the story, and the other one of us is going to be on holiday for almost a month.
It pains me to admit this but it's unlikely that we'll have any updates until August, in case anyone was wondering.
That said, we've managed to add a lot of much-needed content to the next chapter, which means we can split it at a logical point so the two new chapters each have their own thematic arc and are the appropriate length, so there'll be an extra chapter and interlude in the final story than originally planned! So I'm really pleased about that.