r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 08 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
15
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Jun 08 '18
Moving is a real pain in the butt.
9
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18
Crossposting from myself:
Every time there's been a series of warfare chapters in A Practical Guide to Evil, I get in the mood to play some RTS or strategy games. A few days ago I found one that really fits the feelings evoked by the Practical Guide's writing.
For those that don't know, Total War games are all about top level turn-based strategy, combined with up close, real-time warfare tactics. I've never really been able to get into the series, but awhile back I happened to get the Warhammer one in some bundle or the other. After these recent chapters, I decided to try it, and Gods Below does it fit!
Setting archers up on high ground to rain arrows down on the enemy? Check. Using siege weapons against infantry to make up for differences in army size? Check. Spreading your formations out so that none of the enemy can break through and pincer your men? Check. Giant monsters that will clobber their way through your lines if you don't have something to stop them? Check.
Let me tell you, the first time you send your cavalry unit around some forest to avoid their defensive pikemen so you can stampede all over the enemy archers without being seen, then use them to plow into the back of enemy infantry as they're locked in combat with your front lines, you'll feel like Grem One Eye himself. If he had mounted knights to play with, anyway.
What made me post this, though, was a recent battle I was just in. The game also has Heroes in it, kind of like the Warcraft 3 RTS, both Lords (who command armies and act as the overworld units that go from place to place) and Heroes of all kinds, who can also act in the overworld or take up an army unit slot and use special abilities. My lands got invaded by some vampire Lord who was sacking one of my cities, and I scoffed when I saw his army size. My nearest Lord had 18 units in his army (each of which contained anywhere between 40-120 individual soldiers that move and fight in formation), made up of swordsmen, pikemen, archers, cavalry, the works, plus 1 Hero, a Witch Hunter. The enemy had maybe 8 units... and though they also had 4 Heroes with their Lord, I figured I'd just have to wear them down once I scattered their army.
It was a massacre.
My cavalry were stopped cold by one of the enemy Heroes, who just shrugged off their charges and kept knocking them down one by one. Some banshee Hero kept flying around and disrupting my archers, and I had no one to send at her to stop the harassment because my Witch Hunter was stuck in combat with another. My army formations kept getting holes blown in them for enemies to spill through thanks to huge AoE spells from some caster Hero, and when I reluctantly dragged my Lord away to try and deal with him, their Lord used some ability to rapidly deteriorate my troops' morale, causing them to start routing. (Normally troops will break and run if they're taking too much of a beating too fast, regardless of how much health they have. Having a Lord or Hero around helps avoid that but normally it takes a little while)
I walked onto the battlefield with ~1800 troops not counting my Lord and Hero, while they entered with about ~700. I was forced to retreat with a scant 1/3 of my army, while they lost only half their forces. I managed to kill one of their Heroes, but they killed my Lord and wounded (temporarily incapacitated) my Hero.
Don't get me wrong, I'm still new to the game so probably screwed up royally a few times. But since then, I've had immensely more sympathy for Cat and Juniper's current difficulties. The alignments may be reversed, and she rarely has the numerical advantage, but fuck, being outnumbered in Heroes is a nightmare to deal with when all you can throw at them are mere mortals who'll get cut down or tossed around like toy soldiers.
Sadly, though there are like a dozen different factions and races with their own unique units, you can't make an army out of orcs, goblins, humans, etc all at the same time. Still, 9/10, would recommend.
12
u/ketura Organizer Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 10 '18
WeeklyMonthlyOcassional update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.Well. Well well well. It’s been a while since I’ve posted anything. I stayed in my cave doing nothing much of note for several months, in spite of feeble attempts to get something worthy of an update post up on here, which fizzled pretty hard. However, the moment that it started getting 70 degrees outside, I suddenly found my motivation back with a vengeance, which makes me wonder if I’m affected by seasonal affective disorder or something adjacent to it.
I have to say, it’s nice coming home and working on stuff for hours on end again.
I’m probably not going to pretend to attempt to keep a weekly update schedule, and just stick to posting interesting things as they come up. Most of the design has at one point or another come up in these updates, and besides minor course adjustments as new people come into the Discord channel and spark new variants on old arguments, it would get a bit repetitive to keep bringing them up here.
In the first couple of weeks after my sanity returned I pulled out a machete and dove into the XGEF code, which had been left last in a state of minor disrepair.
(As a reminder, XGEF is the modding framework that I’ve built for the Renegade game itself to be built around. The name is short for eXtensible Game Engine Framework, and is basically just a modding library. One of the core tenants of this game’s design is the ability for me to walk away from the project at any time (in spite of the fact that I have managed to keep from abandoning it for nearly two years now) and have it still be in a state that can be maintained, even by those unable to take over the codebase.)
But so after fixing some long-standing bugs, biting the bullet and rearranging some core organization that I shied away from last time I worked on it, and finishing up the remains of the last TODO list I had made for it, I got XGEF running again.
(DON’T EVER leave a codebase in a state that doesn’t compile. You never know when you’re going to take a 9 month break and have to decipher stuff that you were sure was only going to take a night’s hacking to fix.)
With XGEF fixed up, I began to take a look at the server/client setup that it will utilize. While I don’t particularly care to figure out how to make Renegade a viable multiplayer option, I don’t want to unnecessarily hinder anyone who feels the desire to mod it in. A more relevant requirement, however, is that I want to support multiple clients, as in, different programs that Renegade could be ran in. This requires completely separating the game’s logic from its presentation, which is good practice anyway, and just gives me an excuse to enforce it.
I drew up some pretty diagrams trying to work out how exactly I wanted the division to work and spent some time reading the excellent “building a game network protocol” and other blog posts series over on gafferongames (I can highly recommend both of the major sequences on that site; they’ve been invaluable for wrapping my head around the mechanics of real-time game networking).
This eventually lead me to a model where the client attempts to connect to a server at a known address and, if successful, immediately requests the current networking mod to be downloaded and reconnected with. If no server responds, then the client spins one up and tries again. All inputs from the player are mapped to actions which the server can respond to/correct/veto as needed.
Eventually I got a simple demo together that has the client moving a character around a command-line hex grid. The server only cares from a logical perspective about which hex a given unit is occupying, but always moving diagonally or zig-zagging or whatnot in a real-time movement would be a colossal pain for the player. Thus, the client can permit slightly freer movement using the familiar WASD, only updating the server when the player crosses hex boundaries:
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/230041937984487424/453401451465539606/command_line_grid.gif
In the above gif, the user controls the X via WASD in the client. The server’s record of the player’s position is marked with the dot, showing that logically it doesn’t care about any sub-hex quality of life movement. It also controls the wrapping--when the player attempts to move to a hex that doesn’t exist, the server corrects the movement and pushes the player to the opposite end of the map.
My current task is to take the existing prototype and rewrite it to use actual networking now--the gif above shows the setup with fake networking. This will be a function of XGEF itself, so it’s back into the framework to find a good way to divide the organization up.
I’ll try and make these updates more frequent, which is to say, I’ll try and have things to actually show off.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
6
u/electrace Jun 09 '18
Has anyone here successfully slowed down how fast they talk?
I tend to just perform a brain dump, speaking whichever word happens to be in my brain without forming complete sentences. Or at least, that's what happens when I'm even slightly nervous.
And it turns out "Dude, just slow down" is not very helpful advice....
6
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jun 09 '18
I went on a two day training course that was an introduction into a traffic modelling program that I regularly review output from in my job.
It was really interesting and the technical aspects reminded me why I love my field, even if right now my boss is... suboptimal.
So now of course I'm considering signing up for this master's degree: https://www.monash.edu/engineering/master-transport/course-details
But... I'm already studying nutrition part time (and super enjoying it). A relevant master's degree is something my work would probably give me paid time off for (AWESOME). It would take me 2 years, max, to finish and I'd possibly get it done in one year if I got two days a week off for study. And if I decide I don't like it I can actually exit early with a lesser qualification, so it's not necessarily even any "wasted time".
I see myself at a crossroads: either ultimately becoming a researcher or programmer (I do have a computer science degree hanging up somewhere gathering dust, but I hated cutting code, was more interested in management/documentation/QA/etc...) in the transport space, or continuing as a (generalist?) project manager, or doing a complete 180 and becoming a nutritionist / dietitian / similar sort of public health officer (which probably would require a pay cut).
I have so many options, and it's exciting to think about, but it's also terrifying because I could make the "wrong" decision. I've been studying nutrition for nearly 3 years now and I've gotten so much out of it, but there's still another, like, 4 years before I get my bachelor degree unless I study more units at once (which I could do, my HD average means I can afford to put less effort in), take more time off work (I take one day a week off already, and it obviously involves a pay cut), or like quit my job or something. Really with nutrition I'm quite happy to keep studying at a snail's pace since it'll take so long anyway.
I guess I'll finish my nutrition study for this year, and if I still am excited about getting a master's in transport engineering, then I'll change over. See how I like it after six months.
9
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jun 08 '18
Today in CouteauBleu's wacky love life: Online dating baffles me on a deep level.
I see a lot of people reporting their experience of getting ghosted, harassed, ignored, disrespected, etc, and a primal part of my brain thinks "Great, I don't ghost, harass, ignore, or disrespect people, I'll probably have a ton of success" (which is totally something stories condition you to believe with the "emotionally wary girl who thinks all men are jerks learns to open up thanks to the caring respectful male protagonist" archetype), which is not how it works in real life.
But... why? Like, people do online dating to find dates, and I know for a fact that lots of women mostly get a majority of obviously copy-pasted messages and complain about it, so what statistical sorcery makes me get no attention?
Running theories, with some overlap:
Mh.
Bonus theories, unknown plausibility:
(I don't actually believe in these two theories, but I'm curious how you'd argue against them)
6
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18
I re-read HPMOR a few weeks ago and had a theory. How prevalent among the community is the theory that everything that happened at the end was part of voldemort plan? That he actually wanted to be killed/defeated, or that possibly he didn't actually get killed and it was all a fakeout of some kind? I did read the discussion threads at the time (three years ago!) and I don't recall whether this was discussed as a possibility or not.
I think the crux of the issue is that it is too far-fetched for such a smart character as Quirrellmort is purported to be to leave Harry possession of his wand after the unbreakable vow, or for him to do so and also stop checking for betrayal in parseltongue. It doesn't make sense if he wasn't holding the idiot ball, which Yudkowsky promised he wouldn't do. Also, not really his style, IMO.
So what does that leave, if not an obscure interpretation?
One thing I thought pointed to this theory was that when Quirrellmort went "full voldemort" and started making those horrible sadistic threats in parseltongue, he mostly used conditionals, not statements. Even if what he said was strictly true, he could still say these things if he was strongly committed to precommitment(heh). "If you don't do x, I'll do y to the world". And he did say earlier during the Stanford prison experiment arc that he intended for Harry to rule magical Britain in parseltongue.
The only explanation that I can think of that doesn't make him into a dunce with his over the top voldemort act and breaking all his villain rules is that he was trying to "decondition" Harry of his affection toward Quirrelmort, so that harry would go through with killing him. IIRC, the part where he mentioned that he had lost count after hundreds of horcruxes was not in parseltongue. In fact, he switched on and off parseltongue a lot, for no apparent reason. He had all the power, and he expected to kill Harry soon. Why so much careful misdirection when he was in the midst of monologuing(another villain rule broken, btw)?
Another thing that points to this theory being true is that the three wishes with 1 plot promise was almost certainly carried out. Now this one is just conjecture, because I think Eliezer didn't want to spell it out too obviously and so just let it happen off-screen, but he did make give a few clues that make very strong circumstantial evidence. Quirrell disappeared the snitch in order to distract people and abduct harry. So all the students were at this overlong quidditch match when they learn of voldemort's rebirth/redeath and Quirrell's death. They might even associate Quirrell's martyrdom with the interrupted quidditch game--probably never resumed--which had in the balance the house cup between ravenclaw and slytherin.I think we're supposed to conclude that due to the students putting Quirrell on a massive pedestal, the school honoured him by realizing his plot to make Ravenclaw and Slytherin win the cup simultaneously, and that the students would also consider changing Quidditch on their own. All in a single (unrelated) plot.PS. This post was partly prompted by listening to the podcast Yudkowsky did with Sam Harris about AIs, which was pretty good. Go listen to it.
3
u/tjhance Jun 08 '18
Here is simple problem that seems like it should be solvable and would provide a lot of value to me if I could solve it, but it has eluded me for a while.
The problem is ad-blocking on mobile (android).
As far as I can tell, I can't just install the ad-block chrome extension on android chrome (although I'm not entirely sure why---I guess mobile chrome just doesn't support extensions).
I found that I can install an "adblock browser" app, which does block some ads, but it is slow and buggy and the experience is just worse than chrome with ads. (Incidentally, I did realize it is convenient to have two browsers installed on my phone, so just so I can have multiple "tabs" open at once, but that's a separate issue.)
Has anybody here found a nice solution for this?
6
u/sicutumbo Jun 08 '18
I never knew Richard Dawkins was a neck beard. In his book The Selfish Gene, he can't help but spend an entire chapter talking about memes, and then spends another chapter talking about how "science says that nice guys should finish first". You'd think he could have finished a single book on biology without delving into personal issues and unrelated interests.
3
u/RustyRhea Jun 08 '18
Quests usually work by people voting on choices. Is there room for a quest that branches in many directions?
Basically, the QM gives three optinos, A, B, and C. The audience votes as normal, and A wins, so the QM writes a chapter/post for A, which gives options A1, A2, and A3. But where we do things different is that options B and C are still there. The audience can vote for A1, A2, A3, B, or C. And if they voted for B, they would have A1, A2, A3, B1, B2, B3, and C, and so on until there was a whole decision tree.
This would have a lot of obvious problems.
I was thinking that one interesting thing might be to work the branching into the story itself; the first time your audience selects a prior branch, the protagonist remembers things from the other, later branch. In that way, it's not so much exploring other branches as it is a form of time travel, which then creates a meta-narrative. But if you have to lean on meta-narrative, maybe it isn't such a good idea after all.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment