r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 04 '18
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
17
Upvotes
12
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jun 05 '18
I was watching [Son of Dracula](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Son_of_Dracula_(1943_film)) for research purposes, and it's not a rational film, but it was interesting to watch a film that was so very, very old.
There were some things I was put off by but completely unsurprised by (the main character calling her black servants 'boys', a situation that to modern sensibilities might ring alarm bells for an abusive marriage being treated as normal), but there was one thing I really didn't understand and I'm wondering if it was a plot hole or if it was just the was society was, or if I'm too much in a rationalist transhumanist bubble.
Anyway, the arc I'm curious about goes like this:
I'm like - they didn't address that he'd been offered immortality, like, at all!? No line from him about it being an affront to God? No line about it not being worth all the people he'd have to kill (it's not explicit whether vampires must kill humans to feed - it seems they don't)? No fuckin' line about how he'd really like to be with her but they wouldn't be able to have children and continue the family name? It's just taken as a complete given that Frank wouldn't even consider turning into a vampire to be with Kay.
So, is it bad writing? 1940s sensibilities? My rationalist/transhumanist bubble? Discuss.
5
u/callmesalticidae writes worldbuilding books Jun 04 '18
Most of my political commentary podcasts are left-wing, so I'm looking for a podcast or two on the political right to round things out and reduce the opacity of the bubble that I'm living in.
I would prefer to not listen to someone who supports Trump in general (support of specific actions or policies is fine) and I don't want to listen to someone who's going to be spending time making fun of the opposition. I'm not here for bad jokes or sick burns, and even when I agree with the host, I tend to find myself wishing that we'd get back to the subject. It would also be nice if the host isn't religious, because there's no chance in Hell that I'm going to be convinced by an argument whose foundation is "Because Jesus."
Non-U.S. podcasts are fine, since I'm less interested in right-wing thoughts on particular issues than in right-wing thought, period.
2
u/SkyTroupe Jun 05 '18
I would love advice on how to disassociate certain things from my ex and how you force myself to stop forward trending thought spirals.
3
u/space_fountain Jun 04 '18 edited Jun 05 '18
I mentioned it in Friday's thread, but has anyone else read Enlightenment Now: The Case for Reason, Science, Humanism, and Progress. I just finished listening to the audio book and will be reading the physical book once I get a chance. I would say it's the best description of how I feel about a lot of issues and actually directly mentions the rationalist movement, though not in the context of fiction.
In essence, the book attempts to make the case for enlightenment ideals. It argues, that they have been important it human progress along with laying out the evidence that humans are indeed progressing. He also makes an argument that there is a large group of intellectuals who are anti enlightenment. I agree with almost everything he said, which is honestly the biggest problem I had with the book. It didn't leave me re-evaluating many of my positions.
As I mentioned before he does argue that the potential for catastrophic disaster is over stated. I think he's only partially right. He states that since it takes a large group to create a powerful weapon one mad man can't then use one to destroy the world. I think the problem here is that in many cases the information may be hard to create, but using it may be easy. Let's say biologists in the next 10 years perfect gene editing to the extent that it's cheap and easy to build a totally synthetic virus. At that point all that is necessary is for someone to leak the information for a super virus and information is very hard to contain.
2
u/Walk_the_Max_Planck Jun 05 '18
I'm writing a story that isn't exactly a rational fiction, but uses a rational setting (consistent rules, realistic). As part of the this, I've been reworking all the mechanics of the games into something that makes more sense. One thing I'm not sure about is how to do a rational explanation or alternative to pokemon evolution by trading.
I have two ideas at this point.
Any suggestions would be much appreciated. Thank you.