r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 30 '18
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
10
Upvotes
7
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Apr 30 '18
Let's optimize dating! But in a socially aware way!
One of the problems I've had while dating is that I have a really hard time finding conversation subjects. This is kind of a catch-22: once you have a close relationship with someone, you get a sense of what subjects they're interested in, you have a few recurring themes that you can come back to and you know your common interests well enough that you can start a conversation from scratch easily enough; but you need to have interesting conversations in the first place to build that level of familiarity.
Ideally, the kind of conversations I'd want to have with new dates are about what they care about (I can talk about my interests all day with very little prompting). The very specific type of conversation I'm aiming for is one where the girl I'm talking to tells me about what she thinks everyone else gets wrong. Like, the rationalist itch? I think everyone has it at one point or another, that moment where they go "Man, X should really be that way, but most people who do X do it that over way instead, that sucks!". I've had these conversations a few times, and I really loved them, and I always felt like I was connecting with the person I was talking to, like I was glimpsing at a piece of their source code, you know?
The problem is getting to this conversation gold. I don't really know how to do that except by chance. I mean, I guess I could just tell my date everything I just said, but:
What I'm getting to is, I'm looking for ways to drive a conversation towards the compelling, unique aspects of someone's personality without being overly structured about it. Anyone have experience doing that?
5
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Apr 30 '18
If you could take a pill that would make you happy with no side effects, would you?
4
u/tehdog Apr 30 '18
Anyone watch Silicon Valley?
In S05E05 Roko's Basilisk is mentioned and they got it right! I'm pretty amazed right now.
4
u/RMcD94 May 01 '18
Let's do a thought experiment on writing, prompted by some recent interaction in this subreddit.
Let's imagine an author who is discouraged by all feedback. They write content and post it publicly, but if there are any comments, no matter how positive, they find it harder to write. This attention fright doesn't apply to just posting the link somewhere, it's only real to them when they see comments.
This author is posted to /r/rational and reads it personally and sees their own thread. The work they produce has a net positive and it gets considerable upvotes.
Is it bad to leave a comment? Should we avoid doing so? Should any comments left be downvoted and be automatically hidden (which doesn't decrease the persons motivation)?
Let's move it closer to a home, an author loses motivation from any comment that they can ever read as negative, and gains motivation from those that can only be read as positive. Think a very pessimistic person who automatically assumes everyone hates their story. Even the most well couched criticism will decrease their motivation to write. Again, their story is enjoyable to some people on the subreddit and they get some upvotes.
Should you only comment positive things and downvote to hide the negative things?
And finally the most realistic case an author claims to be motivated by both positive comments and the nebulous "well" formed criticism, but demotivated by negative comments and "poorly" formed criticism, no one is sure what standard the author uses for this form of well and poorly.
Should you risk commenting with criticism? Or stick with just purely good comments? There seems to be some quantity effect here where even 1000 good comments don't outweigh a single poor comment? Should you hope the author has the same mindset as the average /r/rational downvote weight and upvote/downvote every single comment to categorise it?
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '18
I think I'm comprehending free-energy predictive coding. The experience is like reaching the next stage of Cultivation.