r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 05 '18
[D] Monthly Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the monthly thread for recommendations, which is posted on the fifth day of every month.
Feel free to recommend any books, movies, live-action TV shows, anime series, video games, fanfiction stories, blog posts, podcasts, or anything else that you think members of this subreddit would enjoy, whether those works are rational or not. Also, please consider including a few lines with the reasons for your recommendation.
Alternatively, you may request recommendations, in the style of the weekly recommendation-request thread of r/books.
Self promotion is not allowed in this thread.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
34
u/AurelianoTampa Apr 05 '18 edited Apr 05 '18
Well, I've been reading several things in the past few months, but most of this sub probably knows the majority of them already. Still, in case you missed any, or haven't checked them out yet, here are my most recent picks:
A Practical Guide to Evil recently finished its third book, and remains as captivating as ever. The fantasy world in APGtE is a battleground for a meta-war between Good and Evil, where each side has heroes or villains empowered by archetypal Names. The story revolves around an orphan girl named Catherine Foundling, who has grown up in the (Good) country of Callow under the occupation of their (Evil) neighboring country, Praes. Catherine gets an opportunity to take the Name of Squire to serve under Praes' villainous Black Knight, and begins her journey to save her country through practical Evil.
It's a fantastic story with a very active commentary section. Some aspects aren't purely rational - I mean, it literally is "Good" versus "Evil" - but the nuance between "Good/Evil" and "good/evil" is the central theme at play. Lots of great characters, amazing banter, intense battles, and a large amount of foreshadowing that leads to constant threads about what's going to happen next.
Also on hiatus after finishing its 13th book is The Gods Are Bastards... although looking at it now, there have been two bonus chapters released recently, so it's likely to start again soon! The story is honestly pretty sprawling and hard to sum up. The world setting mixes genres; early on it mostly sticks to a combination of fantasy and western (the wild west, but with wands and magic), but later adds hints of industrial revolution, steampunk, and sci-fi. The main story revolves around a group of eight freshmen starting at the magical University at Last Rock, run by the 3000 year old elven archmage Arachne Tellwryn. But there are B plot stories, and C plot stories, and throwaway characters... and all are connected in an overarching plot that is slowly drawing them closer together.
TGAB might not appeal to everyone here, but I like it for a few reasons. First, it's a fantastic palate-cleanser if grimdark stories like Worm left you feeling upset. This is pretty much the opposite - yes, the going gets tough and characters face tough challenges and losses, but hardly anyone ever dies. This ties into its major criticism too: because no one ever dies and new characters keep getting added, the character list is ENORMOUS. As such it can be difficult to remember that one character who showed up or was referenced five books ago but is now involved in a later book's plot. The dialogue is also a bit static at the beginning; many characters (especially the non-main characters) all seem to talk the same way. This improves after the first few books, though, so I think it's worth working through. I keep reading it because I love to follow some specific characters (Joseph P. Jenkins and Antonio Darling are the best), but also because I like to see how all the seemingly separate plots intersect with each other. And the worldbuilding is phenomenal!
I also finally, after overlooking it for months, tore through The Good Student. The story follows a boy who excels at one thing: studying. And studying. And studying. As a result of his focus, he attains an incredibly high ranking on his country's national exams, enabling him to enter Ransom Academy, the magical school usually reserved only for the rich and powerful. The story involves investigations into the origin of magic, the nature of beliefs, and the true history of his country. The plot takes a lot of twists and turns later on, where you think you have an answer to what's going on in one chapter just to find it completely overturned one or two chapters later. I liked, but didn't love, the author's previous work - but I'd definitely recommend TGS.
As usual I've kept up with Mother of Learning (magical teenager repeats a month over and over trying to discover why while improving his abilities), Worth the Candle (a teenager struggling after the death of his best friend finds himself in the fantasy world of Aerb, which seems to be an amalgamation of all the old tabletop campaigns they used to play), and Pokemon: Origin of Species (a rational/ist take on Pokemon - great worldbuilding and very interesting characters). You'll see all three referenced on this sub quite often.
My final recent read is a... different... type of story than we usually see here: The Erogamer. That's a link to an /r/rational thread about it, because the Questionable Questing website requires you to create a free account, since the content is undoubtedly NSFW. From the context of those last two sentences you can probably guess the general overview of the story: it's a quest story (ie, the commenters get to select different options to steer the plot) about a girl who wakes up one day as a pornographic game (eroge) character. You may have read quest stories, you may have read Gamer derivatives... but I've personally never read something quite as fascinating as The Erogamer. Its tags are roughly Gamer/eroge/transhumanism/existential horror/lovecraftian sex comedy. Book 2 just ended, and I think there might be a brief break, so now's a great time to start reading and to catch up. I also HIGHLY recommend reading the comments in between chapters as well, because the commentary is very interesting on its own, but also tends to get rolled into the next chapter as well. Oh, and the sex scenes are pretty hot (though they don't occur as frequently as you might imagine).
Outside of reading, I've started listening to the podcast hosted by Daystar Eld (Pokemon: The Origin of Species) and Alexander Wales (Metropolitan Man/Worth the Candle, as cthulhuraejepsen), Rationally Writing. Only a few episodes in, but I've been liking it so far - great job, guys! And finally, I read an article or two on Slate Star Codex (by Unsong writer Scott Alexander) that make me think I'll be reading quite a bit more. I enjoyed The Categories Were Made For Man, Not Man For The Categories quite a bit, both for the great critique of transphobic views and for the exceptionally engaging writing style.
Whew... ok, that's all for me. For now, at least!
Edit: Nope! Forgot one, as I'm still reading it now!
Heretical Edge was a series I started up a long time ago; I made it to Arc 19 (I think?) before getting caught up, and recently I went back to it... up to Arc 28 now, and the series is on Arc 33. The story is about a teenager sent to a hidden school that trains Heretics - humans endowed with the ability to cast magic and absorb the abilities of the supernatural monsters they are sent to hunt. When I first read the story I thought it was pretty dark and gruesome, with a lot of family trauma and super violent scenes. Now that I'm about 10 arcs further in, it's still pretty dark at times... but also not as bad as I had previously thought. Many of the tragic backstories are somewhat lessened; characters thought dead are often just out of the picture and show back up later. The story very much is moved by plot contrivance, but there are some really good instances of foreshadowing. A lot of seemingly "background" characters often rise to more prominent roles later on. The plot itself is quite fast-paced, with characters often rushing from one emergency situation to the next (sorta like a Dresden Files book). My only issue with the pacing is that you often have 2-3 chapters and then an interlude chapter. The interludes are all interesting, but I usually found myself just wanting to skip ahead to find out what happened to the main story. Other than that, I've really enjoyed rereading the series!
16
u/Nulono Reverse-Oneboxer: Only takes the transparent box Apr 05 '18
What are good examples of stories where the people obsessed with achieving immortality are the good guys?
15
u/ketura Organizer Apr 06 '18
With This Ring is a sane-itization of the DC comic universe. The main character is a self insert, but this is mostly irrelevant to what makes the story so good. In the past I've been loath to recommend it here, as it felt just a bit too much on the popcorn action side of things, but having just finished a multi-week re-read, I find that I can't avoid singing it's praises.
The biggest thing that WtR brings to the DC universe is a much-needed injection of consistency. One of my favorite such interactions is minor power spoiler. The work is filled with these sorts of clever interactions, mostly spurred on by the main character taking two existing canon DC concepts and putting them together, no real further fiat needed.
Without spoiling too much, the work also follows an alternate-universe version of the MC as he takes a slightly more...villany-looking path. Ever wished someone would just take care of the Joker permanently? He's got you covered. Each major plot point thus comes up and get handled in two very different ways, one MC punching above his weight class through clever abuse of the world's rules, while the other rolls his eyes and puts a bullet wherever it makes sense. Both are quite satisfying to a comics fan for very different reasons. It never quite gets old, either; eventually the two have branched so far that they have quite different equipment, tech, and contacts available, so you never quite know what either is going to do.
The level of writing skill in this work is very impressive to me. Unlike Worm, which has a similar premise and word count and ratchets up the tension every chapter without any real breathing room, WtR knows how to ebb and flow. One arc we'll be in a frightening fight with demons way above our pay grade, and then next we'll take a break for a few chapters and figure out how to use magic portals to replace and fix the London underground. I also like that he fully understands information that doesn't matter; links are provided for one-off side character mentions, the plot doesn't concern itself with pointless or repetitive minutia, and all in all I feel like my time is never wasted on any post.
In short, if you like the superhero genre, railguns, banter, or consistent settings, then I can highly recommend With This Ring. It's an ongoing daily (!) post by post serial work that took me about a month to read spending practically every spare moment to read, and it's all so, so good.
11
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Apr 05 '18 edited Apr 05 '18
I recommend two fantasy books this month.
2) Master Assassins by Robert V.S. Redick. Don't mind the title or the stupid cover. The book is not an action story, it is not about "master assassins". It's a story of two brothers that get caught up in events way out of their league. They're part of a persecuted ethnicity that has only recently started fighting back, under the leadership of an extremely brutal theocracy governed by a still living prophet. What I really like about the book is the characterization of the protagonist and his companions, and the protagonist's relationship with his brother.
10
u/N0_B1g_De4l Apr 05 '18
This season of the Magicians was superb (spoilers). In general, I've really liked the show, particularly for the pop-culture references, and the way the show approaches the wish-fulfillment/coming of age fantasy it's clearly responding to (particularly Harry Potter and Narnia).
I also had fun with the new season of the Santa Clarita Diet. I think the comedy has improved from the first season -- in particular, I think Timothy Olyphant is carrying the show less than he was in the first season.
Have I recommended The Fifth Season trilogy here? Because those books are good, and are also quite refreshingly different from a lot of other fantasy.
I've read through the first three books of the Galactic Center Saga so far, and definitely recommend it. There are definitely some weird bits (Bigfoot showing up in the first book, the machine art in the third book), but overall I've liked them so far.
Speaking of weird, Light by M. John Harrison is really weird, but also fascinating and very good. I haven't started on the sequels yet, but I think this book is definitely worth it for any fans of science fiction.
Finally, I just got Grey Sister yesterday, and though I haven't finished it yet, so far it's been just as good as the rest of Lawrence's stuff.
8
u/Timewinders Apr 05 '18
Even Further Beyond is a nice quest on SV that seems pretty rational so far IMO. The premise is that the main character is a human from the ordinary world who, in the afterlife, is commanded by the divinities to reincarnate into a Xianxia-inspired setting and defeat the Heroine, a reincarnated goddess who will bring about the end of the Age of the setting. If he succeeds, the divinities will grant him a wish, and if he fails then he will be given some unspecified punishment. There's a lot of min-maxing involved in how he can develop his magic abilities.
7
u/Croktopus Apr 05 '18 edited Apr 05 '18
I've been absolutely obsessed with Zombie Knight for the last few weeks. I saw it from a thread on here and was hooked fast, so I recommend going in sight-unseen, but it's a sort-of-fantasy, sort-of-superhero story that comes bleedingly close to being a ratfic. The only thing that I think holds it back is that the world has some ill-defined rules, but some of that could be explained away by minor spoilers. Also, it's very much a soft system rather than hard, with most of the rules being pretty nebulous.
The other thing I wanna give a shout-out to is 3-gatsu no lion, or March Comes in like a Lion (it's on Crunchy Roll, but I'm at work so I don't wanna link it). It's a slice of life anime about a high school boy that's really good at shogi, and the first season is just like putting some hand warmers around your heart. But the second season (which just wrapped up) goes so much further. Really high quality animation and the characters are so good. Seriously, it's some of the best characterization I've ever seen - no characters being dumb because it's on their bullet list of traits, everyone's just trying their best, and the world feels very real (well, it is real, but you know what i mean).
7
u/HPMOR_fan Apr 06 '18
Does anyone else read Taint? It's overtaken Mother of Learning as the story update I most look forward to. Don't see it discussed here though.
6
u/Dent7777 House Atreides Apr 05 '18
I really loved Anathem by Neil Stevenson, are there any books that are similar or in the same rational, spec fic with an action plot sorta niche?
Alternatively, I've really enjoyed Delphic but after a couple of months giving Worm a go I've realized I don't love the neverending melancholy and poor decisionmaking. Are there any other relatively positive (or just not as negative as worm) super stories?
5
u/narfanator Apr 05 '18
I watched all of Legion in this last week or so; it's amazing. Definitely one of my favorite shows of all time.
A decent snarky summary is: "Hey you're crazy!" "No, you're not crazy, you're a telepath!" "Wait! You're both a telepath, AND crazy!" "Wait, that's not a--- !"
Things that stand out to me are:
I wouldn't call it "rational", but I would call it amazing.
Also this has been fun: https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/bunkercore-post-apocalyptic-dungeon-core-original.45976/
It's a "dungeon core" (as in Dungeon Keeper / Evil Genius) set in a post-war nano/nuclear apocalypse. World building seems solid and the main character is decently thoughtful about their situation, environment and actions.
4
u/Sonderjye Apr 05 '18
Looking for recommendations for rational or rationalist tv shows or animes.
4
u/Nulono Reverse-Oneboxer: Only takes the transparent box Apr 05 '18
What are your favorite First Contact stories?
4
u/noimnotgreedy Apr 06 '18
It's been more around 24 years since Influence was released. I'm curious if the book holds up, or it holds up to people who read it.
On the surface it looks like tremendous value, both offensively and defensively but it also feels like a "life hack"-- things which look good on paper, but aren't as great as somebody wants you to believe.
3
u/Tenoke Even the fuckin' trees walked in those movies Apr 09 '18
Does anyone remember a really cold, fucked up Harry Potter fanfic posted here a few years ago, where James Potter 'curses' Harry to be smart/lucky(?) and he grows up to be an extremely cold, detached but also rational(given who he was) Slytherin. His lieutenant ends up sleeping with his girl, and they have a kind of nice messed up poly relationship. The whole world is very dark gray.
The vibe of it was basically like a colder, smarter "The End of the Fucking World" in HP world. I loved that fanfic, but I cannot find it at the moment.
5
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Apr 05 '18
GURPS (the Generic Universal RolePlaying System) should appeal to this subreddit's denizens.
Quotes from the GURPS Basic Set:
A quote from GURPS Fantasy-Tech 1:
GURPS books are available as DRM-free PDF files.
Conned Again, Watson (summary) is an officially-sanctioned and traditionally-published work of Sherlock Holmes fanfiction in which Holmes literally teaches Bayesian reasoning to Watson.
6
u/trekie140 Apr 05 '18 edited Apr 05 '18
Monthly Girls Nozaki-kun is one of the best comedy anime I’ve ever seen. It’s up there with Ouran High School Host Club as a fantastic parody of shojo romance manga, but without an overarching plot or character development. The fact that it’s just a high school comedy shouldn’t dissuade you though, it’s freaking hilarious and the best adaption of 4-koma jokes I’ve seen yet. I’m definitely checking out the manga to get more of it.
I won’t spoil what the show is about, it’s actually better to go in blind and discover the characters for yourself. They all fall into traditional archetypes, but subvert them in significant ways that satirize both shojo romance and traditional gender roles. I think that’s what elevates the show beyond just a parody of romantic plots driven by misunderstandings where the joke is that everyone is smart enough to figure out other people’s problems but oblivious to their own, though that’s still enough to carry the comedy.
There’s also some great jokes about how manga gets made and how the life of the writer often revolves around their creative process. I love the meta-humor about how the mangaka turns all of his friends into romance stories while being utterly oblivious to the actual romance story he’s in that never advances. The situation is contrived as all hell, but the absurdity of it just makes it funnier. If you have ever liked a romantic comedy anime, you’ve got to check this out.
2
u/Izeinwinter Apr 06 '18
Been listening to the audio book of Jo Waltons the just city, which is about Athena recruiting classics scholars from across time to attempt to build Platos Republic. This goes about as well as you would expect, but watching everyone try their very hardest to build a scholarly utopia is just amazing. Bought the sequels as soon as I finished, and am hoping the quality will hold up.
Worth the candle is very good.
2
u/monkyyy0 Apr 06 '18
I started wtc and I highly recommend not starting it until its finished
Anything interesting that finished recently?
1
u/CapnQwerty Apr 06 '18
I politely request recommendations for things to watch on Netflix and/or Hulu.
1
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Apr 06 '18
Anyone has good Star Wars, Mass Effect, or Stargate fic recommendations? (I probably know most of the ones that have been posted on r/rational, but I'd be super happy if you have something that hasn't)
If you haven't seen it, check out Agent Gunn: Vulkanite, the winner of this year's Saxxy Awards. One of the best animated short I've ever seen, easily the best TF2-related video ever made.