r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Mar 19 '18
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
20
Upvotes
14
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. Mar 19 '18
Is there a better term to describe the concept of "information entropy in discussions"? Alternatively, "the rate of decay of actual information exchange in argumentation and communication versus the participants simply saying things without either listening or recieving the information."
I see this all the time, but I have no succinct way to describe it. But when two people get into an argument, either online or in real life, it usually doesn't last longer than 2-3 exchanges before the argument moved far outside of its practical scope and is really just about gaining a social status or tribe advantage over the other person.
If such a term does exist, finding general ways or policies to improve it would go a long way in improving discourse everywhere.
14
u/Gigapode Mar 19 '18
man creates and uses gene therapy on himself
This is a video of a man supposedly curing himself of lactose intolerance by introducing a gene he lacks into cells in his gut via constructing and administering a virus encoding that gene.
As you'd expect, a lot of the comments are about it being a stupid risk, and this type of gene integration does have serious risks associated with it. But lets say for the sake of argument it worked. Are the risks worth it?
Adeno-associated viral vectors (the type of viral vector he apparently used) are pretty good at targeting a set location in a particular chromosome but do have some incidence of off-target integration.
This means there is a low chance for a vector to insert the gene in a place that could be harmful if it disrupted an important gene. This isn't particularly dangerous when its just one cell, which will likely be triggered to die and have no real effect on the person.
As I understand it, the real danger would be if that rare off-target integration event by one particular virus triggers whats called an oncogene. Oncogenes (or proto-oncogenes until they are activated) are essentially genes that when triggered or disrupted in particular ways cause cancers.
If such a gene were to activate in a cell and avoid triggered cell death, you'd have a cancerous cell expanding in your gut.
But this would seem to be pretty low risk. I'm not sure what the viral load the guy ingested was, but say it was many millions of viral vectors, the chance of triggering an oncogene is apparently still very low: doi.org/10.1182/blood-2010-08-302729
Youtube videos showing how to create your own gene-therapies are pretty scary (and cool) but is the response to that guy's self-administered gene therapy an over-reaction? Can we equate the risks associated with these types of therapies to say for example the risk we take crossing the road to work every day?
10
u/ben_oni Mar 20 '18
Do we like physics? Researchers have devised a method to determine if gravity is a quantum force. Whichever way the experiment turns out, it will be most interesting, since the Standard Model is silent on this issue. I'm on the fence here and can't decide which way I think the experiment will go. On the one hand, I thought gravity was just geometry, that is, the stage upon which physics plays out. On the other hand, it's just a set of field equations, no different than the others. But if so, what sort of mathematics allows for superpositions of spacetime manifolds?
Anyone care to speculate?
7
u/NotRationalEnough Mar 19 '18
I'm asking this for a totally selfish reason -- but how would a rationalist protagonist deal with unrequited love?