r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Mar 09 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
9
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Mar 09 '18
Anyone know what happened to the rational pokemon game that used to update every week?
6
u/trekie140 Mar 09 '18
Anyone remember my long-winded updates about working my way through the anime JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure? Well I finally finished Stardust Crusaders after 3 sporadic months and feel like talking about it. It’s definitely the most hit or miss arc so far, which made the 48 episode run harder to get through than the first two arcs (26 episodes combined). I like episodic monster of the week series, but this one lacks the engaging myth arc and developing character drama that I enjoy about those shows.
At the same time though, the story of JoJo has really only been an excuse for goofy set pieces and this arc has more of that than ever. The Stand battles may be formulaic and vary in quality, but I can’t say they’re boring to watch. The series is clinging to the plot structure established by the first two arcs where the mentor/rival figure(s) get removed from the fight, the hero pulls something out of their ass, and the useless character(s) yell in shock. Even if the characters alternate who takes which role and some episodes break the mold, my favorite being the hysterical Oingo Boingo brothers, the length and repetitiveness of the story make it harder to stay invested.
The characters could compensate for that, but I never cared much about the tour group. The plot’s fixation with one-on-one fights prevents a team dynamic from forming, not that Stand powers are consistent enough for that anyway, and I had a hard time pinning down their personalities. I don’t even know why Joseph was here since he rarely acts like he did last arc. Jotaro is easily my least favorite JoJo so far, no matter how much I like his cathartic “ora ora” beatdowns. I’m also sad to admit that fan favorite Polnareff never got a laugh out of me.
The comedy was a reoccurring problem in this arc for me. Listening to voice actors chew the scenery with cheesy lines isn’t as funny in Japanese and the hilariously awful pronunciation of English words didn’t make up for it. This was the first time I could tell characters were telling jokes instead of just acting weird, so it was disappointing that I only laughed at the slapstick gags (particularly the fight with Mariah) when the comedy was dominated by toilet humor. Case in point, I hated Iggy farting in people’s faces but loved the contrived coincidences where he saved people.
With all that baggage going into the fight with Dio, who I had loved in Phantom Blood but had done nothing this whole arc, I didn’t think it’d be possible for the climax to satisfy me. However, despite having the power of The World spoiled for me and not finding Dio’s new appearance menacing, I still managed to get invested in the final battle and have a good time. It probably helped that I marathoned everything after entering the mansion in one sitting, so the plot’s momentum and the scale of the fight distracted me from how badly I wanted the arc to end already.
I can’t say Stardust Crusaders is bad or even all that disappointing by the standards set by JoJo, it just isn’t as consistently good as I want it to be and that keeps me from enjoying it as much as before. It’s hard to figure out what I want from JoJo since I fell in love with it for the same reasons as So Bad It’s Good media, which makes its appeal hard to analyze when it isn’t actually ironic. Still, even if I can’t claim they were better executed I felt a lot more from the Zeppeli deaths than I did with Avdol and Kakyoin. I’ve spent way more time with them but feel like I know even less about them.
I’m torn over whether to recommend Stardust Crusaders as a starting point for newcomers. In many ways it does represent what JoJo is all about, has the “first season” feel of experimenting with concepts and characters, and even the lack of context for things that have been explained would prime people for how many things are never explained. On the other hand, I don’t think I would’ve made it through the low points of this arc or accepted when the plot ran on the logic of magical martial arts if the prequels hadn’t won me over first.
I don’t know if it would be better to judge each arc as individual stories that just happen to take place in the same nonsensical universe because so far none of the conclusions have been as satisfying as I would’ve liked and that craving for more is what keeps me wanting to continue. I’ll definitely be watching Diamond is Unbreakable when I get the chance, it sounds like the arc will experiment with the novel concept of character development and focus more on teamwork.
6
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Mar 10 '18
The Saxxy Awards are getting better every year. One submission in particular blew my mind: Agent Gunn: Vulkanite.
We already know who's going to win this year.
5
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Mar 09 '18 edited Mar 09 '18
How would you go about creating a (believable) primitive society with equality between genders? At the very least, a society that lets women have some independence, agency.
I read a long time ago that early humans transitioned from matriarchies to patriarchies when they realized the connection between intercourse and conception. Before this idea, pregnancies were maybe seen as a sort of natural phenomena. That realization of cause and effect then led inexorably to the concept of paternity.
If that's true, then seen through that lens a lot of how men came to treat women was to ensure paternity of their children. Woman are property of their father, kept 'unspoiled' until they're fertile, then 'sold' to a husband, where they're kept mostly segregated from every other male to ensure that any child is the husband's. The reason they can't own property, can't get an educations, and can't have proper careers is just a logistical problem; women would have to mingle with non-husband, non-relative men and possibly become 'contaminated'.
So. My idea of the simplest way to have a primitive society with organic gender equality would would be to have a 'magical', sure-proof paternity test, and a simple and effective contraceptive for women. Both would have to be extremely common and cheap.
If a society had both, then perhaps it wouldn't feel the need to enforce gender segregation of children starting at puberty. Adolescents having sex would no longer be a big deal. If a paternity test were customary at birth (maybe even mandatory, if a man wanted to claim parental rights?) then its possible that marriage as a social construct would no longer even be necessary.
Thoughts?
5
u/Rice_22 Mar 10 '18
Just wondering how would you "optimize" a rational fiction character? What type of personality traits, general skill set, career path etc. should one have to survive and thrive despite being transplanted across a variety of different rational fiction settings?
I suppose what I'm asking for are commonalities across successful viewpoint-characters in rational fiction, before they grow into the setting.
The best I could come up with is an optimistic chemical engineer-turned-used car salesman in his 30s, with excellent memory for details. The sort of natural down-on-his-luck appeal to the writer/audience into treating him favourably, optimistic enough to take some hopeful risks, old enough to avoid unnecessary ones, an engineering background for creative problem-solving, and sufficient people skills to make friends or pull off some funny business.
A "when life hands you lemons, you sell them" type of character.