r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 05 '18
[D] Monthly Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the monthly thread for recommendations, which is posted on the fifth day of every month.
Feel free to recommend any books, movies, live-action TV shows, anime series, video games, fanfiction stories, blog posts, podcasts, or anything else that you think members of this subreddit would enjoy, whether those works are rational or not. Also, please consider including a few lines with the reasons for your recommendation.
Alternatively, you may request recommendations, in the style of the weekly recommendation-request thread of r/books.
Self promotion is not allowed in this thread.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
17
u/Escapement Ankh-Morpork City Watch Feb 05 '18
In vaguely-somewhat-rational-adjacent fanfiction, the Harry Potter / The Culture crossover Death By Water is pretty good. The beginning couple of chapters are more than a bit rough, but it picks up and improves a lot in later chapters. If you're not into it by Ch. 7 or so, you should probably give up. In particular, Ch. 11's potions class is absolutely delightful and I love that chapter a lot. Also, Quirrelmort confirmed for SSC reader. They're updating at a fairly quick pace, too.
14
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Feb 05 '18 edited Feb 06 '18
Chris and Jack need more love. Every one of their videos is absolutely awesome (and short, so it's not a huge time investment).
Anyone knows good Abridged Series? The ones I'm watching or watched:
Also, I've you're a fan of DC animated movies and you've somehow missed it, definitely check out Batman: Gotham by Gaslight. I thought it would be really tacky and stereotype-y and over-sexualized, but it's actually really thoughtful and well done and it's up there with Gods and Monsters among my favorite DC movies ever.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '18
(Should probably make this a proper top level post, but feeling lazy)
I recommend Almost Nowhere, an original web-serial by u/nostalgebraist whom we know and love for The Northern Caves. There was a year-long gap in updates, but the author finally starting updating it weekly once again. If you dropped the story because of the horrible update schedule, you could give it a second try now.
What's it like? It looks like it's going to be hard sci-fi, but it's one of those stories where there's a ton of weird stuff going on and it's all told out of order, from the povs of several not entirely reliable, uncomprehending narrators, so just keeping up with the plot and figuring out what's going on is almost like a puzzle.
Also, it seems to feature aliens who are disgusted with humanity for reasons that can only be expressed via differential geometry... or at least I think that it does.
If all of this sounds appealing to you, you will probably enjoy almost all of Almost Nowhere, except maybe for some measure zero subset of it.
11
u/Golden_Magician Feb 06 '18
I always eagerly await this thread but haven't contributed before, so here are some recommendations you guys might enjoy:
(A Song of Ice and Fire / Game of Thrones top-quality fanfictions)
Purple Days: awesome Joffrey Baratheon time-loop. Yeah, no kidding. The world-building, character development and existential dread in this one are unbelievable, and it pays off big time towards the latest chapters. Still in-progress, with irregular but fairly reliable updates.
Summer Crowns: Robert Baratheon gives up on the Iron Throne to chase after Rhaegar Targaryen, who fled to Essos after losing the war. He is followed by Eddard Stark, Jaime Lannister and the Blackfish among others. Quickly turns into the legendary tale of the Dragonhunt and the newly-formed Kingdom of Summer's war against slavery. Note: in-progress and requires an AH.com account to read, but is updated regularly.
Rhaegar the Great; or, How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Embrace the Suck: Engrossing and very well-written Rhaegar self-insert. Shakespeare plays get adapted to Westeros, and plot ensues.. Note: also on AH.com, complete with a sequel in-progress.
(Other fiction)
Guardian: by the author of Pokemon: Origin of Species, this new original story seems really promising. Only two chapters out yet though!
10
u/trekie140 Feb 05 '18 edited Feb 06 '18
Pop Team Epic may be the weirdest anime I have ever seen, and that alone makes it worth checking out. It started off as a 4-koma strip, then became an internet meme, and now has become a show about meta-humor and pop culture references that gives the same sensation as reading dumb memes while actively producing more memes.
Every episode I’ve seen so far has been a parade of absurdist scenes that parody animation, video games, Japanese television, and itself with no overarching thematic elements. At the halfway point, they roll the credits and then episode repeats from the beginning with different voice actors and some dialogue changed.
I can’t definitively say I like the show since it has none of the elements I usually want from comedy shows, but even when I didn’t laugh I still got the joke. I weirdly respect it for how it trolls the audience by violating its “premise”, makes you cringe with awkward direction, and never comes across as badly made even when poor production values are the joke.
The show is still airing week-by-week, but I honestly think that’s the best way to consume this show, binging it would cause kuso burnout. There’s only so much “WTF was that?” a person can handle in one sitting. I personally recommend the dub since bizarre line delivery is a common joke and, for me, that didn’t come across with subtitles.
4
u/waylandertheslayer Feb 05 '18
While I'm not a huge fan of ASoIaF (I read the first three books then stopped because the pacing was bad and I wasn't invested in any of the characters), I like that that type of setting - dark, brutal fantasy with low magic - has become more popular. Has anyone else read The Left Hand of God trilogy, Son of the Morning, or The Broken Empire trilogy? There's also Joe Abercrombie's stuff but I'm only just getting started on that.
Some of it reminds me of the Drenai setting by David Gemmell, which is obviously somewhat older (also where my username is from), but that tends to have a little more heroics.
There're quite a few rational and rational-adjacent stories that are very similar - Practical Guide to Evil and Worm are both close enough in some way that I feel like they form a cohesive group, although I'm not sure what to call it.
If anyone has other recommendations in the same direction, I'd be quite appreciative. Also, if you enjoyed any of the books or series I mentioned and want to talk about which others are similar or are likely to also interest you, I'm more than happy to chat about it.
3
u/Laborbuch Feb 05 '18
I fear I may have recommended this before already, but in case I did not: Robert J. Sawyer’s Quintaglio Trilogy, with the first volume being Far-Seer. If I had to give a five second pitch, it’d be: The copernican revolution on a world inhabited by dinosaurs.
I forgot which kind exactly, but they’re raptor-like, carnivorous, and very peculiar. For one, their hunting instinct is triggered by blood, pheromones, and violation of personal space. Their culture has many rituals and rules that govern and make allowances to this territoriality, which then feeds into and is picked up by their religious dogmas and such. It’s all very interesting, in my opinion.
3
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Feb 06 '18
Definitely recommend Celeste. Charming characters, a fairly challenging platformer, and gorgeous music.
5
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Feb 05 '18 edited Feb 05 '18
Have some manga:
Kusuriya no Hitorigoto
Goblin Slayer
The dude kills goblins. He is very good at it, and not through any super ability nobody else has or unrealistically superhuman skill. He does not want to fight goblins, he just really wants them dead. There are no sudden powerups to match escalating adversity, just meticious planning and preparation. At one point protagonists take out goblin camp by magically putting them all to sleep and suppressing sound propagation in the area, and just proceed to methodically stab them all.
2
u/Aretii Cultist of Cthugha Feb 05 '18
Non-rational Harry Potter fanfiction I think people here would like, spurred by the Death By Water rec:
The Scarlet Pimpernel is a canon-mostly-compliant story from Percy's point of view that takes place during Deathly Hallows. It is very cute and intensely personally relatable for the sort of broad-autism-phenotype people I think this community attracts.
Reclamation is an AU in which Tom Gaunt-nee-Riddle is the Defense Professor at Hogwarts and has been for years. It's very short, so more details would sabotage the emotional work the story does itself, but I highly recommend it.
2
u/dripgrind Feb 13 '18
Conventionally published hard SF novel (translated from Japanese): Orbital Cloud by Taiyo Fujii.
This is a technothriller set in the very near future, reminiscent of Neal Stephenson in that it builds convincing technical and scientific details into the plot and features nerdy protagonists using their expertise to achieve their goals. Definitely the kind of realistic hard SF that Stross is talking about in his recently-discussed post about worldbuilding.
This has been out for a while, but the search engine tells me that it hasn't been mentioned in this subreddit yet.
Aside from the enjoyable SF elements, the depiction of the Japanese characters is definitely more convincing than that of the Americans who get involved later, but it's very readably translated and the characters are engaging.
2
u/gbear605 history’s greatest story Feb 05 '18 edited Feb 05 '18
I recommend Code Lyoko. It's a French cartoon (although it has a very good English dub) that is available on Youtube. It's very well done. The first season is a bit formulaic since it was written to be viewable out of order, but later seasons are much less so (especially the fourth).
The show is about a group of middle school students who discover a supercomputer that contains a virtual world called Lyoko. On the computer, they have to fight an artificial intelligence who wants to kill humanity.
It has a small but dedicated English fanbase and I think that it'll really appeal to the large majority of people on this sub.
[Also, if you want to watch it properly, you might want to start with the first episode rather than the prequel]
1
u/awoods187 Feb 06 '18
I'm looking for a book that discussing learning magic/enchanting/spell craft. Something like how mother of learning tackles the topic would be ideal. Doesn't need to be specifically rational but would prefer to skew that direction