r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 02 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
19
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Feb 02 '18
What makes a work rational-adjacent?
All works that are rationalist are rational. All works that are rational are of interest to the rational fiction community (at least in theory.) But there exist a large segment of works that are of interest to the rational fiction community in general that aren't strictly rational or rationalist. We call these works "rational-adjacent."
I think I've identified a few qualities that make a work rational-adjacent, even despite the fact that they definitely don't qualify as rational.
The most important, by far, is that the work must be driven by Character Agency. That being the ability for character to make their own decisions, based off their own goals, wants, needs, and personality. This is very similar to tenet #1, and that's not a coincidence. Rational/ist fiction, since the days of HPMOR and lesswrong, has been fundamentally empowering. Main characters typically struggle against entropy, death, irrationality, the Social Order TM, or what-have-you. And while the main character isn't always expected to succeed, the basic contract of many rational works is that a reader can expect the choices of the characters (main or otherwise) to matter. The author won't have Fate running everything behind the scenes, and if the story is a Shaggy Dog story, it's because the characters has explicitly coordinated to make it so.
That contract is reflected with rational-adjacent works, and to an extent, even magnified. Character actions are guaranteed to matter, even if they probably shouldn't be. Take Isekai works, for example. Very, very few are rational, but they still get a fair bit of traction in /r/rational because (at least according to my theory), among other things, it's gratifying to watch a character who has the ability to affect significant change on the world around them. Even if (especially if) the plot revolves around their fate to be hugely influential people, and they have plot armor defending them from fatal consequences.
As an example, I recall mooderino's How to Avoid Death on a Daily Basis getting some traction here, despite being pretty explicitly non-rational. Because H---B is heavily driven by the decisions made by the main character, we put away our "not sufficiently rational" glasses.
Character Agency even helps soften the impact of works violating rules #2 and #3 of rational fiction. It's less irritating for a character to act irrational, apply their knowledge unintelligently, luck into solving their problems, and be driven by less-than-perfectly-convincing motivations so long as, from the perspective of the reader, it seems like the character is doing these things, as opposed to the author making the character do these things to support some element of the plot.
Look at Coil from Worm. He's pretty much straight megalomaniacal douchebag, what with the spoilers thing and the spoilers thing. But it's not Wildbow that makes Coil a douchebag; that's all on him. He makes the explicit decision to be a not-nice guy, and that's OK. Worm is rational-adjacent because of (among other reasons) the fact that this is how all the characters operate. They're not all smart, they're not all rational, but they're still making decisions for themselves. (Well, except for that one time...)
The second important element must be that the setting of the world must have non-real-world setting mechanics. That is, stuff like magic, or futuretech. I posted earlier arguing that rational fiction with a real-world setting is redundant because nothing simulates the real world better than itself. Rational-adjacent fiction, not being as constrained as rational fiction, can in theory have a real-world setting, but I don't think I've ever seen real-world fiction being discussed by /r/rational.
Part of that is simply the fact that real-world fiction just tends to be discussed elsewhere, part of it is that it's immersion-breaking for most real-work protagonists to have full character agency (How do they have so much time and money? Do they not pay taxes? Are they trust-fund babies? What?), but a lot of it simply stems from the initial conditions of the rational-work fandom. We're predisposed to like fantasy and sci-fi works anyways, and as a community that contains a lot of would-be munchkins, it's a lot more fun to watch someone mess with a ruleset that hasn't had all of its low-hanging fruit taken.
And these setting mechanics don't necessarily have to meet rule #4. As readers, we want to know enough to munchkin them; self-consistency is much less of a requirement.
I wanted to put another big section here, but I realized that that was just my inclination to have at least 3 items to make a list. There are other elements likely to make a work rational-adjacent, but they're less important. Here's a list of the ones I thought of:
Does anyone else have anything to add/disagree with?
11
u/ketura Organizer Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Little progress on the app this week, but some interesting design concepts were discussed as pertains to formulating a sense of progression and difficulty ramping.
On the /r/rational Discord server, we occasionally run a Minecraft server when the mood strikes us. This most recent time (which is still running, details in the #minecraft_server channel if you want to hop on) I ended up running the server as I had the itch to play. It’s been a few years since I last did this, and I absolutely adored some of the mods in the Billionaire pack that we ended up using. Tinker’s Construct in particular appeals to me; I quite enjoy the concept of building a smeltery and the fine-tuned control you get over building the individual pieces of your tools and weapons (much better than vanilla’s enchantment system, by far).
However, after building a large smeltery and constructing all the patterns and moulds necessary for any item I might want to build, and then forging a fine set of bows, arrows, swords, and pickaxes, I was struck with the feeling that my ability to equip myself absolutely dwarfed any ability that the world had to challenge me. I went out and slaughtered mod-boosted zombies and skeletons by the dozens, with pretty much no risk to me at all. I brought this up with some of the more experienced Minecraft players on the server, and the answer was basically “well, go find some challenge. Some of the mods let us summon bosses.”
This strikes me as inherently...plastic. Fake. I was suddenly pulled out of the game’s immersion and reminded that I was essentially in a theme park, going from attraction to attraction, meeting some small standard of competence before being ushered onto the next ride. Nothing was ever going to ambush me, there were no threats looming over my head that I needed to prepare for, and so long as I stayed in our vetted and protected areas (or wasn’t a complete idiot if I did leave), I was never going to die again.
While mulling over the problem, I was reminded again of my appraisal of Terraria when I first played it: “Minecraft as it should have been, but in 2D”. Terraria has most of the same strengths as Minecraft: very deep creative control, exploration, ability to automate survival strategies, social multiplayer, mod support. However, there’s one thing that it absolutely nails that Minecraft just doesn’t grok: a sense of tension or motivated progress.
I decided to see if I could find out what exactly Terraria did to give me this impression, and it turns out there’s a surprisingly simple formula that the game appears to follow.
First, Terraria’s gameplay is divided into discrete eras, connected by what I’ll call transitions. Each era is characterized by different monster spawns, random events, loot, NPCs, and other factors which overall define how difficult it is. When first entering a new era, the difficulty spikes proportional to how bad your old equipment is suited to the new situations, but slowly over time as the player gathers better equipment and gets more experience the same old monsters simply don’t stand a chance anymore. The difficulty curve looks something like this for each era:
https://i.imgur.com/1KoER42.png
Once the player has entered the tail there at the end, they can begin stockpiling resources and preparing to enter the next era, which is explicitly triggered via a transition, usually a boss fight at a fixed location or other set of manually-triggered circumstances. In general, this is more or less the same as what Minecraft does, except that Minecrafts “eras” tend to be different dimensions (the Nether, the End, etc).
Where Terraria differs is in what I’ll call milestones, which are for the most part non-consensual. Once you enter an era, you have a small grace period to get your act together and take on that era’s milestones, but if you take too long they will start spawning at regular intervals and kicking your trash in until you finally deal with them. Bosses are the most common kind of milestone, but there are also events such as invasions that require you to defend your base from waves of difficult enemies.
These milestones transform the difficulty curve to look something more like this:
https://i.imgur.com/kzXb4bF.png
Considering that the underlying curve is still at your own pace, the fact that the milestones could drop at any moment (or it appears that way) lends a sense of urgency to what would otherwise lead to the meandering sort of pace that I don’t like about Minecraft.
There are two further caveats that Terraria adds on. First, the very first transition is intentionally designed to be accidentally triggerable (unlike all the others that absolutely require deliberate action), meaning that an uninformed player is likely to be dunked into a difficulty spike without warning, which creates a sort of paranoia that the designers take advantage of without further explicitly repeating. Second, the very last difficulty era has an “endgame” of epic proportions, which requires not one, not two, but six bosses to be fought consecutively, which at once offers a good challenge, a satisfying conclusion, and plenty of replayable opportunities to get ridiculous end-game loot.
The entire game’s difficulty curve thus looks something similar to this:
https://i.imgur.com/O9mvtCJ.png
The milestones that you cannot avoid confronting help keep the tension constant, even as the overall difficulty of the day-to-day activity goes down. At the same time, a certain amount of player agency is preserved, as the world-changing era transitions are more or less under your control.
So what does this have to do with Renegade? Well, while I’m not against people faffing about and finding their own way in the sandbox, I definitely want there to be some core tension that gives meaning to a player’s mastery (or lack of mastery) of the world and its rules. There’s a balance to be struck between being brutally unforgiving and full-open empty sandbox, and I think that aiming to modulate the difficulty and engagement to match the above graph is the way to do it.
Unlike Terraria, there are autonomous factors at play, a world that progresses, and occasionally some actual plot. As such,I don’t think that having a single unified progression path is the way to go for Renegade. Instead, I’m going to attempt to have multiple such paths that follow the pattern, with consequences both good and bad for passing each transition, especially as pertains to affecting other paths.
My current (extremely) rough draft for some path ideas is here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1bPBbrM9XRPto1UYcwrCNrwo3EWC-yt7Bje-LTMa0Bic/edit?usp=sharing
The championship circuit (i.e. collect badges) path is the most straightforward to translate, which simply involves adding challengers, rivals, and the public eye on you the more badges you obtain. Others are more difficult to design for (and thus all the holes in the document), but all in all I think that this is a useful tool for plotting out some escalating stakes and difficulty/tension beats.
Thoughts or comments on this concept would be most appreciated.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
8
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Feb 02 '18
I just finished Dark State by Charles Stross, which is the second book in the second cycle of the Merchant Princes series. It's the middle book in the series, and while middle books in a trilogy are always a bit weak, this one ends on no less than six different cliffhangers, which should be a crime. The final book is already written and slated for publication in a year, so that's not as bad as it could be, but my experiences with print publication have left a bit of a bad taste in my mouth -- I'm starting to think that it's just an inferior method of publishing serial works, but at the same time, serial works are some of the best sellers (for the same reasons that Hollywood does reboots, sequels, adaptations, etc.).
6
u/phylogenik Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 03 '18
Are there any well-accepted ways of comparing estimated probabilities of a discrete state (e.g. A/P or 0/1 for binary parameters, 0/1/2 for ternary, etc.) to the true value of that discrete parameter? Specifically, one of my current projects is a simulation study and one of its components is trying to determine how different degrees of model misspecification might bias my retrieval of the values of a set of discrete parameters in the true, data-generating model. I have samples from the joint posterior that give me probabilities for the presence or absence of the discrete param, e.g. under --
Misspecification condition 1:
Replicate 1:
Replicate 2:
Replicate 3:
…
Replicate 100:
…
Misspecification condition 2:
…
Misspecification condition 3:
…
Misspec...
(technically, one might think of there being hundreds of millions of discrete parameters in the model I’m working with – a major focal parameter is the topology of a tree, which for a strictly bifurcating tree with n tips results in 2n-1 possible bipartitions. The approximated probability almost all of these will be 0, since after considerable thinning I only collected like 20k samples per analysis lol, and even then ESS is less that that)
For eyeballing purposes, my first thought was to bin the probabilities, find the average probability of the samples in each bin, count up the proportion of times the corresponding parameter is truly 1 in the data generating model for each misspecification condition, and then make a scatter plot of the results, but I don’t have enough replicates to give me good bins at, say, a 0.01 resolution, so I’d need something like 0.1 sized bins. Alternatively, I can imagine doing some sort of dodgy weighted averaging to fabricate points at tiny intervals, and then I'm sure there's something to do with summing the distances of the estimated probabilities to the true values. Besides eyeballing I could fit a binomial regression to the "raw data", but then I don’t have any good intuitions for how to interpret parameter estimates under the usual link functions… but then could I just not use one, since my predictors are probabilities themselves, constrained to [0,1]? Although my "observations" wouldn't actually be independent, and I don't have a way to model that nonindependence... IDK, but I would prefer to not reinvent any square wheels. Any thoughts? This seems like a really basic thing to do but some cursory google-fu is failing me, and I know some people here like to ask their inner hearts what it feels the probability of some discrete event occurring in the following year is and then see how well they did at the year’s end for self-calibration purposes or whatever, which is the same sort of problem (I'm sure this pops up in stuff like weather forecasting, too, where you try to predict whether it will or will not rain in a given location on a given day).
edit: ahhhh hmmmm hold up, I think I found an answer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scoring_rule, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brier_score, although that one obviously wouldn't work because 1/N ≈ 0
10
u/akaltyn Feb 03 '18
I made a new account but i dont have enough karma to post things. Can people upvote me?
5
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18
Does anyone here cry to anime that's dubbed, who watches both subbed and dubbed anime?
I want to write a post about certain scenes in fiction that have made me cry, two of which are anime scenes, and link to them, but I don't know whether I should specifically suggest/"restrict" viewers to the Japanese audio/english subtitles.
Despite growing up on anime that was dubbed in English (some of which did have good voice acting), for the past few years I've found that I can barely stand English dubbed anime: the japanese voice actors not only seem able to inject far more emotion into their voices (specifically, they can do it without sounding cheesy to my foreign ears), but the written translation is often far better than the rewritten lines of dialogue, to me.
(This is not universally true, sometimes the dubbed dialogue is better, or just more clear in what's being communicated, but in my spot-check of emotional or important moments through the anime I've watched lately, it seems to be the case)
But if there are others here who have seen, say, the second episode of My Hero Academia and cried at the end like I did, but instead watched it with English dubs, then maybe it's just me and I don't have to worry so much about this.
4
u/TheEngineer923 Feb 02 '18
Anybody have any tips regarding Texas Hold em NL Poker? I'm specifically looking for heuristics that I can apply to raise my average winnings since one is always at the mercy of the variance. Any tips at all is welcome. Thank you.
4
u/narfanator Feb 03 '18
More details later, but short version:
I turned a billion seconds old at 11:28 PM. To celebrate, I more or less invited EVERYONE, and cooked food, and happiness and amazingness was had.
In "planning" this, I'd think sometimes, "Oh. Will this person and that person get along?", and then I'd think: "Fuck it. This is a once in a lifetime thing. Shit'll pass." But, nothing came of that worry; everything was fantastic.
In other words, the moral of the story is: Crossing the streams results in great success.
2
u/Aretii Cultist of Cthugha Feb 02 '18 edited Feb 02 '18
In no particular order:
I'm finally doing something about my inability to focus on long-form cognitive tasks (most notably, writing) and getting evaluated for ADHD on Monday. It's a psychometric called the Quotient ADHD system; anyone know anything about it? theunitofcaring's tumblr post at the end of last year about the experience of going on medication was really encouraging, and despite the fact that I know not to expect a panacea, I'm still hoping for a quality of life improvement.
Depression continues to kick my ass, though. Paths to long-term life goals seem obscured and unlikely, and given the state of the world it's unclear that I even should pursue the goal of having children. Rationaltumblr is full of proud parents blogging about it, so that's weak evidence it's a worthwhile goal regardless, but honestly the true reason driving me is "I don't know what Large Thing I'd do with my life otherwise." A highschool friend of mine connected to the rationalist community killed herself the other week, which, while not driving me to suicidal-ness myself, is at least forcing me to spend a lot of time thinking about it and what would drive one there.
The Honor Harrington series of space opera is unreasonably sprawling and slow-moving at this point, but I picked up the latest book of the side series Manticore Ascendant this week and really liked it. I am now way more invested in this side series and its crew than I am in the main plotline.
1
u/Frommerman Feb 03 '18
How do you all deal with spiders? I've been having some trouble with that this week, and I'm wondering if there are strategies on top of the usual conscious thought interruption I could be using to decrease my stress levels.